High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/40017/2017disposed of

M/S Rajinder Singh & Bros & ANR v. Chandigarh Pollution Control Committee

2023-05-16Mr. Justice Sandeep Moudgil26 pages

!"# "$ "%""

" "$ " &' ' &()

$$$

* "%+ & ,-

./ 01 /2

0 "

3333 45 67

020

33333 45 , - : )

;

0 /0< 88 0 "

3333 45 67

020

33333 45 ,&- ):(

/7 #0 0 0 "

3333 45 67

020

33333 45 ,- *&:&

"220<08 0 "

3333 45 67

020

3333 45 ,)- *(

8 0 90= 4 5 > 3 0 "

3333 45 67

020

3333 45

,*- : &

./ 7 7 9?

0 "

3333 45 67

020

45 ,- :) :

"@0= /2 !020 0 0

3333 45 67

020

45 ,:-

* : (

./ 08 =

3333 45 67

020

45 ,(-

6 A790 /090 0 "

3333 45 67

020

45 ,-

(

./ / #0801

8=0B 0

3333 45 67

020

& ,-

( (4

09 >08

3333 45 67

020

+ 020

45 , -

): ( ./

8 $ C 0 "

3333 45 67

020

+ 020

3333 45 ,&-

:: (

#0 #0

0 "

3333 45 67

020

3333 45 ,-

&()* ( ./ /0

B 72 9 0 0

3333 45 67

020

+ 020

3333 45 ,)-

&(** :

./ 0 "

3333 45 67

020

020 3333 45

,*-

&& :

/0 08

3333 45 67

020

3333 45 ,-

&) :

A0> /2 0 "

3333 45 67

020

45 ,:-

):* :

;

3333 45 67

020

3333 45 ,(-

): :

9 0 /

3333 45 67

020

3333 45 , -

): :

>0@ A07 ./

C08 /0< 88

3333 45 67

020

3333 45

) , -

*:* :

3333 45 67

020

3333 45 , -

: ( ./ 33 / 8 7 0 "

3333 45 67

020

3333 45 , &-

((* :

#00 #70 B01

3333 45 67

020

3333 45 , -

):: :

6B091 "220<08 0 "

3333 45 67

020

3333 45 , )-

)(: :

01 /

3333 45 67

020

3333 45 , *-

)&* :

$0B 08 0 "

3333 45 67

020

3333 45

* , -

): :

/<00 /2 0 "

3333 45 67

020

3333 45 , :-

) ( :

01 /090 0 "

3333 45 67

020

45 , (-

)&& :

/0 <0 A07 0

3333 45 67

020

3333 45 ,&-

)) :

017 B01 0 "

3333 45 67

020

3333 45 ,&-

)(& :

/0 A 80 0 "

3333 45 67

020

3333 45 ,& -

): ( ./ !

<8 > 3 0 "

3333 45 67

020

3333 45

,&&-

*) ( ./

0B2 "90D2

> 3 0 "

3333 45 67

020

3333 45 ,&-

) :

B 0 /

9 08 = 0

3333 45 67

020

3333 45 ,&)-

(* ( ./ 0 0

/0< 883 0 "

3333 45 67

020

3333 45 ,&*-

:( :

./ "7 ;

;

3333 45 67

020

3333 45 ,&-

*:*

/7 0 "

3333 45 67

020

3333 45 ,&:-

* #33 22 ;

B 0 "

3333 45 67

020

3333 45

: ,&(-

&:( 4

5 ./ !0 >7E9 / 8 7 0 "

3333 45 67

020

+ 020

3333 45 ,-

&)& ./ #0B

#0B= 0 "

3333 45 67

020

3333 45

&)&& ./ 00B /< 0 "

3333 45 67

020

3333 45 , -

)& ./ 00 0 "

3333 45 67

020

3333 45 ,&-

(( 01 60

3333 45 67

020

3333 45 ,-

(&)& ./ /7 0 0 "

3333 45 67

020

3333 45

( ,)-

( ./ 0@0 ; 0 "

3333 45 67

020

3333 45 ,*-

):: ./ < A /<

3333 45 67

020

3333 45 ,-

)* ./

080E= 7 0 "

3333 45 67

020

3333 45 ,:-

* ./

<08 0 "

