M/S Cholamandalam Investment And Finance Company Limited v. Rajender Kaur












 

 

  

    

!"#$##"#$ %&$& '(#
$)#* +&

,,, &(&(

-

#. /#  ,)&

 

 
 
 
 
  01  2*

 3(!#&!

!)#4 0 #&4



## 5#.#.4 0 #&4 )&(&(

 3

#$"(4 0 #&4 )&

 
 

(&#& )&(&(4 )6

0&( " 
&(& %(#4 ##(" #& 88 09



)# :

1 :

( ;((( '#(#2# ( 6 &

= 66 )#&( #&  1#(1 )( (1 ((&(#& > ! 4 &#*

 3!

 #* &#("4 6# & $##&(1 6$ (( #  / ".& 3(1!

:#2( /#  (  # ##(" "# ?44?  6$ > ((& "# #1$& 9

&

)&* 2#(1 @   $# (1  > # *#

 (& #& 5" =
4 #.# A#
"*4 '#(#2# !(#6& 6 B&! ))&*C

$&1#1 #& &($ ##("(1 #6#( "#

8 '4 2< 6#(" #! )#*$& )"# &#& $#=(1 6# "&4

&

"#(6( @

6$(1 0& @

?8

2< #$"* :#2( /#  9)(  / ".& 3(1!

9)(  ? $ 484  (

? 6$

( # #$ & / ".& 3(1! 06& #.

&(1 #$ &4 $ 884?44 &&#(1 8



 (1

(&(#&(  &

'(# (#"

0& D6 $&

(&* %&& 6 !& B&! &C

< ((&(#&

$# #& 

8

((&(#""* 4 2> &"* #"" 6!

$# #& 88 0 9



 "1#"

!( :#2( /#  / ".& 3(1!4

#""(1

) &!$ )#* &&#(1 #$ & ?448??

<(&!( )(  #*

 @ 2. &( # &#& ( #1#(& $#  3*$2"(

)( ))&* () & &#= 88 09

8 

 #" #& 88 1# ))&* () &  ( = )

 #& &!#&4 #&! #" #&

8 ?

09

?



))&* () & " <#*

44  6# 

)  !#

 0

?

6(" )  #& #& ?

09



)#
!(6 :

( (#"

#1(&#&4 '#(#2#

( #& ?

09



<#4 &!64 


E 8 (&(& & )& #. /#   <(& )&(&(4 &# &#= "(> (!$&  #&  9

& #. /# 4 :#2( /#  #.<#& /# 4 &!( < 6 <(""

6#  / ".& 3(1!4  "& ! $ #2"

& < ))&* () & <(& <(&!#<  09

  +(2&* <#4 !<4 1#& )& &#=  #"&#&( $(4

# "#<

 E! 66& < $# 2&#( )!*( #"

)( ))&* () &4 !(#

#& )&4  "& !4 #1#( 6("
!(6 :

( (#"

#1(&#&4 '#(#2# ( #&  09



(  ;

&#"4 '#(#2#4 

$)"(# 

 )& )6 @  &(&" #. /#  -

!"#$##"#$ %&$& '(#
$)#* +($(&4 <!( < &# &#=

? &&#""*

&#( &# &#=
E 8 &#&(1 "(> (!$&  #&   "& 6# 

 (&(& &   88

%& !# # &! 1!

)* $$ (4 

)* )"#(& (  884  #1#(&

&#* &#((1 6$ &#=(1 )!*( #"

)( ))&*4 )#

011( #$4 (&#& (( !# )6

8 +#

"

)#&( < !#

? %& 2$(&& "#

"

 (1

#1#(& <(&! (6*(1 1 ( ( )& %& 2$(&&

)* )"#(& ( )&(&(6#& "* $$ ( (< #$4 ! 

#1#(& )&(&(6#&

 %& &! 2$(&& &4 <!(" 1#&(1

(.

 )&)"#(&(664 "& (1!& 6# (< )(( 8?

2#  (.



1#&

+#

"

2$(&& ( (



(

$&# 4 " 1#& (.

 )&)"#(&(66 )(& 2# 8?

&

+#

"

#" 2$(&& $"*  6#  )"#

 < $# 1& #"

$#&& #2 &#(" 6# 4 <

&( 2#

 %& 2$(&& "#

"

)&(&(6#& <!(" (&(& &(1
E 8 09

 )&6#& #. /# 4 <! <(& )&(&(4  "* # "(> (!$& 4 9

&  6#  / ".& 3(1!

& "

&#* :#2( /# 4 #.<#& /#  #. /# 4 <!# (&4 # "(> (!$&   "& 6#  +#

"

2$(&& &! 6# & < > ( 2 1!& &

 %& 2$(&& <!(" 9 ((1 )<

0&( " 
&(& %(#4

. )"#(&

&

(("

2(1 $#(&#(#2"

(< 2#

&#( 8?

30'03D% & +#

"

2$(&& &! 1!

)&(&(6#&

#))# ! <#* &&(1 #( ( )&(&(6#& 



! (=

0&( " 
&(& %(# ( )# )#")#2"* (""1#"

<(&! &(

 +#

"

2$(&& $#*

#4 F(1!

&4 <!(" 9 ((1 )<

0&( " 


&(& %(#4 &#(1!&#<#* . & )"#(& 1 

))& !(

&&(4 "#

"

"(

) #& ? )# ;((( 5 ;"!( F(1!

+ 0 &(&" 


!"#
$%
!& "'(
(
)$*+
&,!$#
$-
$%
$!& "'.

3(1" 5 1$& ;"!( F(1!



