High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/982/2004disposed of

Maha Singh Arya v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2016-08-24Mr. Justice Augustine George Masih8 pages

! "#

$

% ' "(&)*

++

- )!.!

'

!+"/

0

1 )' "(&(( )2 ,31 )' "(&(( )2 , & (2

++

- )!.!

'

!+"/ %#45%'55

55 67) ,8

!"

# $ %&'( )"

"

)" " # #

)" # * "&+ &, -.%%"/

0 )"-%./1223 # " - %+ "

"

" )"# " ## --(-+ (44 0 )" !

+.

&/ -..- # 5 "

)" /- 6+'()"

!" "-% # %&'()"

!"

" "# !"

# # " # +- -- -..7!"0 8 6&+ -..719

# *

3

#"

!" # 5 "$%&'()"

1 :# 3 # " # )" +- -+ -.%;1<= -3 -- -- -.%;1<= +3

+%+'( +7-'()"

!"#"

# # "!"" 4" " ) 9 "-!'

6 ."9 : "/ ; .)1.<& ' "(& -! ."9 : '

"/ )6 ."9 : (&.)

" " " # )" > 8 %;+&&619 ? *

3 # +& -- +&-,!" # # %&'()"

-/&'()"

-+@ "#" " #

!" 9

# 1" "# # $-/&'()"

8 "#

4 " " A4"# " " !" "( =& > .,,*"! / & !, "

"

"

/> /:* ,

)"

/."!

, ) +

"

)!:.

!2 &.

"* /.:

6 +

"

)!& +.)& "/ "?.

"+) ) !!.

":.

!

!" !.

)/

!

1."

2& && !:

"+

> "/)!" "& "/, )( &."< "/&

,)

/*:

" (> )"1 6 !1 ,,+) "

2& &2 ! /,

)"6

) )/ "( 1+ "!

"& ,)

/*:

"!

"4:, (& .) 6 !/ !.!!

:> ) & !)

!" )

2, //2" " !.+) ) .

&)

! !"

++, :,

! "/ ).1!

! ! "

"/

@

+ "( " > 2 :> / !.!! "! "/

9./(1 > ! " "& .)"4:, (&.) "

)

++

,0

$

/( )! -! '

"/ )! / / "

$6 2& & ,! )

! 1 , ) , "/ ,! .

/ " ! 1 , )

"/& > "(! 1 , )+

*6

)<

+) /, "/ !

! AB+ !?.

* )/& ! !!.

! &.!/ )/ "(,*C B " !" ## $%&'()"

!" 9

# 1" 3 " B

(5!" "/ 9

#

" -, -+ -.%+ # # 5 " )"

+ -.%%

",C !" " # )" 9 ? *

1" 3 # -/&'()"

-+@"#" #

)" )"#

# $-/&'()"

!" 9 ? 1" 3 # " # )" ! " /

" &+ &, -.%% ( + -+ -.%;1<= -3" # " -5 +%+'( )"

05 -- -- -.%;1<= +3 ( :# " # " ;# +7-'()"

( 1B-3

" =" + -+ -.%;1<= -3 < #,-( "

=" "#

)"

"

# "

" 8

!"= "

4 # "

DA!"A 8 1" 3 ( "

#" # "

DA "( ;E < "( "

"! /

" ,,

$

! "/ "

>

:,* ) !) "( 2&

! "2 9./ ,,* (" !

!!1 )

"

,(.

!!2)<62 >

2&,

."/ ) ?. !

" 72 &

+ ""

/:

,286"21+) !

/ "'

"$1.!

:

!!

!!

."

)1)

! + )!?.

* )/",*

!)/ )/ "(,* " + "6&2 > )6 ! :

2 ( )/ "/1+) !

/ "@& !) !0;

"/0;

+.)& /:*& ) )< !&!" <& '& "5 ,!" > 1> / !

/

/!E& :

!FDA$

"/FDA;6 & "/!" @ !&) 5 , "/

+ & "/!" & "/> / !

/

/!E& :

!FDA

"/FDA6&

" !!!" ./&. "/.)/ !" %

1> / !

/

/!E& :

!FDA 6F DA 6FDA "/FDA0F &) ( )/

"!

)!

)"

/ !

./( & /6

) E& .!

>

/ !.!! "61 ,,2 "(",.! "#B G > / & !:

", ) !+"/ ! "

:.

, ,

/1 !.!+

)/.:

( ". "

!!

"!

"! !

6

6 " :!

!.&

> / ) ) !+"/ ! "/ "> 2 ,,

."/!

"6&,/ ,, !

/

/! !( ". "

"!

"! > / " "(+ *1 !

"! /

" "

!&:* >

! > "/)!G &

"/ "( & ! " :

" ) 1

,* "( / " :

'

> )2 !

" 1 "

"

/ /.1

> / 2 !

")

!"

< /

> 2 )1

"

)) > /

:* ,

)"

/ !

./( " & !

"

6

6 !"+ ":.

.+&,/ !

"/ ! )/ "(,*6 )/ /

>

! :> "

/!& ,,:

.

, 1."

+ /:*

;

> "/)! "/

/ " ) !+

> !

B/

/!

"/ "(!

)"

/ !

./( 2 &) ( )/

!

& :*

)1 /C 5 "#"5 1" 3!"

# = " )"F =261 "( !+

/

)1 "

"

)<

> ,.

/6 ! :

"

++ 2"

/ < ,! , "/ " > ,, (

@ :

2& && !:

" / & /+.)& & !

)1'&) % "%& " 9FB> / !

/

E& :

B"

;

) "! /

" !D

AB & ++ ++

/ " 2 !!B:E !FB )):)

& !

& !" > / " ) )/

!&2

"! /

"1 "

/ " !

/

/ !

.!) ((

/"

" > / ) :.

! F "/F & !:

"+)/.

!+"/ & ,

)"

/ // "

, !

./( &

)(.1 > )"1 ,

)

> )2"

/, )(

!+!! :,

"

+) 2 !!&2" " !

/

/E& :

& ! !1 ,* "9

.) ," & ! ++

,2 " "

)"

/2 &

!.:9

) "

"/

;F

"

)"

/2 & < ,! "/2& &2 !+.)& /:*

++ ) "! /

" !D

AB6 :.

1"

&!:

"

"."/ )'

" 2 ! !!.

/ !2 ,,!

"/2"

) ! :

1+ "!

+)

& & ! + / +.)& ! "( , "/ 2& & & ! ,

) :

" / 6

6"! / ) ++)+)

E )<

> ,.

< ,! "/2"

++

!D

ABC 8 "

" # A" #

)"

( # )"

"" " "

!" <= - <= + "

"

"

!)"

# !"

( # $ +%+'( +7&'()"

" #

# +/ &% +&-7 7558

B 5 ' G'8 B G'8