High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/1066/2022dismissed

Bhola Singh And ORS v. State Of Haryana

2024-02-19Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mr. Justice Lalit Batra12 pages

" # $ %&& ' '(" $)&

$ *+,-. &/01 .0.2130 *+,-. &/01 .--1,1

!" # $ % '%( ) '*+' +'# $ % +,+" -# $ %&

. )/#)0 )1 )2 '+ -# $ %& )3 +# $ %4'+ " $# $ % )5 * '#

64'+ *+7++# #6 ,+ - #6 8888 0.21304/& )

+' '% -'+'"- $ '%# " )99/.9..# %,'-7 7 .: &.9):#,6+

; -#!*+#4++ -+'% %+- 4-'+%% < &&%'+, %'

)35#)32#/91#/./#/.3#/.0#/3)#3.1 &+ 7#++ ' ; -% # % % &' '- &% $'%'

-'+ (% $'% 4$#+ +% (%% "6 " !"'-+#! '-+ &*+'-+# #' '-+=,, &;-''-+4%<' & "+%+- 4-'+"

$#+ -+%'- 4 ))9/.9..#+ ' ; - % # % + (% $'% ' + +'&>% "

. +, $'" % &'"' "#4

% %6,+'

& '

- ,6+( $'%# '-+'$'-'

# #' &+%#4#'" %'

3.5 &+7 7#+ , &&& "+, $ '" %?@ &'"' " / + %% (% $'% ,% " --'$ & " + , $

4 $ '% & % $'%'

# ,'

# ,% " --'$ & " + <+ %?@ &'"' "# &&',%"

& '" # +"#,6+ % $'%'-7 % # #+% +$%+ ''+-'+'%'"'#,& +' 3 % +''" +'7 #+'+ + +% "'+% ' 6#,& +'7 # -'+$ '% &%<'#" ,6+ '; -% # <+%<' ?@ +#+$ '% &%<'#" ' % &+%<' %%

%<'% %'$# #,' '- &&% '( )*+ # 0

+-' &+ %'

%,% "",

' '+ # 4+'%+ > )''- +'

%' ' > ) #+ +4-' +" &% "' A'-+ +&&%++'-'%' + -4'+ 4'-+# +' #!"$ *+'+ *+

%+6 & '>"

+ +6+ 44+ +" 0)).9)0#, )9/9"#4++ -4'+'-+#$'-+# A'-+#4'-+#!''-+#-+,''-+#*+4' '-+ *+'-++$'-&#' -'4 +'&' ' % ( 6 &'-+,'--''

B()3)1& ''-'- +&' 4++6%+ + &!"$#+%%

+$'-- '# +''+'+ 4 +#4+ - +" %* +"4'++'%'$ 4 "- +"

%6% % ( 6 -4'+' '""+'-++ %6# 4 *'-'+'&' %"

+ '-+"#%% & 46& "+ -4'++'%'$4 4+'+'- *'+"'&

, +%% % 'A' +"4'+''

*' +" +&#+64+'& 77 + 4& "#& "

4+#+?A@'-+ $'-+4& ;

'#!*+ & "+#'-+4& 7 % (/.#7+ '-+ +'%''%% ''

6 & *'- -%'

-'+%% +,' &+-'

# %'

)35#/91#/./#/.3 /3) 4'+%'

)32 74-' -%+ .

#+ : & '$'-'

# %+ -' %% + '-+#

$' '-+# "'-+# +''-+ +#! '-+ C *+'-+# *'-+# "'-+# "'-+#!+"' '-+#' '-+=,,# '-+=7++' # # '+ '-+ 4 &' +&# "6 %+ -' %%

*+4' !4&' 1 ' &%+4' +%% & &% $'- %'

.917 7&' '-'"(&%'%& + ""''

& &&%'+, %'

)35#/3)#/./#/.3#/.0# /91#3.1 4'+%'

)32 7-'%% + '-+# $' '-+# "'-+# +''-+= +#! '-+C *+ '-+# *'-+# "'-+# "'-+#!+"''-+#' '-+=,,# '-+=7++' # '+'-+ *+4' !#+%% 4%+-(+ $'

25.9):# 4+'%+ +6 -'6 %'" ' 5

+&# $'

:..9)1# '%'

/)27 74 4 *+4' '-+# A'-+# ;4'-+# ','-+#"'-+#;+ 4'-+# +"'-+#

4' '-+# ,' '-+# ! '-+ C ! '-+

'-+4 ,""

&%+'

%% ( / #+ 2 '%+ &&%4>%'$6',,6+7 '

#+#+ % ""'7 % #+ -+% ""'

" 591.9):#+% % % ""'+%% &% ',& +7 &'

( / #+ )9

+ '; -% #&%'$'-+%& '#" ,A%'$6' &+'%'"' 6"'#

,& +'"6#+ % 4%+--'%% #& +% ""''

