Gurdev Singh And Others v. Chandigarh Admn. And Others
!"
#!
$%% %"&% %% % %" '( ()*+* , ,
"% -. ",$!/
/!" /%" %0!"
-. /,$!/
/!
/%"%
!
"
#$ %
#& /!
/%"% 1$, $ ' "! (
" "
! " " ) "
!
" * !
%
""
* &$,$$--% %-,$$--&.
/0% 0& "12 3
4 5 ) $6-3. 7 72 !
,8,&%,,&.
/032 1 )
& 5 "
!
!
"
!1 ) $$0
" 1* "
* !
* !
1 !1 3 "1 "*1 ( *1 "
1* 0 9
!
# $ % &'" ()* ! " $
$ & ! " # " #
-.
## "
" ! '" & $ # '" 0 " 1 2( 3
))
$
))) &
! ## $ #" " " 0 ! #
" 0 ## 2 & / "# /4 2
))
" '" !
* )) 5 ! !
#
"#
60 7 -.
/4 2
))
))) /4 2 **
))+ 8 $# 9 5 " ! " /0 4 !
()):
!" #
" $ ! '" /# & ;0!
& 2
** ))( ! !
()):
! " ! /4 2*(* ))
/4 2 *()
))( /4 2 *)
))( "
" " !
#
)))(
60 7 -.
/" $
" # /4 2 (:
)):
/4 2++( )):
/4 2 +:+ )):
/ 2 () )):
/4 2 )+ )):
/4 2 ++ )):
/4 2 *
)):
/4 2
2 +:
)):
"# "
" "
" #
60 7 -.
*())( ! " # #
" '"
* )):
$ ) +
#
"
( "
2 "
# ! (
) ,0" ! ! 0#
! ! "
( % "
& "
% &'" / " &!
!
&" * ! &"# "
1# !#
"# 0
!
0
# " 0!
&!
0 $ & &! "# "# ! < 1 ""
" ! " ! "
$ & ;" 0 "#
/0 4 2 *+(+ ))( ## $ = #" !
0" 0 $ & & &"# #
-.
#" # #
"# !> 8 :
" " * 4 #$ :#8,8$ %,,8
! * *1 "
"
!
""
:0$3468 $--6 !
" 1 * %%,$%,,6 ; ! "1 "*1 !
/ :0$3468 $--6 "
<+
%%,$%,,6 "
! :0 $$&8% %,,3 "
"
:
< =
$3$%%,,4+ " * !
" 1* *1 0
'
. 2 6 = . 0
'
"
0 ? "# $
)))
" "
" ! !
'"
,
0
$ "
0
4
% &'"
5 /#
2
!
0 $ ! #
#" " " 0 '" " ! 0
" ##
2 & / /4 2
))
"
* )) 5 ! !
60 7 /4 2
))
))) /4 2 **
))+ 8 $# 0 5 ! " ! " ! 0 ()):
$ ! '" /# & ;0!
& 2
** ))( ! !
()):
! "" ! /4 2 *(* ))
/4 2 *()
))( /4 2 *)
))( "
" " !
#
)))(
" # "
" !
60 7 0 *())( "
#
" '"
* ))
/" $ #0 !# #
0" " !
#> "
$&$,$$--% # ?3 5 ) !
%%-,$$--& # 4 !
&$%,%$--& # 4 !
*" 3@$&,%-& %&,%$--& # 1 @$$ 1.2 8%3,%$--& 1 :#%$%4 $--&!
4%%,-$--8 :#%$%4 $--&!
*1> '
*1
" ;@ %&,--8 ,%,;$--;
# 1 1 $--8A$$, 1 1 $--4A&48 1 1 $--;A$6& 1 00000000000 A486 1.'2 00000000000 6,&,;$--;
1 :#33&& $--4!
-$$,6$--; :#33&& $--4!
""!*1 !
" :#%$%4 $--& . 2+ !"
#%33 $--6!
"!
"
1!
!"
!
$,&$,$%,,& !"
#%33 $--6!
""! *1 :#33&& $--4 "
! *
!
#;$;8 %,,&!
" :#33&& $--4 (
!"
*
"
* / 1 !1 *"
4 $$,$,3%,,& #;$;8 %,,&!
! !
$%,4,%%,,& # - !
*
%6,%%,,& $&,8,&%,,& !
!
$3@,$,%,& ,3,&%,,&
+'3*,(,# 4 3+.2 $8 + " .B'B2A $$B486B&%A;,$ 1
5 & " ! "
!
* ))
: " "# ! # " !"
0
! ! !"
0 $ & & $# 8""# $
0 $ @1 A))*B $" / *
-.
& "# ! 0
" 60 @" 0 5 /# "# &0 /# & A)))B %;
60 7 "
? #
" '" 0 # ,
& ! 0#" "
" "# ! ! " 0" '" '" >
, " 00 0 $ & &> - !
" 1 C 7*"/ "60784 9*:(4+7+/''( !
9*;49 .%,$62;;4&+ " *1 C 7*" / 0 ?
& % &'" ()*
A ? &>B
)) "
" 0 " 2 6
)))
(: * '"# '" !
&# "# #
" '" #" 0
80
"
&0 & 5
/# &
! ## 0 "# /4 2 ))
" '" !
* )) 5 !
60 7
))) /4 2**
))+ ! " ! " , !
()):
!" # ! '" /# & 0!
! !
()):
!# & " !
# /4 2*(* ))
/4 2*()
))( /4 2*)
))( "
" " !
)))( &
# /4 2 (:
)):
/4 2++( )):
/4 2+:+ )):
/4 2 () )):
/4 2)+ )):
/4 2++ )):
/4 2 *
)):
/4 2+:
)):
!
"
" " !
60 7 *())( " !
C"
* ))
"
) +
#
"
( "
"
# ! (
) ,0" ! !
"
#
# !# & "#
" ! ! "
& " "" # 0 / & # 2 ! #
& " # '"
*
-#
"#
"# # 0"
! : @ 4 =
0 5 , /4 2
*
! # " ! 0 1 1 2 2 ! 2
! " 2
0 " #
"# " 60 @" 0 5 /# /4 2*(* ))(
)))( @ 4 A"B * + C
0 80 0
&0> ?)
'" ! ! " & "
"# ,
0 " " #
"# "
2 & / 3 5 /#
" $ 2 > ? " !
# ! " !
" " 30 # " 0
-# 0 <$% " ! 1 0!
> ?: 0" ! ! " ! " "
" > ?
;"
# 0 0
! "> $, = ! *
"
! #
" 1 "" / * ! $$ ""
"
"1 /!" /%" %0!" /!
/%"% $! $! ()(8<(41 :
(
D?# :
*" D?#