Harchand Singh And ORS. v. State Of Pb. Etc.
!"#
"#"$#% !"# & ' ( & )*+,
!
"
+ -.+ ///'0 -.+ /0.
' # $%& '()#* *+ ,-'.* ,) '+ ,-' /* 0' ) (& ,
* '##+ ,-' /* 0' ( & ),
' #*+ +)'$ 1*('+ ,-'.* *%'#*+ ,-' / !' 20$**. 3 //'0 1
-$**. 03'/5-55* /-'03 -6/*7' -8-+
9:60*'//*-'(( '*;-/9:6;3+$ '( '/5-55* -(''03 -</* ;-/9:6;*/+$**. 03''5'$(/ $-5# - *#*'-55, - ! * 03-('5**'/='- (/
!"# $%!%&& !"%!%&&'% ( ) *
$+!
!
%!"# $!, (
- .
/-
/0 - 1
%
2 3 4$ 4 /
/
- 5 5 (
- -
/ 6
- 7%) -/
7 (
(7 //
*
$8*9 $8)
:*
;
7
-
- 7 %
2 -
;( <
2
* -/
%!##' (7
/-7 3 -
- =555 5% -
(
%
2
$ ! !4 "
;(<
2
* -/
!##'
$ 8* $ 8)
%
! "#
$ % & '(
))
)
2
7 * -/
- - 7
;(<
2
9 * -/
!##' (7 -
.
/-
!4" %
- 7 (
(
%>
7 - %2 .-
?
/
1
!4" !##' /
3 (
7
3
7 -/
%@
3
.
/-
!$%%&& 3
;
(
.
/ %
2
A!+ $!+!
!"# +
.
,4 ( B(
- 7 ?
/
3 - A 0
( % 2
.,+ # * - / '#5+ * (' -(/* 03'$' *(/'-('0$3+0-3+ 0 3+03' 0#3 .,+*%5''*(/ '-(' 0'3' 0/3 6
/ - # 5*,'( %/*(/ 0 '3+'+ *. 03+-'% ('
*
*'(/'- > /-' $'# <?:@!AAA?
@>A -6/*;-/9:6;$-'5 !2A!AA6' $-'5-- $%' -('' -</*;-/ 9:6;9A!AA>$8(%+''.' $'# 6:6+.' 5' A!!!AA<+*/# /'$''B.' ;1.( #"%;-9+ '#' < * B*'' 5$ ' -(' * /-'0 '3$'(/. #/' -9 C ' 5 * *' .* * ' . 03-'5 /*'#2A!!A6+**'/='- -03.5' C%%%%%%% D
- / / -- -
,/ 3 ( 3
(
3
( (7 ( (7 /
// /
A ;
%2 -
( - -
"& E
3 7 7
3
"&% 2 < 73
%#&&#&"$"" #!!# &&' ! 4#$ &&%
-- - (7 3 ?6*( %
!%$%&! /
% 3 ?6* 7
- -
./
(7
.
/-
%F *+!>A6!A6+**'/='- .'
' $%*"*. 030 '3 D 3 -
7
-
G/
H
G- 7 / /
3- 7%%%%%%F 9 -5 ('-*' +* -- /( -5 ('- $**. 030 '3+(,' /*' ='- *'/ "23456#% 3" 75#' ( & ) C% 2 /- 3
/
-
(
./
H
7 &"%&'%&!$ (7 ?
/
;( * -/
D
9:( * -/
%
-
3 -
-
E
% 4A+!E 6 3 /- ( = 6 >3 9
- 3 ?/ 7 -
( /
- ( %
"23456#% 3" 75# ' ) (&
C%%%%% -
-
(
/
-
H
7%F 6%7 2 #75"# !5#78 349:54 !"#;
864:":
3"#!
