Kunal Verma v. State Of Punjab Etc.
!"# $#%&'&()#*+,!+-./ 0 1,(!23#+4!
5 "!"# ,(6!*!($"7#+'
)
+#'#(") + &28+##"&(97/$5%!"# + +(,+!9++!/$5%!"# +"7#8#"&"&(#+ +'7&'7!(97&/ #8,"-$5%!"##(#+!2/,(6!*
!"# +!2 ) ("7#8+#'#("8#"&"&( &2#$,($#+#%"&( :
+/"7# 8#"&"&(#+ '##;' "7# &(5#'"&9!"&( &( . $!"#$ < / +#9&'"#+#$ !" 2&%# "!"&( !&*=!2/ &'"+&%" >,$7&!(!/ ,($#+ #%"&('< ?@< /2!"#+(!$$#$#%"&(<
/ +4'4# &($#8#($#(" !9#(%-/ !2(9 =&"7 %!22&(9 + "7# '"!",' +#8+"'/ %("#($&(9"7!""7#!%%,'#$7!5#("*##(!++#'"#$' !+ 7#8#"&"&(#+1,(!23#+4!&'+#'&$&(9&(,'# >/ 2%;/ ,"7 &"-/ -!2& 17,+$/ >,$7&!(! &"- !2(9 =&"7 7&' 8!+#("'/*+"7#+!7,23#+4! '&(%#$#%#!'#$ !($'&'"#++&-!(;!
3#+4! 7#4!++&!9# +&-!(;!=!' &A#$ +
!($"7#
8+#'#("8#"&"&(#+!2(9=&"77&'8!+#("'7!$9(#,""$&'"+&*,"# "7#4!++&!9#%!+$'"!*," 84/"7#%482!&(!("+#%#&5#$!%!22
+47&'*+"7#+!7,2&(B,&+&(9!'"=7#("7#-=,2$%4#*!%; 74#C7#(!" .84"7#%482!&(!("+#!%7#$74#/7#'!="7!" 7&'*+"7#+!7,23#+4!=!'2-&(9&("7#;&"%7#(7!5&(9','"!&(#$ '#5#+!2'"!*=,($'("7#'"4!%7/&(6,+&#'(7#!$!($2#9'!($ 2" *2$=!'D&(9," "7'#&(6,+&#'&''&'"#++&-!(;!7!$ !2'',
#+#$&(6,+&#'(7#!$!($2#9'7#%482!&(!("*+,97"! %!+"+#45#7&'*+"7#+!7,23#+4!!($'&'"#++&-!(;!" / >,$7&!(! ("7#=!-/!7,23#+4!=!',""#+&(9E!88-$(" *#!"/!88-$("*#!"F "#+ #=7,+'/!7,23#+4!',%%,4*#$ ""7#&(6,+&#'=&"7,"4!;&(9!(-'"!"#4#("""7#82&%#>!"#+(/ "7#'"!"#4#(" +&-!(;!=!'+#%+$#$!
"#+!*,""7+##4("7'
=7#+#&('7#$&'%2'#$""7#82&%#"7!""=8#+'('7!$!""!%;#$ 7#+G(#=!'7!5&(9! =&"792$#(7!($2# 7#!''!&2!("' =#+#=&"74,
2#$ !%#' "#+"7#+#9&'"+!"&( "7#/"7#82&%#7!5#*##( &(5#'"&9!"&(9 "7# %!'# +4 $&
#+#(" !(92#' >!+9# (,4*#+
8#+'('7!5#*##(!''%&!"#$ #5#+!2'"!",'+#8+"'7!5#!2' *##( &2#$*# +#"7&',+"*," +!24'"4+#"7!("=-#!+'/"7# 82&%#&',(!*2#" &($,""7#%,28+&"'(+"7#-!+#!*2#"8&("," !(-2#!$=7&%7%,2$2#!$"7#4""7#!88+#7#('&( "7#%,28+&"' 7!5#7#!+$2#!+(#$%,('#2 +"7#8!+"&#' "%4#',""7!" +4"7#8#+,'!2 "7#&"'#2 "7!"( +**#+-=!'%44&""#$ 7#4!++&!9# +&-!(;!/'&'"#+ "7#
< 8#"&"&(#+/ =!' &A#$ !
"#+ #= $!-'/ &#/
!($ "7# %%,++#(%#";82!%#( *#"=##( " .84("7&'
%!'#/ ( +**#+- =!' %44&""#$ + !""#48"#$ " *# %44&""#$ !%"''7="7!"!"2#!'"!88-=!';(=(""7#$#%#!'#$!7,2 3#+4!!($"7!""7#4"&5#8 "7#%+&4#=!'"4,+$#+!7,23#+4! !7,23#+4!+#%#&5#$ '"!*=,($'!($!2'! +!%",+# 2#9 =7#+#!'+&-!(;!+#%#&5#$"7+##&(6,+&#'("7#7#!$!($("7# &($#A &(9#+7#&("#("&( "7#!''!&2!("'=7=#+#'"!"#$"*# =&"74,
2#$ !%#'/!88!+#("2-=!'"#(',+#"7!"!7,23#+4!$&$ ("',+5&5# "',99#'"'"7!"&"&'!%!'# 8#+'(!2#(4&"- 7# 82&%#7!'&(B,&+#$"7#%!'# +4$&
#+#("!(92#'*,"!+#,(!*2#" 8&(","=7=!'"7!"!88- ("7#'#%&+%,4'"!(%#'/!4 "7#5&#="7!""7#82&%# 7!'+#!%7#$"7#$#!$#($7#+#B,#'" "7#"!"#,('#2"7!"
%!22$#"!&2'!+#*#&(9#A!4&(#$!($ +"7!"8,+8'#'4#4+#"&4# *#9&5#(/&'("!%%#8"!*2# 7# 82&%# 7!5# "!;#( "= -#!+' " #A!4&(#"7#%!22$#"!&2'7&',+"7!'%4#""7#%(%2,'&("7!" "7#&(5#'"&9!"&( "7#%!'#&'*#&(9%($,%"#$&(!+,"&(#4!((#+ 7#+# +#/"7&' ,+"&' "7#5&#="7!""7#&(5#'"&9!"&( *-"7# ,(6!*2&%#7!'+#!%7#$!$#!$#($!($(4+#8+9+#''%!( *##A8#%"#$ (5&#= "7#'#%&+%,4'"!(%#'/!4 "7#5&#="7!"
'4#"7#+#A8#+"!9#(%-&'+#B,&+#$"&(5#'"&9!"#"7#%!'#&(! 8+ #''&(!24!((#+ 7#+# +#/&(5#'"&9!"&( "7#%!'#*#!+&(9 . $!"#$ < / 2&%# "!"&( !&*=!2/ &'"+&%"
>,$7&!(!/,($#+#%"&('< ?@< /2!"#+(!$$#$#%"&(<
/&'=&"7$+!=( +4"7#,(6!*2&%#!($&'#("+,'"#$""7#/ #%"+< /7!($&9!+7""!;#"7#&(5#'"&9!"&("!29&%!2#($ 7#8#"&"&('"!($'!22=#$!%%+$&(92- H
!"I #*+,!+-./ 0 !