High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/11430/2021disposed of

Arun Rana And ORS v. State Of Haryana And Others

2021-07-09Mr. Justice Arun Monga3 pages

!"!$ $$ %&$'()$(%*($+,-.'$,/$0-&123$2&4$(2.52&2$2'$ $ $ $ $ +(2&4%*2.($$ $ $ $ $ $ $ +Y0$&89$::\#"$,/$!"!:$ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ 42')$,/$4)+%>%,&?$"@9"<9!"!:$ $ 2ILH$.BHB$BHN$8EOGIK$ $ $ $ $ $ F0GEDED8HGIK$ $ $ JGIKLK$ >EBEG$8=$(BIMBHB$BHN$8EOGIK$ $ $ $ $ F.GKP8HNGHEK$ $ +,.26$?$ (,&Q3A)$6.9$1->'%+)$2.-&$6,&*2$ !"#$#%&'('

)"*',-%:04'=C9&-1'23456-&#1'

75"'&8#'9#&0&05%#"$*'

)"*'+-:%##$8';8-3<-/1'22=1'>-"?-%-**'

R0IGKGHSG$TBIUGN$EOI8LVO$WDNG8$S8H=GIGHSGX9$ !"#$%&'$(!)%*+%,'"!-.% '!#&0&05%#"$'-"#'D#75"#'&80$';5C"&'$##A0%B'0$$C-%6#'57'-'<"0&'0%' &8#'%-&C"#'57'.-%3-.C$'30"#6&0%B'&8#'"#$95%3#%&$'&5'65%$03#"'&8#0"'6/-0.'5%' &8#' 95$&' 57' W#&#"0%-"?' X04#$&56A' U#4#/59.#%&' 2$$0$&-%&' QYWXU2ZR' -34#"&0$#3' 403#' 234#"&0$#.#%&' G5*MH' 3-&#3' KJ*KO*NKMO' Q2%%#VC"#' ![LR' -%3\5"' &5' 9"540$05%-//?' -//5<' &8#.' &5' 9-"&0609-&#' 0%' &8#' &#$&' &5' D#' 8#/3' 5%' MI*KJ*NKNM*'

N*'

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

"#9"#$#%&-&05%'3-&#3'KS*KP*NKNM'Q2%%#VC"#'![MSR'$##A0%B'$0.0/-"'65%6#$$05%' DC&'&8#'$-.#'8-$'%5&'D##%'-34#"&#3'&5'&0//'3-&#*'>#%6#1'&8#'9#&0&05%*' P*'

F' 8-4#' 8#-"3' /#-"%#3' 65C%$#/$' 75"' &8#' 9-"&0#$' -%3' 8-4#' B5%#' &8"5CB8'&8#'"#65"3$*'

S*'

F&'$##.$'&8-&'5<0%B'&5'&8#'9-%3#.06'65%30&05%$'9"#4-0/0%B'75"' &8#'9-$&'.5"#'&8-%'-'?#-"1'&8#'$#/#6&05%'9"56#$$'75"'&8#'95$&'57'WXU21'-$' -34#"&0$#3'5%'KJ*KO*NKMO'"#.-0%#3'-&'-D#?-%6#*'F&'0$'5%/?'-7&#"'&8#'$0&C-&05%' $##.$' &5' 8-4#' $/0B8&/?' 0.9"54#31' 7C"&8#"' $&#9$' -"#' %5<' D#0%B' &-A#%' &5' 65%3C6&'&8#'$#/#6&05%'0%'-665"3-%6#'<0&8'&8#'-34#"&0$#.#%&*'!C"$C-%&'&8#"#&51' &8#'<"0&&#%'#V-.0%-&05%'0$'$&-&#3'&5'D#'8#/3'5%'MI*KJ*NKNM*'' H*'

F%'&8#'0%&#""#B%C.1'.-%?'5&8#"$':C$&'/0A#'&8#'9#&0&05%#"$'<5C/3' 8-4#' D##%' -<-"3#3' #/0B0D0/0&?' 309/5.-$1' #4#%' &85CB8' -$' 5%' 6C&[577' 3-&#' %5&070#3'403#'-34#"&0$#.#%&'3-&#3'KJ*KO*NKMO'&8#?'303'95$$#$$'&8#'"#]C0$0&#' ]C-/0706-&05%*''

L*'

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

2&'&80$'$&-B#1'/#-"%#3'65C%$#/'75"'&8#'9#&0&05%#"$'$CD.0&$'&8-&'&8#' #V-.0%-&05%' <8068' <-$' &5' D#' 8#/3' 5%' MI*KJ*NKNM' 8-$' D##%' 3#7#""#3*' @8#' 7"#$8' 3-&#' 0$' ?#&' &5' D#' %5&070#3' /-&#"' 5%*' >#' $CD.0&$' &8-&' &8#' 9#&0&05%#"$'

9#%30%B'"#9"#$#%&-&05%'57'&8#'9#&0&05%#"$'0$'C%3#"'-6&04#'65%$03#"-&05%'57'&8#' 65.9#&#%&'-C&85"0&?*''

I*'

^#' &8-&' -$' 0&' .-?1' <0&85C&' 65..#%&0%B' 5%' &8#' .#"0&$' 57' &8#' 6-$#1' &8#' <"0&' 9#&0&05%' 0$' 30$95$#3' 57' <0&8' -' 30"#6&05%' &5' &8#' 65.9#&#%&' -C&85"0&?'&5'3#603#'&8#'9#%30%B'"#9"#$#%&-&05%'D?'9-$$0%B'-'$9#-A0%B'5"3#"1' -$'#V9#30&05C$/?'-$'95$$0D/#*'

"@9"<9$!"!:$$ $ $ $ $ R2.-&$6,&*2X$ ,G'

1-4*)$ !

"#$%#$&!'($)*+,-.&$)'/,$0!1! !

2$'.3/!

"#$%#$&!&$(/&%)45$!1!

2$'.3/!