#7"
5# ' ) (&
: *'$' +'// ',+*'* 03 .*'*(' ./(('#'( ' .'*',-*'((# * 5 # /-'03 * ' /-'03 . / # /' $''' '#'.B.';1.( # "%;-E9+ '#'
A *5 # /-'03.'(-*'((# $% * 03"?:A<A?!AA>' "?:A92?!AA>+.*-*.' 5 $%*"*#*' 5' !<A:!AA<* 6.'( "?:A92?!AA> *+*,.' (-'03/( *'/' . 03 '#'* 0 '3.'( 5 $%*"*#*' '.A:A!!AAC *'/+",( '( 962?!AA'#/7 0"3 ::!6?!AC' ",( '( 962!?!AA'#/7 0"3 ::!<?!AC+'$-'5/( $%* +*'($-'5 5 $%* ;$( 5" ! *+"?>!2?!AA6/( $% 5') #*+* 0 '3+-*'((# *,'( %/=5 ' 2A!!
AA6 ' $%* ,5/)'$ - C90!3/*)'$#'(' .('#' ,( 5 -+::>+$*"0 '3$-'5'( 5 $%*"+ *#*' '.A!A:!A2 2 '' C+ / * (%+ ' *' '(( * @# '':/*. +=- $ ''0/3 .** 'B#*('/*(' * $'/ (-%# ( ' !AA!AA<+*# +*'* (' 8/'((.** - /,(('#'( ' .'
> *5+*'$' +* (%+*'*(' /* ''(5'#(' -/(' ' /5 '/ -'( / '#'*(' '#-('(' ,%5-*8 / #'/*-*5' * '('/ '#' < *+ *' $ ' *' * 7' -8 "((-+ $' ,( 5+ '#'+*' '.' -5 ' /6A('- '-+ ('%$/ * ,/ -!20303/*;-/9:6;(+.*( #/' 5$//- /( $%*(' ./,(('#'(
' .'+ * /- " *' '.' -5 ' / C+6A+AAA@? '- ('%$/ C */+ 5'/'-+' '*'-*'( +** -( .(('*-('# =5 03/*(' * 58'*/'((#* 0' - /*,(('#+.*'+*' -5' ?' *+*$%*' 5'*''-*'# /*' -03*'. +** - ( / (#'/ !(!"" 9
*''5'%+/''5'//'-+*' - *#*$-55 $' ' .' +%/*.+ *'5$'-*/'-*(,'/-'$( (-%+*$% 5'%-'=- * - (/ (+'-' $% * ,/ !(!"" "#7 #75"# ":78 4 6 # !%"$#
4:" 78 3 7575"# * ,:"
<5#= > 57 :
: *(' -(' '#/* 03+*',
.*5-*,#5' '-+*'* '/*'-8 (' .*-*/'((.**;0;' *;- G/*,(('#+- $-5 -(' -('0#3/* (-% ' !AA!AA<+/* ' ,5+-('.*/' ='- *'/+$ '5'$(/'-8*/+*%- *'8'* /*.(' ''/'((#*,(('#($ ' .**= (('(%*' (' ' '/* *'#/*,(('#' '*8 /5''#* '#''-('(*/*,(('# + +, - .
/#$ 0$(-),
. 3 -/
3 - 73 3 3
- -
3
( -
-
7 /-
(
1- 1
3 % 7 ( 3
101 G- G ( - .
( %2
( ( -/7 /
- 7 //
. - -
%D
(
- ( . - (
%
7
( - / % /7 /
I
(
- / .
G(G
- . //
% //
- - 1(1 .
(7&J (;
/ / / '&/ /./ / !&&/
/ G- G% D 3
. (* -
3 /-
A
1
I
H
6 A* /-
6 A /-
6 - -
;(<
2
* -/
!##' .
( / '& / % /
3
( (;
-- %
- /
( 7 33
? +6
H
6 %2 .
3
( - / 3( / 3 - 7(7 <
(;
-- :*% - / -
-/
- -
( (7 /- (
/ (;
-7/
:
3
.
%D
-
.
( ( .
