Soma Nand v. Pb.St.
!""
##$$ %&
#
##$$ %&
#
' (
%") *+ ",-.
!
(
'
/& $.
!
##$$
#
(
(")
$
1.
'&+
##$$
#
#
##$$
! , #!
! #&"- 2$ ! "
'
/5.
-&,-
"!
4"
6 78
$ " " " 0&, -!.
*" .
!!& 2!
* !"! $9 #!
,
" -"*
! #&"- 2$ ! " '.
"!
!:&"
-"* #!
,
" -"*
! #&"- 2$ ! "
'
-&,-
# !",
$ " " " 0&, !!.
! #&"- 2$ ! " '.
"*# !"!
&2 " ! 9 ",& "*#"* .
"*# -"*
! "
8.
&$ 5- ! !"!
&,
* - ",& "*#"*
'&+ "$", !"*"
## 6
$$, "!
!:&"
&# .
!!& $ " " " 0&, !!
!"!
2!*",
,," * "!
!"! "
-"* #!
,
" -"* ! " .
# !"*"
## ", 6
2 &
"! 2 -
## $ &#
" *
!** "! .
-& -9
* 2$
!** "!
-
," #!& " *2" ; 5-"!- '0
",
2 ! "
>" 5-"!- '<8
",
4-".
!-
"
,
!!&.
$*"? 9
5 !-"$ 5 2 & -" 5$!)
- !- '<8
)", -&2 #! ##
5- ## ",
- &,- -$ -.
- -",
-
-"
- & ".
- -&2 &,- -$ * .
,, "" 5-
2$ ?
#&", ) "$
&2:& $9.
-& )" !-.
9&, 2 - -&2 -&,- #& ",
2$ ) & "
# * 2 -
2.
- # #
!"* "
@ $9.
-"
-&2 & ," ", -.
& * ", 59
!*#$ " " ", " " !"* .
" ", "! !!.
##
"$
# ! " A '
2 $ **"
& !!
$ **"
& !!.
" !**" *
!**" "
& "
#!& " = *"
9
5"
&2:& $9.
#&2$"!
#!& !$ #!& " "!
!$& #!& " "! $ "
0&, 5 #!", ! " '
5-".
!!& #$ "!!.
!$ "*
$ "*#$"!
!.
$ ! !&$ = *"
! 5"
!""!
$ !&$ !"!
&2*"
$"
! !&$ .
*"" *"* .
9.
!"! .
2!* !*#" '7
/ &2*"
" ! !"! "
, ! " '.
!&$ 2!* 5$$ '7.
" =-"2"
$ #" !**!", *
4- .
&2*"
"! &2:& $9
## " "*"
-*.
-& 5-
," -&2 ," *", -"*$
4-&.
* !&$ 9
9
"", * -&2 * 59.
-.
#-9"!
!&$ 9
9.
"", * 2$ 2&", -.
-! #="* !"*
:&$.
5- - * 2$ 2&", * !&$ 9
9 !&*2 -&,- -&2 * 59 -.
#!"
$$9 !"* .
&!-.
!"! " ! !"!
#!
! #&"- 2$ ! " ' & "
"$9.
$ !&$
,& "!
$$, 2 & 5$$ *" .
" 2!*", " 5" -.
&
!#"
!""
$ !&$
,&
"!
!:&"
$.
!!& #!
,
" -"*
! ! "
' & ".
, *"
##!"
"! =" ", !
&2*"".
$ !&$
,&.
!*#" '<8 ! " & $" "
" !"!
" ".
&2*" $ !&$.
&# !" .
!2
-
5-"!- '1
",
$
$ !&$
## ", !"!
&2*" .
"!
!:&"
!
!!&
,
" -"*
! #&"- 2$ ! "
'.
-.
"
&2*"" *2".
! &*.
"" "
# =!&$#
!*#".
/ & - &2*"
"! " 5-"!- '<8
",.
$ "* 9&, 2 - -&2
"$ 2$
!"* "
4-&
"
#!& " 5" .