3333 45 67

020

+ 020

3333 45 ,(-

)::& ./ #008 / 8 7 7 0 "

3333 45 67

020

3333 45 ,)-

):: ./ 7 9@ 0 "

3333 45 67

33 020 0

3333 45

,)-

&)) ./

33 3

0 "

3333 45 67

020

+ 020

3333 45 ,) -

&(( : :

./ 0 / 8 7 7 0 "

3333 45 67

020

+ 020

3333 45 ,)&-

:* ./

7 7 0 "

3333 45 67

020

33020

3333 45 ,)-

(& & ./ 0CB0 / 8 7 0 "

3333 45 67

020

3333 45 ,))-

(: & 0C A790

3333 45 67

020

3333 45 ,)*-

(* :4

5 ./ #72 A2 0 > 3 0 "

3333 45 67

020

3333 45

,)-

)* "CB0 09 0 "

3333 45 67

+ 020 0 "

3333 45 ,):-

&: ./ 3 7 0 "

3333 45 67

020

3333 45 ,)(-

::& & ./ !0 7 7 7 0 "

3333 45 67

020

3333 45 ,*-

):: ./ 67 7 08 0 0 "

3333 45 67

020

3333 45 ,*-

&& & .3 0 78 $

0 /0< 88 0 "

3333 45 67

020

3333 45 "'

F#> 3 !

/ /"$

$ >

" #

#"%&'())%*'+( !

, -

#"%%)./).%*'+/

#"%%0 )&1'( )1/+. )1/*' )1/)* )22.' 1''//

1''2/ 1'+&. 1'+(/ 1'*2( 1+'&& 1+'1) 1+'2& *'+/

)1+/2%*'*+ +.&/&%*'**

4 5

#"%%*1//'%*'** &1&))%*'** )&&++ )&&+.%*'+/

&1&''%*'** -

#"%%&2.+.%*'+/ - 0

#"%1/(/)%*'** 7 !

" ,

#"%%+2+.'%*'+/

#"%%.()1%*'+2 9

#"%%*1)/)%*'+2

#"%%(+)1%*'+/ 4

#"%%(2&*%*'*&

#"%%+)2+/%*'*&

& $ !

#"%%(/2)+%*'+/ - $ !

#"%%+'&/2%*'*'

"5 !

#"%%&1(+1%*'** " !

#"%%&22*/%*'+/

8 $

8 "

#"%%*//'+%*'+2 $ ! $

" !

#"%%1)&)'%*'*+ -

#"%%1+.))%*'** #"%%(2&* //(& +)2+/

1//*( *'*& 4

#"%%.'2((%*'** #"%%*+/**%*'*& : - !

0 * /"$

$ >+ !

">5 + 9 # ;

; .+

! ! !

< !

* , #

)/* # # ; < ! ! ;

# !!

;

7 #!

# ;

;

*1=*.

)) )2 > #!

+2() &( &2 )'

+2/+ !! ! %

& ,

;

; #"%%)''+(%*'+( !

) , ;

! !

+2)/

A ; ! abadideh 9!! "

$ B, #

# B, #

! # 7 @ !

&+ +* *'+1 ; ! !

! +' '+ *'+(

!! ! % !

'2 '+ *'+( ?

%+ &

% ! ! ?

B, # *1 ') *''1 ?

%) !

! ;

! !

! ;

A !

!! !! ! !!

, C!

- B, # !! !

;!!

*( '. *'+( ;

! ; # ?

)

!! "

$ 0 D;5 # 0D#

'& ++ *'+.

! ; ;

% ! *1 *.

+2() *+

+2/+ !

&' '2 *'*'

! '. +* *'+.

, # !!

# ###

! +( '* *'+( ?

! !!

; 0D#A

E ;

### < ;

A% !

-! D -D +2% # +( '* *'+( ?

0D# <

-D A> ;

A ?

%++

( " !!

** '. *'+( ?

% +*

;

### !

# B, # ! +' ') *'+( ;

! ;

%! !! !! B, #

abadi deh !! 0D#

! +1

0D# ! ! '. +* *'+.

% /

! ; , ! ;

A +1 '( *'+( ?

A !!

abadideh 9!! ! ;

; !! !

0D# ;

### !

'. +* *'+.

;

! ! ;

; ;

A !

! # !

7 #! # *+ '& *'+( ;

7 !