/- / -
;(-/
- 7<
!##'%F !A -8-+ *% '# *' 5'B# / '-803/*'$,(' +*.( $//'-5/* '-'-/*,(('# "#7 #75"# ":78 4 6 # !/767 %"$#
! *(' '-(*' ('- - +. % +.*+*- *'-'*.(/''((. *$%*".( $ - #'$(%'-- * +*$//*(' # ,+'-' $ -0!3/-!6/**#*'"5 '' ' '-% 7' -8+ *'$(' ' (5
-+!A20*'//*/'*;-/!A2;3+ * ' -/*(,' -*'##, -+*''/* . ''5 * *+ '5-* '+ ' ' $-5#, (%'5 +/*'-8 (' +$ *-5#/-/*;-/!A2;+' +'( -5 '$$/*-5#/-/*;-/!A2;+* $-5# * ,5 '%+ / *$% $-5#','('$(/$# $ *(' ?(-- !! 5'B#*'$,$5+*(' -(/ * *#**' 5' ('-+ + ''#' * 2<2/ *, - $%* ;$( 5"+-'( ' ; * -/
7 = 6
;+ .*-* +
%#&$,#&$" &!+*'$'# + ''
.*/='- *'/ $$% 3
3 3
!%:
-
+!
+
3
/
!%!%&! //
/
&!$
- -
% /-
( /
-
&!$% % 3(
- 3 3 - 7 . - (7
/
-
-
+!
+( &!$
!"#
(
- % $%2 3 K L
+ ( 3
-
/-
( K
L K L%2
/ -
-
+ &!$0 - 3
7 / -
//
/
-
(
0
/-
(
-% -
(
0
/-
(
-
- % /7 /-
(
- -
(
0
- % %2 .-
G-G / -
+
&!$
- /-
%2
, - - -
+
(
- 3 - /;
7
(
+
!"# (
/-
3
-
&!$% (
$!
!"#
(
$
( %
, - /-
+
-
-
%
, - 3 - /;
7 7 / /-
&!$ ( - 1
1
!"# % '% -
(
/-
-
$!+!
!"#
-
/ /
-
+
,-7/
, - /-
%2 (
-7 /-
(7
/
$!+!
%
3 - /-
3
/-
/
-
-
+
&!$%
%2 -
+ &!$ (
-
+
-
+!
+( % 4%2 / 0 -
!"#
/-
+ (73 - A / / /% H 3 (
-
0 -
! !"#
-
+
&!$
-
(
0
-
+ % "%2 -
+ -
/ - -
--(
0 -
-7 /-
7 / ( &!$/ -
-
3
7
!%!%&! % 2
- (
/ - (7
( . /-
7 % #%
+ &!$
3
7
-
%
-- -
-
/
&!$% %!%!%&! %
/ , ( /
-
-
3
7 / 0 -
-
-
/ - /-
7
% 2 - - ! -- . 3 -#!( -- ( !% $ #-$ 4 - 5 - - !% $ 0 #-$
- 4) !2 ,+/'5#(%*$//*(' # ,+' * *5' '-' -!60!3/*;-/!A2; 5'%$','('$($-5'# *(' ?(--
.,+ -,/*'$,+*('-*#/*'-8 - # ' * ,% - .+ 5' /'-+ '* -',/*'$,='- -('+'=*(,' (-%+'$-5/'5 $%* ,5/)'$ !6 *"/ ('B#/-*+/*$% 5' /'-+ ',(% -('# * '- / * /-'030 '3+??/''+*%(', /'- $#5' *'$,='- -('+'*$-5( **'/ 503 '3 *(.** -(' ( F/ * ,(('# -- + $ ' ' #'( ' / * '#''* $3 *(*(*5/*(. .*-*/'((.
**( '''-'-*'#/ * ,(('#/* / */+ *%'$ , ' -*+ *#* # *' $'F ('#'B# ('-+***'#( '** '-'-/*,(('#+ * ' ' $-5//'- -3 *'5'B#/( 'B ('- #* -( ' '' *,'/( $% * -( ' //-+ '( ' ,'-+ * '#''-*''-/*,(('# -*'#''-*''-/*,(('#+$ 5'' ' @ $ , + *$% * '-8/('-803/' )'-* (' +5'%$', + -'((%.
