M/S Eastman Industries,Ludh. v. The Commissioner Of Income Tax

   

  
 

  

 !
 ""## $ %&!! 
!'(&#) *%% +" 

  !
 "
  !
#!
 $%&%'( 

$!)'*+,)-.$ )/0*1234.(% $(0%.55%++.'(

$.6%&0,)-.$,.(401!%'*$!(.'2*'7)'&%+.'2

&$*20*.&8*'2%$!.'20)1)'*$!(.'2*'7)'&%+

$(0%$%3%')%  , -./.
0 / 0%.&&%&&%%*&*'.55%.+)'2%$!%4(*'

 (0%
'4-% .94(1 :

;

$&0$(1(0% :

4(<.7.*'&((0%$2%$2.(%2 =

5.&&%2>?(0%
'4-%.955%++.(%$*>)'.+10.'2*7.$0%'40 ; $ &0$(1(0%$*>)'.+<5.$(+?.++8*'7(0%.55%.+ (0%.&&%&&%%++8*'7 &)>&(.'(*.+@)%&(*'& +.80.3%>%%'4+.*-%2*'(0%.55%.+

A;.< "0%(0%$*'(0% .4(&.'24*$4)-&(.'4%& (0%4.&%1(0% $2%$  ''%9)$%&  B 1  B  .'2  BC  .$%  +%7.++?

&)&(.*'.>+%D ;>< "0%(0%$*'(0% .4(&.'24*$4)-&(.'4%& (0%4.&%1(0% .22*(*' & =1E FB-.2%(>%((.+()$'3%$

  2%4+.$%2*&+%7.++?&)&(.*'.>+%0%&.-%>%*'7>.&%2 '-%$%5$%&)-5(*'&.'24'6%4()$%&80*404.''(

$-(0%>.&*& $.26)2*4.(*'D ;4< "0%(0%$*'(0% .4(&.'24*$4)-&(.'4%& (0%4.&%1(0% .22*(*'    &  =1E FB  (  (0%  ((.+  ()$'3%$ 2%4+.$%2  *&  +%7.++?  &)&(.*'.>+%  *'  .&  -)40  .&  (0% *'4-%.++%7%2+?+*.>+%(>%*'4+)2%24)+20.3%>%%' &C1C 1 =FB1(0%&.-%0.3*'7'(>%%'3%$* *%2 ;2< "0%(0%$*'(0% .4(&.'24*$4)-&(.'4%& (0%4.&%1(0% *'(%$%&(*'4-% &

1:=1 = FB.'2+%.&%*'4-%

& 1C FB0.3*'7>%*'75)(8*(0*'(0%2-.*'

*'4-% $-(0%$&)$4%&*&+%7.++?&)&(.*'.>+%.&(0% &.*20.2>%%'2%$*3%2'.23.'4%.'22%5&*(-.2%G 0%$%+%3.'( .4(&.$%(0.((0%.&&%&&%% *+%2*'4-%(.9$%()$'

$(0%?%.$ ::

B:

2%4+.$*'7*'4-% E1

FB0%.&&%&&%%8.& ($.2%$.'22%.+*'7*'%95$( 4?4+%5.$(&0%.&&%&&-%'(8.& *'.+*&%2'

C ::C)'2%$!%4(*' EC;C< (0%4(%$(.*'.22*(*'&8%$%-.2%.'2 (0%*'4-%%.$'%2 $-+%.&*'7.'2*'(%$%&('+.'&.'2.23.'4%&7*3%'( &*&(%$4'4%$'&8%$%4'&*2%$%2.&*'4-%)'2%$(0%0%.2*'4-% $- (0%$&)$4%&0%.55%.+8.&2*&-*&&%2>?(0%55%++.(%)(0$*(?3*2% $2%$2.(%2C C ::E
'.55%.+>% $%(0%$*>)'.+15.$(*.+$%+*% 8.&7*3%'

' =

108%3%$1(0%4+.*- 2%2)4(*' +%.&%*'4-%.'2*'(%$%&( *'4-%)'2%$!%4(*'H (0%4(8.&$%6%4(%210%'4%(0%5$%&%'( .55%.+ %.$'%24)'&%+ $(0%.55%++.'(2*2'(5$%&&@)%&(*'&;.<( ;4<&$%7.$2&@)%&(*';2<1+%.$'%24)'&%+ $(0%.55%++.'(4'4%2%2(0.(

C (0%+%.&%*'4-%.'2*'(%$%&(*'4-% $-+.'&.'2.23.'4%&((0%&*&(%$ 4'4%$'&  8*++  4-%   *'  (0%  2-.*'     *'4-%  $-  (0%$  &)$4%& 8%3%$1*(*&.$7)%2(0.((0%.&&%&&%%0.25.*2*'(%$%&('4%$(.*'+.'& .3.*+%210%'4%(0%$%&0)+2>%&%((*'7

F.26)&(-%'( *'(%$%&($%4%*3%2 .'25.*21*(*&(0%$%.

