High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/9237/2023allowed

Gopal Singh And Others v. The Bhakra Beas Management Board And Others

2023-11-15Mr. Justice Jagmohan Bansal18 pages

#$% $& $!'$$

$& $!

( )*** *

)

& + &,, --

./ 0,12 23

4,,3

536

2 %273 % 819 %3 23

4!.

)

#13 0,12 23

4,,3

536

0 + 6:;

4!.

)

#3,/ 0,12 23

4,,3

536

%273 % 819 %3 23

4!.

)

06,/ &6 23

4,,3

536

%273 % 819 %3 $23

4!.

)

=,3.

0,12 23

4,,3

536

%273 % 819 %3 $23

4!.

)

(8)

$36 0,12 23

4,,3

536

%273 % 819 %3 23

4!.

)

#13 !9 23

4,,3

536

0 + 6:;

4!.

!$8

>%?

8!- # 0

#$ 8$ %$0$?

!"#$%#&#$'

(

) !*+,*#&##'

( -

!+#*."#&#$'

/ !#&$&*#&## !#"+++#&## 0 !++1+$#&#$'

) 2

(( (

4 4

5 6

- )7 -2 )8

4 97 :::

#$ 8$ %$0$?@ #- (3/)

44 87 ; < 87 8

= 4 ##,>##%

6 < +& &$ #&#$ ? #+' +* &$ #&#$ ? ##' #+ &$ #&#$ ? #$' 87 4@ 8 )

= (< ( ( A%3A' 4@

4 3 #>#&+1

4 ; B44

>B4 9 C - 44 44 7 4 666 0 6/ 47 =

; B44

>B4 = 8 4 44

44 4

47 6 44

4 )

7 8 4 8 ? 7 = ) 4 47 ? = 4 )8 6

( B7 ( 2 6 = ( <

$$D 47 47

)8 97 94 )

= 4 $ 7 E ( 4@ = (

4@ 6 7 47 7 8

44 8 4

C 8)

8 4 4 4 47 44 8 = 4@

87 7 8 &* +# #&## ? #&'

= ( 4< 87 < 6 4

( +& &$ #&#$ #+' 87 E 8 4

F 4 8 4 (G E ( 47

4 8 4@ 4 8) 87 8 6 8 ( 8 47 7 8

44 = 47

7 7 8 4@ = ( 44 4 4 87 )8 44 )8 F A0?G' 7 4 47 = )8 F 4@ 47 4 $ 7 4

7 8 4@ =

4 47 F<

87 #&+" 4 #&+"

4 ? ?

7 8

4 47 = 4 47 4 447

7 8 = ) 9G84

44 4 =

87 8< 7 = 4 ? )

! "# $"!$ # % % !# # $"

& "&' ( )& '*& $"! % $ ( )%( )

$ "# $"!$ %!&%%

""$ $ ' "" $"$& "

$% ! & "" + ""$ ""$ $

% &&$ ""$ ! %& #

$% $%

,$!

$"! $"!

$ # $ "$ -"! $ ""$+ # $!# $"!$"! %&%* $ #! $ ""$ % # ## #& ' $"$ $! & & ""$ % $ #! %& "

' &#!' + " "' & $ $"!$"! % " $"!$ $ $"! %#!'! ""$ !&.& & ( !

# " & "$

$ % $ &! $

$/!# $"! ' % % '

# & $"!$0 " 1&$ % #! &## #$"$ ' +

.&$!#1

& $

$! $"! "" &

$!#"

# $ $ $! "1 %# $ % $ $"!$ % " & " $" ,# "!&$"!% ! $ # &! !% $ &$

#! , $ $ ' $

#!"

& ! $ 0 ,

4 4 ( 8 447

44 4

7 8 4@ 8 4@ 47 F )8 8 ( 87 8 87 4 4 44 87 )8 F = ( <

47 44 4 8 = 87 ( 4< 8 8 ( 4@

6 4 4

3 # #&+1

8E = ( 8 <

44 44 4 4

4 47 = 47

6 44

4 447

8 7 ?84 E =

47 7 8 3 + #&+"

44 = 47 < 87 ( 4 4 8 4< = ( 447 E 4@ 47 8 8447 = ( 44 4 4 87 )8 44 F ( 8 87 8 44 44 4 4

87 )8 44 F = )8 44 F 4@ 47 447

8 = +"##

#&+*+.