5- .
" - !"
#!& " 5" 2 = *".
&$ $9
*"" &#
2$*"- & & - &$
4- .
,&
$"
! '<8
$%
&
& #9 29 >" .
!&!
'B.
1&# ",-
'B #
-".
1&# ",-.
& -", '.
$
& #9
29 >"
#
& >" # "!*"!
-!) 5-"!- & "!" & " 9 !& &
' ' ' ( ! )) ' *! #"
))+ ' "
))+
- "
4-9
#! "$9 !*#" .
'<8
'1
4-&,-
9
#!
& *".
$* #"! "!.
2$ &
"!
!"! "
"
!!& * -"
! "
"
<"! !
",
, " "
9 ",
".
!$ -8-" ** .
5&$ & - &$
/5.
" -
&# - "
&$ $9.
& *"
5-"!- !!
",
",", !!
9 - !*# ", ".
5- -.
"* - ! ) " .
*
9 "! - & .
*
9 !$ $ ".
5- &", *
-#"
"" ", -
'
*& $9.
- " !" !9
*, !*# ", "
' ' 7
", *"
.
& *" 5- - " =!&$# ".
5-"!-
",.
&2$*"- ".
*&!-
#! ! )
$#
9 , .
* )
! " =!&$# >"
2 "* = ! -"
C * >" 58 * ( 8 "
$9
,
2&
9
"
"
* "!
5)
D
2&
'(
!-", % *"$) *9 !-"$
.
5-"!- 2&,- 5$9
'" $"
B- $"
) "$ 5-"!- - > &$"
!&#
5-"$
2$ ?",
! 2$ ".
5-"!- *9 " &,- " 5- " = ",&"- " *9 !$ -
2 -
* &,- "
*9 -&2 *
*9 -&2 E 9&, 2 - -5 "
>&* #& 2$ )
:&"$ * 5-"!- " &,- *9 !$ - 5 = ",&"-
4- *9 -&2
*9 -&2 E 9&, 2 -
,* !9 !
2"", - 5-$
,
*" *,!9
! , *
2$ ? 5-"$ *"$) *9 !-"$
-
&$
#!
"
9
8 <,$"-.
1"
",- .
'
'
%) 7
4 >" F
## $9 G 2 7
(
$
-" 2!* " !
2& " )
G " ",- -&*2 "*#" " ", & 0&"!"
( ,"
# $"" 9 " )
".
! !!.
5- " .
" # " 5" 2=
B
= *" ""!-" # "
" G
/ & - = *" ""!-" " ".
0&"!"
( ," ! #! >"
4-&.
5-
!-", = *" ""!-" .
" 2!* ! $ #&2$"!
#!& !!.
-&,- != *"", B
4- .
2"&$9 #!& "
*" & - &$ "
! &*
B
2& "
$ "* # " )
4-& 2"&$9 !!$&
" # " )
2
!, $9 #
"! -&,-& #- 5- ( ," ! !
"$ 2$.
&$ $9 &", " $ #- !!$&
&$$9 -
$& 9
2& & *"
" ".
=!&$# " .
5-"!- 2 - 0(.
*"
2 # B 5-
"* ##", " 5" 2= #*
" " " "!
" 0&,.
@&-"
B
= *" ""!-" !-
2 "", * ! ! " "!
" # " >" )
".
#! ! *
/
" "
&2:& $9 ! G .
5- -&*2 ) * ) !! " !
" "
", =!&$#
! = *" &,, " 2!
* * -"* $ #&2$"!
#!& !!.
-&*2 )
.
=!&$# ".
2!* " $9 #! B
5" -& &",
- !*#-", ! -
4- .
! " "!
#!
!!& =!&$# ".
9 5- B
= *" ""!-" =#
-&*2 )", - 5
&$ ", ! - 5 ) !!
$$ !"
$ " -"
4- .
#", =" ! ", & -
!:&! =!&$# ".
