Satish Mandaokar v. State Of Punjab And Another
!"#" $%&'&
% ()*& + *+ ** ) ****
!
"
#
!
$ %&
'
! '$"
!
) + $,
- .,/"01 &2 0 *+, -
!
./) 00
" 1 23 ( /4 5454)5+/
!
.546.)5307
!
&
7 %! 271
*), - 23"7 7
!
5)5.)5+/ # $ *!
,
7 7
# 68 9 7 7
0
! ! #
! # 6 $ 3
&
7 : !
; # "!
6
! "
# + )/ .< .</6= # "
"! # ##
!
!
7=
7
"
77
6# #"
+ )/ .< .</6=3 "
7 " !
#
#
- 2 -
7 !
!1( 5)+>)4 <+5<)5+? + @5 55 5556= "
'
' ! - " !
A!# 7 # 1
B " !1 !
7
-
)7 7
!
+</ (7 3 # ! +//+* +//+!,"!" !
#' 23"
7
!
! "!! # 7 0 *<, C
#!
7 ! " 7 7 23
"
! ! 7
#! #
! +45))5+? *
A =., #
+55D # "
# " <5 !
"
)
+@4 - & E !"!" +5/ -! *., 3
#
+554)5+?" 7
)7 7
7 # 7 +5/ - #
( )
!1 +@5!
"#
! "
# <5. - " #
( ) " + 5> /4 /@+6=# 7 +@4 -
!"
7
"
! "! # " # # # #
#
!
- 3 - 6
)
7 # +)/! #
! 7
#
! 7 !
" #
# 7 !1 "
*>,
7#
" "
!
+</ (3!
)" !1
"
"
)
"
!
!7
(3 !
7
! 7 !# ! !
#0 !
" "
!
= #
# ! 7
# ##
! 7 !# ! *4, C !
# 7 !
)4+5)5+/ 0
!
+?<00"
5>+))5+@
# !7 #
+<5<)5)5
" #
7 F # #
7
7
7
" !
! #
# "
+ )/ .< .</6=
# # # "
+! # #!
A#7 7!1 + @5 55 5556= !!
"! !
" !
- 4 - # # ! #!
"!# ! !
## !# ! "# *?, B */, 3 #
! !1 +@5 ! "
!
5+5.)5+? "! " # !#
+>54)5+? " '
&
7 " # ! 7
9
;
# *
A<,
#
@ 5. 4))6="
!!
" 7
"
!
!1 1
*@, ' !
!
!
)55+)5)5
!7 " # 7
+<5<)5)59 !
#
! #!!
.546.)5 30 # 7
!!
7
7 #
! !
6
( ) "
"
+ )/ .< .</6=
# # # "
! #
)
A 7 7#!1 +@5!
!!
" # !
" !# !1- !
!
!
!
)
- 5 - *+5, ' 7 # !
"
" 7 !
" #!
!
! 7 " 1 !
# ! !!
! " ! "
!
! *++, ! !! ! "#!$ % & ''
# 0
A! "
./)00 A!
!!
! # 3
"
A! 7# !
" 23 !
!
##
! ! " 23
A!
!!# ! *+), ( ! # 1 23 7 " 7 !
# " 1
!
*+<, %# *+.,
7
7
#
! 5+5<)5)> + $,
- .,/"0
.,/
1. Whether speaking/reasoned?
Yes/No
2. Whether reportable?
Yes/No