High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/2034/2001dismissed

State Of Punjab & ORS v. Chain Singh & ORS

2026-03-11Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja4 pages

, %" ,+ %" ,+ %" ,+ %" ,+ 7>@ 7>@ 7>@ 7>@,+ ,+ ,+ ,+77 77 77 77. H/ . H/ . H/ . H/ 466,!

466,!

7>7 7 7 7 -- ))%!"

-- ))%!"

-- ))%!" -,!( !"

-,!( !"

-,!( !"./ /

, 7>C 7>C 7>C 7>C,+ ,+ ,+ ,+77 77 77 77. H/ . H/ . H/ . H/

-- ))%!" -- ))%!" -- ))%!" -- ))%!"

-,!( !"

-,!( !"./ /

+, ,!

#!$%! &"%'(()' #!

!$%* "& %-- ))%!"./ ! +,"& -,!( !" DDDD '. %)/ '. %)/ '. %)/ '. %)/

01 2 3%2,+- !"%-- %)'4&%)) !5 5 &%* !)%6(","& 3%((% %" ( 778777-% (*2"& ) %! ((()6"64 4"#(5 '#(%-#.& 6!%+"

", & 9 + !4 ,#":/ * + (%"& 01 6 +)2 "%"6!5' 6! "& - !" 4% % ./' 4 "%6! )%!( ,3! ( *2 -,!( !";)%!( (,3! ' 6"#%" ( 36"&6! "& E !# "%" ,+ E6))%5 6(&% %#6' &6) %"&%!<, ,"'6"64" %"&%!<,"'4%F ",* * %4B#6 (E6( ,"6+64%"6,!(% %" ( =88>6# # (#!( 4"6,!@,+"& %!

!(4B#66"6,!4"'?8@.+,& &," "& 9?8@ 4":/ / +, "& -#*)64 -#-, ' !%F )2 I+, "& 4,!"#4"6,! ,+ 2 2( ) &%!! )A 3% %( #!( 4"6,! ,+ "& ?

?8@ 4" 3% -% ( *2 "& % %!( 4B#66"6,!,) )) 4",.+,&,"9"& :/,! 8788='3& *2F%< "E% %)# ,+ "& %4B#6 ( ( )%!( 3% % ( G > '777;J - %4 +, %%!6J % %!(

%564&%J' > 7'777;J - %4 +, %%!6J %!( '777;J - %4 +, %6 #F<6! %),!5 36"&%)),"& "%"#",2 * ! +6"

%!(6!" "-,E6( ( #!( ?8@4" 0>1 6 %"6+6 ( 36"& 3%( -% ( *2 ' %-- ))%!"./;)%!( (,3! ./ 6!E,< ( + !4 # #!( 4"6,! ? ,+ "& ?8@ 4"' 3&64&4%F ", * -%")2%)),3 (*2"& ) %!

( + !4 ,#"E6( 6"%3 3%( (%" (77877 77'3&6) 5%!"6!5"& F !&%!4 (4,F- !%"6,!G '777;J - F%)% +, %)) <6!( ,+ %%!6 )%!( * 6( ( %3%(6!5 %)) ,"& "%"#"

",2 * ! +6";6!" " 6!"& 6+%E,##!( "& ?8@ 4"556 E ("& ,+'"& - !" - ))%!";"%" ,+ #!$%* %-- %)3 - + (%""& 6!"%!4 ,+"& %-- 0@1 F- -#5!6!5 "& %+, %6( 3%(' ) ) %! ( "%" 4,#! ) #*F6" "

"&%" "& ) %! ( + !4 ,#" (&%E6!5 )6 ( (#-,!"& 3%((%" (78 888 .KJ/+,"& -#-, ,+( " F6!%"6,!,+F F%< "E%)# 6!"& 4% ./6!&%!( ( 0@1 % %! ( "%" 4,#! ) +#"& #* *F6" "&%" "& (%" ,+ !,"6+64%"

"6,! #!( 4"6,! @ @ ,+ "& ?8@ 4" 6! )%"6,!

! ", "& 3%( (%" ( 78 888 .KJ/ 3% 888>' 3& % "& %4B B#66"6,! 6! "& - !" 4% ./ 4,FF !4 (E6( ( !,"6+64%"6,!(%" (=88> 6# (#!( 4"6,!@,+"& ?

