High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/9848/2025disposed of

Dinesh Garg v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2026-05-12Mr. Justice Tribhuvan Dahiya8 pages

'()(*+*, !-.*/*+*0

$$$ 9

$$$ ! "# $ %

& :$ !' !1 * + $ :$1:' !!

!1 * .' 4$

/+ .!

2 +

!!!"#$"%$" &' (=5&'2/4

) * ! + + ! ! * ,

- - / /0*! ! +/ / 1 $'2 + + / !

! /! ( * +1

+:,:3 *-

* 13 * !4 * . + !

! + 3 56$5"$ ""6 ..5$"&$"#' / +( ** * ++* !

!! "&$"7$""7 ! 5$"&$ "#' ( = ! =% % * 1.4$

* * 2 !.4 * =

! /4 * !* ++ *' 8' ! +.+ ..

.! .. * !

* /! !!1 3$ $ ;!* .+ * !!

!+ +

, *!- !1 3<"#'

! *

! .* * .* 4*!

!$ *.! .* * !

! + * 4 + ! *3 >$"$"# .. $#6""5$ ! . .4' *!6%$63 6#$6& +.* 33!!*!

! !* 4$ ! +/ / &$"7$57>"'2+ 4=2 4 !+ 13 .! *. !+ /3 +

+ 3' $$'5&$"#$"#$ 3( 33 * /! + 2+ 4= 2 4$ 21' 3 + *. >,-, (- + 13

* '!!&$"#$"'*!

!2 !.!42 ! 2 2 <* *<2 =* !<! .4 2 / 4 3<? !<@ + 13 13= !!

'2 .! . 3/ +* 3 .! 4 +( * '/0* 3( 33 ++ +4= 2 4$ .1*.!! ($

12!!3

4 1$* $<"6<"5=5 = ' ! & :*' "' /+ + .(

*/. 1 * ' + .. 2 ,- A

% 4 2 4 3.. (*!&4+

* 2 .! /+ + + 3 * !1 * *3*3 !/. 2= $ @ 2 $ +4 +.( $

!3 /.

, - ((( ((( ,1

- , (- 2 1

.( . .!4 2 ! 3/ + * 3 .!

.42 4 .4 ! *<* *<2

=* !<! .42 ! *<* *<2 = /

4 * !<! .42 / 3<? !< (*.!

! + @ + /' + 4' *.!

4 4

13 !3 /.' +4'/0*

*.!

3( 33 + &

13= !! 4 ! . /0*

! * !

+ * 4

! ./

4 3<? !< @ *$ + 4

13 /+ + 2 .. / .! 1 . 3 + 4 /

** !

.4' * 4 + *!

!' *.!

* + * ! * .' 2

1 + + 1 4 ! *. >$5 + 32 *!! >$5$

* 2 1.4 3 ! 1$

!! * .'* B!* .! 13* . +

4../

( + 1 * !! /4 3 */0* 3( 33 +&4 *+ <

3 !

* + C/. 0/ D 4

@ ' @!

!! "6$"5$"5&

! @A $"55" +"5%' 39$ + 4 D ! + * 2 *'

* *+ 3 ! +

3! 4 ! 3 / 1 ! /4 ?<? D *

! /4 * !* ++ *< * .34 !* ++ * + * *! !

* 1+ @?<@.* .!1 !49 !.4 ! 3 ; $ 5&<#=""

,5- !!"$"7$"$ $5$ ;! * . + * ! ) !/2 .40*! ! !

( *

! *. 3 ' * 3 * /! ! !1 3$ * ( *

.1 /0* ! .4 + *. * =* 3 * * 3 !!! *. + 3'!

)*$ *. + .. 2 ++* 4$ 5!3267!

( + * =* 3 * * .. / * !! .4+* ..

! .! / ! /4 * 3 4 + * *! 3<@ 33 <? !<@ *$ + 1$ + 4$ ! . + .4' !

