M/S Prenda Creations Pvt Ltd v. Union Of India And ORS
#1-
2 6!(# ( !$% & & #7 '*) ( "
= " "
5 ) ( $ '
$
A
A= >
!" ! - *1 )5
)
58 +1 )- -
,
# "
$ ??? , ) .+4 + 4
)
, 4
!"#$%&'
("
( !
) )
*+
, - '
' )
4, , .
/ +
' , , , 01234 4 ,+ *
@
* +
5 5 )#6$7)
=, 9
!(7) 5
5)
)8 *)
9 9
) , ' :1;
;
, , * 0< 3
- ,0*
3 4 0 3 0'+
0 4' 3 0 3:03
#2- @* 4
'
* , , 1
4
, ) +) = 5 ,
:'
*
)'*
)5/ @
4
*
' =<) *+ , + .
#7 " ( !
+
5 B 4 *+
, * + -
"7
5 )#67 * C 5 ,
' =B 4 ;
* + -
"7 5
(" ($ (## . B 4 @
, * 4
#( " ( ! 4
, 4
=B
* +4 *+
$ (" ( ! 4 *+ ,
- 7 (" ( ! 5 4
+* *+ , 9 & (" ( !) B 4 *+
4 ,
, * , *
) + +* 4 * + E4) 4 4 *+ -
, 4
,
)
4
+
* + -
"7 5 +
#3- ' @
* ) ,
, +0=5,
3 :'
*
)'*
5/ - , 4
4
B F ) 4
" = ,
*+ - + +@
% <)
;)- &) 1 )8
)4 .
@=G/5 6%#! "# '
#7 (" ( !)
, B
)
4 '
, 4 < ' + 0 ' 3 ( -
!( 5 ) ,
) - ,
+
< ' +, 4 .
'=<) < -
!( 5 ) - + 0 3*
, -
!( 5 H ) *+,-. /*01,21+,3 4 ) *5-6*78 -297,2:.- *1,7-297,7*97,
! "!
!# "! "!
#4- !
!
"
!
# #
" "
"
# "
"
" $$$
#
#
% &
'
"
% ( ) # #
""
" %* 7 ,
.
,) $ 4 ,
8
)4 4 *
4
+ , 4
0 =<) 3
, )(4; % - , 4 ,+ *
)
05 .
/ +3 -
"7 5 )
#5- '=<- 4 )4 4
* - +
= $ 9 , < ' + ' =< ) ) ,
4 , *+ - ,
& 5
4 B 9 .
/ + ,
9 /'+ 4 4 ;
*+ $)
* .
/ + ,
,
4 ; ' ='- 4 ) @
.
/ + /
$ (" ( ! = ' ) )4) "
+*F *+ - + $ 6 @
& (" ( ! B
, , 4 - , , *
, , F 5 #( - , *+
40 *3
)
, .
/ +
4
(" ($ (## # ($ (##)
*+4 + , 4
#6- ## @
(6 ($ ( ! ,
* @
4
* +
@ * H +,
-.%-/%&-&(
0 %/ # 1
2 3 2"
4 # "
# 2"
# " " " #
5" % 6" 1
" $ &
," % 7
) 2
2"
$ ," $ %
2 " 8 ," %* (6 ($ ( !)
4 4
;, 4
# 9 F
#7 ($ ( !)
, ' + ) )
, 4
* I
) , 4 * ' 9 !# ($ ( !)
,
=< ') - 4 ) 4
!( ($ ( !)
; , 5 )
, E4) ,
4 4
; ,
#7- !# ($ ( !) , + , - < ,
5 ,+)
, +
F
;, - < ,
*+
@ E 4 #! @ F
(% (7 ( !
, +) +) $ 4 + , 4
* ) ) ! $ ,
4
#" @ 1 4
; 4 *
#$ (7 ( !