?8@ 4"%!("&#'"& 3%!,6F6)%6"26!"& "3, %4B#66"6,! '"& +, '#*F F6" "&%""& 6F-#5!

($#(5F !"3%)6%*) ",* "

"%6( %!("& 3%(-% (*2 3%",* ", ( 0C1 , ,! &% -#" 6! %-- %%!4 ,! * &%)+ ,+ "& -,!( !" & %E & %() %! ("

"%" 4,#! )%!(5,! "&,#5&"& & -%- *,,<%3 ))% 4,( ,+ "& 4% ./%F F#!%*) ",+6!(#*"%!4 6!"& #*F66,!F%( ,!* &%)+,+ %-- ))%!";"%"

01 - - #%) ,+ "& 4,( &,3 "& &%" E6( "3, -%%" !,"6+64%"6 ,! (%" (888 8>%!(=88>6# (#!( 4"6,!@,+"& ?8@4"', ,F )%!(+,F6!5-% %",+ E !# "%" ,+E6))%5 6(&%#6' &6) %"&%!<,"'6"

"64"

%"&%!<,"3%% %4B#6 (+,"& -#*)64-#-, '!%F )2'I+,"& 4,!"#4"6,!

!,+ 2( )&%!! )A A& )%!(,3! - "%6!6!5","

"& - E6,#%4B#66"6,!6!" F ,+ !,"6+64%"6,!(%"

(888>,#5&" + !4 #!( 4"6,!?,+"& ?8@ 4" 3&64&4%F ",* * ( 46( (6!" F,+3%(( (%" (7888.KJ/%!( F%< "E%)# 3% %% (G 777;J- F% )%+,%%!6)%!(%!( 77;J - F%)%+,5%6F F#F<6!)%!( 0=1 & ) %! ( + !4 ,#"6!"& - !"4% ./3&6) ( %)6!53 36"& "& ( " F6!%"6, ,! ,+ F%< " E%)# 6! " F , ,+ "& #* B# !" %4B#66"6,! E E6( !,"6+64%"6,!(%"

(=88>#!( 4"6,!@ ,+"& ?8@4".%--,K6F%" ) )2% F,!"& %+" "& - E6,# %4B#66"6,!/' - "%6!6 6!5 ", "& %F E !# "%"

,+ E6))%5 6(&%#6 6 )6 (#-,!"& ( " F6!%"6,!F F%( 6!" F,+!,"6+64%"6,!(% %" ( 888>#!( 4"6,!@,+"& ?8@4"%!

!(4,! B# !")2'5%!" (* ! +6"

",+ "& %F F%< "E%)# '4,!6( 6!5"&%"*,"&"& & %4B#66"6,! )%" (","& % %F E !# "%" , ,+E6))%5 6(&%#6 &6) %"&% %!<,"'6"64" %"&%!<,"%!("& & 3%%(6++ !4 ,+%,#!(,! F,!"&,!)2* "3 !"& "3,!,"6+64%"6,!#!

!( 4"6,!@,+"& ?8@4" 0?1 !E E6 3,+%*,E '"& 5%!",+"& %F F%< "E%)# *2"& ) %!

! (

+ !4 ,# "- "%6!6!5","& %+, F !"6,!

! ("3,!,"6+64%"6,!6# (#!

!( 4"6,!@,+"& ?8@4"'4%!!,"* %6(",* #!$#"6+6 (,#!+%6& ) %!

! (

+ !4 ,# "' "&# &%E6!5 -% ( "& %3% ( *% ( ,! -,- %-- 46%"6,!

!,+ F%" 6%) E6( !4 4 %E%6)%*) ,! 4,(' "& +, ' 4%)) +, !, 6!" + !4 6!

- !"%-- %)'

%#4&*,"&"& %-- %)% +,# #!(",* ( E,6(,+F 6"%!("& &#' (6F6 ( 081 )) - !(6!5%--)64%"6,!./'6+%!2' &%))%),"%!((6-, (,+

/ %4& %4& %4& %4& '7 7 7 7 "6< . . . . L& L& & "& - %<6!5; %,! ( & "& -,"%*) ;, ;,