Iffco-Tokio General Insurance Company Ltd, v. Kirti And Others

   
     

    

    !"#$%& $$  ' () *$    ! "#" $%&%'(

$)*(+,-./01,(% $(2%,33%--,'(  +,,-./. 0/1 2 44$*%0%/ (2%,5,$//,(%/6 3,&&%/7+(2% ($ 11*/%'(-,*)&$*78',-.%5,$*9 $&2$(. (2%$*78',- :.(2%*'&8$%$

1,$7%,$*'4$%4*&($,(*';<;

;

92%$%*', (%$$% %$$%/(,& (2% 

%'/*'40%2*1-% :2,& *-%/(2%3$%&%'(,33%,- 2%5*/5.(5)*'$12*-/$%','/ ,(2%$ ",'=%%0>8),$ 9/%1%,&%/: *-%/,1-,*)3%(*(*'8'/%$"%1(*' << (2% ($#%2*1-%& 1(.  9 $&2$(. (2%1( :2%/$*0%$.5'%$,'/(2%*'&8$%$ (2% 

%'/*'40%2*1-%5%$%,$$,+%/,&$%&3'/%'(&7% $%(2%$*78',- 2% ,1(&'%1%&&,$+ $,/=8/*1,(*' (2%3$%&%'(,33%,-,$% (2,(  '  

.  ",'=%%0  >8),$  5,&  $*/*'4  ,  )($1+1-%  7%,$*'4 $%4*&($,(*';?<#;

< '2*&5,+.(2%

%'/*'40%2*1-%&($81@(2% )($1+1-%.,&,$%&8-( (2%*)3,1(.2%&8&(,*'%/4$*%08&*'=8$*%&%5,& (,@%'(0%$')%'(&3*(,-.%5,$*52%$%2%&8118)7%/((2%*'=8$*%& 2%,11*/%'(5,&5*('%&&%/7+'% %0%'/%$>8),$.525,&1)*'4*'

 2*&1,$7%,$*'4$%4*&($,(*';?<;A


 /,(%/



5,&$%4*&(%$%/,(-*1%"(,(*'>2- '(2%1-,*)3%(*(*'.*(5,&3-%,/%/(2,((2%/%1%,&%/5,&

+%,$&-/%5,&$8''*'4,!,7$,($+*'(2%',)% ,'4,,),(2 !,7.,'4,- 8'/**&%,$'*'45,&1-,*)%/,&
?

.

B;3%$)'(22% C8,-* *1,(*'1%$(* *1,(%&5%$%%D2*7*(%/7% $%(2%$*78',-,&DA.D  6,'/D <(%&(,7-*&2(2,((2%/%1%,&%/5,&,-,7$,($+(%12'*1*,' ,'/2,0*'4 @'5-%/4% 1)38(%$2%1-,*),'(& ,*-%/(3$0%(2% )'(2-+%,$'*'4 (2%/%1%,&%/2%$*78',-,&&%&&%/2*&)'(2-+%,$'*'4 ,&

.

B;.A E 8(8$%3$&3%1(&5%$%,5,$/%/. BA(2/%/81(*' $&%-

%D3%'&%&  5,&  ),/%,'/  )8-(*3-*%$   

 5,& ,33-*%/2%  $*78',- ,5,$/%/,&8) 
.

.

B;,-'45*(2*'(%$%&(FE3%$,''8)2% ,)8'(,5,$/%/*'1-8/%/

.

B;8'/%$(2%1'0%'(*',-2%,/& 2%  $*78',-  1'&*/%$*'4  (2%  ,1(&  ,'/  ,33$%1*,(*'4  (2% %0*/%'1%  ,//81%/  2%-/  (2,(  (2%  ,11*/%'(  5,&  1,8&%/  /8%  (  $,&2  ,'/ '%4-*4%'(/$*0*'4 (2%

%'/*'40%2*1-%2%/$*0%$.5'%$,'/(2%*'&8$%$  (2%

%'/*'40%2*1-%5%$%2%-/=*'(-+,'/&%0%$,--+-*,7-%(3,+(2% 1)3%'&,(*' 2%1'(%'(*'$,*&%/7+-%,$'%/18'&%- $(2%,33%--,'(&*& (2,((2%

%'/*'40%2*1-%5,&*)3-,'(%/,&(2%,11*/%'((@3-,1%,(

?