1 4
' < - + 2 * #6 (7 ( ! 5
J
' *
* @
4
F
+($ (% ( !*+ * (" (% ( !) 4
4
1
,
, + @
,
, 1
; +
+
* *+
4
4 ,
#$ @ ; /F '
*+
5 * /
) '*
5
+ 4
1
4 4 *+ '*
E4)
*
#8-
4 4 + /F '
*+'*
#7 9(7 (% ( !) # " ,
4
4 B + 4
*+
5 * /
) < 5
+) '*
5
4,
4 1
4 + , @
(" (% ( ! *+ ' + '
/ )
) J
- ,) =J-) 5
) 4
4
,
* 4
#( + E4) ; 4
(" (% ( ! *+ *4*
1
,
, + # " ,
4
#% 9 " (% ( !) * ,
, ( 4 4 *
*+
+
4 +
+*
4
,
, 5
4 , ,
*+
< - +' :J
' #& 9 % (% ( ! 4 4
(K $K , ;
4
, @ 4 ,
+ +* %$K , <
4 ,
, ,
#9-
4 , ,
4
4 #6 9 (% (& ( !)
, *
* 4
, , * ( *
*+
, *+
4 * ' =<) )
- + , - - < , ;
*
,
, )
4
; - < , ,
( (7 ( ! = " , , - < ,
@ ) *
,
,
;
* ,
= $
, + ,
@ - < , @
# *
, ,*
@
@
=< *8 , 4 *+ :J
' 4
(" (% ( !
% &'!
,
, + E4 =
+
9 , %<
#10- * ,
() @
, /F '
' *+ 5/ 9 , , ) , *+
4
*+ @ )
#(&&$H&7H 2 ( ! , 4 + ,8
, )
+
) ,
4 124 4
, , 4
@
,
8 F
12 ,*
+ ! *
*+
, * *+ , , + ( ! 4 +
+(# (& ( ! + )4 , C
D
4
, F
+ *+ = - ,
+ '
*+ * + , -.
<
' H .- - - . /(-( .9&.$' +:);)* ) 0 % <=$-->&( 3 -%->%&-&(
0 $ ( ! 123!$ # .9>&-: ## , ' "
%
#11- :);) "
# # # ?
7 2 '% :);)# " ?
4"
"
%* " @
H#&! 6H 2H ( " , , , , , 4
> 4 <
12 4
+ ' +
,
$
)
4
+ *
* 4
1 4 *
+ , @
*
,
*,
+ , *+ 4 *
+ , 4
* # $
,* *+
, @ 4 F 7
*
, + 4
4
* * * * *+
!( 5 ) 4 -* -
!( !
4 4 ; *+ - + E4 +)
## (" (#%4 *
#12-
+
* - + < -
!( !
5 )
9
+
- .
#7 (" ( ! *+ $
4 +
< +, *0 3 =
+
4
B
" ($ ( ! % *
= '
, *+
4 *< ,01234
) 5 =
-
!( !
5 )4
9 @
4
*+
=
4
4 @= *
;
## (" (#%
*
5 )4 .
*+ - + +
.
=< * +,
#13- & @ *+
4
!( !
5 4 + 4
)
+0.
,34
< ' +, *
+ B
,
<
+ + )
+4
) ,
E
6 @ 9
*+
,
( (7 ( ! , 4 *+ = $
@ - < ,
-
#"# 5 ) #67 ) , + **8 9 - .
,
+, 4 0 '=<- 4 3
, , - < ,
) *+ , + ,
' + ' !( @ $ + ,2,
,< ' +, *=< -
!( 5 )#67 4 ,
#14-
, <
* = 9
,
- + -
!( 5 ) 4
=,
## -
, =,
) ( ( !# *
-
+ ,4,
= - + F=$! 4
## (" ( ! # (" ( !) * 4 - +4
*
< + *=<) '- 4 ) -<7 ! @ + , 5 .
/ + ,
4 +
- + 4 4 4
" (" ( "4 )
4
+ 4
* *+ < - , +
#6 ($ ( ! 6 ($ ( ! 4 -
+ 4 * *+
) 4 + +
= $
+ * *8 +
'
,
")7!) "% %()'
,
#( (7 ( !
7!)$$)$7" $7) <-
#()$%)#7( (( -
+'
)(()((( ((
#15- , 4
4 -
+
4 .
/ + * !! @
+ +
,.
