Bachan Singh And ORS v. State Of Punjab And Others
!
"#"$%"& ' ( (
( )*"
"+,#, '- ( (
!" - . / ( 0 00 1 . / 0( 0 0 0
#### $% &'
()* ( " $+ "()&)+
$ "()* ( ",- $, .
& / ()* ( ",0 $1 ()* ( ", #### 0 0
(
&&"'" 23 - 4)5 6 "
7 & 8 & //(
+*/(!
& *&"/ "
/( 8 " .
&"&* " & 9 / '
'
&&/
+ / %
& & *&:,;222 ;< & *' "'
" 7"
&&'
!
#
#
" #
3
+ / %
&1 & !*',3
- **&:,;222 ; 2 0(
&&''
"
7 $
% &'
(
) ))& )+)
, ,
)-./
0'
./ 0..'
1 )2
,
"
,4
'
0..'
#
,
0'
.- 0..'
"
5 5
#
,
0.')+ 0../
'
"
"
5
0'
.- 0..'
#
5 5
,
*
6
% 5
+ #
"
#
)0 ).
"
% 0'
.- 0..'
,## 5
*
6
5
+
% 5
+
% 5
#
$
85
!
#
#
" #
6
'
))0 3 0.
3"
5 5
"
5
'
#
"
)--'
;
#
5
'
,
#
"
#
"
6
<
*
5 5
"
0'
.- 0..'
# ##
"
*
6
(
,##
#
1&2 "
(
,
( )--&
#
# ,##
1 "2
##
))0 ).
"
"
"
#
6 4
5
#
)0 0.
"
#
(
"
#
"
'
#
#
5
'
5
#
6
9
:
" ##
#
(
6
5- , (
5)' , =/"& *( (!
& *&"/
*"" 7 + / %
& + / %
& 1 ( * 2> & "
7 4?
*&"/6( "
/ !
*&"/ ( ( & -2; ' * 7
'
& 9 ,- / '
'
* >
& // //'
3
&. *&"/ @
(!
(, & ( !
(% "
(
('
* 7* ( / "(9 ,-'" + / &* & /(A6 4 =( ' & '
"'
""
7 //
&* * & /
& A9 7
# = *&& %
&)"/( '
,-/ '
'
' * !
/ // 7(' "/ 7
# ('
*
"
" '
" / + / %
& '+ / %
&1 '
' "
'& 9 ,-4
'
66 4 /''+ / %
& & + / %
& ' 9 ,2> " // '
" 7 ( !
*&"/ 2 ) * 2> (" &: , >2 "
"" + / %
& %
&1 7"
&&'
>?
@
#
0 +
?&@ 5
5 1(5)2
0 +
# #
5 1(5)2
?+@
"
#
#
#
#
# #
%
A
5#
"
(
#
#
.'
0.)+
(
#
##
"
"
#
##
"5 "
*
#
; =/"& *( * & "
7 ( * 3> 2"
&&' ' + / %
& + / %
&1
<
B
)--/
+&+
-+
+/C
&0C
;
0// 3 ) 3"
)0) 3 / 3" # 9 "
9
4
.D
'
'+
''
/) 9
)'+ 2 )'
5.2 )''
.2 )/+ 1/5.2 )/ 5+2 )/'
1)5).2 )-.
1 5+2 )-0 1 5+2 )-
1+5)+2 )-& 1 5+2 )-+ 1&5 2 )- 1 5+2 0.
1'5)'2 0.'
5 2 0./ 1+5/2 0.- 1'5.2 0).
)2 0)) 1&5'2 0)0 105)02 0)
1&5))2 0'.
1) 5) 2 & - 1+5.2 9
) '
3 )./ 3" # 9 "
D9
)D / .D
'&
'+
'
'-
/.
/0
/&
/+ 9
)'/ 1+'5)&2 )'- 105)&2 )/0 1&5 2 )/
105.2 )/& 1-5) 2 )// 1'5&2 ) 1 5+2 1 5+2
1&5-2 / 105)&2 0 & 1+/5 02 -0) 1 5+2 9
)0
# 9 " 9
.D '+ 9
0'0 1)5)/2 ##
6# 6
%
-
" &?4*&6,3 2< & "/ = - >"
7 :, >2 * ? < &)"5 0 2"
&&'
>E
,
#
"
%(F( #
*
"
*
" #
;"
(
" G
5
A A #
0 =/"& * < & "/ ( 8 &//( +*/(!
& *&"/
"
/( 23 -"
&&'
>9
#
#
(
.+ 0.).
$ "
,
4
)+&& 0.).
3
"
5
;H
; ; ,
7
*B
#
;H
* ,
7
)- .0 0.)
7
"
)0 3 ).
3" # 9
#
.+ 0.).
(
;
=
23 -/"
"'" @> ( &&''
"
7
)
I
D
).
#
$
"
#
5
).
# #
#
(
,
#
G
6
*
#
+
#
#
#
6
"
#
#
B
0.0
=
=/"& /(
* 3 3'
& 7$( &. *&"/ @
(!
&* " /"
>
$
#
;H
,
6
9
"
" A (5)D$
;H
,
$
9
"
"
+
$
#
.+ 0.).
1 A 5+2
(
*6 "
*6
# ##
#
9
"
#
6 4 "
))0 3 ).
3"
$
"
)0 3 ).
3"
9
))0 3 5).
3" " "
(# ## 7
#
"
"
"
"
"
9
1))0 3 5).
3"2 6 4 #
" 9
0 +
7
,##
A 5&
&0 0../
AAAAA AAAAA AAAAA
/
$
#
)0 3 5).
3" 9
)0 3 ).
3"
9
" "
(# ##
#
= 3 )" &
* & 7" ' " & & / '
9 ,- *&& %
& 1 '
' * !
/ // 7(' & /( / *&&
%
&1 =*' *(' /"'" // > / "( &&" ""& " &7 00 1 0 0
)'6)$7
:" . CD, :" & CD,