&$ "$$
$& "$9
;& -*
&$ "$$ & - -
#$9 2$"-
* !" " )
&$ "$$ $
-&*2 ) - $9
- & ",
$$ !"
$ " -"
<*#- "!
$$9
5- -" =!&$# $ -&2
=# -"
*# &
!!" " 5-"!- ,&$
4-&.
$9 !"!
5- ) -#"
=!&$# "" "
*
*, - 5 &2:& "
4- .
! &*
"**"
!9 " "! ##", !"* ",
&
& -
*# $9.
5- - "! ! &,, "
:&$ !"!
& ",
* ",
&$ $9.
2!*
$& "$9
' *!
A
9.
&2:& -
5-"!- '<8
",
'<8
2!
*
" ! 2!* = ! -"
!
#$
#$ % #& '
( ) (
)
#*+*
( )
) (
)
)% (
! -!
)% . % ) /0 ')
) '%
) #
)
)%
) (
)
) )
) )
(
)
) )
)
)
)
%
2
)
) ) -!
)% % ) /0
%
) ' )
)
%
-!
)%
%
)
%
! ( 3 )
5
(
'
&6$
-7
'" 5", <= '<8 .
! # " )
##" " ! " "!
" '<8
! '<8
= ! -"
8)
!
) -
9 %
!
#$
'
#&##**:
/; #&0
( ) ) ) %
) %
% ) )
%
( 3 ) /<
0 #6##**:
/&&$
-0
=
!
" #$
'
7
4-&,- '<8
2!
* #! ! ", # " )
*
# 0&"!"
( ," !!.
2 5-*
0&"!"
( ," !!.
#" " $9 # "
! &* $& " )
2 -"*.
" ".
! - 5 .
=#$ " # " .
5-
-
*" ", -* !! .
-&*2 "*# -.
2 - # " 5 2&
/5.
&", !& &2+! != *" ".
*" &,, ".
$ ! !&$.
*" ! #!",.
" " -"*$
2&
$& 9 2 -"*
*"
&,, " -"*.
,"
9 #!",
# " * " " .
!!"& &", "* *
" ".
*"
&,, "
-"*.
!
9 2
2& ! .
=#$ " .
>" .
5- .
-
*" ", " ! !! .
"*# -&*2 ) -
< -&,-
*"".
!*#$ $9 &! ", " "!
'B = *" ""!-" .
5-".
# )
2& !$ -&*2 "*#" $9
&",
$$ !"
$ -" 2!*", &
6 -$ 5-
" "
9 "!
!9 '<8
" " .
&", #- 5", ! * " -&,-& ( ," 5- !
4-& ! & 2$ 2!* $& "$9
& - -.
5- .
! !!.
-&,-& #- !", '<8
0&"!"
( ," .
"$ 2$ -"* !!
" $9 -! " " =!&$# ".
$ " " "
9 5 -
"!
"* # 2 5 "" "
&# =!&$# ".
&2:& .
2& * -
:& $9.
2"&
#
- $ " 5 :& $9
!!", -#"
4-& 5- " ", "! " " = *" ""!-" .
=!&$# .
!- !$ #!", #!
*" >" .
9
.
-5", !*#$ " ! "
2& & *" &,-
&!-.
"" !.
##$"!
0&"!"
( ," !!.
!", >"
",
*"
2.
2"&
#
!!$& ,&$
! -#"
$.
-"
"$", &,- .
$9 2"&$9 -" ,"", & ",.
* ", -.
"" "
$$9 =!&$# ".
!* -&,- - &2:& $9.
! "
"
!!&
4- .
'<8
$& "$9
"#! " #" " 'B 5-"!- '<8
",.
2!* 2 " ",
!-.
! ",
9 "* !!$&"
2& ,&"$
!!&.
#!
,
" -"*
! ! "
'
' & - & "",
" !.
!*#" 9 #!& ".
&2:& - &",
A.
.
-&.
# $9
5) !!&", "! -
" '1
4-&,- #" '1 ! )
* .
