Bajaj Allianz General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Mohammad Rafiq @ Mohammad Rafi And Others
! "#$ % &''
()() **+( , # # (* -!
( "# '
./$'
!!"
$% 0(11($ (2+3 0(11($ (2+ ( $ /0#
% 5. 6'
6 # &'"
)"!'"* +"# " !!"
#( /" (!
/ 0% #"* +"#
"
"* +"#
44444 7 '
" !!"
6"7"7 !!("
0 "!
:#
,(!
" "!
"3"( # (- %3
'"
"#
"
"!* &"
(3"& ( +!"(- #(#(
,(!
#<
=(
"++
7%( +(
&(+%!"
2+#(
$&(+! +#*
"!!
'
3"
#%
* <
## "# "#
>
%-
"#
,(!(
#(#(
#(!!
"+#%"!
"!(8"#(
&"--"
",(?
@ &"--"
",( #& %3& '(,
%"--"# "
6(;( ,(!
+!"(- #(#(
2+#(
$&(+! +#*
3"
"++
7%( %,,
&(-
&(+%!"
=
A # #(-
#* &"--"
",(?
@ &"--"
",( ."
#"(!
,(
%
=&
#& * 6"- #* &"A* &"!(
" *<
#&
,"#,%!
".
A* &"--"
",(?
@ &"--"
",( =&
&"
(3"&
=
+
# ;"( 3(#"#(
6 0A "#
"#
# ";
%# '&
"
";
%#
B2 2+&
!*
,,
2'(,# %
;"( 3(#"#(
6 C
(
+"- "# .
&(3&
"&
3!(3 -"
(
B2 +&
&(# +
#
)&( '(#
%"(
( %!.
7%
#"=
0* 2+# * &"
(3"&
(
,,
(+!
"-
"!!3
=
%
"&
3!(3
((
-(
( ,( +("!
&!
,"-(!.
;%#
,%!,(!!
-(
%!#(-"#!.
9
"#
A
2+#(
A A*
9 3(#
"# !(+ 2#"#(
"#"%* C(#(+# &"!( "!!3
%,,
> -"
?%"
;"(
+"
"=
,"-(!.
&%3 "-
#"#-
! ;"
'(
,"-(!.
+!"(-
+
## @ >
%-
"#
+!"(- #(#(
#(!!
"!(8"#(
"-
+!"(- #(#(
##
,(!
#&( '(##
#"#- #"=( !(-( ".
;7+#(
+!"(- #(#(
;"
,"=
,(+#(#( % 3
=
#& '
(
'"
=
'! 3
3(#"#(
9 -(##
;%# (# "!!3
(# ,"! 9
6 C -(## !.
(
"(
(( !(+ * 3(#"#(
+#(,(+"# '
%!.
%
6"7"7 !!("
0 "!
:#
%+
"!!3
+!"(-
&(3&!.
D+(
+!"(- #(#(
-".
=(
!.
(-(
" "
#&( +"
,(!
'(##
#"#- #"=( !(-( ".
;7+#(
+!"(- #(#(
;"
-(7
7
+".
"#.
#"#
+!"(- #(#(
'
(
)&
!".
3( 9
,"+# "(
&(+! ( 6 C
!
=
;7+#(
& "!(
,,+#(
(( !(+
(# ;(
(
( !"#(
#-
(#(
!(+.
-(#* '
(
'"
=
'! 3
(
%,,
>
,"! 9 ;
3(#
3#
".
+!"(- #(#(
-".
=(
!.
(-(
?%"
!"
3
"#(* !!
'( (% ' ,"-
%
! " # $%&'(&)&*
"+ , # -
, . + /
/
0$$ * ,
" - 0$ ! ! /
! ! - 0$* ( ! / " ! ! 1 $ +- 0$* '
+!"(- #(#(
#(#(
<+!"(-"
D"-(
%"--"# "
6(;( E* C
"!& #"
E
"- B"
" E
+!
(
;%# ( !
#(#(
<+!"(-"
#*
+%- (
(( !(+ FD *
FD *
!(+.
FD * '
!(+ FD '
FD * '
!(+.
FD A
+!
(
;&"!,
:"
7% 3-
"#
#(#!
G2#"# $
3&H FD +#(,(
#"#-
%"(
I"-"
FD
!(+.
FD ,# &"( "3%- "
"!!
"#(* +!"(- #(#(
,(!
"!!
'
"( '"
"#
(
#%
* <
## "# "#
>
%-* 3"
," %
#(#(
<+!"(-"
#*
"(
#!.
"!!.
#*
#"(!
#&(
!( "33(
#&( '" " "!
;
,
" !!"
6"7"7 !!("
0 "!
:#
&" &"
"3%-
" !!"
#(
#(
(
,,
'!!
#&
"(
(%
"!* &"
(3"& '
3!.
"'"
* <
," %
## @ >
%-
"#
,(!(
+!"(- #(#(
#(!!
"!(8"#(
"-
#"(!
#&(
( !
;,
"!* &"
(3"& +"
",!.
!(
)&
!".