/ +
, , * , ,+ *
(! (7 ( !4
*+ - +
= $ ) 4
*
4 + ;
, +
)4 ' +
;
)*
,
@ - < ,
!" '
, 4
* '
4
4
(% (% ( ! H#"
B
(7 (% ( ! < H
4
,
<--5 : J
' @
'
, +
' + *
!$ @ = *+
+ 4
*+ , +
,
#16-
<--5 : J
' @
, #(&&7 ( ! ;
8
+ , )
G /F
4
$
)
F
, 4 +
= F G /F
% (% ( ! H +) # "
%% 6 :#
% #
"
'
'# # #
%*
G
4
<12
<124 #((K
@
) #((K F
, < 0123 4 *+ 9 !7 -
+ ,
(% (% ( ! *
, + 8 F
% (% ( !
)
,
,4
, , +)
+
#17- !% 5
4
,
, *+
4 , +
*+ E * () $ $-!) !
! ' 4 5678916923.69:;1(2 4
* H 07 " @
'
# #
"
" "
% 7 "
"
% "
"
" * !& < 8 , & 5< ! 3!$ = $ (## 7& /@ #%
) 4
* H +> ;
7 A"
" " 7
-%)
" "
7
- 1
"
1"
"
# "
7
&> "
"
% ) "
"
"
5"
"
"
"
7
-. 1
# "
"
%* = * 8 ,
E , 3!$ = $ ((! #$7 /@ !""
) 4
H
#180?@ 4
# 2 % $ B@
90 &---# " #
&& 0 &---
#
'# C 3
% 5" 4 "
2
" %
" " "
% )
'
# #
" # % "
# #
%* = :<*1/77:!155*+,7 01,21 = $
& '4$*5&4 H 0% "
"
" 5"
# % ) #
# "
#
# ' # % "
" "
" #' %
# # ' 8 #
#
"
% 2
3
" 7%$% 8 && 7 99(
#19- # ' 5"
# "
'
"
# "
% "
# #
"
%) # " "
" "
7
-
1%* !6 =+ ,
8 , ) *
+ 4 , E *
, 4
*+ =
= - + )4 = 4B
+4
4 *,
'
$ (" ( ! H!
@ =
+
+ ,.
/ +)5 )
, - , )
) , *+
, ,
<
, , ) 9
, 4
) 4
, 4
* 4
+ 4
@ , 4 * I * *
,
+9 ,
0 3 @ , + +
*+
+
= 9 - +
+
+ ,
#20- ) B * 4
, = = $ (## /@"6
)4
* H +69 )
#
"
" "
"
D %/---E %4 #
" #
" # "
%
< D
&F%-&%&--&
# #
" # % ) " '
# % ?
5"
"
"
%1
# " "
E
" 8
"
# "
%
5"
# "
"
%
"
"
" "
" 7 A" ;$ 0 %((.- 999% 6A
#
"
" " 3 " "
3
;$ 0 %((.- 999
"
% 4 #
" "
5"
B" # 5"
%
#216; ) 0 D %7 1%$% 1)D99> &FF(99>7
F&-/5"
4
@ 7"
" # "
" # "
1"
7
"
# %;
7
"
#
# "
% ; )
" 5"
4
@ 7"
" "
8 :
3 " $%7 2
# G +7 8 :
3 "$%7
2
H9II>7
(/.G9II7
/9.G1)D 9II7 I>9&>-!5"
#
" # #
# "
" %
#
"
%# "
" % ; "
# #
# "
#
%
" " G7
% (F F& F +)
E
%) # B % " 2 # #
"
%;
" 7
' " "
2 # B"
5" " %
#22- ((% #
5" "
"
" "
1
"
B
#
# " #
#
"
%$"
5" " # #
# #
" 7 "
# " " % 7 "
@
#
# # "
7 #
" ' " " "
%* 6: ) 7 8
# "B %2
2 4B 4 G 1)D 9FI 7 ../ 4
@ 7"
"
+ #
# "
"
" % #
# B " #
# "
"
1 "
# %
"
#
"
"
""
"
' "
' " '*% 6> ) " 7
J 2 ""
% ,%
% ?
2"
210?E7 E-(9IE9I-GH9I-!(7 D./>
#23- 4
@ 7"
" 4
" B"
"
1 &&F #
"
"
'+
#
"* "
5"
% 68 ) #
"
E
# 5"
% #
5"
5" "
"
E
% #
A" "
B"
%* "(
8 , ED* - B $ +( !
