Vishal Goyal v. State Of Punjab
!"#"$%&'"() * +"#, (- ( . " "$ ' +# / 0$1 2 . #&$3 $ % 45 //
' # $ % ' /
")/'36!
7" , '$0'
8''
)36!
, & " "$ ' #9 ,7 ()) 0$1 2 '/')36!
" "$ ' , "( 3 ,"#& " "$ '8'
$ &' '' # 2 "("$ !
# *3 30$ :) 0$3 '/ ! "$# ' 8"# ' 3 ("! / "$;"'
<&0')"# '"! // '), (" , 7 #' 8"# ' 3 "$# , & " "$ ' $3 , '#$ , !=&( "$ //, $3 ) ' #"3 $ #"3 $ > (
' /!" -)+"#,'
$ " " -
0'7"
83"#, (( 8"$8 , #, 7 #7$ ' ( $3 = #0'"$8 ? 2"8, +"(( 8 /"$8,&0'
$3 #, $ ' 3 "$
8' = $ # ( 7" ,$ #& (/"$8, '#0= # !'' # $30 # "3 =0$ #, , 3' ! "6 3 #0= #*!'' # '$ # =$ -$ -*) $3 , '
'#, , 38$ $ 2 "$8 $ >, $ #, ' 0'$ 3 '= $ $37 $ # , '( +"(( 8 /"$8,&0'
)#, ##0'&'"# 3 "$3 , , '( $3"$ , # "36"(( 8 , 3!$# '0! "$# ,0# # /, 0' , ' !
= ( '$ , , & " "$ ' ($87" , ,"# !
!!0# 3 , 3 #(3 , # "3 ( $3 3"
' $ & &( $3 8'
22 3 , ' ( 3 #&" ,
! , , ' 7 ## -0&$# (("$8 , ( $3/, !( "= 3 , , ( $37 ## "(("$, '$ = 03, 32 $&( - 32- , & " "$ '
$3 , '#7" , , !=&( "$ $ ' /
") ( '$ 3 / $"' !0$# ( ' , & " "$ ' , #02=" 3 , @# / " & $3 $ # '0! 0' , 3 !$# '0! 3 !($-7" , , $ = +"#,'
$ "" -
'8 "$830 &&'6 ( '= ,
'2 $5!
(3" # & ' = $ $3 , , & " "$ ', #$ #(3 $-&( 3"' ! (- $-& '#$ $3 , "
$-&( , #2 $#(3 , 7
' <"$8 ( ' !$# $ '= , '"8"$ (7$ '
0'7,, 3' ! "6 330 !$#"3 '
"$ ' 8 '3"$8 , ' ( $3 7 # 6 , = $ (- '80 3 2- ( '$ 3 !0$# ( ' , & " "$ ' , , & " "$ ' ' = "$ 3 "' ! ' $(- ' & '"3 '=0(- ) ! =2 ' ) @#/ $ # '0! 0' 7,"!,7 #"$!'&'
3$0$ ) 2-#"A& '#$# 3 ( "$ , 20#"$ ## '
( # , & " "$ '7 #$ , 0$3"$8@'"8"$ ( = =2 ' @#/ # '0! 0' @#/ $ # '0! 0' , 3 $ ' 3 "$ 8' = $ 3 3 0$ ) $3 ,
3 !"3 3 3 6 (& ,0#"$8 #!" - "$ , $ = +"#,'
$ " " - "$ , =0$"!"& (("=" # 0$"!"& (==" );"'
<&0', ( /!" - 7 # !' # 20 ? ( $37$ '# !$ '"20 3@ &( 3 , "' ' #& ! "6 (
0'!$ '"20 3, '( $3= #0'"$8* !' # !($-7 ( 32-# "3@#/ # '0! 0'
'
&&'6 ( '= , 6 '$= $ , (( 8 "$# , @#/ $ # '0! 0' , 030( $ (-#(3&( #"# 2#(0 (-7'$8 $3 , " "#
0'7,"#' #&$#"2( ' , $ "' 03"'= (- ( 0& , "( 3 !"6"( #0" "$#
'$ 9 0' 7, $ #, , 3 = 3
=& '!"2(-3"#&## ## , ' #"3 $ # +"#,'
$ "" - "#!( "= 3 2-( '$ 3!0$# ( ' , & " "$ ' , #& ' , !"6"(0' '3 '#) , 3"#&0 3( $3= #0'"$8?2"8, $3:2"#7 #7 #7$ 32-$ >"(("
= /"$8,/ $3,0)2' , '"$( 7
0'/ "3>"(("
=/"$8,/ $3,0 , 3 A !0 3 &7 ' '$ -"$
60' ,"#2' , ' $3,0#2 $3
0'7, A!, $8 3 , &'& ' - >"(("
=/"$8,/ $3,0$ , #"# 0$' 8"# ' 3 A!, $8 3 3 7" , ,"# 7"
>, $ # "3 >"(("
= /"$8,/ $3,0!