& &&%'+, %'

)35#/3)#/./#/.3# /.0#/91#3.1 4'+%'

)32 7 +& 4%+-4

+%% # 4+'%++6 -'6# #%'" ' ))

& &'%#+ %'

>"' ./4'# # +& + ,'% % % # % + %'

%&+% & %'

%#+

'; -% 4 % '-# %'

/)/ &+7 7# ,+'#+%% ' %%# #%'" &'"'%'

+6 %+

% &%$'

%# > 3 )34 ' $'

% ). , $ #+ '; -% # %

$'%+(% $'%#& +%+-?@#,%" 4 -'+"# # , $ # % #'++', $ "#'" +%?@ &'"' "#4 &&'# + $'%(

1 ( # (

..(( )/

+ % & + % $'%( +$ ,"' #+++ 4 - '-+ &'$ &%

6# & #6+'

,% "'-,6

' , &'&&'%%6,6+ '; -% "*'-+ '

,"''

#+ % & +,"'#+'% +%'"$#

*%'4+'%+4'++6'% '

+ +& #,%'64++% "'6" # '""'', '- +' # +,6 & '- + '

'""'','- +%'"'#,6+% "'6#+6 4&6>%' +''-+ &'$ &% & 6# & <6#+6,"'#++64<' ,

4 4'++ ,&' &+'

>%'

-'+&'- &%'"'',''6+ ,6+ '; -% 4$#4++'

4" + ," +#+,6+'"- $ '% &&& "- &%6 1 ( # ( )3 + ++ #+ % +- ,& +'7 #++$ '% &% $'%'

# #% <+ %?@ ?@#,% "'" +% $'%(#4"' #

<'6 '&%#,'-" ,6+'7 '+ >%' & ' A' '%'

+& #+ +- ++ #& ,6+% $'%(#, '"' '

1 +#

1% # 1 ( # (

..(( (*

%+ !

2# )0 + 'A (6 4' 4+ %'$6 '

4', > D(3# D(1# D(2# D(.9#+'+'%'$6

3 " ''

'- +&% % +'%'$6" $'

" ' 4''- + -+# + % & + ,"'#+'%+6'A 64'+,6#+' %'$'&'%'

+ , '% 4$#+, $" ,"''

' %%, +'7 #* 4+ " ' &+'%'$6" '&'%'

#%'6 '% #+ +6 +$ '+ - 6 '" $ '6 ",'+ # +' %'$6" $'

"#'4''-#+,64'+4 &+ , $' %%'-'+'%'$6" '&'%'

#6 '""% '4 +''%<' ,6+'%'$'&'%'

$ +4'#'%+'%',"''

,& +'7 ,6+ % & +# $ $# #+ '-'- +" ,6 + ' ; - % # $'(($' + >%'

?@ -' '" ''

& %'"' ',''6# # + '"%+# '+,6 -'-+'-+ '$ &% & # & 6# 6 + &&'%%6 & '

,% "'- '" #,6+,6+ 6 "'+ %%%*'-%+%'"'#, %<'% + '&'%'

?@ &+'A 64'#+,'- $ '

6$'

'6%'66#+,6+' &' #'& 6# '-''- + '&'%'

" ,6 + 'A 4' +

%%%,' ''-'&'%% ' - 0.11. .*1 51..--*1*'

*.60.*1 1..21.

7.. )1

'-+% &'$'-'

,'-" ' +#+ '$'-'- &&'%% #+ +%% E '%"

'- + % & + # ,'- '% " # +6

4 %'$6" '- '% "#4+'%+%'$6 % ' > (3# (0# (2# ()9# ())# ().# ()0# ():# ()1# ()5# (..# (./ )5 '%+ '% "'- ,6+%% # 6 4+ '- & + '- '% "# %'$6" ,6%% E#% '

6$++'+6 6 & +'-''+%'"$#, %+ *+'#+ +6%+%'- &% $' &- ' +'# + '$'-'- &&'% % # & " + %'$ % & +' %'$6 +'

'-# # % %'- +"# -'$ + '

' ,'- >%'$6* 4 +"'%'%+ &+ -+% $6 ""

%'$6",

' ' > ()/# ()2# (.0# (23# (20# (2:#

(21#+6% +% $6 &- ' +'?@'-'&'%6# '%++$ ,, '+,6 6+''-

%% > (3# (0# (2# ()9# ())# ().# ()0# ():# ()1# ()5# (..# (./# 4++$,, $+ ' '

$# '% +6 +$ , , ,'- & + -', $'

%,--'$++% $''+% '$ '$

+& #+""

% % ,+ '-+"

'6 %'6 (8.#( "9(

:"""

