High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/42223/2016allowed

Karam Singh v. Naresh & ANR

2018-11-22Mrs. Justice Manjari Nehru Kaul9 pages

#$% &&&'(( ) *+* "

*%" * &&&*, (*

----- '

*( ".!",

"/01 "(

(%,(( ##2//1 "(

(% (* 3 45 ,( ",,/"( *"// 6"*, "7

38 '

"7 (%* ",,/"( / + ' *

,/"$

(% ,7

$ *%( "( 9 *("( (

: #". ;%"$"( " %* "

"( "* 15+ * (

*,(/7 + (*15+ * ( "

("0

*+ .(( "//.+*(5,( * *("**, *

<% ,(( %"* / , *( ,(( + '

*(($ "* (% .+$ ( "( 3 15+ '9 ,"** 7/"

1( "/#** *=+$!"(%"/6% 7(% ,(( / 7(%,((

,/""("$"*((%

"( 15+ ' ,"** 7/"

=+"/"$*( "( *(/"**!"(%"/ 6%%(% (*"+*6 %"

$*%(+ 9

"9 "6(%#( 8>'6"** ** ;

/7*("((%,(( %"* /"

,/"(+

9 8"9>'"$"*((% (*"+* 6(%(%"//$"( *(%"( (%"7

/""/( "( (

0 ,/" (6 ;+

/ *

!",

" 2+.."

6(% *

;

+(7

6$ / * "% <%

,/""("/ $6(% "

#$%*

"/,"2+.."

2 %+*

@/"2+.."

//"$ 2 $ 6 (+ $ ( (% % +**

(% /* " "( "

+( 8 '6%(%7 "%"

(%;

"% % ,"/"+*"

*%?",,7 " '"

, 6 "

+*$ (% 6% / 2+.."

+(7 :% (%

,/""( "*0 (% "* ( 6%7 (%7 6 "

+*$ (% 6% / 2+.."

+(7"//(%(% "+*"**"+/(% 6(% *("/$ / 6*<%

,/""( 6"* *" 7 "

#$% " 2 %+ <% "

( (%

,/""(6(( %*% +*?

,/""(*%"

(%*(

"**"+/(6(%%** #

"(%"*6//"*% ""<0"*

" <%7"

,"(%

,/""(( / $(% ,

(*(:%(%7 "% "

" @"5 "

" "+* * " "

/7 "

*% "

, "

6(% 2""** " "+* * ( 3 "

/7 2"+ " ?",,71"A"1."7"

6(%@"(%*6% "*"+* '"6" "

6(%

6(% "

(( "

.( "(("0 "

( $$ " @"/0"

" (%"( (%* 2+.."

* *% +/ ("+$%( " /** 1+* '"

, $" " 2""* / 6 (% $%( /

,/""("+* '"6"$""

/ 6 (% $%(/$

,/""( "+* "

*% $" " 2""* / 6

(* /+( * (%/ (%"

,/""(""+* 31."7$""@"(%

/ 6 (%%*(

,/""(;**(%*"+* "

*%$" " 2""* / 6 (% *

% " 6% "* "+* 1" " "+* 2"+ "$"@"(% / 6*( % "%"

$(% *<0"

""#+ "*%*

2".#$%2+.."

"%(%*, ("*"

(% /+(%*

"+* 1// (% .+ 6 " (( ( ( ?

*,("/ !"(%"/ >.+ % " 6"*

( '2>4 %"$"

% 7(% (

+(7"*%* ( 6"** +* <% "(( 6"* ,

(( (%, /""B> "( + 9 " 8 >' 6"* $*( "( '

/#("( !"(%"/6% (%, /%"%"//" /7

"+* "

/7 "

*% ?",,7 '"

, " 2"+ " <% "$ "+* 6 /"

( " (% "

* 6 ( /+ (% %"//" (%",,76(%(%, /"( (%

,/""(.+ / (%"

(

,/"((%

1 ""$*( "((%

"**

,/"

/+$(% /$"/ ,

,/""( " .+ % " /"

( "/ (

"( 9 *+

(%"+*( "( "/+ 9

8"9>'5,("+* 2"+ "*

#"( 6%

$".+/* "$"*,"

"(( "/

(%=+/=+*(;

) ,+$

"( /"

( "/ %"

$*%((% (*"+*+ 9 "9

"6(%#( 8>' 1$"*( (% "

"( (% ,((

,/""( / " ,((

#** *0$

$ "$"*( (% "+* + >' "* 6// ?

,+$ .+$ ( "( 3 ,"** 1( "/#** *=+$!"(%"/(%*" ,(( 6"** ** >(*(%* + *("*(%,((

,/""(%"* / (%, *(,(( @"

+*/

(%,((

,/""(%"*"

$+(%"( (%

,/"("*(%( "/ (

"( 9 *+

(% "+*( "( "/+ 9 8"9>' "(%"+**% +/%" %"

$*%("

$/7?

