← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/16675/2007dismissed

Gurcharan Singh And ANR. v. Union Of India And ORS.

2019-09-09Mr. Justice Gurmeet Singh Sandhawalia8 pages



     



       

   

       



            

        

 !

"#$%&

'()*+&, )"! %+     !

  

 "  !

  #$ !

     !

   !

    !

  % &'  

 "( , )"! %+ -'

 ./ $" )   *

(

./2*1-*330  !

!

 )) 4

  ) 5(    

( # "

5 5 ( 

    **/6**0 +  

     "

   )      

    !

    4

     4

)) !( 5  .21*+,- .//01-*330      (  !      '     

- -  

) 27(

7(     

  8     4 (5

   8  8     5 .20* (45  *3...201 4

)) !( 5  .21*   9  )  )  

  4  '    $

(   !   (     ' (

 .67

  !

  ("

  (  

! :! *1.3*337    

)    

;<(= .21*  < >-.=

5    +,-./2*1-*330     )      (

   '   - - $

  (       

      (       ) )  (!(    4 !

 )

    )(  *13?*3375 

!  ))  5(       5 3*31*330 +,-*773-.2;? (> < @= 

          

    (       

  5     

5   (  $     4    (     (5    )  (5                    4

  !

  

    *33..201        

5  + )                  3/3?.201 

 ) ?*5$

       

    

  *;-     @

 .;27   (5

       

!   ( 

.15 5  

5  $  @ +         !  '  A (  '    '  ))! (

                 5(#  .73..2;/ !

 

 

    !          

    

   5 

   )  !'B    (

! 

 +,-.*3.0-*3.1 

        .03;*3.2    

  )     )

     )5 







)-'  

  #  !  (    735     5 

  () " ) 8 !

  $ 123.4 (+2 3.5 %      5

!  .;  5    (             (

$   

 5 ! 

" )

D7 

  5 4    

()   

    

)  

( >(5 )

   (  )  

 )  )  ! + !)  ( ) 

   ) (" )#   )!    )  (-

 <*=<?=

   

(5 ) 5

  )

!(5

5

   



     !))5 (  "

(5<(=  

;<.= $  >

  ) !

   5   (   



  

(   >   

5  

       **/6**0     +  

   $/ ;

  !  ( 

5( 4   ( > (5  )  (                 

(

 ( )  )(  

   >

5  

   )5

 55"

 (5+<(=  

;<.=   > (5 

 55  ) !  



  .;5 $  

5     )  

5  5)5(5   ) ) >( "   )   # 4!

 !

(5!

     

! ) (  

     +  

 $ )  )   



 !@ ! 8     .207 )+ *30 

  ! 5 

 

/ @

 5.2//(5 

5.20*$ >+  - E$    5     5   

 !  .20*  )  +  

! 5 

 .212   (      ! 

 

  7        4      

   4

 5$ ! 

 !)  ) 4

          (     

   

  7    

 

  /   !         #  

 ! ( )  ) 0  ; 

 (  

 (    ) )      5  $

 ( (    5  

  <$ #    !  :  <.2/2=* +;*7(  ! 

   <.203=  *  +  /20   <   .203 )+ 703<= >>>>>>>>>>>> 2  $    &              "  

! >)   5       +           )5      )

!    )   ,  



   ,  (   

  ) ) > ( " 

-    

        (        !) ) ' !

) ! 

( ! ) 5 )(  C ) ' 

  )      

  5        )        

)  5 E 

0    

        ?331*3.2   4

  .730*3.7  (5  4    

  ) 4

(  



   ) C )-'    )(         )  #  )    

    

 !

 4

)) !( 5

 .21* $

    )  )5 !

" )

>+   6 .7%73% 4 )$8+ 5)     )  

    ( )  5( 

  



 )  3*31*330 +,-*773-.2;? (5 

( 

    

!

 

   ( 

5.2;?

        

  !%  !  (     ( )  

(  

 (  ( 5    ( ) 5 

 )5    '   5(# .73..2;/ >-.  



 

:('

 !     

B) 

 $

 5       ).201  ! *1.3*337< >-.=   ( 5  5*25 5 (  

  

   (    

  



!)

 ( 

 ( 

   !  +,-.//01-*330   )>  ./.3*33/ ((   

 *1.3*337  5

  ) )-( 5  (!

 8 !

   

 

 )  (    !

 )  (   )) 5    !

 .21* 

  5  !

( ! 

    

  ) 

 )  3232*3.2  , )"! %+  

 '(,&  



  

!  "  

!