Rampal v. State Of Haryana




   


 


 

  







     

 

 








     

 

 








     

   


  

  







     

  


  

  !

 

  
 

 



      

 

 
   !" 



  

 

 



   



 



  

 " 

#$%$%&'#(  )*+),  -.&  %/  0)1%'2  $(%),  %' 
 & 34  5)$#5  (#2%/$#(#5)$ &,%1#$)$%&')5)( &.$)78'5#(#1$%&'!4"" ""6!3)'5 
(#)5-%$.#1$%&'9:6:"&0(*/1$

& !45)$#54  !(#2%/$#(#5)$ &,%1#$)$%&')(-),)8'5#(#1$%&'/ !!6!4!3444  ""6"""!"9" !!"9"""" 
)'59:6:"&0(*/1$":!:6&0;+,&/%<# 8=/$)'1#1$":!&0 

1$)'54 "&0$.# ',)-08,1$%<%$> ?

(#<#'$%&'@1$
& !35)$#53  !(#2%/$#(#5)$ &,%1#$)$%&'

)(-),)%/$(%1$%/)(8'5#(#1$%&'""!""!
)'5
& !"5)$#5 3  !(#2%/$#(#5)$ &,%1#$)$%&')(-),)%/$(%1$%/)(8'5#(#1$%&' ""!" 
*&<#/$.#/#+#$%$%&'/+()>%'20&(%'$#(%*=)%,0&($.(## -##7/$&+#(0&(*(%$8),/)'51#(#*&'%#/0&(.%/*&$.#(-.&5%#5&'3  



#)('#5/#'%&(1&8'/#,)++#)(%'20&($.#+#$%$%&'#(/8=*%$$#5$.)$ $.#(%$8),/)'51#(#*&'%#/&0$.#5#+)($#5/&8,.)<#$&=#+#(0&(*#5=>$.# +#$%$%&'#()//&'&'  "

 )$&'#+)$ 
$%/.%//8=*%//%&'$.)$)'> &=A#1$%&'#*)')$#50(&*$.#$)$#-%,,.)<#$&=#+8$)/%5#1&'/%5#(%'2$.# +%&8/&=,%2)$%&'(#/$#5&'$.#/.&8,5#(/&0$.#+#$%$%&'#($&+#(0&(*$.&/# 1#(#*&'%#/ .#(#/+&'5#'$1)'#00#1$%<#,>1&'$(&,$.#1(&-5%0)'>$.)$ 2)$.#(/  58(%'2  $.#  +#(0&(*)'1#  &0  /81.  1#(#*&'>  =>  $.#  +#$%$%&'#(  %$  %/ /8=*%$$#5

"

#)('#5  55,    )(>)')  <#.#*#'$,>  /8=*%$$#5  $.)$  $.# +#$%$%&'#(.)/),)(2#'8*=#(&00&,,&-#(/0(&*<)(%&8/$)$#/ <#'58(%'2$.# 1&8(/#&0$(%),1&'581$#5=>$.#$(%),&8($8/%'2$.#<%5#&1&'0#(#'1%'20)1%,%$>

0&,,&-#(/&0$.#+#$%$%&'#(5&1)8/#(8178/&8$/%5#$.#A)%,+(#*%/#/-.#(#$.# $(%),%/=#%'21&'581$#5  &$&01&**&$%&'%/=#%'21(#)$#5=>$.#0&,,&-#(/&0 $.#+#$%$%&'#( 
$%/.%//8=*%//%&'$.)$$.#+#$%$%&'#(1)''&$=#$)7#'#<#'%' +&,%1#18/$&5>$&&'#+)$$&+#(0&(*$.#(%$8),/)'51#(#*&'%#/0&($.#5#+)($#5 /&8,)/$.#(#/+&'5#'$/ +&,%1#.)/(#1#%<#5$.#%'+8$$.)$$.#1(&-5-&8,5 =#1&*#<%&,#'$$.#*&*#'$$.#>2,)'1#$.#%(&5*)'

!