,+$

"( (%( "/ (%"*

$*"$"*( (% (*"+* + 9 " 9 " 6(% #( 8>'6% "* (% "**

(

/+$ (%

,/"( (% (*"+* "

C+ ( %"

$ *%( + >'"*6//

? %"* ( (%"( ,+$

(%( "/ (%"*

$+ >' (%$

+ (%"( (%

,/""(%* 5"

"( % %" *("((%"( "+*"

*%%(% "6(%(%2""* / 6 %* *"(%@

% ",/" /"*45:D; "/(%"((%0

6", +*

"+*$ .+ 7 6"* /+( " (%

( * ( (% "*

,/""((%"( **

2""*6"* (+*( %(% "B+ .+ % " +/ 5"

(%"*"*%+

(+"(/7" % 6"* (% *( , (

"( (% .+ 7 # /"

/7 (% ,(( / 7 (%

,/""( 6"* "/* * ** 1( "/ #** *=+$!"(%"/ ,+$

"(3 (%$

+ (%"((%.+ 7%"* "+*6(%"2""* +((%"* +*

(% *

/" " (% (

%"* *% 6 (%* .+ 7 (% @ ( "+* 7 /+(6", "%* ("*"/" "(6 +>(%* + *("* 2""* * +*

(% *

(* %"/

( ( * "// 6(%(% "$

6",

($*("

+(($ ?%"* ((%"((%.+ 7"

"(+ (% *

.+ % " * ( *,+( >

(

$ "$"*( (% "+*(* ((%"(+

6", 6%%%"*( * "(% (*(% "(+

.+ 7 6%% %"* ( (% "**

(% ,+ , **

$ > *+,,

%* (( * % %"* ,/" /" +,

!"!

#$$%&'(&)*)+,(#-.

(% %"/"

+*/

(% (*"+* %"* "

$+ (%"(

(% *"

"//$"( * (% * "/ "7 " B>

$*( "$"*(

"+*"

/7"

*%"'"

,"2"+ " "(%*""*%"

$*%""/ "7

* $(%"(+

.+ *"+* (%,

% ">(%

,/"("*(%%"

$ %"* "/ "7

"$"*((% "+*"

(%"//$ .+ 7 "* + >' * " +( "$"*( (% (*"+* 4 6*(6 +/("("

+(( /. ,"

7"*,

+ #( '"*

(%*"

("+*"

"/ "7 "$( "/ (%B>"* ? %"* / +, )

/ , #$$0&'( &)*)+,( 1%. " "

$+ (%"( (% **("/ $ (* ( "(( "(#( >'"

/+("

/7"+*$"%+ (%+ ("+* +*(

" $ +* %+ ( " (% $ +* %+ +*( %" "+* 7 "$

+*6",

"*12""* (+*

(%*

(* /" " (

( ""$

+*6", >%"%"

+*/

(%,"

(* >( * ( *,+( (%"(

"( 9 ,"** 7 /"

( "/ ( (% (*"+* 6 *+

( " ( "/ + " 9 " 6(% #( 8 >' 1$"*((%

$"( 9 ,"** 7(%( "/ ( (*"+* "

/7 "

*% " "/"* ?",,7 '"

, " 2"+ " %" / " ,((

#** ?

(% *" ,(( 6"* * ** 1( "/

#** * =+$ !"(%"/ .+$ ( "( 93

* $ (% (%"( (%.+ 7*"+* 7"$

+*6", (%,

>'"

"(( "( ?

,+$

"( /"

( "/ (%"*

(%%"

$"$"*((% (*"+*+

9 " 9 " 6(% #( 8 >' 7

* $ (%"(

,/""( !"

#$% %"* *("( %* 5"

"( % (%"( "+*"

*%$"% ""2""* / 6 %* *<% /$"/

% ",/" (% /"*45:D; "/*(%"(0

6", +*

"+*$.+ 76"* /+( <% ,(( / 7(%,((

,/""("$"*( (%"

"( ,"** 7(%( "/ (%"*"/* * ** 1( "/ #** * =+$ !"(%"/ ,+$ .+$ ("(3 7

* $(%"( ".+ 7*"+* 7 * *

2""*(6 +/ ("(( "((%

+ >' > (% "* %" (% "//$"( "$"*( ("+* "

*%*(%"(%"+*"2""* / 6 (% *

.+ % "6% 6"* " (( 2 "/ ?

*,("/ !"(%"/ #". ;%"$"( # 2 "/ ?

*,("/ !"(%"/ 6%/ ",,"

$ (% 6(**

5 "* : ( %* "

"( 45:D1 %* 6% %

+ (%

// 6$.+ * (%,

.+ % "

!" E <%+*(%0

6", +*(%

6"* /+( +("( (%*"

( (% (

%"* , +/(,//" "(6 +6(% /$

*F85

,*, "/( "$+/"

*%", (% *5($

$%( ( / $

(% *

.+ % " <%+* %"$ * (%"(+

.+ 7"+* (%,

.+ % ""*6// "*(%/"6/" 6

& 3((%* *(%"((* (%"(+

6", "(% (*(%"(+

.+ 76%%%"*( /

0 ( <% /"(,"

"$ ",%

(%*".+$ ( "*"*+ #

$ #%&

' ()

* (%)

* (#)

+ $ , -

/ $0

(%111(2) $++ %3)

$ #%3 #%& 5 5

. 5

5 ( $ #2 #6)

$ #%8 $ #%&

# "* (% .+$ ( ( +*/

(*"+* )

& 3(* (%*"

* ",,/"

/( (% "(*" + *("*

(%"*%">(%"("* 6", 6"*+* (% "(% ( 6"* (% *F

*( 6%% 6"*

/"(

* "( <%+*

*( (%$ + *("* "7 (

"*""$

+*6", +*(% 1

$/7 (% , *( ,(( * "// 6 " (% ,+$

"( ,"** 7/"

( "/ ("*6//"*(%.+$ ( "(3 ,"** 7/"

1( "/#** *=+$!"(%"/"

*( "* <% ( "/ ( * ( (

$ "$"*( (% (* "+*+ >'"*6// ?

( * " /"

(%"( (%

* "( " % "

*%"// *( +"*"5, **

, (% (*

(%"*"(%( "/ (*%"//(%"*6(% +( $ /+ 6(%(%*

* "( *"7 "

!"# G"$+(( :%(% *,"0$D "* G* :%(% ,