! *+ '& *'+( ?

%+)

*+ '( *'+( ?

%+1

; ! ; #

)/* # # <

7 ! !

B !

! !

0D# ;

; ;!

7 ! !

! +2 *+ # 7 ;

;

!! !

; ;

% !!

+2()

+2/+

++ F !

! ?

*1 ') *''1 ?

%1 %) !

! # !

; ! < *+ '& *'+( ** '. *'+( ! ! !

; ; ;

%###

- ! % ### ; !

; !!

+1 !!

)/* # #

, ; ! !!

! '. +* *'+.

;! expost facto !

0 * ! ; ! < !!

!! ! ;

! +) +2 *+ # 7

%### ! ;

!! ; !

;

! ;

%! !

# B, # %###

abadideh !! 0D#

0D# ; ;

A ; !! ;

: +) - ! !

%### , ; E

;

%###

; !!

+1 0 ; ;

8 ! !

;! !

+( , ! ; !

** '. *'+( ?

%+*

;

%###

;

!! % (i) that accused will close the unit forthwith; (ii)that accused will not run unit before the permission granted by the CPCC;

(iii)that concerned authorities shall disconnect water/electricity supply to accused unit and to seal the said unit. +/ ,

;

+1 !

! %

; +2 ,

! !

! *+ '& *'+( ?

%+)

! % +2 '/ *'+( ?

%+1

! !

# 7 @ !

; !

&+ +* *'+1 ;

! !! !

%+ %&

" ! ; ! ?

; ! ;

( ; B,

# *1 ') *''1 !

! !!

;

- B, #

%### < E

;

%### !

# #

;

!! ; ;

!! "

$ 7

0 D;5 # 0D#

'& ++ *'+. ;

% !

*1 *.

+2() *+

+2/+ !

&' '2 *'*'

** '. *'+( ?

%+*

*+ , # !!

! ; ! '. +* *'+.

%/ ; !% "1.

!"#

$ %&&'$&$&.

The Consent is valid for Cutting of Wood (Saw Mill) with gross capital investment (including Land, Building, Plant and Machinery) of Rs. 5.68 Lacs only.

The Consent to operate has been approved by CPCC from pollution angle and the industry shall obtain all other formal consents from other concerned departments (if needed). 5.

The unit shall obtain prior permission from СРСС before

expansion/ modification/upgradation of the process /plant/ machinery.

The authorized person of the unit shall intimate the CPCC before closing of the unit.

Conditions under the Water Act: Water shall be used only for domestic purpose.

(i) Following standards must be achieved before disposal of waste water into the public sewerage system,

( pH Between 5.5 and 9.0 Suspended Solids 600 mg/I BOD 350 mg/1 Oil & Grease 20 mg/l Ammonical Nitrogen (as N) 50 mg/1 The effluent should meet the general standards as laid down in the Environmental Protection Rules, 1986, before disposal into the sewerage system.

(ii) All the underground water retaining structures shall be lined with an impervious layer so as to avoid seepage and contamination of subsoil/water.

(iii) The unit shall comply with the provisions of the Water (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Cess Act, 1977, as amended (hereinafter as Cess Act) and Rules made thereunder.

(iv) The unit shall regularly submit to the Committee returns of water consumption in the prescribed form and pay the cess as specified under Section 3 of the Cess Act. ) * *"+ (i) Unit should maintain the ambient air quality by controlling fugitive emissions (if any) during the process. (ii) Unit shall not install/use D.G. set without acoustic enclosure and without the prior permission of Chandigarh Pollution Control Committee.

The unit shall not handle/generate any Hazardous Waste

in the unit 10.

Unit shall a Paint activities like Electroplating/Wire Drawing/Casting Powder Coating and Paint activity without prior permission from Chandigarh Pollution Control committee.

11.

The applicant shall take adequate measures for control of noise from its own sources so as to comply with the standards.

12.

No complaint should be received. from,nearby. neighbours regarding pollution aspects against the unit. 13.

The unit shall regularly submit the environmental statement in the prescribed formV for the previous financial year not later than 30th of September every year to CPCC 14.

Unit shall apply for renewal of consent in the prescribed form at least 90 days before the date of expiry of this consent order.

,-.-*( /.011/.

2/ /.

-. / 3*,-

-22(4-. -51

1/.

