Deepak Kumar v. Ramphal And ANR

 


           
 

!"!

#$ %% & &' %%%% !!

("*"

' +    %%% ", #"

'$

 -+ '% .

 .

 .



 



 

 

 
 


 
 
!
  .

 .



% %/(01



 

 
"  

  $ % $%$&

'(

!
  
)  #"
* 
+'( 
 #

  
'(
 , !!
"  
  
%$ % $%$

'(

!
  

#"
-.
) / 0#

'
 

+

# 
1
2
3#

 
$ 

'
  


!
 !!,  






 (
 


 
!

 


# 
!  
 
 
 
% % $%%2
4
3 %%%,5

 
6
+
 # 



!


!

 
 

 

 
!


3 $%%,5

  6

'
( "


"#(

!  
 

#  #( $%$$

'

 


(

(

!# #



  (

  #'  "
 




!

"  
 !!
 



# 

  (
"
)!  
  




 $

















+
 


#

)!  
!
+


  
 
(

 #    
 
 


  
!
 
 

' +

   
% % $%%2
'#
"

 
!
 
'
3 %%%,5

 
+ +
  (
3 %%%,5

 
7


#' 



 !!


( "



"#(
 




!

 
 #(
$%$$
 
 
!


+
#"

)!  $5* 
 
9 
:  
+
#';# (  

! 
 


!
+


  
 
(
#  
 
#' 

 "

 (

;# 
+
 ""
'( !  

!#
!
!  $
 
!  $

(  

 "
# 
.#  
 
3  # 
!
<    
 
= ! 
!
.# (
7 
 
$%%$
-2 !#  ( (

((  

" ..

 / 
!


'

'(
 !!
 
! 


  
#
' "

.# $8
!
$%$$
+

'(

#"
) /
0#
 



'
 
# 
1
>
3#

 +
 !!
 
!  

#
+ 

 

! " 
!
! 
7

!# 
#' 




#


# 


  

!


 #

 
!
. 
8
!

   
!

+
#"

!


 "
 
# 
!

 

!
   
#"
-.
) /
 

# 
1
2
3#

 
$ 


 
%$ % $%$
 


  
'(

 !!
 
'
 


 
$ % $%$&

 

















?

7


 
# 
!
 
 

" 
#"


 



! > : 
# 
!
 
  
 

 





 (
 

(
$%%2  ""
!
 ( 
'
 
'(
!  
!


 
!
  (
 

 



'  "
#

 

!  
   ,!  $
 
 
!


9 
'+

!

 



 
 
!
+



 
 

 #"  

#
'

'



7
#
!

  
 
#  

#


'(
6 @'
.# 
#




 

 

  



         6+
7


! 
 (
!


  

'(
  # 
!
 
 


+
 
'(





'


! 
!



  9!
 "
!# 

 
!
. 
>
A-8/
!


#

#  

  !" # "$ "

"

 & "'()*

+

) $!&

*!!

 % &++ , - # "$

 "$&("

)* ,"

. / &+ - "



-"$ -

"  ,,

$  -"0-

 #+#/ 

   ! -"$ -, "#+& 

& ' & "

&$-%!3$  - #  -,

+(,% +",

# -   - -"$ -# "$ "-&  / 4

%   -  ,,   , "  #+  & 

&  ,

 #/!  -

    &+  -  &

   - 

   -  -

'

 8

  (

% , $& " "- &+  - - 

##$    , -  "

"  - &

&+ - "



,

 -%!

-"

"    

&3 

-  / +     ,  -  "

  

   -  " ! 

##$    ,  "

"  -  &

 "-        -

) $!&

* #/ 

   & "

&$$ "$&("

)* ,"

'

) *8- )*+



  $ "$&("

)* #"+  + 

  " -   !- "  $

  -  "

  ""   - 

&$,  7#! - , " , -  "  % 

$ &+ -   "    "$ - #""-,

 -

" " , ,

#   ,"

 + " -%  - 3$ 

7# - -  " 

  +( )*-" 7 

"

 # 9

)&*"

+ "

 , - 2 ", ,5

+

)

,*9

*"

+ #" ,#

!! 9

)*"  ,  - ""$ , , ,$  #&+ - :/$ "$&("

)* ,"

. , - 

9 )* -  & 1

&$"" ",  -   + !- 

 " -  !- " # "

"" ,"$  - "$&( $"

)*

"$&( $" )&*

"$&( $" ) *

"$&( $" )* , $" )* -   -" !+ -!

+

  +

,

 -  # & !,

 -  & 1

&$#+ ""

"$ -

"  #", 

  - - 

%" " , -"

';

%

#
!

!







 ( 


 
# 
#'5. 

 
 (
  (

 " 
#

#
 

)'

3(
'# 
!


B   "

 &

















! 
!


 
 
#
'(

 

 

#
  !

#
!
 ! 
!
# (
  


# 
B  
+ 

  (

B

 
   
 
!

)'

3(
'# 

 !

  (
"
 


#


!
# 
#'5#
-/

 +    "
 (  "

 (
   
 (
 
+
!

 
' "

!

)'

3(
'# 
(
 #



 
!

 
+ 
 
!



 
#







 (



)'

3(
'# 
!


!
 


" 

" 
'!
)3

 . 
8
!

'
# 
!


#
+
 #

#  !"
 #     # (< %

"--% 3$    +"$ 

!

,+ # - - & "1

&$

 2 &$"

&+

$  -"

 #  3$ "- & !

 &++

$ -

 +

,+ / 

&  /  "$ ,+

,

&+

$

-"

$  - 1

+ , & " $  :/"  "  $  "

.) ,.*;

$ !

!# 






#
 
# 

  
 (
#

 "


!
 (



+ 
)3

 
'# 

 +
'(

# 

 
   
  
 #  

'
" 
'(
 (
#


!
 (
 



'



## 
!
 (
+
 !
'(

# 



# 
3(
!
)'


)#

9 
 
<  
7   
 
22% 7

 ?




















! 
 $

(
  

 "
! (
!

 #
# 
. 
-$/
!

.3<=.7

 

 (  (
+  , !!




 
'!
)3
#  . 
>-/
!

+

'



#

+
 . 
>
-8/
!

 
#



!
'!


#


#

  '  9 
'+


 

# 
1 2
3#

C
$



'
!
# 
#
   

 !



 
" (
#

'
 






!
 (
 ! 8 3# (


 
  
 






















/.

 .



1 %%  3#

D 
 ",  E, D 
3 ' E,