High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2331/2004allowed

Kultar Singh v. Jagtar Singh And ORS

2019-09-13Mr. Justice Arun Palli37 pages

!"!#$ %

&$ '(&&(

" # $

% & " )*

#!#+,- " &

"" ( )*+,- , ./ " ( 0 #

$ ,- ,224

" " $

$ & #

,3 2* ,223 '

" " ""

, " &

0 " ",225 &1 & & " " 0

1 26 2,

" " 0

4 1"$

&" & & "$

& 7 " $"

"" 8 9

& " 44 4../0 4, 4../1 $& : & " "5

7 " ; ; " ""

" "" " , * 0 , * " " ""

" & & &

0 1 " 0 , 0<1

1 '

" "

& "

& " ""

: 7 ,, 4../ "" &

5 " $ * """ 44+4, 4../ & : &

" ""

$ &$ 0

" "

= " &

" "

""" 4*

0" 36 1

"$ > " ".2.4& $

$" 5 & $ ? $ " # @" " ,,

$ : 7 "" "" 0 " 4*1 5 & $ & $

$ & 5 " 6

$"" " " " " "

" ,0

1 $

$$< $ " *0(

= " ""

& ""

" " &

) =" 8

"&9 4 $

" " "$ &

" & " $"$"

., 222+

/ ""; " &

" "

: > " $" >

" $

" : " > & &

" ., 222+ $ & &

4 " > & &

"" & "

" $

- A

& "

: &

" "

" ""

" ,6

" "" "

&"$ " "

$ $ & ,6

& & 0 4

&" " ""

. & " 8$

9"# @ .

B $

"&" ? $

: 7

" $

$ "" "" " 4*

$ &5 $

& &

44+4, ?

$ 0" 41 "

" " $

" "

"$& "" "$

&"CD , 4, ./ "" CD * "" " &"CD "" " CD# ) "" " " CD# / $ CD# &" "

" CD#

/ - "

9 ' :$ "

" !

$ 74 ! 7, $

7* 0

:1 73 $ 7) $ 7/ $@ 76

0 ""1 7- :::::

:::::

#7 #74 !

1 #7,

0" #7*

$ " " &

" 0:

" "

1 "

$ " " :

" 4, " 0 1

" 73 B

? 7

F: "

&" ? $ $ $

"$ 7 : & $ $$ "$

A ! 0

" " 0F:

73+1 + 0F: 73+!73+1 4* : "

"$ $

# $4..)

$ & " " "

"" " 8

" 9 : 7/ $ " 5 7 : &

"" ""

$ "

# @

$ & 76# @" 7 F:

76+4 4) "" $"

" ; ;

7-+4 "

$ $

$ D " " "

1 4/

" " " #74

&8 ./90 4*" ; $ 1

$ !

" " "&

? $ & ""

" F:

#4 & $ & ""

$ ,4 ,4 " & & $ F:

#, "$ !

E" " #7, & $"" "

" $

" 4

44 " " " ., 222+ &

" : > 4, 4../0

:&1 & " "

" 5 "$

% $ " ., 222+

" $&

#7,

E& " " "

44 4../ A ' 8 $ "$ $9 5 & ;

; :& 4- " 4" & " #7* $" $ $

" -435 "

"* $

$ & 4.

" & 0 ""1

& $ '

$ &"

:0731 0 "$

& " 44

" $ &73 = " " $ 5 "

73+ " " $ "

> " "

$ $ 8

"9 $ F

"$ "

" "$

"$ &

" $

" $ &

& 7 F:

76+4 $ & 8 " " 9 7 &5&:

& 44+4, 1 "&& "

:$ & " $ "" 0F:

#41 '

&F:

#, "

#7,!

E " & "

., 222+ &

$ :

$ $ F:

#, & 1 "

" $"

$ > " & $ " $" /2"

" "5 $" F

1 )." "&

$ $& $ $ $ : " " "

" "

& $ " !$&?

( 4.-/041!$&()20)/1 $ "" "" 4..- 0,1(((*//0 1? $ $$

4..-041(((,)40<?1 ( 0 1

4..30,1(((/.)01? $

" "

& 1

" $ "

;

& $

$ & "

$ : 44+4, :1 7 : &

"" " &5 &

$" " ,2 ?

" "" $ & ,4 $

& &&"" #

" "

$ $

$ "73 " "

"$8 " 9 "$

" H= " " "

" $

"" " &$

&&$

" ""

;

; "" " "

F " $ $&

" ""

I ? & 73 $ :$

5 & "

" J" & $ "

( 5 & $ & " 73 ""

0 $& $

" "

$ &

,, " "" "

&$ 05 17 "

# "

46"

$ ,* F &

&& $

$ $" 0&

" " &0 "1 $

& "" " #7, !

