High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/17186/2007dismissed

Gurdial Singh v. Pb. St. Civil Supplies Corp. Ltd.

2017-03-07Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan3 pages

"#$ %$&'(')*

+,%'"-.')/0 $#'#')$, (!

1$,(+( +)2"3.#"#$ '4'-.+55-'$( ,5,"#')6'7'#$%")%#0$,( $(5)%$)# (!

* 86 . 9 6. ,$($)#*:

,7,';.')/0")% , +)'(0 +5#"<%4&"#$(<

,#0$5$#'#')$, ,7") 0"+%0",=")% ,."%>"-<%4&"#$(<

,,$(5)%$)#(")% 0$#0$,#0$$5,#$,( -&"-)$>(5"5$,7"=3$"-->$%# ($$#0$2+%/7$)#?

3$,$ $,,$%##0$$5,#$,,)# 0$#0$,#0$2+%/7$)#(0+-%3$,$5,#$%')#0$%'/$(#? ::

0$ 5$#'#')$,< >0 >"( >,;')/ "( " .+3 )(5$&#, >'#0 ,$(5)%$)#:

,5,"#')< ,$#',$% ,7 ($,4'&$ ) "##"')')/ #0$ "/$

(+5$,"))+"#'))

#&7$(+##0"##0$5$#'#')$,>"(($,4$% >'#0"&0",/$(0$$#<$)%,($%)

))$@+,$::!+)%$,+-$

#0$+)2"3 '4'-.$,4'&$( +)'(07$)#")%55$"-(!+-$(<A <,$/",%')/ (7$"&#(%)$')#0$=$",(AB")%AC0$5$#'#')$,(+37'##$%,$5-= ##0$("'%&0",/$(0$$#)

))$@+,$::!0$5$#'#')$,%'% )#&0"--$)/$#0$("'%&0",/$(0$$#"##0"##'7$0$,$" #$,<4'%$,%$,%"#$%

))$@+,$::!< ") ')D+',=

'&$, >"( "55')#$% # '( #0$,$"

#$,#0"##0$5$#'#')$,74$%#0$5,$($)#>,'#5$#'#')&0"--$)/')/#0$ ("'%&0",/$(0$$#")%#0$"55')#7$)# #0$')D+',=

'&$,#"-(&7$( +##0"#4'%$,%$,%"#$%AC

<5"(($%3=#0'( +,#< +,#0$,

5,&$$%')/(3$ ,$#0$')D+',=

'&$,>$,$(#"=$% 0"4$0$",%#0$-$",)$%&+)($-( ,#0$5",#'$(")%0"4$"-( &",$ +--=/)$#0,+/0#0$ '-$ 0$5,"=$, #0$5$#'#')$,')#0$5,$($)#>,'#5$#'#')'( , D+"(0')/#0$&0",/$(0$$#$)%,($%)

))$@+,$::!")%#0$ ,%$,%"#$%

))$@+,$::!<"55')#')/')D+',=

'&$,<)#0$ /,+)% +)%+$%$-"=,$/",%')/"&#(%)$')#0$=$",(AB")%AC")% ;$$5')/#0$&0",/$(0$$#5$)%')/ , '4$=$",(")%"55')#')/#0$')D+',=

'&$,')#0$=$",

)-="

#$,#0$,$#',$7$)# #0$5$#'#')$, 0$ -$",)$% &+)($- , #0$5$#'#')$,< , +)'(0 +5#"< %4&"#$<0"(,$-'$%+5)#0$"+#0,'#= #0$)83-$.+5,$7$ +,#

)%'"') 1 "0"%$4")1$,(+( <+(')/",%<

C! .+5,$7$ +,# "($(0$5$,+("- #0$("'%"+#0,'#=(0>(#0"##0$ &0",/$(0$$#')#0$("'%&"($>"('((+$%')#0$=$",

,$/",%')/"&#%)$ ') #0$=$",AA 0$5$#'#')$,&0"--$)/$%#0$("7$')#0$=$",

>'#0+#")=%$-"=>$4$,<')#0$5,$($)#&"($<#0$&0",/$(0$$#'((+$%') #0$=$",

>"()$4$,&0"--$)/$%+)#'-#0$')D+',=

'&$,>"("55')#$% ')#0$=$",

0$ -$",)$% &+)($- , #0$ 5$#'#')$,< , 7,'; .')/0< %4&"#$<0"(,$-'$%+5)#0$"+#0,'#= #0$)83-$.+5,$7$ +,#

)%'"')$4,";"(0$>",'1$,(+( 5$,"#'4$)(#'#+#')"-.$,4'&$ ",%<6+&;)>")%#0$,(< B !.

<>0'&05$,#"')#"&"($ >0$,$ #0$ ##", ,"%$(0 :5$,"#'4$ 75-=$$( .$,4'&$ $/+-"#')(< AC<>$,$"55-'&"3-$<>0$,$"(')#0$5,$($)#&"($<#0$&0",/$(0$$#>"( '((+$%+)%$,#0$+)2"3 '4'-.$,4'&$( +)'(07$)#")%55$"-!+-$(< A <>0$,$')#0$,$'(5,4'(') #";')/"&#')$4$)"

#$,,$#',$7$)# ")

$75-=$$

)#0$#0$,0")%<#0$-$",)$%&+)($-( ,,$(5)%$)#(0"( 5-"&$%,$-'")&$+5)#0$"+#0,'#= #0$5$@ +,#') )') )%'"")% ")#0$,1$,(+(9+)'($##=."#=")","=")"<

!.+5,$7$ +,# "($( <>0$,$')#0$5$@ +,#0"(#";$)#0$4'$>#0"#,%')",'-=#0$ +,# (0+-%)#$)#$,#"')#0$5$#'#')#D+"(0#0$&0",/$(0$$##'(#3$%)$'

#0$ &0",/$(0$$# , #0$ (0> &"+($ )#'&$ '( >'#0+# 2+,'(%'&#') , #0$,>'($>0--='--$/"- #$,&)('%$,')/#0$ "&#(")%&',&+7(#")&$(&+5-$%>'#0#0$

"&##0"##0$&0",/$(0$$#>"(&0"--$)/$%"

#$, '4$=$",( #0$'((+")&$

#0$("7$<"7 #0$4'$>#0"#-$##0$')D+',=3$&75-$#$%")%#0$')D+',=

'&$,(+37'##0$,$5,# "%4$,($,$5,#'((+37'##$%")%"%4$,($,%$,'( 5"(($%"/"')(##0$5$#'#')$,<#0$5$#'#')$,>'--3$$)#'#-$%#&0"--$)/$#0$ ("7$ 0$,$'()/,+)%#D+"(0#0$&0",/$(0$$#")%"55')#7$)#

')D+',=

'&$, "# #0'( (#"/$ 0$,$ ,$< #0$ 5,$($)# >,'# 5$#'#') '( %'(7'(($% $(5)%$)#( ",$ %',$&#$% # &75-$#$ #0$ $)#',$ ')D+',= 5,&$$%')/(>'#0')('@7)#0( ,7#0$%"#$ ,$&$'5# &$,#'

'$%&5=

#0'(,%$,

6. !

(2;( 0$#0$,(5$";')/,$"()$% * $( 0$#0$,$5,#"3-$ *