  '

78((2%
5,&$%4*&(%$%/'



,(

A   2,--%'4%*&((2%)'(2-+*'1)%,&&%&&%/ (2%/%1%,&%/(*&,$48%/ (2,((2%1-,*),'(& ,*-%/(3$0%(2%)'(2-+%,$'*'4 (2%/%1%,&%/.(2% *'1)%&28-/2,0%7%%',&&%&&%/,& )*'*)8)5,4%& (2%8'&@*--%/ -,78$%$  2%  18'&%-  &87)*(&  (2,(  ,(2%$    (2%  /%1%,&%/  5,&  '( /%3%'/%'(.2%'1%. BA(2/%/81(*' $&%- %D3%'&%&5,&5$'4-+),/%2%

? 4$*%0,'1%*&((2%$,(% *'(%$%&(*%FE3%$,''8),5,$/%/7+(2% $*78',- 2%1'(%'(*'&$,*&%/7+-%,$'%/18'&%- $(2%,33%--,'(&,$% '(5%-- 8'/%/ 2%,11*/%'(5,&5*('%&&%/7+ %0%'/%$>8),$%/%3&%/ 7% $%(2%$*78',-,&G;

%3$0%/(2,((2%,11*/%'(5,&,$%&8-(

$,&2,'/'%4-*4%'(/$*0*'4 (2%

%'/*'40%2*1-%
5,&$%1$/%/'2*& &(,(%)%'(2%'8)7%$ (2%

%'/*'40%2*1-%5,&/8-+)%'(*'%/*'(2%
2%,11*/%'((@3-,1%,(

?

 '

",'=%%0>8),$5,& (,@%'((2%2&3*(,-.
5,&$%4*&(%$%/,(

A  '



2% 1'(%'(*'$,*&%/(2,((2%$%*&/%-,+*'-/4*'4(2%
,'/(2%

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
AB;.(2%*'1)%,&&%&&%/7+ (2%$*78',-1,''(7%&,*/(7%'(2%2*42%$&*/%. (2%/%1%,&%/5,& &8$0*0%/7+,+8'45*/5,'/(5)*'$12*-/$%',4%/+%,$&,'/'% +%,$ 2%/%1%,&%/5,&&8$0*0%/7+ 8$/%3%'/%'(&3-%,5,& $,*&%/7+(2%*'&8$%$7% $%(2%$*78',-(2,( ,(2%$5,&'(/%3%'/%'('

A (2%%,$'*'4 (2%/%1%,&%/.*'&8121*$18)&(,'1%&. BA(2/%/81(*'),/% $ &%- ;%D3%'&%&*&*'1'&','1%5*(2(2%/%1*&*' (2%"83$%)%8$(*'

- +#)' ) $"$)0 1

23-""  2%$*78',-,5,$/%/*'(%$%&(FE3%$,''8)'(2%1-,*) 3$1%%/*'4&.*'(%$%&(*&(7%,5,$/%/ ,&3%$"%1(*'

(2%1( >%%3*'4*'0*%5(2% ,1(&*'%'(*$%(+,'/ 1'&*/%$*'4(2%7,'@ &$,(%& 3$%0,-%'(,((2%$%-%0,'((*)%.'*'(%$ %$%'1%*&1,--%/ $*'(2%*'(%$%&($,(% ,5,$/%/7+(2%$*78',- 2%,33%,-*&2%$%7+/*&)*&&%/ 1+,,-./. 2  /4 , 6  )@ G2%(2%$&3%,@*'4B$%,&'%/

%&B G2%(2%$$%3$(,7-%

%&B