M/S Sahib Transport Company v. Food Corporation Of India And ANR








 







 


 






!"

#
$ %&'



(

)*+,-

!

"

!"!!
&.+
/(01
(+2
32(4






5


6+7+

)
2(

)(
()
(0

+2)+

 


  
 
    


 

 

+,-
& (8+0
(9
)*(9

0
2 &
:

:

72(9
)*(9

0
+2)+



;
;
;
;
  
 
$('
0+
2
0(+
1
)
14
0
2- 3
1<
(<<)
14
0
)
)()
#
14
>0*0
0
2- 3
0(+
1
0)

1
)7<)

*(?(
()

0(
+
<7)
0
(+
34
)2+)
14

0(+
1
))

1
 )
()

0(+
1
)1()
3
2(*2(<

(4
)
@74
>0
0
)
2(

)(

(
2)


4(+ 
(*+
()<

0
<

0
2
(
0(
0
2- 3
(22)

(>()

0()<
()
(+2
*(*


()(7
$ 
(
+*
:77A+0('
27+7(

0
)
@74
)()

"B
+


0
2(

0
2- 39
(349
/0
(<
/<0
0()
(+
(22)

0
+(3
)

0+
))7(
*(2(*49
0 9
0
+2)-(70+
2(++)
(
)
7)
(7+
!

0
)

0
 *
0(

>(+
(
*(
*(+

*(?(
()
0 9
)
)
)()
"

"# C9
0
(+
34

0
2
3
>(+
 )
()

>(+
)1()

(
2)


4(+
3
2(*2(<

(4
)
2*)<+
>0
0
)
2(

)(







 0
2
3
1<
(<<)
14
0
+()
)
)
(
>
2
1 
0+
79
>0*0
>(+
<+)
(+




!C

!"

C9
()
0+
7
)
)
)()
!C "# C
14
*)<
(
)<

0
 *
0(
0
327<)
)
0(+
1
2(++)
>07
++7<
(4
+0>
*(7+
*

<<
(
2274

0(<

2
0()
3)
0
3(
1(*A

0
+2)-(70+

(A<
(
)*+
( +0

(**)(*
>0
(>
( 
*
()
2274

0
2
3 7+7(

0
( +()
)*
++7)
14
0+
79
0
+2)-(70+
0()
2(++)
0
327<)
)
)()

#
$ - "'
(<(
 <
0
(+
34
)2+)
()
)1(<
0
2
3
3
2(*2(<

(4
)
@74
>0
0
)
2(

)(

(
2)


4(+ D()
*7+

0
2- 3
+713+
0(

0
+(
*(+
0
+2)-(70+
0()

( ))
(4
2274

0(<

0
2- 3
)+2
++7(*

(
)*
14
0+
7
)
)
)()
!

C "#

70
*)+
0(
0
(70+
0(
(+

*))
(4
)<

0
 *
(+

0>
0
2- 3
0(+
()

*324
>0
0
&
2++
014
)1(<


(
2)


4(+

+713+
0(

(**7

0
( +()
(*+9
0
327<)
)
2(++)
14
0
+2)- )
2(

)(
)++

1
@7(+0)
(+
0
2- 3
0(+

(*

7)

1
)7<)

*(?(

0(+

()
0
&
2++


D()
*7+

0
2- 3
70
*)+
0(
(7+
!

0
&
2++
4
2)+

 7

&

(<
(
(
**7+
0(
0
+
(
*(
)*(

*(?







 (7+
E

0
&
2++
>0*0
*(
1
))
4

*(+

7(+
3)

(7+
E

(

*32)
>0
>0*0
(

2+

0
2+
*(+
0 9

+7*0
**73+(*+9
0
327<)
)
)1(<
0
2- 3
3
2(*2(<

(4
)
@74
>0
0
)
2(

)(

(
2)


4(+
>07
( )<

(4
2274

0(<

*)<
(4
)<

0(
 *
+
(1

1
@7(+0) D()
*7+

0
+2)- )
2(

)(
2-*(
0(+
034
+722)
0
327<)
)
)()
# 9
0>9
(4
**)+
0(
3
(
27+(

0
( +()
)9

+
)
0(
0
+2)- 
0(+

*))
(4
)<
(+

>00
0
2- 3
()
+
>A<
2(
0()
3)
(
*(
()
0(
3<

+7*0
*(
0()
)*4

)*4
( *)
0
1))<

(+
(4
**)+
0(
0
(70+
0(
(+

<
)()
(++
(+

0>
0
2- 3
0(+
()


*32)
>0
0
& 2++

+713+
0(

+7*0
**73+(*+
0
+2)- 
>
(A
72
0
3(
( +0
14
++7<
+0>
*(7+
*
()
( )<
(
2274

0(<

0
2- 3
()
0( 
(<(
)*)
0
3(
14
(
(+)
)
>0
(
2)

"
)(4+
0
( +()
+(3
3()
14
()
*7+

0
+2)- 
+

22+)
14
()
*7+

0
2 (A<
0
+(3

()
*7+

+2)- )
2(

)(

*)
()

3+
0 9
0
2
)
14
0
2- 3
+
)+2+)

14
@7(+0<
0
327<)
)
)()

#
()
<(
14

0
+2)- 9

+
()+)9

(A
72
0
3(
( +0
14
++7<
+0>
*(7+
*
()
( )<
(
2274

0(<

0
2- 3
()
0( 
)*)
0
3(
14
2(++<
(







 )()
(+)
)
>0
(
2)

"
)(4+9

04
*0+

(A
72
0
3(
( +0 0
0+
1+(+9
0
2
+()+
)+2+)



$ 6
/:
'




















 /

$


DD'

!

"

!"!!












 

()









00
+2(A<.(+)
+.
00
2(1
+.