(%$(0.('%(.-)'(>%4'&*2%$%2 $2%2)4(*')'2%$ !%4(*'H (0%4(%+*.'4%*&5+.4%2'2%4*&*' (0%!)5$%-% )$(*'  &0&"#(1)*$&!!

!'

(

2)232
+45 0%4'(%'(*'$.*&%2(0)70*&'(2*$%4(+?43%$%2>? (0% @)%&(*' $.-%2>)(.&(0%&.-%0.&>%%'2%.+(8*(0>?(0%$*>)'.+.'2*& (0%$% $%>%*'7.26)2*4.(%2 0%4'(%'(*'+.4/&-%$*( '4%*(*&.44%5(%2(0.((0%*'4-% $-+%.&%.'2*'(%$%&( *'4-%*&*'4-% $-(0%$&)$4%&1(0%$%*&'@)%&(*' *(>%*'7 %+*7*>+%  )'2%$  !%4(*'  H     (0%  4(  0%  5$3*&*'  2%.+&  8*(0 2%2)4(*'&*'$%&5%4( 5$ *(&$%(.*'%2 $%95$(>)&*'%&&0%*'4-% %.$'%2 $-*'(%$%&(.'2+%.&%-'%?*&'(*'4-%)'2%$(0%0%.25$ *(& .'27.*'& >)&*'%&&$5$ %&&*'
'(0% .4(& (0%5$%&%'(4.&%1(0%$%*&'@)%&(*' &%((*'7 

F.26)&(*'7(0%*'(%$%&('2%>*(&*2%.'2'(0%4$%2*(&*2% (0%5$ *( .'2+&&.44)'(0%*'(%$%&(5.*2>?(0%.&&%&&%%*&2*$%4(+?+*'/%28*(0(0% >)&*'%&&  .'2  8)+2  >%  2%.+(  8*(0  80*+%  4.+4)+.(*'7  (0%  *'4-%  $- >)&*'%&&$5$ %&&*'0%+%.&%-'%?.'2*'(%$%&(*'4-%*&'(*'4-%

$-(0%>)&*'%&&1$.(0%$*(*&*'4-% $-.55+*4.(*' -'%?80*40 -*70(0.3%>%%'%.$'%2 $->)&*'%&&$5$ %&&*'
'&)404*$4)-&(.'4%&1 (0%$%8)+2>%'@)%&(*' '%((*'7F&%((*'7

(0%*'(%$%&(5.*23*&B.B3*&

E (0%*'(%$%&($%4%*3%20%$*>)'.+$*70(+?$%6%4(%2(0%4'(%'(*' (0% .&&%&&%% %+*.'4%'  &0&"#(1)*6  (")2%&'(%'0.'4%(0%4.&% (0%.55%++.'(0%5%9)$(8.& 2%.+*'78*(0+.)&%;>..< 95+.'.(*'(!%4(*'H (0%4(.'2 *(8.&*'(0.(4'(%9(*(8.&0%+2(0.((0%%95$%&&*'A*'4+)2%2*'&)40 5$ *(&G*'+.)&%;

< (0%95+.'.(*';>..<8)+2*'4+)2%$%4%*5(&>? 8.? >$/%$.7%14--*&&*'1*'(%$%&(1$%'(140.$7%&$.'?(0%$$%4%*5( 80*40.$%*'4+)2%2*'(0%5$ *(& >)&*'%&&.&4-5)(%2)'2%$(0%0%.2 A5$ *(&.'27.*'& >)&*'%&&$5$ %&&*'G)$(0%$1(0.(* &)40(?5%

$%4%*5(&.$%.++8%2.&%95%'&%&.'2'(*'4+)2%2*'(0%5$ *(& >)&*'%&&1 '*'%(?5%$4%'( &)40@).'()- $%4%*5(&4.''(>%$%2)4%2)'2%$+.)&% ;

< 95+.'.(*';>..<(!%4(*'H (0%4(
'(0%5$%&%'(4.&%1 (0%*'(%$%&($%4%*3%2.'2(0%+%.&%-'%?*&'(%3%'*'4+)2.>+% *'(0% 5$ *(&.'27.*'&2%(%$-*'%2)'2%$(0%0%.2A5$ *(&.'27.*'& >)&*'%&& $5$ %&&*'G 0%.55%.+*&2*&-*&&%2 (, -./.
0) (/7 8+
) /90 /90  %>$).$? 1

-/ "0%(0%$&5%./*'7F$%.&'%2

%&F "0%(0%$$%5$(.>+%

%&F