3*7*0/4

8* - a) Any upset conditions in operations/process in the premises, which may cause increased effluent or result in violation of standards prescribed in the Consent Order be reported to the Chandigarh Pollution Control Committee at the first instance.

b) The applicant shall practice good housekeeping. All pipes/valves/drains/ conduits/sewers shall be kept leak proof. Floor washings from operation/ process area shall not be allowed to find their way in stormwater drains or open areas. The unit shall not throw any solid waste in open inside/outside its premises to the nuisance of the public or to be deterrent to the environment in any manner.

c) The applicant shall go in for recycling/reuse of water as far as practicable to minimize the discharge of wastes into the environment and shall work to adopt clean technology to

reduce the generation of environmental pollutants. d) The unit shall take necessary steps to ensure that noise pollution is not caused from its operations to the nuisance of the public or workers. The unit shall not burn any material on the road side and or inside/outside its premises to the nuisance of the public or to be deterrent to the environment in any manner.

e) This consent stands cancelled if there will be any encroachment of Government land.

f) The unit i.e. 5

9 :

shall comply with the provisions of the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986 and the rules made thereunder."

** ,

! !!

0 + * ( / !!

! , #

! !

*& , 0 + ! ;! ?%

0 * ! ; !

&' '2 *'*'

! ** '. *'+( ?

%+* ;

! ;! !!

;

# !!

< ! !

;

*) , ! 0 ( / ;

& !!

, ! !

! !

;5 C - @ -

*1 , # ! ! ;! ! ! %*+ '& *'+( ?

%+) ; < !

!! ! ** '. *'+( ?

%+* %### ! ! '. +* *'+.

C ? !

# #

; ;

; - F!

! '. +* *'+.

0 D;5 # '& ++ *'+.

;

! !

** '. *'+( ?

%+*

! ! *+ '& *'+( *.

, !

;

# * "

"" (

* ;<$= !

$&;= " &;&>$&$&

; ; ! ! !

;

; C# ;

5 !

! !

! C# 7 C# !

! ;

+' ') *'+( ;

# # ### ;

! ;

! !! !! B , #

; - F!

!! , # !!

! '. +* *'+.

;

! ;

! !

# # +' ') *'+( ; !! !

! ! , %### ! ; ; #

B !

! ;

%0D# !!

! !

*( ,

# !

3 ? / @ ( / ;''$

%%<

8 #

)/* # # < @7"= ! ; !

# !! @7"= ! ; <

) "1. Where the allegations made in the first information report or the complaint, even if they are taken at their face value and accepted in their entirety do not prima facie constitute any offence or make out a case against the accused.

2. Where the allegations in the first information report and other materials, if any, accompanying the FIR do not disclose a cognizable offence, justifying an investigation by police officers under Section 156(1) of the Code except under an order of a Magistrate within the purview of Section 155(2) of the Code.

3. Where the uncontroverted allegations made in the FIR or complaint and the evidence collected in support of the same do not disclose the commission of any offence and make out a case against the accused.

4. Where the allegations in the FIR do not constitute a cognizable offence but constitute only a noncognizable offence, no investigation is permitted by a police officer without an order of a Magistrate as contemplated under Section 155(2) of the Code.

5. Where the allegations made in the FIR or complaint are so absurd and inherently improbable on the basis of which no prudent person can ever reach a just conclusion that there is sufficient ground for proceeding against the accused.

6. Where there is an express legal bar engrafted in any of the provisions of the Code or the Act concerned (under which a criminal proceeding is instituted) to the institution and continuance of the 21 proceedings and/or where there is a specific provision in the Code or the Act concerned, providing efficacious redress for the grievance of the aggrieved party.

7. Where a criminal proceeding is manifestly attended with malafide and/or where the proceeding is maliciously instituted with an ulterior motive for wreaking vengeance on the accused and with a view to spite him due to private and personal grudge." */ , ;

; #

* %### ! ;

! 5 F!

** '. *'+( ;< !

! *+ '& *'+( ?

%+)

;

! ;! ;

*2 8 ! *+ '& *'+( ?

%+)

! *+ '( *'+( ?

%+1

;

7 #! # ;

; < &'

; !

;

! ! 4/"$

$ >5 *3)3 &

$ Whether speaking/reasoned Yes/No Whether reportable Yes/No