'! +0 ' ! +1 *!! +

+* * +* *! .!/ *..4 3 ! ( * * * ! 3/*

!/4 *!* ++ *< * .34 !* ++ * + * *! !

*$ * ( *3/+ +

.1/0*$

+ ' 2 / 0* ) *. 3 + ' 2 .4 ! 1 * ( * 2 * !$ #$

' .! * . * ! 1 *. 3! ' 1 3 ! E F ,

*/.- * .3' E

F 2 . ..

+ 3$? !' .! *. 3.(

3 + *. >,-, (- + !1 3 . ' * * ( +:,:3 *-'2 +

$ %$ /3 3!/4.!* .+ 1/ * !!$ &$ G!

!.4' *

! .* * + . * 4 *!

! ! 3 ! **+.' 1 *! 6%$6 3 6#$6& + . * 33!!*!

! !* 4$ + 0* + ! 2 3 / 1 *. ! + /3 +

+ 3$ 2 .! .! *. 3 / + ( ** *' * ! +:

,:3 *-'2 2 +

$ 3 3 + * !

!1 3'

.! *.>,-, (-' *!

!3 * ( * <* *<2 =* / 13

13= !! $ G! *. >$5 + !1 3' 3( 33 !3 /. *!

! + 14'! .4 * + <

3$ @ ! ' .4 !.( +/ (3 /.

/.+ '!! * ( *2..$ 21'

2 *! / 2 * */ 2 +: ,:3 *-'2 *2 * !!.1$ !) * +: 1. +

$ /0* ( *:,:3 *-* /* !!+ + + +

$ * / * !! 1.' 0 + !4 .( /* 3 3 +*.>,-, (- 1( * H !! ! 4 + * !

3( * .!/ +.1/0* $

. . ' ( / * !! + !3 3 +*!

!+ .* '/ .4 !* ! .

/ 4+ * ! $ *' 3 1.* + ' ! + .1* /0*$ /.

/0* /4 ! )( * !4 3 ' /.$

&$5$ ' * /4 .! * .

! /43 E F

+ 3 .1* .3' . 2 /*$ * .3

+ 3!=E

F' 2 * ! /!. 2

. *.>$5* * / !! *!

! .4 *$ 1*. 3! .

2 .

.4 + 4 !

13'3 E F * .3* /* ! *. ' * ..42!

!!!.4! ( * * *

+ *. 3 + ! ! 3 ! ! +/ '&$"7$57>"'2 *

.43! 3 1 *. !+ /3 +

+ 3$ . *

. 4

( * * . !!</3 ! . 2

+ 3 + $ ? !' .!4 / * !! /4 @ @A=&"="& .! 1$

' 2 ! *.*. + 32 !! E F'2 * 2 + 0* +*!

!)*. 3+ $ .1 +0!

3!! 6$ I !1+! * ! 3+ ! + <4

+ 3E

F$ !

+ *. 3

! ! 2 < / !! / + ( *$ / ! 2

. *.>$5*.( */ !!

! .4 *$ * !1/

!! .

' !! /4 4 J ) ,

*/.- ! * .! / 2 / $ ? !' + 3 . !

( ** *'! /3 ! * *< (=JK) ! /4 * . *

.!* =

!/4 *!* ++ * * +4 ( *$

+ 3 !

+ J (=K)' 3 ! + 3 !

( * + $ .

+ +*'2 ** + @ 33 + 2 * / ! .4 /4 3 !

+ 3 ! !

+ 3$

** !

.4'+ 3 E F )*. 3+ * .! 1/0*!$ 6$ * !!' .. 2!$ ! !

*! * ! 2 + .* ! ++ 3

3'/0* +.+ ..

* !

' ..4+ 3! .*!*!

! 3 1 /

!' ! 2 *. /+ + 3! +0 1 *$ !

* /* ! ! ++ 2+ 3! +* * !* 4 + !$ -.*/*+*0 8 &9