*
*=/*(''*5'%$8 +/ '--55 '#+*-'# ('* / */'$(#*-' ('-'( -*= ($( 3 *#**-(5/.* ( (' ' -$ $. $%*( .,+* .*'(.**( '% - '5# *5(, '(' *#*=-/ /-,%'-*/+/ +*- /#*.*-**-(5/ */+ -('* ( (' $. $%* ( * *%'*' '$'*-'( *-- /.* .*-*$,(%*.* *('( % /3 * '$, .
( /'-('+ *' *$% * - (/--' (%*+ -'((%.* '$- / * '$, -(''03 * -(5 / .* +*$%* /* ( *5 .( $ * (,' - ( '* / -- * $-5# '5 $% * ,,# */('(%*$%*(/--5'% $-5.*( .+(''5'% 5' $%* -' (.-- #3 8(+ / ,-5# * '$,+ * " -55 *'/)'$5'B / '#*,- +('#*.
* #' / ( '* --# * .* -(5/( **'5/* '/* ( * ( (' + $-5 - ' * *3 *'$,5'%'(/'-('*(5/* ( *( -- +-,-5 '.*-* *%*.5'%+ 5'/'-+$-5 ?(+$ '5? 5 *'* ( ..**', ' (*( (' +'/(- * -(5/.* +$.#-*' ( ( (' !> *#**"*'5' **'$,/-$ -*' (' 'B#* (%+'// ',+/* *. "?C<>9?!AA<+$%* +'.(('+* .% /( $%* ?'+*'*(,'' ,'-'+$ *'-5 '''5/:+!2+!2@?8' *'-8 (' / ( 8' 3 7575"#
5#'
( & )' $%*7' -8"((-+ $'
,( 5+ '#'+ ,5'%, 9A ' ACA!AA9+.*'+ -/* 3 7575"#
5#'
) (& +-5 ' ' ' , -*8
6 ' A2!AA*+.*,'( *+*' /'('5/-5 '/+2:+:9+C2A@?''5/ +!+C!+2C!@?*'$ ' , ,-*6 ' A2!AA ' *$'('-'5/ 9+!<+2>9@?+ ' # +
,5'%, 9A ' ACA!AA9+/*'5 $#','('$($ $ *(' ?(-- ,+
'(' *.% /( $%*(' ' "(+*'*-5 ' -/** ' ,5'%, 9 ' ACA!AA9 /*$%$#','('$($-5(' *(' ?( -- !< *5+'(, (%5#*'+ 5'/'-+ *=-/'% ('% ( '* '5' -+'(.**'( / (#'+*'$,$-'5' *'//5#* '$,--('/5*/'-*'*'$,-' *(,'%=#*(,')'5'$' +$% --(,' -#, -$.'
8 $' - $%* + * ('%# *' * ' % '( (' * '-8 (' .,+*' , -#(%'5 !C -8-+*'$,$-5' 8/ /'-*/+ -,/*5'B#/*'$,/-+ *" 5/' ' '-(-**+* 8 / /'- 0 '3+ *$% * ' ( B ' 5' '5 '* / /-# * ,5 (-%0 '3 !9 *+* * (%?'// ',+'.((' *'#5+/5(%- *'*.(' 03+.
'-8 //*#*8 $(- +' +*'* (' ''#'(-5 /*('% ('('#*-5 ( /*(,' $(- */+-*".(( '$( ,.?
!: *5+- 5'-$'# * ('# $(- *' , '(/*'*( -- */+ # + * " '( /' /5 '((.# * 03 -('5 / * '-8 (' $-5# (' /5'-8 5#64 !
":785 "$ 7
2A '/5'*+ * " / 5 * . 03+*'5$#-5 ((%/,(+*'8 $ 5 .*-*/+*'5' 5 .*-/ !>+AAA@? '-*+ '-* / * $ /*.* $%*5.* *'/* ?$#@6;6#!6 96#6 5=8"$ 7234"9
'
4:6
"%5675"#A 2 *5 # /-'03' *-8* '.' '5'' ' '//5 2! -*5'-'(/*'$ - +*+'((* #' (-'03+/'%+'(' 03 / *//'0, *0.
', & B',#* '8 6<5#=B "# !
B"
'8 3" 76;4
B"