-&,- ! '1
# 1"
",-
/5.
", -" = ! ! '1.
$.
-" "*#* .
" " 5-
$" '<8
(
! >)
'
% ?:
! ( ) (
%
) )
) '
2
#@6A* )
>
(
! >)
'
!
9
) 8
) %
%
% @ !
) ?
! ' )
)%
%
!
% ) ) ) )
)
") )
%
!
( % )
!
?&
) B #6#?*@ %
) !
%
!
% )
(
%
!
%
) ( ) % )
!
!
( ) )
#$
- )
)) ( % )
!
) ( ) ( )
B )
)%
) %
)
(
.- .-
)
)%
) )
9 ) )
!
!
") ) ( )
#+#?*@
)% % ) ) )
B )
5
)%
B #6#*: (
% 5
)% -!
)%
>
(
!
' % 7
'<8
# 0&"!"
( ," !!.
! $9 -&2
#" $ !!&!.
-! 2$ 2&
!"
-".
& !*#$ 2", *9.
*&!- * 29 5-
2 !"2 '<8
##"
" " '<8
!!& '1.
##
" !
" ", "
)-"
5",
!!$&".
" *
! &*
$$
" " '<8
!!& '1.
)-"
= *" ""!-"
&$ $9.
'1 " 2$*"- & ",.
-& 2"&$9
$& "$9
.
* "!
6 -$.
* "! 2$
" ! '<8
'1.
'<8
* 2 -"$ #
!"* " & " ,&$ ", -! -&,- #& ",
2$ ) -.
5- .
'1 =!$& *
! " - '1
"
* E( "
E( "
E.
* ",-2&.
!*", * -" -&.
= ",&"-", "
!
"! 2$ " ! '<8 '1.
)", 2 - '<8
'1.
"$& 9
!
,$ ", ! "! ".
"*#* 2$" $9 ! '<8
2$" ! '1.
"#! "
$" 5", 2 - ".
2 " " "! 5- 2 5-* 2!
* !
#"!&&$9
5- $"
! #!& " $9 '<8
-&
##
#!& "
*"
$" 9 '1
!!*"
!
$" - !*#" '<8
2!*", "$& "$9
" ",
'
*& $9.
=!$&" '1 * 9&, 2 - .
5-
"$ 2$ -
!"* " .
#!"
$$9 ," * "" "
$$9 ! =!&$#
" '<8 " 2$", 9&, 2 -
!!& # " 5" 2=.
2"&$9 * -", ##", " 5" 2= *,! & - * -"*
!"*
4-&.
&##" "
"!.
#!& " -&,- " $9", '1
&2:& 5", '<8 2"&$9
$9 "*# #!& "
4-&
'1
!!$& 2*"!-
&$ * ",.
& ", *
$"
! #$ ! '<8
#!& " -&.
2!* "!&*2 & !" ", 9&, 2 - !"!
#!& " 5" 2!* "!&*2
& ##", " 5" 2=
!*#$ & - " 2!* & $
6$
2 .
&$ $9 &##" "! 9&, 2 - !"!
!
#!& "
# '<8
! !
#"! "! #", $ ,
" #
/5.
&$ !" !9
*, "& ".
,$ &$.
",",
",", !" 5 -".
*&$ "#$ ".
5-"!-
" ,
' ' "5 !) &# !" !9 5 "
.
-& " "
9 ! " 9
!:&" 2 - "
"$9.
"" "
$$9 =!&$#
2!* $" !"!
5-"!- .
",.
5-
!!*#$"- $ *&!-
.
# " ) " .
2!*", ! !
5- & -
! &* "
& - .
2 # 0&"!"
( ," !!.
5- ## " 5" 2=
B
4- .
5-
,
##
& ",
# & ", -&2 5- ) -#"
$.
#!"
$$9 5- 5- "" $ !"!
# .
-&,-& #- !", ( ,"
! # -
4-&.
!!
