High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/20279/2020allowed

Mahesh Dutt Sharma v. Serious Fraud Investigation Office Through Investigation Officer

2023-03-29Mr. Justice Sandeep Moudgil11 pages

!"#$%$%

!"!&"'

!"#$%$%

# ()*$ + *+ ** ) ****

!

" ! !

# !$ +,"

-!& ./01 $ % & ' (

( # )#*+*,-./ .0-+,-./! ('

+0!+0!,..123!,,2!4,0!,55#

!./+4! 26153!24!660!.62!662!660!.65!.66!.6.15313

#

! ,-.5 .,-78 " 6-4! 6.2! 6.0!6,-!642!640!62.!622!626#! (

9 ! :

%

& " ( ' #7 (' ; # #7 ' < = 1

! > # '?3 '

(

.--" & "

#7 '

"" "

- 2 -

!

(

" ' ( @ " #7 '! '

" '

' ' "!

!" '

* (' !

"" ..5 (' "' (&

! " % ' !

@( (' @

%

25 #

! ,-.5 +07 #

! ./+4

' &* ' 7 & ' " ,1(3 #

1

3 !./2+! ! " > ? "

"

" ' # ' ! !

# ! $

( ! ( & 8 < ! 9

A 1#$3! 05++ & 8< 5- &

A < 1% ..5 3

( & !

(' " 7 ! "

8<

- 3 -

< 1#$3 ! 7B7

" " ( '@

*"

('

!" " "

! '( <

" !

( ,.,143 #

!,-.5

!"# $ "

% &

!" @#

"

#

'

( '

(

6+ '< ! ,--," (& " ,.,143 #

!,-.5

(

(

'* *

'( ! ' ( # ' ('

( :

C :

! ( * (

*('

" D

- 4 -

& ' (

! ' (

'! ('

,. #

D" ! '" (

('

( (' "%

(

' (

" "

"#

" E *

" "

#

D" ! ' (' & '! #

(

" 650 # #8 " (@ '('

!& " " 77

!

! " ( '

%#

" (' &' "

,1(3 #

1

3 ! ./2+ % " > ? ' ! (

@

F

(' #

! !

!

'

(

- 5 -

! ' (

(

!' !

'( G (

' ( (

'* *

' ' ,--+ ,-.2D" !!

'

' ( (

' " A (' ( 7 '

('

'' !" " ( ( ! (A

! "

" %

'

(' #

7( ( %

&

(

" "D! " !

( (! F '

! " (

( & '

! ' '('

!" (

" " 8 " ( ( & ( A '!

'" (

- 6 - (( !" @

(' !"# $ " 1

3 & #

! ,-.5! '7 < ! " ! ' ;

=! ; '

= ;

F = F ' ' !" # $ " '

&

! " '(

% #

!

( < " " (

(

% ' " ( !"

( ! #

" " !(

%#

!

( ( ' (

('

(

% (!

" ( ( (

'(

- 7 - ( ( ) * + *, -' . /

+ 012 1 (

,+-0,-,,!

#

" A !"# $ " 1

3! ,+-0,-,, " 7

! !

"

!

# ! " ' ,.,143 #

!,-.5 ' (

!"

,4.-,-,. ('

!" $

$ 3$ & 4 1' 5 *677-

,4.-,-,. ('

! "

(A

"

' ( ! '

'

"

( ' ( !

' " '

'!

'

- 8 -

' ( '! " (A

(

" (

!!

!

" ( ' F ' !( " ( ( F " ! !" '( " ( (

'" 7 " ( ' ('

(

" %

%

5 *,,.4-0,-,." ( ' E( C7( (

& ' 7 '" !

7 $% % &

% %

% !% ' ( )

- 9 -

* %

% # .$ $$ & 4 # 188 1 *-, 81 5 * (5 * !

#

( #

& 88 *-797 ,--5,-,5" F " #

" '( " " (

( ( " ! F '

'( ' ( F '

7 9

#

)46-,-,,

.0-6,-,, ( ( ; + ,-. / ' 0+ % %

% %

&

= 7 ! '!' "

.0.,,-,, " #

A ( !(

<1# 3).,266,-,,"

- 10 - " " .5-.,-,5

% 7 ( ! (' #

('

! " 7 13 '( 8 (' #

.+.-,-./ 13

( & D ' ('

#

.2.,,-,- 13 ( '&('

-2-,,-,, " (

H (

H

' ' " 'H

&( #

'" A ! 'H & " !

! & ' A '( !" '" H

'! '

' (

! #

"

( '( ! '! " % (

( ! ! ('

( (* %

(

- 11 -

( @ "! !"

" " ' ,/-5,-,5 1 +,"

-!& ./0

& .

1. Whether speaking/reasoned?

Yes/No

2. Whether reportable?

Yes/No