3( 9
)&
#&(
& #"!= 3" - -(
+"* 9 3(#
#"#-
%"(
'&
#
'(# ;
;,
"!* &"
(3"&
,"+#
% # 3" ;,
"3(#"#
%!#
"!!3
( "+?%(##
+&"3 ,"-
"3"( # &(-
+(-( +"
#"#-
%"(
FD
7% 3-
!(+ &"!!"
)<
"#
+(
#(#!
2#"#
FD
D"-(
"-
B"
" E
,"+# +%
'(#
"# #(-
)&
#&(
& #"#-
!(+
,"(!
( #&
'
3!.
+"-
+!%(
"!!3
#"=
%
"&
3!(3
((
# # (# +"
(
+"
#(;%# .
3!(3
"(
(%
"'"
&(3&!.
D+(
%# 7%#(,(+"#(
+"
%!.
(+&
'
3!.
"%-
-
#%
*<
#& #"=(
"++ +&(!
'
(,, !!3
,"+# -"=( ".-
;"-
;
#& * &"A* &"!(
#%
*<
#&
)&
#&(
&
&"--"
",(?
@ &"--"
",( - #"D ".
# #
( (
&"--"
",(?
@ &"--"
",( =(!!
#"(!
- & %!
&" ;
"
"++ 3!.
%#
'
3!.
3"
**<
"-"3 ,%#% - (+"!
D ;( "##
+&"3
"'"
+("!
(#
#%
*<
D+(
3"
**< "+&
"-"3 %,,(
- #"!
"3
"- (#(
+"
#&"
!"+
)&, *
"'"
A
-".
%+
"++ 3!.
"++ #( " "!
#&
#(
%#
=
%
"&
3!(3
((
F
#&'(*
& "!(
(( !(+ "
( FD
FD
3(#"#(
+#(,(+"# FD <
!(+.
FD <A
2'(,#
%!.
%
)&, *
+"
"'"
," %
(# !(";!
".
"-
#<
"3%
+" "
%!.
!"
"!
( '!!
%+(
+%-
%"--"# "
6(;( '(,
7%
#
'(# ;
E
#( +" 2&
%+
"3- FD
#";!(& & &%;"
".(
#&!.
*< %
#"(!
=&
#& ;"- #* &"A* &"!(
- !
.
#'
=&
&%;"
&"( ,!
%(&( ;%(
" *<
#& 2&
-((
!##* , +( #
& +&(!
& ;
#& &
%&""
&-"
"
&" &-"
"%3&# & ""
/&"#
'
#(3( % !!3
2&
;"
= ";
= FD
( ( ", "(
(3&#!.
(
#&!.
-
*<
#&
+#(,(+"#
,(! C
"!& #"
E* "++
%,,
> -"
"++
# )"%-"#(+ 6"(
7%.
+&
(- "(
-- .
"(
+#(,(+"# FD
#( ,"-(!.
%,,
3"#
"++
7%( %,,
&(+%!"
"3%
?%"
#%-
"'"
?%( #,
<+!"(-"
%#
,(! ##(-
"- B"
" E '&
"# #(-
3" "
,(-
%"(
'&
#
'(# ;
+(-( +" ;%#
%( + D"-( "#(
#%
& #(!
D"-( "#(
( +&(, +!"!.
(+"#
,%!!.
% #
3" '!!
#(#.
(
,,
"3%
,"+#%-
'!!
"&
3!(3
((
"#
3&
( %#
#
'(# ;
,"+#%-
"&
3!(3
((
"#
)&, * (# (3&#!.
&!
#"=
%
"&
3!(3
((
,(
3 3(
#"(
(%
?%( #,
" "!
,
-".
=(
!.
(-(
&"
(
"3%- "
;, -
+"
=
A "# ";
%# '&
&"--"
",(?
@ &"--"
",(
+
# 6
0A
'&
+ (
";
%#
B2 2+&
!*
,,
2'(,# ;"( 3(#"#(
6 C +"- (
B2 2+&
!*
(
"&!.
3!(3 #!.
"# &(3&
3&* &(# +
#
%!#
+(
( % 7%( +!% &"
7%.
#"=
- (+"!
!!3
(#"!* 2+# * &"
(3"& '& -"(
#"#-
" !!"
#
( %#
,(
3 3(
"!* &"
(3"& #"(
(% &
#"=
%
"&
3!(3
((
(
", "(
+"
(3
+
;7+#(
" "!
;
,
I"#(
/"%
=
;7+#(
#&
!".
3( 9
+
!.
"%#&
9
#
'(# ;
%# "(
- !"( %"(
"%#&
9 #%
& #(!
%( + 3
+(-( #("!
", "(
9
%!#(-"#!.*
(
"(
2'(,# "+?%(##
" !!"
#(
#"#-
%"(
+(-( +" FD
7% 3-
"+?%(##"!
"#
FD &"
(
", "(
#"
#"=
" !!"
#(
+"
D"-(
"- B"
"* .'(#
E '&
% #
3"
#"(!
+!"(- #(#(
&"
#& %3& #"#-
%"(
+(-( #("!
FD & '
D"-( "#(
( +&(,* %"(
,%!!.
% #
3" -"
'!!
#(#.
(
,,
'&
+"!!
+ D"-( "#(
",# 3"
";
%# #'
#&* (!
% # +%#(
+"
", "(
+!"!.
(+"#
%( #&( 3"
#'
#&* "(
'(# %"(
* %!#
% # +%#(
(
%( + D"-( "#(
!".
3( 9
'!!
D !"(
+"#3 (+"!!.
#"#
#"!= 3" - -(
;%# '&
(# %!
-"#("!(8 %!#(-"#!.* 9
3
A
#"#-
"- B"
" E -"(
;%#
3&*
+" ;(
(
,,
#
'(# ;
(
)&, * #&
"
(;!(
9
%!.
% #
D"-( "- B"
" E
('
-.
";
(+%(
,(
3(
#"(
(%
?%( #,
" !!"
#(
( %#
?%"
#%-
"'"
"!* &"
(3"& ( "'"
"#
?%"
#%-
%"--"# "
6(;(
'(,
7%
#
'(# ;
E
2& +"#3 (+"!!.
#"#
& &%;"
+(
( % 7%(
&(+%!" #* %!#
'&(+&* %,,
> -"
#"#-
- (+"!
!!3
(#"!* 2+# * &"
(3"&
D%
;(!! 3" %+&"
- (+( "
%+
,(!
"(
#"#-
;(!! 3" %+&"
- (+( "
( %#
" !!"
#(
+#(,(+"#
C
"!& #"
- (+"!
!!3
(#"!* 2+# * &"
(3"& E FD
#"!
"
> # )"%-"#(+ 6"(
7%.
+&
(- "(
-- .
"-
--
",# ,( ."
-
#"#-
C
"!& #"
E
#& %3.
#"=
A
(+&"3
A
C%( + D"-( "#(
+# +!"(,(
,% +#(
>
" ?%"
#%-
"%-
-
*<
#&
"!!3
7%
#"(!
,(
%
=&
#& 6"- #* &" A* &"!( "(
-( ' #"=
"3-
"#
FD
%"--"# "
6(;( E #"#
& &%;"
&(
#'
'&
' =(
"(
=&
%"(
"%#&
9 =
-
7%
,"#&
#'
"%3&#
"%3&#
66 &"
(3"& J ((#.*
%
#!
"
"3- '&"
#&
K
)
#";!(& #&( ,"+#*
-((
-* #(#.
(3( +( #
3" ".-
, "3%- "
" !!"
#( -
7%
"
'" &(3& (
%;#* #&
- #"D #%
(+# (
,( +("!
#"#%
7%
)&, *
'&(! "( -
7%
#"=
( "#(
"3- #* #"(!
&
%
&(- '!!
,"+# "!!
+&(!
'
(,, #(#%#
#&.
' #% .( '&
#&( ,"#& -#
&"
#"=
"++ ;"
= ";
=
FD & ' ,( +("!
#"
"+#(
= #(-
#(- )&, *
( ( ", "(
-
7%
(3&#!.
"
#%
*<
#&
(#
?%( #, )&",#* #"=( > ,% +#(
(";(!(#.*
(3&#!.
"
?%"
#%-
"++
7%( %,,
#%
* *<
3"
D
(#%
& (#"!
'!!
;(!! 3" %+&"
- (+(
#%
* <
?%( #,
;
(";!
#
!(,* #&, * ?%"
#%-
"'"
#%
**< "+&
&"
"(
%,,( 3* - #"!
"3
'!!
"- (#(
?%( #,
( ( #"!
(
#"#- % !
> ,% +#(
"'"
&"
+("!
(# '!!
#"
#"#(
+&"3 3"
#%
*<
*<
?%( #,
" !!"
#(
( %#
?%"
#%-
"'"
&"
"-"3 ,%#% - (+"!
D
(#%* ;( "##
+&"3
#%
**< &"
(
;7+#(
"(
(
'(!!
?%( (+
#'
"##
"# !"# (
."
+"!+%!"#( #&( "-
(
"+& "##
'(!!
+&"3 *<
#& #&% #"!
"- *< #'
"##
7%
'(!!
?%(
#& (
."
+"!+%!"#
"- **<
+"
(3
7%
&"(!
&"#.
'&
-#
%,,
> ,% +#(
'&
#( ,"-(!.
(#(
'(,
#& +&(!
' #"!!.
&(-
"++
7%.
%,,
&(- ";!
= ",# &(-!,
+"
+".
%# =
+#(,(+"# & ' %,,
;"(
7%.
+&
(- "(
-- .
( (
"#%
"(!- 7%
'(!!
?%( "##
'& !
#(-
)&, *
( ( ", "(
-.
"'"
&"
,%#% - (+"!
D
"##
+&"3
#%
**<
(#& D+(
7%#(,(
L9
('
-.
";
(+%(
,(
"
#,
?%"
#%-
"'"
," %
#<( 7%
%!#"
#!.* " "!
,
" !!"
# "++ 3!.
+!(
" !(+"#(
* (, .* &"!!
#"
&
+(
;"+=
+
?%"#
2 )!
E&#& "=( 3<"
B<1
E&#& #";! B<1