", =!&$# ".
5-
) -#"
* 2& "+&" -&2
-&,- # )
2& ",-2& -" ", -#"
* 2& "+&".
!!
", - .
(@ #"! ",
2 #$ ! !
4- .
! " '1 2!* 2$"
!:&!.
$"$9 " .
-&2 ) -#"
* 2& "+&".
&!-.
!&!
!" "!!
"!
"* =!&$# 7
.
- "!
& .
* -&2 - .
!!
", =!&$#
; " " , -
" !.
*
! &*.
" - ! .
5- ## " 5" 2=
B 0&"!"
( ," 5-2 5-*.
=!&$# ".
2!*", *
9 &,, " $ #&2$"!
#!& !!.
-&2 -
", 5"
!:&!
2!
!= *" " B.
B !!$&.
2 - & - &$$9 -" #! " = *" ""!-"
# " $9 ) =!&$# ".
2 - & - &$$9
* $& "$9 .
2 -
& - &$$9
-&*2 )", .
!!& $9
- &
$$ ! -"
$ $ $ ,
#)
4-&,- $ "
0&, !!.
$" ! $ 5-"!- '.
'
'
",
< -&,-.
", &
" -
!!&.
" #!", ! " '
5-
"
2 #
&$ $9.
5- # $ "
$.
-& ! &
*" ", ", &
!!& '7.
5-".
- !!&
!-",
2& !**" ", ! *"* 5"
$
## 9
/5.
$ !!&! !!&
"! 9 * 9 +" "*"
-*
4-&.
!!$& ! #"& #.
9.
-&2
$ !!$&
!!& - * -"*$
!:&!.
*&!- #" - 2$ 2&",
* !"! .
#="* $ !!&!.
9 * !&$ 9 &
!!&.
.
!*#" ", * 59
2!* "!:& "
$.
-"E "#="* * !"* !!&!
& -
* 59
"!
".
! * ",.
& ", *
.
)-"
&$ $9.
-" " 2$*"- '1
&$ $9.
" "!
)-"
&##
, ! " '
2!*
2$*"-.
& & - &$
" "!
4-&.
"!
!"! ".
! !"!
#!
,
" -"*
! #&"- 2$ ! " '.
$"
2$ 2!* "
4-&,- $ !&$
,&
# ".
* *" & + '
) - (& $ .
95" !!&!
/5.
&2*"" !*#$ $9 &$
".
* -"*
"$ 2$
!"* " .
* 9&, 2 - !"!
"$ 2$
!"* " .
5- -5 * " &= *".
&$ ",
" !
" #!& "
-
*&$ "#$ ".
=!&$# 9.
&
& "& =!$&",
",", #2 " ", -
4-9
,&" ,$ &$ - " !" !"
"
-
5" "!" !".
".
-& " 2!* &5 -9 " "
9 ",
", -
=!&$# ".
- 2!*
", " "
9 ", $9 &2+!
#
$& "$9 !.
#
#!
" ! .
#
2!
* ! 2 829
? "!
% #"!"#$ *" 5- - -
"!" !" ".
& & - * $ "! 5- - &!- "!" !"
&$ & ",.
* ", -"8- $ "
"5
2.
!"*"
## ", 6
# $$,", "!
!:&"
!!& #!
,
! #&"- 2$ ! "
'.
"*"
/5.
!"*"
## ", 6
"!
" "!
!"! " !"! .
#!
,
! #&"- 2$ ! " '
$$5
!:& -5" - "*# ! &# .
-.
"
# $.
& 9 2 !"!
"! -5" - !$$.
"!- ,
!"!
!& 9.
:&"
9 - .
"! -5" - $ * #"
$
!!",$9 ##
;"
*& .
9.
#"
!!& -5" - & -"*.
!! !
! & 2$5.
5 -5" -
## 9.
9.
:&".
5" -.
9
=#"9 #" $"*"
%
&
)")!"!!
%& ./012/ /1./1324156789*3152:81; 12*: