High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/12669/2008disposed of

Mohinder Pal Goel v. State Of Haryana And ANR.

2017-11-30Mr. Justice Rajesh Bindal,Mr. Justice Gurvinder Singh Gill4 pages

! "#$# "

& '!( )"* !"

!"#$ %&'()!*+,-.) "/)+0-%1"( %&'()!*+,-.)*!2-%1)!3-%40-((

!)+)%,$ "-.!#/ !$"%"0-%0 "!, " "- /&"#0- #-%$ "#0)"* 0 "(!% "(1", " 2! /!"0-

-%$ "# 0)"* "3/ !( !#0-%0 ")(44

"/)+0-%1"(5 '!, "! ,,"! ! &" 1! ,"*" "

5& ! 5& 1!"

& "(

!3 -5& -0 7 " !"8!-901"

0" ,%#*'!1"1

& .*! 3 -5& ##"

'!, "#:!!,&"! # : &" 6

5&"*" % #

7 " &:

)! "

:##1"/ !,1!"! ""*

! $#;

6' .# !!

0!" ,!6",!

!%.

< -

<&"1!!1", 4 1 &.:!.2

& "( =- !-&# . # !, " %":/ 1.&!

& "( 7 !-- !"1

< ! 5&" # !, " 1 ""* 6

#%#!0! : "% ."# ":!5& !( !. 6 !" ! !" ! 0 #"

# " ! "

&.:!!," 1", #,""!

& : !1"!#

& 6 :

0! &" 6" ": * ":

"",

1!" & 5&1 6" '!1"1

& .*!3 -5& ##"

'!&6!!"1 & 5&6" .* ! &"0.& ##!, """ &"!"

% .* "! 6&, !# 1 .*)(440 "1!!:,# 1

:!()0#( 0*>"

#0 !"1 # !, " 1 "!< #* = 5&"*"

,"!"% &"" #:.*!:41 &"!" &.: !!"1 .&

6"" $# ;

60"!"!"1 :##":'!,!6",!

< 1!!1", &66 !!"1 :##11"/ 01!"

," #*1 !"1!#"6 #

01!!

#"#* .# ! !!, " !% *" , "!&" "!""

!%#! : ##*'!11"/

:! 01!!! 0

.#*.

< !":/, 6 %1! ? !" !": ) &"!" &.:!.2

& "( =- ! -1" #.*!, "0 !:

< 6!! 1

1!! " !#*, 3"

# "!, " ,&! ! ," #* ## ":!,#) &"!"&#

,&! !

< 6*0 :"! 1! ! , -

<&" )"#"

# "!," ,"& !,,"

./ ! ! 0!, "! &

&##*: #!

&"1! :

&0!1%"0 # ! :, !: # # !1", )#:!.*" 6!

0!, "1 ""*

11"/ !

@$#;

6@4 &,,"!",!6",!

!% . ! 1! ! 1" , -

<&" 4 ! ,!6",!

0 ":! 0 ? 1!! :"!

@<@4 ,!6",!0 11"/ :! !

1!# 1 ,# / #* 6!" '! ? !": 1!!!:"# #* 60# 61!

!:!

.#*. ? ":01!!1 !%.

"&.*!, "+!"!"1":"! ": 1!" ! :! ! . 0 % ": ! ,!6",!

) 0!, "": #!&".* !1 !!,!6",!!. / ":

!":4 0! ,!6",! :!",#A&"!" !!",!6",!0 : :! 11"/ :! ! .,#& ! ": , "1! :,# / & !":4!. .* 6!,!6",!'! ::! 1! :1 ,# / 01!!

7 " .

!":.*& 6!," !,!6",!

, 6! : !!",!6",!! !/ "

## & , ;% !"1 # !

% ":!,!6",!

#0"!",," #*! :1

#/ 6 1 :!. " #*, A&"!"! & !, " % ":! ! , & 5&"",

.*! &" !, #.* !:0!" &"!"

"1!!:,# 1!!# ( 0*>"

#01 #6.*!)(44 '! !

<.*!, "1!!1", 0 :##

"&":1!11"/ !,! 01!" :#*

1! ",#1 %" !" A"!"

: .%01 *:"

!," 1" , '! : "% . :

"" " 6#* - !, "!": #! &"0! .&" 1! =0

B01!! !##., 1!" 1! : ! ":*4 #&"0!( !##. # & ! :& ": ! :& :,

1!! ! , " # & 5& +2 !C # D&6

$&"% "( 6!$## %

D&6 !!" ,/ 6B" E B !!"+,".# E B