High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/41290/2016allowed

Yadwinder Singh Etc. v. State Of Punjab Etc.

2018-07-19Dr. Justice S. Muralidhar7 pages

!"#$%$ &' ( )

' *+, ,-

!"#$ %&'(# )' *'

#+# ##"$ $ ,+#

#%# #% $ %&'(# )' *'% '- ,-./+0 *' ,% (' ./- ') 0'% ') 01#"

'(%, # )"% )' 2,# ! ') '-3 %#% 4567-64.

!% ,% (' 8-.$ 8. ') %# #" 0'% 9)' ' : 0:;$ # '"( #' <')##$ ( # %# #% #"" ('2,#"

*'(%! #! )'1$ ' # ') ('1*'1 #&% #

*# % '% %#% 4/44-64>$ *# = %(% ' #**#

)' "#% #" 0',?""#2# #!#$ )' !! #1 ('%%@ # ' !, ') ('1*'1 ('1*"#( ')$ *' ') , &'#" ,%(#"

#!#$ #"=#% # ' %#%

-/68-64/$ # (&%$ = $ # '(% # *#

#& "% %*, #1(# "A = ', #A ,%, )",($ ('(' ' *, #% ' ') #((,% #& %("#% # *'("#1% '))% ,"1# #1$ '

+(& #% !'#" ') # "!#" A1 '

('(" '(#" (')"( B#= 2,% '"A ' , # *'*" %'

' #& ' )!

= #( ' +, ' *'( !

' *'*A$ !

' ") #% "

A #% ' !

(,% ' 1 "!#" A1 (&" %*, # (')"( = =' *#$ #&! " '&' )' '(#" '%$ '(#"

#1'A ' '(A # ,( ( # '", )%'1 !& ' *# ' " %*, A ('1*'1$ ') (',$ ('1! = (# "!#" ('2,( # ="" '=&$ (1#" %*, %' ' (#"A ( 1"& ' '"A =' *# ' %*, 1 ') ('*$ ('2,( #% ))( (1#"

#( % ' (# ))( #% ('2,( & ,*' '(A # "#! )'$ "#= *( *, 1$ & *, 1 #% C1 *, 1$ (",%! %# *#"A )' (1#" #(

'=&$ 1' ') ' (&" %*, ' D (')"( ') =' *# #)'1 1"& ' (1#" #*( )'$ "!#" A1 *"#A 1* ' '"& (')"( = ='

*#@ = #%%% # ') ,! # #%& 1*#( ') %*,

2,# '(A # "#! 11E% , "" (' %# ' '"& (')"( = =' % A *,! ' )'$ & (1#"

"#= 2,% ' !& %, !#% ' = ') *# ' %*, ('!E! *(*" '"A$ %# "!#"

A1 #"' *'&% )' ('!E! ('1*'1 = =' % ') # (1#" %*,

(' 8-6 00 # C* *'&' !#% (' ' '"A *'&% )' ('1*',%! %,! #"$ , *1 ('1*',%!

& # #**""# ' &'#" #! '=& A &A #, #% ('*$

(' 8-6 00 (#' '" *''A@ = ('!' ' # ('1*'1 *# #&@ (#"A@ '

(')% (' "# '"A ' '))( *( % ,% %# #" 0'% # # "' 1' '))( *( % ',% 0 & ' '))( C! 0 = %1' # #%%% )'1 1 ' 1$ 1# ! C! '))( '

' ! #% & = 1'%#" ') *'') ') '))( # ! ('!% &= ') ( '"'!(#" #%&#(1 (# #% 2, % )' "'' !

A'% (' 8-6 00 ' ('! ('1*'1 *# ' %*, , '

1## #(A ') *'(%, *( % )' (1#" #"@ #"

0', (#' *1% ' #&"

A'% ('* *( % ,% # *'(%, ( % )' &' !

(' ./- 00 !

0',

,$ # '

&% # '&$ = ') '"A *# ' (1#" %*, =',"% ' #"=#A ,))( ' 1# # (1#" #"

&= ') *#$ "# ' , " ))(@ ('%,( =',"% #& ") 2,# '(A # "#! )' ')( ('11% A *' &'"&% !'&#( ' #%1#' )' #(2,! '))(#" *'= ' = " C(! '))( *'= (#' *1% '

('1*'1% B =$ & ')( &'"&! '"A =' *&# *'$ , )"(! %*#&A ') ( ##( ' &'"&! (#,! '#" "' ') ") ' (#,! '#" "' ') *'*A A C%! 11 # ') "' ') ")@ (#' *1% '

('1*'1% C(* # '&D 1'% !#& '))($ &A #' # #"" ' '))( ',"% *1% '

('1*'1% 0', ( *'') ') '))( )' 0',$ #!# =',"% &'"& ('%,( ') *# '

%*,$ )' ) 0', %' ' *1 #1 '

('1*'1% *# =',"% % ' *"#A ( ,*' 0', ' , #(2,#" ') #((,% A , &! #%1#' ') (1#" +,( % & ') #%1#' ') (1#" +,( ' )'( (E ' "# #% #%'* ( %!% '

*"#A% ,*' 0', ' , & +,( A1 ' =',"% #"=#A ') +,( ")@ # ('1*'1 *# ('!E% #% (E 1# 1''% #% ('11% ' #" ') A1 ')

#%1#' ') +,($ # "#$ 2,# ' '))($ = ( ') '(A %' ' *1 '

('1*'1%

" ,*1 0', # #1*"A ("#)% "!#"

*'' ' ('!E! ('1*'1! (# ')

!"#% # '

&% # ,%D

! "

%&'

(

)*+ ,

(

!("

( - "

(

.- -

(

(-(

. 0

(

( *

(

- -

(

( -

(

# "

(

+ ,

(

3 * (# %' ' )#"" #A' ') C(*' &#!% # '& ($ &= ') *' ') , &'#" ,%(#"

#!#$ #"=#% # ' %#% -/68-64/ 1#% *,,#( ') '% %#% 4/44-64> *#% 0',$ 0', )" # ' ,)," *,*' =',"% &% A *! *'(%! #"& =""

') +,($ ) "1 #( % *# #((*% (('%!"A$ * *' #""'=% '-3 %#% 4567-64. !% ,% (' 8-.$ 8. ') 0 # '"( #' <')##$ ( # %# #% #"" ('2,#" *'(%! #! )'1$ ' # ') ('1*'1 #&% # *# #

A 2,# % 2,# * *' / ,-0 ( ) & *# ! ? #'% '

*'# " '