High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/1418/2002allowed

(O&M) Santosh And ORS v. Ranbir And ORS

2018-09-24Mr. Justice Harsimran Singh Sethi7 pages

!"!#$%$&'( )* )& %+&" +!,% --..!//& % 0!,%1%

&2$,&" +!,% - !%.&"!& %

,!%!& '

,&$/31*, /$45"6# !, +!..!//& %

% ,$7!!.5"6# !, ,,!%+31*,5"6# ! ,,!%.&"!& %

,)16$,!8&5"6# !,,!%.&"!& 9:&%1,&#! *.&7 ;;; <= ..!/ +% 2!!& $/!" 27 +! 8$"85 &" %$> #+$/",!& +&"!,+&5+1%2&"..!//& &" +!,..!//& % ? 8+"$!"$&* ,6!+$#1/,##$"!& &((@5,!&+&#!*!& #*.!&% $& 95@5A: 8,"!" 27 +! /!,&!" , ##$"!& % /$*%,$21&/5 &$. +!,!$& !,,!!,,!" %B +!,$21&/C <= +!,$21&/27 4$&D$& ##1& +!D! +!"!#!%!"% 97!,%5$&#*!9?A:&"27*4$&D"!"1# $&A9," +!$&#*! +!"!#!%!" 8,"%.!,%&/!>.!&%!%8,4!"1 *& +/7"!.!&"!&#7 A:5&&1/"!.!&"!&#75A:&"27../7$&D*1/ $./$!, E58,4!"1 "!.!&"!&#7 95?5A:$!5A:>E +!,! !,5

" 278,"$&D5A:&##1& #&6!& $&/+!"%5 /*1& 95@5A:8%8,"!"2787#*.!&% $& <9= F!,&!"#1&%!/..!,$&D&2!+/ +!..!//& %#& !&"% + $&6$!8%!6!&"!.!&"!& % +!"!#!%!"5"!"1# $&8% 2!*"! GAE + +!$&#*! +!"!#!%!"$&% !"GA9," +!$&#*! +! "!#!%!" $& 6$!8 .,D,.+ 9 +! "!#$%$& &H2/! +! )1.,!*!1, $&#$%# &'$(# )* +'%,- $#.*/$0 $/$#0-.1 2

!/!6& !> ,# +!%*!$%,!.,"1#!"%1&"!,':

# $%&'

( # $%& '

) # $%&*'

+ )$&#! +! "!#!%!" /! 2!+$&" %!6!& "!.!&"!& %5 +!,!,!5 "!"1# $&8$//2!*"!GAE + +!$&#*! +!"!#!%!" 8,"%+$% .!,%&/!>.!&%!% <= F!,&!"#1&%!/, +!..!//& 1, +!,#& !&"% + "!%.$ ! !& $ /!*!& 5&*1& +%2!!&8,"!"&##1& 1 1,!.,%.!# % <E= % .!, .,D,.+ ? $$$ +! "!#$%$& $& #0-.#% .*3$#.4'(/#.5 -(-0'6) 7$#.#5'0,-#.60,'$* 8 -)-%258+!,! +!"!#!%!"8%8,4$&D&.!,*&!& I2&"8%

!9" /!%% +&7!,%D!5EJ +!# 1/%/,7 +!"!#!%!"/!%% >$% 2! 4!& $& ##1& , +! .1,.%! #*.1 $&D 1 1,! .,%.!# %

,D,.+ ? $$$ +! "!#$%$& $& ,&7 )! +$H% #%! %1., $% ,!.,"1#!"%1&"!,': B)% $

- , * .

* ) %*,/

+ )$&#! $& +! $&% &#! #%!5 +! "!#!%!" "*$ !"/7 8% 9 7!,% D! &" 8% 8,4$&D & .!,*&!& I25 +!,!,!5 EJ +! # 1/ %/,7 /!%% > 8$// 2! ""!" +! $&#*! +! "!#!%!" , #*.1 $&D1 1,!.,%.!# % <?= F% /75 /!,&!" #1&%!/ , +! ..!//& % #& !&"% + #*.!&% $&&##1& #&6!& $&/+!"%+%2!!&8,"!" 6!,7 *!D!,, !%D$&% +!!& $ /!*!& E5A:&##1& 1&!,/ !>.!&%!%&"/$4!*1& ,/%%!% !8+$/!%.!,.,D,.+@ +!"!#$%$&$& #:(#;'.'$#%.*3$#.4' )* #.3#(%-#* ,3,$3#(#.60,'$*"!#$"!"&($&$6$/..!/(E 5 %1* 5A: $% .72/! & ##1& /%% %.1%/ #&%, $1* +!8$! +!"!#!%!"8+$/!/$4!*1& $%.72/! !#+ +!#+$/",!& +!"!#!%!"&##1& /%%.,!& /#&%, $1*