)2 % +#" +'A "6 '-+#A'-+#$'-+#-+,'#!''-+#*+4' '-+#4#A# # *+#+6,%",A% " '% >"''

,6 D(..# 4+ '- + % & +# "*'- + >"''

('(%+'&#+ $+%'$6 4 #$'(($'

5 +'A 4'#%'$6%' ' > (:1 (10#+

''-+'#++'&>% 'A'#,%" '% ,

%%'- +'A " &'A

A' ) '-+ )%' 4 * .%' 4 * /%' 4 $& . A'-+ )%' 4 &'-'

* . ''&- /%' 4 +* / $'-+ )% 4 $'-'

&* . ''&+ /%' 4 +* 3 -+,' )% 4 $&6, 4 0 !''-+ )% 4 .&'%'%'

&+ /&'%'%'

$& 4,

" 37 '

$& 4,%* : *+4' '-+)4'- & 1 4 ) ''&& " .% 4 '-+' >&'- 5 A )&'%'%'

&- .%'

4 $'-'

&* 2 *+ ) &'%' %'

$ '-+ 4 '# "'

4'- . '''-+& "# %'F 4'- .9 '% +

% % # +% +,6 + % -6 $ ++'

'A',%"' +%'$ +$'%'"#+< &+ # &+'%'"' 6% $

4 & &&%# + + , $ " '% $'

%# +

-6 % , + % ', % %% < +

%%% .)

4 % '- 4# #+%'6 &+'%' -" ' ,& +' 7 # + + + + 4 >%' +''-+ &'$ &% & 64,

6#'', %6 $' +% #+ -++& "#4+++ %'"'4$'

6 ,6+#,'

<' , '% & "+$'

%$', % #+4++ +--'

,%"''' ,6+# #,6+% "' 6 $#'' <' ,-- & "+% 4++ + "'% -+ & + 4 '

+ "'%-+ &+ $'6

#'' <'

,-- & "+$'

%$', % #4+++ $' 6#4<6" 4+'-'&'%6 '' <' , "' 4+++>% '

+>%''- &+''-+ &'$ &% &,

6# # &6 .. "''-+, $'',%6 + -$&%"#++"'%-+ &+% "'642# 4+#+"'%-+ &+4.3 +& #-'$ +'

"'%-+ &+#++"'%-+

&+% "'6#++,6,'

#4++% "'6 4 4" 4 +#4+ 4 , $'

6%'$64' '-4 & &&%#,%"% $ # +'%'$'%# " &4+'%+ + - 4 6#+,6% %'

,% "- +-'$+'

"'%-+ &+$'(($'+"'%-+ &+ "'6#,'

4'++% "'6# ,'- 4 " #4+#+,6+ '

>% +'-+ '$ &% &,

6# & 6 ./ +'"6#& '&6'--+ +, $'&%#' +- & "+'&%"#++%'"'4 $'

6 ,6+#,+ %+ '+% ' +'#,'

'+% %#+%'"' %% G% & ' H %'6#++G% & ' H4

4 '+,6+% "'6 ,6+ +& #+ % ,6-#+4'++%'"$#*'-% ,'%+#++64 4+ &# +6% -#+' +' & '-+''-+ 4+ &#++'& '-+ '-" + #,%" 6" ,6+% "' 6#++6" , + E &+% "' 6 .3 +"

#+& "

'""-+#'- ,6 +, $'&%% ,6+'7 #* '" 6# %%

&+'

"'%-+ &+#++"'% -+ &+% "'6#,'

#& "+$'

&%" +% "'6,'-" ++6#6 +,6+'+'% <''6

#'+<+% "' 6 + 6 ,'- + ''' & + --'

'6# ' + , 4 % % # + + ' +' 6>%''-+'-+ &'$ &% &,

6#++' >% '-+'

'-+#,$ ,6+'A'?@#%

'+ ?@% 6+ &#'+ ,% % #++ 4 ', ,'- +,&' &+>%'

?@#-'+&'- &%'"'',''6 +"#,%" 6 ' +",6+ '; -% '( #

.0 % <%#+'"- $ '% &% $'%'

# #

+ % < +4'+ & %# ,% " %'$6 % # # '" # + % $'% ,6 + ' ; -

&&& "6- $'6# , '6 &- "'(%''

# # (%''

& + $'

% %

<%#+' "''+# #+"' '"' & + ,'#+ +6 ,& +4'+* ' %

6#+ -++ '; -% #& +4'+ 4'- ""'4-'+%% 7 6#'&6#, 4'+ '%% %4'+4#, 6&+>'6 &+'

&'"''

+&''- & .: % ,

4& +4'+ .1

+"'% '%'

?@#'&6#'C# '

& 0.2130!

/0';.

--1,1!

/0';.

)4 8" 2 "9< = "

$ >"=*

2 9

8 $ >"=*