:$ & " : "

= ""

$ 8 &9 5 & $$ "" : "

" ""

= : "

$ "&

1 ) * 2",!3** !&45 "45!3

( 6578 !

"& # +!#+!5 5-6!

,!8 # ,2220*1((( *.3>

59 453, +:

#9 45 4..*(((464 ,3 : $ " " ""

: "" $"

$ " $ & "

$ 7) $

8 $ 9 & $ :$

4..) $ & "

& &

> 76 @ 8

&$ "

& "

$ &

0 $ "

,) "";

$ & "

" $:

" &

" & $ 5 & ;

&: 44 "

,/ ?

$&* " " " $ " :*

$ "" ""

" $ & "" & $"

. " " $ & "" ""

$ " " "" $ ,- !" "

5 "

"$& " " 8 1 & )3" ' ""& C " &

$ /2 0,1 " :

0 1C 1 &

7 " + 1 0 1"

C 1

" "

$ "

& $ "

:C9 ,- ? $"" 5 0 1 01 "" & $5 $ & 5 0 1 0 1 &

5 " 5 0 1 0 1 ( 5 & " "

5 " &"

0 17 & " 4

& " $" )3" ' ""& 4--,C 0 1 7 $ /2 " 4.2- 5 $ &" $ > " &

: ""$ "

$ 5 7 C 0 1 "

: 73 ""

: $

" : "

& & C ,.

" "

$ " $

": " 42

" ' ($:

4../ " " $ & 4, 4../>& $ "$ $

$ :$ >

#74 " & 42 :$ $

$ "

$ $

& "

" > #7,!

E &

0 ""

$" :

"> 0 1 "

&> ?" $

44 4../ ' ($: :

42 " &#74 '

$ $ 42 4../"$

$ $ & $" ".,& "

" !

E; $ &

' ($:" 42 4../

44 4../: "

4, 4../ " .,

$ ' ($:

&42

#7*

$ 1 &$ "

$ :$ $ $" $ & & ,2 222+;

;& $

$ : "$ $ $

6, 222+"

$ & "

" $

-2 222+"$ "; " :$ $ $ "

? " $

1 :$

" $

$ &"

& & ""

& & &

" 1 ? : $

& " $

$ & "73

: $& $ "$ " "

$"$

"$ 7 $ &: & $ " ""

&73 5 & "" & " +" &: = : &" "$ "

$ " : " :

#4 ?

$ 7 F:

76+4 $

& & "" &

= : $

% " ;""

7* $

( ' D""

> 1

; : 7) $

7/ $0

" $ 7 1 # @ " ""

$": " 7

9 ?$ # @

; " ;

"$E & $

" :$ " "

$ & $ " " $ 7 F:

76+4 0 " "" $

" $ " $ & : 7 " 8 9 " 8$ 91 1 A: " 7* $

" ' & $ F:

5 0 &"

( " 1 " &

$ "

"$8 " 9

,2 4...

: 0

"$ " 1

1 A: "" $ : $ & &

" $ & 0 $ &"

& $ $ 1 && " "

$ :$

$ & ""$ &

$ " 36 ?

$ " 26 2,

$ & & > 5 & &

& $ &

" $

$ & " 4 :$

:1 E

" & & " $ " & " + "

& "

" "

; 0&

& "

" " " "

" *2 $ "

" $""

&$ $ " ?

(

2!)466!#3&, )) 6#!"

4..-0,1(((*// " & ?

( 5!,55 "

63) "

# 94) 5!

; ,5"

EB # =K4,43-3

& $ "

5< #!#+,3&, 5!#+, #6 ,5"

EB # =K 32.).6 6,4 )345# )!#+, #6 ,5"

EB #

=K6-**3) *4 # $

" " $ "

1 $

$" 42 4../ " " " F:

$ 4, 4../ " +&

& ? :$

& " & :

" "

$"$ & "

& $ G

: F:

#40"

:$ *" $ & & ; ;1 " $ &

& "

$ &

D""

" $

"$ &"$ "

& "

: $

$ : $ "

& $ ., 222+" & " & "& "

$ " $&

" " 1 $ ") / 6

; & 0" $

" " & "" 7) $ $ & &

4..)

" > # @ 76 $ $

& $

$& $ &

1 E :$ 7)

$ "

" $ $&

$ "" " ""

"" &

4.-- "

" " -&"

1 $" $ $ & "#74

"" $ &

& ,4 & 44 & & " F:

#, & &$ ,4 44 "

$ 42 $$

" ""

" $ $$ " $ & &

" $ $

$ 1 = : " 0: 1",-"

$ 4.*3

" "

$ $

" &

"" 0

$"" :

$ $

:1 $ :$ &"$ ""

" "" " " 5 &

:1 E& $ "" " " $& 44 4../ "

&$ 7 ,, $ & 7 : 5 &$ " : "

*, = "

( $ " "

: 73

" &

;"$&; :

" $ ""

" & " " $

" : ?" $ : & : :$ &

" " : 73 :$ & ""

5 " "

" $ " *)

" $ $

" $ " , $&

" $ $

$$< $

$ $ $ "

" * (

" $ $ "

" 4 &

& $ & $ " 1 $ &"7) / 6

$ 7) $ "&

4..)