44 484 4 4 (

44 8

4 47 6

4 447 47 44 8 87 (< ( ( 4666 0 46/ B 47H 0

' 4 +""1 A !16/,G' 44 4 4 87 ( = 447

8 8 ? =

< ( #&+* 47>4

8 = ( < 4 44 4

= ( 4@

= E 4@ 8

( < 87 #& +# #&+" 84 +$

) (&

/& 2*2 /&$2 34 +$ ) 25 ) /&6 +$

) 7& ' $"! %*&

# 22/2 ((& #1 % " # 2 ) $& ) $ ) *$ ) ," , !

# # & &

/$#3.6 && %##

" /$# 38' +9%6 $$# " (

% &-2/&0 3"! / $ ) ) $&

)

: , ! 22/2 )9 ;29 ;

);)9/;($4 ) 3(""-9<9)6 (

&!(&% " # 2

$& ) ) * $ ) 3(""-9<9 6 =

/$# 31#6 $" ' (& # " " # 2 %& " &$"! " ' "

",' " $"! #&>0 ? /$# 3.!6 % *% - )$& 2@ ( #

% " "

$" ' "" #! /$# 31#6 &% )$& 2 + '% * 2 $& #' (& &" =9 2 *& + $ & $"% " #! 22/2 %

22/2 ) )2$&

)A B ) " '! + $& # % % $ " $&!

$*%! $"! &CA/" %.

,# ,

4$ " $" > &" " #!22/2? % $& * #B!&$"! &CA/ %.

,#9,

A4$ (""%* 22/2 % ! "%

4$ #!% ( #

%& % * ) $& B )3 )

6#!2=9 22/2 && $"! # " 3 6 & "

$&"' 22/27& ) " ! - ! % "' - " $ .%' , "'&

% " !"

" # # &' $" $ "!$;

-$$ # "!D& "!D4( ) ) )0

3"! / $ )

)$& B )

' , ! 22/2 9)B;29 ; );)9/;($4 ) 3(""-9<9 6 ( " ""'

#! 2 > ,

, $$ 3,,6 22/2 $"% & " 3 6 ' & - ! ! #

"' 22/2

+++A+:$"! 7& ) $ & " $" #! % ' $ # '& " A $ " + "$ $ & $"! % %;# ' $ ,# !

" %* $ $$ . 4"$ &&%*A

;

' '#- $ $$A & ' & $"! & > ,

, $$ 3,,6 " (""-9<9 /! $"! '$ $" !

' "(""-9<9B&?E )9)+ #& $$# $ $"! %*&

" # ' & " $"

"!&$"CA/ "1 .%' '% ! # $"! &&

*& "

"" , $"! '# $' " 9 ! ' $"% 22/2 % # " $"! &>22/2+ #& $$# 22/2# $ $ & '% ) " 3B - &D

&' #!!

3 " (""-9<96(

' $"! #! %& "" " $ " 22/2 7&

) $! # & $" ! F ' 22/2

( #!/$#31#6& $& ) ) " & $"! " "

",' " $"! #& 3 # 6 " (""-<9 A<9 + #$8' .$ 4" 3(9+++6 &>& '

"" "G73(6923 69);

) ) )3(""-9<96 7 !

,H' ))) )3(""-9 <9) 6

""' & '

# H$ %% 7( );)

$ $" " ! " I"& '%

& !& $"% &"" $" # '& $

; " $ #! 22/2 $

% " ! 8' .$ &> ""

2$!*! # $&" !

& ' $"!

$" ! " ' ? ! $ #' ,#$ A""'" JJJJ JJJJ JJJJ / /& +$

)

! " # $!% & # # ! ' (()( ," , !# !-"(& $ " "' 2/& '#&' /$#;. $$"! .