.#%(#1$&(#'#(),&0 &,%1#)(>)'))'5$.#8+#(%'$#'5#'$&0

&,%1#&'#+)$-)/+(#/#'$%'$.#&+#'&8($ .#>%'0&(*#5$.##'1.$.)$ $.#>.)<#2&$/&*#%'$#,,%2#'1#%'+8$-.%1.1&8,5=#/.)(#5&',>$&$.#852#/ 1&'0%5#'$%),,>%'$.#%(.)*=#(  #2)<#)85%#'1#$&$.#*%'&8(.)*=#(

.#>/.)(#5/&*#/#'/%$%<#%'$#,,%2#'1#%'+8$-%$.8/ 

.#*)$$#(1)*#8+0&(.#)(%'2&'    '.#)(%'2=&$.

/%5#/&'$.)$ 5)>-# 
  #;+(#//#5&8(%'1,%')$%&'$&+#(*%$$.# +#$%$%&'#(%'+&,%1#18/$&5>$&+#(0&(*$.#(%$8),/)'51#(#*&'%#/$.)$-&8,5=# +#(0&(*#5&'"

 1&'/%5#(%'2$.#+%&8/&=,%2)$%&'&0$.#+#$%$%&'#( =#%'2$.#/&'&0$.#5#+)($#5/&8,$&5&/&



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

  <%2&(&8/<%&,#'$*&5#/$&1&'$(&,$.#1(&-5 %/1.)(2#&0+%&8/&=,%2)$%&'&0 $.#+#$%$%&'#(-%,,.)<#$&=#1&'/%5#(#5%'$.#)=&<#=)172(&8'5

'0)1$$.#$(%),&8($+)//#5)'&(5#($&$)7#$.#+#$%$%&'#(%' +&,%1#18/$&5>$&0)1%,%$)$#$.#+#$%$%&'#($&)$$#'5$.#08'#(),1#(#*&'>&0.%/ *&$.#(=8$.#(#08/#5$&2&%'+&,%1#18/$&5>$&)$$#'5$.#08'#(),1#(#*&'> 0&((#)/&'/=#/$7'&-'$&.%*

$%/(#+&($#5$.)$+(&.%=%$&(>&(5#(/8'5#(#1$%&'!!(

 -)/ %*+&/#5)(&8'5$.#A)%,+(#*%/#/-.#(#$.#$(%),%/2&%'2&'  #/+%$#/81.

/$(%'2#'$/$#+/$.&8/)'5/)'5$.&8/)'5/&00&,,&-#(/2)$.#(#5)(&8'5$.#A)%, +(#*%/#/  )'5  1(#)$#5  ,)-  )'5  &(5#(  +(&=,#* $&  $.#  +8=,%1   <#'  %0  $.# +#$%$%&'#(%/$)7#'%'+&,%1#18/$&5>&')11&8'$&0$.#<%&,#'$)$$%$85#&0$.# 0&,,&-#(/$.#(#%/#<#(>+&//%=%,%$>&0=,&&5/.#5 
$*)>=#5%00%18,$0&($.# +&,%1#0&(1#$&$)7#$.#+#$%$%&'#(%'+&,%1#18/$&5>$.(&82.(&)5)/%$%/ /8/+#1$#5$.)$$.#0&,,&-#(/-%,,$.(&'2$.##'$%(#(&8$#$&.)<#)2,%*+/#&0 $.#%(&50)$.#( 

.#(#0&(#%'$.#+8=,%1%'$#(#/$-#)(#&0$.#<%#-$.)$$.#/# +#$%$%&'//##7%'2%'$#(%*=)%,5#/#(<#'&0)<&8()=,#1&'/%5#()$%&' .#+#$%$%&'/ /$)'55%/*%//#5)11&(5%'2,>



+.&$&1&+>&0$.#&(5#(=#+,)1#5&'$.#1&''#1$#50%,#/

 # $   ! &<#*=#(  #  !$ 8,)$%  ! %&'(&')'*)(+,-'

 %&'(&')*'+./012'+30'4

'3