← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/2688/2023allowed

Bhandari Interstate Carriers v. Improvement Trust Ludhiana And Another

2025-11-18Mr. Justice Vikas Bahl9 pages

              



 !" # $%&%!'(  ))* + '# ,% ' ,& ,,% ,& )))) %%!' , - ,&.& /0,!1 / ' ,.& 2.#+% '

'# '!+ , ))))) &0!'# '&  (  32 ) 4 -54 2 



 

     -54 27 )

2    !!"      #     $             %!

%& !%!&    '    #  (   )(   *  +  , ' -./  ",  ##  '    4  2     !

+ 

   '1    2        3

& 4 53+ ,  $ 



6, 

, 7 '2  $   '    1  -5

 '!%

!

!% .6  '   '2 

%0 !% " ,  , ' $

, , 2  ,,  '   -8$/ 98$$,  ## $  ,2  ,

 #  '   %!

%& !%!&                ,    ' 1         ,      

'    4  2   4  4 &

+ '

  ,2   #    ,   ,    '  

 ' 

  

2 44   4 :

5#     

  ,  '

#   

$ 6 ,, ''   

      

   

 !

"   # 

$ %  

  $" 

&



 '

  '

()  %

$   '%

*  '

()

%

#  + '

()&!

"  ,-   , , '    '    6  ,         62 3

& 45 3  +   ;     ,    '   6  ' ,2  $  '    1  - 5   '!%

!

!% .6  ' 

8        5                  5  '2      %0 !% "     , , ' ' $  



#+    '  ,                 6,,'',                          '    !

%"

!% ", , .

$, '  '  - 8$/ 98$$,  ##  '   !

%"

!% ", 5    ,  .!   /



   /  

&,  "

    "   $

    /

   "   &  "  $  /

/ '

 !    0 1



& $ 23

" $



$ "

'

 "  /

  /   

 5 0650 6  $         

      " "   , " 

  "   / 

 

        /  

0650

*  !   "

5

& "

57" " $



$  $"

'

5 3   

                  

       

 !      "#$% &  "# '%  !  "  

    "        ""      

    /  

 " 8 !  

     /    "  ""  " 

,   

90950 6:" *+ 5( 3  

   ; < "  "% =0 000( &  <"

 / %77 000( &

     " "  %

9 790(  /    "

 

"

 %590(     /  "&$ " 

 

 

% 00( "  " "

     " " &   , "   !  /"

   

 "  " % =0 000( , #! " 

0=67

.0 50 6

% 0 000( , #! " 

09.

0550 ="#! "% =0 000(  *+ 5( 3$  

   #!

"% 0 000( 3



"#!

0550 >    $

" 3

  5

" /  3

(5( * !    "          "   /    "     

    

 /  "$"  5 0650 6 8"  /  3



 ?

!     

  < "   , & "

" " 

  /   "

8 "  # 

!" 

 ,  &   "

 

   /     "

8 "  # 

 "

/ %5 90 >0 ( "

8# 

 

070750 =3

 7 "

8# 

 "

00 50 =3



" , & "



 7 & "

  

    "  , "  ) ! , // #!((690=

0 50 =  

  < "  "% .= 776(

 

    "!"  " %

.= 776( $ 

 ,  779> 9

60650 =    &  

<  # 

    ,  



 8"#! 

0 50 =3

  6 "/

 ),8  

5.0. >>.

56

 >>6 3

 =

3

 > "  

     "

 , "  1 ! " " "    

&



, "    "   



"        " "        /      "  

! "   $ &  



$  "  /"

 

 



$       "  /

 "

 1 "

     

      " "     "   /      /  

 /  

5 0650 6

$    $

 

 @ !     "   ,   /  ""    



   " "   , & 

 $ "" /      "  A !  /   

$    B    " "   ,   /

9   /  & 

        " "   ,  # !         "  "  /

       " "  , &    

&  &

/"   $4  !  7 "



 &$ $ 4 

$ 4

4" $



$ $ '

 %"  /

 

%767 ( - ,

 . "



 " $ 4% 00(

" $

&'

%7=7 ( - ,  0 "

    $ 4 ,4

& $ 4

4" $



'

3

 "  /

  /   

 5 0650 6  $         

      " "   , " 

  "   / 

 

        /  

0650 6- "

3  '  ,               6,2  #      , ,,                   '       1  , 

'

 5

 '    ,,   7  ,,  , 

'  7   

 ,, ,    ''  

 ',  7 ,  ' ,

  # ,  ''

1        '  '       ,   '1 6,   '1  2  '     !

%"

!% "

1  ,   ''  2  <

5=> 

 # $(  )*

!+,))- +,

.

/( ( .  /011 51     , 2                                 3 !  

 

  3      !

 

        "       

6 $      

 !      

         !

  

         

                 4 5 !            

                             

:     !    

 

!

           

!

 6   

                

      !

         !      6  7     !          !    

 

!

        6      !       7 )*5

 *  .

/17 0089 ?

5       '  ,  ,'        , 5%!

%& !%!& ,   ,    '  ,

%

@,  

 ,  %!

%& !%!& '#( )( *+   '   -./  "##, 

-54 2  !1 /; , 7 *  

< ;6A B ; A B