# &>

# ! /$#;71 &

""$ % # 3! ! *! 6 $" $& ' "" $ % *% % ""

% & "

4 ;, !

22/2 $ "" $ " "" # $ &$"!

% $"! # # ' " $ $"!

! /$#;.! *% !

$ & $"! % 4 ;, ! " $

&$"! (

% $" &>& $"! #"" -$-2$&0 +&

6 #$* ( 8 44 6 47 47 7 8 = 4 ? +$ B)B 7&> ' $"! %*&

# 22/2 JJJJ JJJJ JJJJ 1#,7 % 7 A7& 1#8'"" #22/2 ' $"! &

&! 1# 8' '

3(""-996 %% " ! && - ' #! B ! ; ! &% )

7 &% & ' ' ' ( "

" &

#!" #&'! % &"#% ' " %&% "

&$ !$& & $"!

#& $"! %*& - $$ # 3+!" 8! " 4( ) ) )6 " ! 3(""-9 9 6 & $"! %*&22/2'" *&

! * ! &' $ '! $ % - %+!" 8! 4( ) ) )%

" 4( )K )

) 3(""-996 + "$$ $"! ' # $ &#;'& ""! ! 8' 1# $"! ' # $ -" " ' " 22/2 "1

% # "

' 22/2 " "'& 4( %

& & *#!2 " I"&'% -"#' "" =9 ) ! $"! #!

-& $$ " "'& 4( # 3+!" 8!" 4( " "'& 6 &> *#!2 ,# 4( & $$$#! 8'$ #$

# $"! # " " '!

$"$ $

& =4(

# "

# $

JJJJ JJJJ JJJJ (

2 & $$ $"! %*&

# " 2F * ) $& #! K 3+ ! " 8!6 " % !%*& % $$

9$ $ $ %' %"'!& $"! &> + % &$ & # @G $ $$ $"! %*& # 22/2@ ++

; 4 ( E ( 47 8

47 I 47 7 8

44 4 4I 7 47 8 7

47 7 4 4 47 7 )8 4 4 4 47 7

( 9G84 * + ,

-#!.

/ /

0 1,%4 4

4 47 4847

4 8 8 4 47 4 <

8 47 44 4 4 +1 6 = L$ 4' 3 "6

4 47 87 8< 7 4

4 +1 6 = 4 ? ) (1,&3 "6 J) ?$ #' % G ! 2 % & (

(

+ #& ) " ' !$ ")" &# " '

$ % ' $ % "# #!# ,' $$

"! % % M B K & "! ""$ # )B + ' $ " (

(

+ " '

& % %89 ,9 ) ,9

) C29 ) G-9,' $ 89 ) 4 # " 3H%: 69 )39)" 6

% ' '% % ) " " , & # ,' $$

#&B K &"! 7

# ! ! -#!9 9!# & *#!G !2, " !$ $"!$ " # #!'' ( ) +

) + $ "!$ M B K & "! ""$

# % ' $#! , . # ,' $$

& 1 "'

$ & "! &

' .& & & ' "$

# + % & ' "" # % &' #

" "'"" % & ""$ $ ""$" %! "#"'$%

# 0 KB

4L +$

= 8847

44 4

4 4

4 47 = < #&+* 7 4 47 784 4 47 = ( 47 @ 8

47 484 4@ 8 7

44 7 47 = 8) 4 4

484 4 47 4 7 4 47 = 8 4 47

47 E447

= ( 4@ 8 8) 87 8 (

4 4 =

( E 8 7 44 8 ) = )

L$4'3 "6 7 (

) 4 8 4@ 8 7

87 8< 7 =

47 44 44 4 4 = ( 8 87 8 44 4 4 44 87 )8 F 4 4 87 F 8 ( 44 4 4 44 87 F

6 < 8 )

8 44 47 44 = 87 = ( 4@ 44 47 7 7 4 8

> 4 47 = 44 8 4 44 E4 8 7 7 44 8 4 7 4 8

4' 7 4

(#$ 8$ %$0$?)

# &

-- /I$ "*&; E ; "# E ;