 8 &(&"  !# $%#
$/"(& "$&
$%

,$$0"
! 1$
&%
(
,( ,
#
 ' 
$%
!& "'(4  ( 8G 3(1" 5 1$& F(1!

1!#"#*#
 8 &(&" (("&

"0!$(&')0&,!$
! 1$
2$%,3
, ,&"%
2 3
(
 
" "$&(
&%
$%
!& "'(4  ( 8 ?8 )# FC2" 0)9 <!2* 3+

#1#(&

#6#(

1$& F(1!

1!#"#*#4 !# ($(





&#4 "#

"

)& 2$(&& &!  (""1#"(&* ($) 1  %& 2$(&& )(& #"( ( 4 ( ) #))## #4 &!64 (1!&"* 

#1#(& )&(&( %& 2$(&&  6# > &( $#(&#(#2("(&*

(("

4 #$ < 2#   "* #""1

(("

"(> (!$&  #""1 9

& 6#  / ".& 3(1!4  "& 6# 

+#

"

2$(&& 6# 

"* ) "#(1 ( ;2&  * 7(2 #"

6 !&

 B;7C

<

 30'03D% #"

 +#

"

2$(&& (&# $(1 &&(1 #( (  #1#(&

4

! (&(& & )&

0&( " 
&(& %(# +#

"

2$(&&

 $* (=

$(1 > ((& (=

0&( " 
&(& %(#

 %

( 2$(( $# "#

"

)#&(


$(1 6(& ($) 1 4 #$  "*   )&(&(6#& ( 2# =  &! 1!

(&

"= )(&

# !#(1

#"" #"

&($4   ) #))## (& 2!#"6

(1"*4 

#1#(& )&(&(6#&

( )(( &4 &!  (""1#"(&*

 #)& &  )&(&(6#& 

! #))#4 (1!&"* 

#1#(& (&

 @<

$(1 1#& (.

 &(4

( )(( (

( $#&& 6$

 )) &( 8?

&() "#&



 H8?

&(I@

(("

!#""

&&#(  (1 ) $#&& ;2&  * 7(2 #"

 0))""#& 7(2 #"

$)< 

&$(  (.

 !#""

1#&

 &! &!(&* ) &#=  &#= )  )<

6 



 * ;2& ;

5#= '(# (#"

%&(& &( 8  8 J 8 %& <""

&&" $#""*

$#&& 2#

 $* )#&* = =  ;7



&

&#(

#4 <! 6#  )"# #$

#& ) (1 ;74  #"

 FC2" )$ %(#G F(1!

#( &! F(1!

& #"(1 &($ #1#(

E(&! 1(1 (& &#("

#4 # & <""

=< "#< <""

&&"4 6 
$# 1$& FC2" )$

# '%,
 " ,0#(
&%
4
& "'(

(
$,!$
!5
$%,

?

?

3

8G #"0&'!(&""#
(&,$6(
, ,&"%

(

(("&

"0!$(&')0&,!$
! 1$
, ,&"%
4
'(

  3

8G 6%,(
,$6
(
""'##
$%
!& "'(

?

 3

?G

 '
$%)(&',#
$&"'1',("(
&%
(
!$6
!$6
$%
 $6 ,
$-,$6
!'1!'&,!$4   3

?

"$&'#
$-
!5
$%,
$%
!& "'(
(

 &
'+ 
,$
$%
!& "'(

 ?

3

8

 ?

( )(( &4 9 ((1 &(4 !

( #6#( 1$& "#< 2. 1#

#4 #6& 6(1 1$&4

$

"

( &4   

#"

4

 #!# F<4 

9 (

&#= 6# &!  6 )(( 8?

 "#< 2. &

( )(( !4 

 @<

$(1 <!&! ! 9 (

0&( " 
&(& %(# #"

<!&!   & 7! 1!

 )< " (& *&

( )((

&4 )#&( ! "1#& <! &!* ! ). &!( ) &(

# &! ! #( #& ) (6(

"

(

)&(&(4

( )((

&4 ! 6(& #))# !

<#* #)))(#& (  #1#(&
 
&! ! #1(&#& #2 1#&
 
&#*

F<4

! &#(1!&#<#*

$ #&! &!# 6("(1 &

  @  2&4 


!"#( )( 
"/,(
 )# ;"!( F(1!

9 ( . )"#(& F<4 =)(1 (< &! #

&#( "#))(1  )( "(&(1#&(4 &4 #"#* 24 < " (& #& &#1 < (&# "1#& )#&( &

  &!(1 !#

$ )&)"#(&(66 !# &#=(1

&#( &* &#

(("

)( <(& (&(& & )&)"#(&(66 1# "(> (!$&  6# !#""

( #((1 #&   

"

(

 (< &!64 ($) 1 & #(

#&( # "1#& & )&(&(6#&4 (6  #(4 $#* $ > ((& &4 (6  $4 !#""

#"& &4

# "#<

#&( $#* &! #1(&#& &!(

"#($ 1# 1#&   1#& (.

 (< #$& $#

(("

(&G )(( 8?

"#< 2. 6 ) (1 )##1#)!

 ' #6#( ) )4 )#&( $#* #))# 

%& 9) & < 9)(&( "* #"

 (1!&  )#&( # #66 & F<4 &! ( & #6& 4 !#""4

#

 $ )&(&(6#&4 1( #> #& ))& (&* &! ( ) &!  ( #$ &#* <(&!( &< <=

# ?

8 &# () #2 &$

8

(1 #&( (6 #*4 !#""

#" &# () 6

2 
 3















 




E!&! )#=(1 #  K @ E!&! )&#2"

 K @