"" $ & $

$ & " # $ @

5 " $ "&

$ $& & &

"" $ & ?" $ & 7 : &

"&$ &

" # @

$ $ &

5 "

$ & 1

$ " 4&

" &

"" "

" & "" " $ 1 E "

7 $ &: 44&" &

:$&

" " $&"

& $

5& ** ?

: :$& $

&: &

> " : & $ &

& 7

;""

*3 ?

" $ " ( " & (

& ""

& (

: " " & : = 5 0 1"$ 5 " $" /2" 4.2- "" "" " 5 0 1 :" )3" ' ""&

)3" ' "" & 4--,

! # !

! /2" 4.2-

&'( %

&.(

*) 0,1 " /2 " "

$ " "

& " " $ $ " )."

$ )." "4.2- "

! */ = : & "

1 $ 4,

" "

% "" 0 $

+@$

"&1

$ " &

@$ F

E F

$"" @$ B " &

4../&#74

" 0'

& " "" "

,4 &" F:

#, & $ 44 4../ ,4 & " 1

& "

&&& = &

#, & &" ?

:$ 5#74 "" & &"$ " " $ " ""

44 4../ &

"& & " & & ""

7* $

"$ ""

" +'

& ?

" $" F:

& 4, = $

& *6 A: ""

& &

: 1

0 " ""1 &

$ & ""

B &

: 73 "$

( $ &" "$ "

" " $ "

$ ?

= &

: 73

*- ( 5 & 5 0 1"

: 73 " *.

5 " " &

: " : " " & $ "$

$ " "

$" )3"' ""&

5 & $ & "

"& = :

" ""

4 "$ ; ""

07*1

& " & 0

$"1 ="

" " &

@$ "

$ 7 ,, : & $

" "

$$ & (

" &

" @$

" ?

& $ !1 F

= 7 F:

76+4

; $ 0

& " "" &

0 F

& $ ? ;

$$ &; & $

$ & " 4 : &

& " ( & ""

@$ : & $ $

=0 1

$$ &

" ? " =

& " $"

" "

$ &" 7) / 6

$ D" & ;""

$ + ! $

" 4, (

": &

" &

" 0 1 &

$ & : ,, 4../0F:

76+41 $&" ;$& ;

" 0

@$ 1 "

"" &"

,6+40 43+)1 "

@ & & $44& ""

$ "

D" 5

& " $" " $& " $" + " J & "

$ :

" $" " 0 "1 & "

5& 3 & " " " " :$

#7,

., 222+ & &&" &

$ " A" & "

"" #7, !

E 0& :$ "

., 222+ &

8 9

? $ &&"

& $ &"$

:$ " & "$ $ $" " $ & 0 6, 222+ " ., 222+1 " $" & & " > 5 & " $""

&$ "

$" )3"

' ""& " &

" &&" "

0 41"

$ J " 4 & " " $ &

($& $& " " &

& "-&

;

" "$

"$$

" " " & $ $

" $ 7 : 44&

$&" & "

= + ., 222+ ""

$& "

$ ( 5 & &

" F:

#4 " " 1 A:

$ &&0.2.,&" 1 "

. $ A " &

$ & $ & " 4 " $ &

;

& & " :$ "

& " $$ "$ & &

$ & $ " &"

" 3 )

" *(

" / 6

$ &

$$"

" ( 0#" * "

& 1 1 E "

& &

" $ 7 ,, $ &# @ 0761 ""

.,& :$ & $

; $" ""

"$ & 0 $ 1 $ $ &

" " 8 9 = &76 8$ 9 ?

7 "

& # @ $ "

!! & 7 0 & 1

" #

/ @; $ &

& $ &

J " $

$ $ 7 =

;

760# @1

( 5 & $&

& 01 : = :$& &

: $

$ " : 4244 & > & $

" " ": &

" &

& 3, = " 4, $"

/3" ' ""& 4--, & " 5 "

: 44& 5 $&

" 5 ""$ ,- " "" $" )3" ' ""& 4--,> , 5 " ""

$ &

0 " $" /2"

4.2- ;

; " " & $

"& 3* ( 5 & "

$ " ( '

" "" "

& "" 5& $" $ : & "

& 7 )=5 -

% >&(?

+ C J+A , 7 C J+A