= <$7 20 , 03, !, (( $8 3 , # = 2 ' =="##"$ ')
"
( 7, 6"3 '3 ' 3 3 0$ :) &"$ 3 7" , ' 8 '3 , 03!$30! 32-
0'!"6"(#0" , (#2 $
"( 32->"(("
=/"$8,/ $3,0 "$#
0' $3#, 7 #' # '
"$ 3
'= (" $ "$8' '
$# ''"$8 , #0" &'& ' -$ ,"#!$ A '3 ' !"6"(0' 3 3 $0 '-:)
, #2 $&( ! 3$' !'3 $$ A0' 7 #0'8 32-( '$ 3# $"'!0$# ( ,
0', 3$ " ( "$
, &'& ' -( 20 2-7 - 03"$!$$"6 $! 7" ,, ',0#2 $3#, = 3 =& 30& , # "3=& $-
0'3 #&" <$7"$8 ,
! , #, 7 # $ , 7$ ' , &'& ' -) #, $ ' 3 "$
8' = $ # ( 7" ,! !!0# 3 #& (/"$8,$' ! "& #0= #* !'' # '$ # =$ -, & " "$ ', #2 $"$6(6 3"$ , !
# $ , 2 #"# $"$B0"'-!$30! 32- ,#"(3 ' '
##"5 '$ 3!0$# (
' & " "$ ' = 3 '
' $! 6 '"0# '3 '# & ## 3 2- , !"6"( 0' , 3 "( 3"$6 # "8 "$, #2 $!$30! 3"$ , &' # $ !
# $330'"$8 , !0'# "$6 # "8 "$) , # = $ # 6 '"0# 7" $ ## # "$!(03"$8
># ' #,) $1 9 &' $3 8"$3 '& ( , 6 2 $ ' !'3 3 !$!(0#"$, #2 $ ''"6 3 $ , 2 #"# , "$B0"'- , "'=@# / # '0! 0' , #!
'6 30 !($-"$ , $ =
' 0$ " -7,"!,7 #( '$$ = 3 #+"#,'
$ "" -$ :"8, #(
+"(( 8 /"$8,&0'
$3 C"&0');"'
<&0'?2"8, #( $3
0' 31"$"$8 , ( $3 , +"#,'
$ "" - ( 20 :&( # 7 ' 3 = '!
$3 0 , : &( # 9, #'
# :D &( # 7 ' #,7$ 7" ,"$ , : 2"8, # ( $3 7$ 3 2- +"#,'
$ " " - 20 , &## ##"$ &( #7 #8"6 $ , & '#$#"$ , 31"$"$8?2"8, #( 7$ 32-
'$ 9 0' 0'"$8 , & '"3 '= 0(- ! =2 ' )$(- , &## ##"$ ,' &( #= #0'"$8 #B- '3#)?2"#7
:2"#7 $#" $3?2"#7 #7 ' , $3 36 ' #& ' , ' #(0 "$ , 6 !$#"3 ' 3 (( , !$ $ "$# ( '$ 3!0$# ( ' , & " "$ ' $38$ ,'08, , &("! ' !'3 $3 , 3!0= $ #&( ! 3$
, ' !'3 20 $ !!0$ !0$# ( ' , & " "$ ' , 6"$8 #08, & '="##"$ 7" ,3'
7 ,"#& " "$ ,"## 8 )7" ,0 A&' ##"$ $- &"$"$$= '" # , !
# ) ,"#& " "$"#& '=" 3 2 3"#="## 3 7" ,3'
7$$ '"='3 '# $3#6 !
3 &'"() * E/F # $1 -