,D,.+?6$$$ +!"!#$%$&$&7$#.#5 '0,- *#%!%1., &"

!" .,D,.+@ +!"!#$%$&$& #:(#;'.'$#%.*3$#.4' 1* 4#*'%1., $%,!.,"1#!"%1&"!,'

,D,.+?6$$$ +!"!#$%$&$&7$#.#5'0,- * #%!%1., :0

0 %*&# 0 &# 0 %*&# %,

,D,.+ @ +! "!#$%$& $& #:(# ;'.'$#% .*3$#.4' 1* 4#*' %1., :B12 /

4 5 $ '

9 9

0- 6 0- 5

6 $(%';5

* 5

- 8 4

8 <

!<"

= -

> 9

= -

=? /

/ /!

4 5 $ ' .

+ @ & +!/$D+ +!.%$ $&& !"26!5 +!..!//& H%,!+!/" !& $ /!" E5A:&##1& /%%!% !5E5A: 8,"%1&!,/ !>.!&%!% 2!%$"!% 5A: & ##1& /%% %.1%/ #&%, $1* &" /$4!*1& !#+ +!#+$/",!& +!"!#!%!"&##1& /%% .,!& /#&%, $1*

!=" <= &6$!8 +!.%$ $&%& !"26!5#*.!&% $&.72/! 8,4%1 %1&"!,': $ '#6* (3.0 #**'**'6 >5 0,'$->3.#% (3.0 #**'**'6 >5 0,'3$0 &#*! 9?A: 9?A:

1 1,! ,%.!# % F EJ9?A:K EA: 9 / &#*! %%!%%!" 9?A: 9?A:LEA:

K EA:

1/ $./$!,../$!" E E E !"1# $& 8,"% .!,%&/ !>.!&%!% "!#!%!"

A9,"9?A:K EA: AE +EA:K (A:,1&"!" (EA:

? !.!&"!&#7 &&1/ 9?A::EA:

KA:$! A:.!,*& + A:>K 5A: EA::(EA:

K 9?(A:.!,*& + 9?(A:>K 95A: @ *.!&% $& 8,"!" 5A:>EK 95?5A: 95A:>EK ?5E5A: F%%&%, $1* 5 #&%/$" !"

5A:M$!

G5A:!#+ +!%$>#+$/",!& +! "!#!%!"

/ 55A:

( F%%% ! E5A:

1&!,/>.!&%!% E5A: & !,!% (J (J 98?@ 2= ?@ <(= ##,"$&D/75%D$&% #*.!&% $&95@5A:8,"!" 27 +!,$21&/5 +!..!//& %:#/$*& %,!+!/"!& $ /!" #*.!&% $&

!8" 2= ?@/&D8$ +$& !,!% G(J.!,&&1*8$ +!!# ,* +! " !#/$*.! $ $& $//" !.7*!& 5/!%%.7*!& 5$&75*"!!,/$!, <= !!"/!%% *!& $&5#*.!&% $&2!.$" +!..!//& %$& ##,"&#! 8$ + +!, $% $.1/ !" $& +!$, 61, % .!, +! 8," !, "!"1# $&D +! >/$2$/$ 7$&7N1 +!1 1,!.,%.!# %$&##,"&#!8$ + +!"!#$%$&$& ,&7)! +$H%#%!%1., <= ##,"$&D/75 ..!/ $% //8!" 27 *"$7$&D 8," " !" 9.%%!"27 +!/!,&!",$21&/ &$. +!!> !& %& !" 26! )M/$ 1"D! ( *$ M+! +!,%.!4$&DA,!%&!" ' !%A M+! +!,,!., 2/! ' !%A