! #66"
-
#7(6)4
* H +(-% )
"
" '
# "
%
# " "
'
5" 5"% # " %;# " #
# "
&H 7
&!%;# 5" "
& 7
F
"
% 1
"
"
"
% ) "
# "
"
"
%
#24- # # "
"
# ## #
" "
#
#
%
#
&
#
%)
" " # %
# "
6 #
" %* "# ,
B'$ !1 .2 !
! $ !) #6%% -
$6&) - H 0F% )
E %) # B
% " 2 # #
"
% ;
"7 ' " "
2 # B"
5" " % ;
## 4
"
#
"
"
# "
%* "
8 , ED* - !
!*'
4 !
) $
4
1 $2 5 ) 3B " !
! 5= #67% - #&&$) 4
* * H
#250I%
7
"
" # "
1% 8" #
# "
" % #
# B 1 1" #
# "
"
1 "
# %
"
#
"
"
" "
"
' "
' " '%A"
"
# #
7
#
"
# "
#
% "
'
"
# #
7
"
# "
%)
D " 7
"
# " 7
" "
# % # "
#
@ "# %
#
2 # "
# # ## # "
"
%
#
#26-
# "
%<
#
"
"
" "
#
%) " " #
7
"
%* "! ( !' " B $
' <!' B ( 3!$ =)
' <"
(' <+ !) #6%( #-
$& )
- H 0.% 4
"
B"
"
1 &&F
"
% 8"
B"
' # B"
' B"
"
%8"
"
"
"
#" "
B"
% 1
5"
"
"
B"
% 4
"
$
" #
#
2"
## "
B"
%* "" ,
8 , )
D , * , *
)
4 +
#279 + , .
,4 * < ' +, * '=< @)
9 4 - +
, *+
*
< ) , 8 F
, 4
)4
*
)
"$
*
+ , *+ 4
+ , *+
) ) + * , 4 ,
+
+ "7 2
* * * # "
-
75 5 )B * * , * + *
-
75 5 * 4
@ *+4 + 4
* ,
+
+
*
*+
, *
+
' + '
) '=)
,)
, 1
"%
-
75 !
5 *
#28- *H
# * 4 *, , 4 F ,* @) 4
+ E ,
$ $!) ) C $!) (## -
77 "& *
% (% ( !) 4 8
4 ) 1 4 4
, ( $K4
-
75 5 * , ,#((K;
* ,
#((K +) )
* E *
B
,
+ "6 2 * $( < 4
*+
)4
' 4,+ , + 4
*
1 4
2
*, ,+4
*
*+
;
)4
*, + 2
+ + )
+4
=< ')- 4 ) @
!# ($ ( !
H
#29- +$"
" (-%-/%&-&(
) 2 $
2"
$ D6,) 37 #)07 6F," #
% $"
" (-%-/%&-&(
'
2"
# "
0 "
"5" "%
-&%-F%&-&(%3 $# . 4
) , 4 + 4 4 * *+ + - - < ,
@
,
*+ ,
( (7 ( !)
* + 4
4 * 4
,
, 4 @
, ,
* 4
, , 1
* , *+ 5/ , , 8
*+ " (% ( !) $K , 4 + F 4 $K
, * + , $ 2
, 4
+ (# (& ( !
4 *
, 4 , , &6)" ( 1, 4 + , 4 * ,
5
* *+
,4
4
4 *
; 2 ) )
;
#30-
*+ ) 4 ,
4 ) )* -
75 !
5 )4 H ?: ' $ "!$'! <!
< ;
"
"
"
"
""
"
#
#
#
#
#
"
# "
G $
# '
# " "
#
#
1
3"
##
# ' "
1
5"
"
"
"
"
#
# '
"
"
>IG $
" "
#
G
#31- $ "
# "
1 # % &
"
"
" "
% <
% "
K K
#
" )
# '
"
/ #
5" " 5" #
"
" "
"
% ( "
"
#
#
%* E4) ) -
75 !
5 4 * * 4 ,
H D 4
4
* , 2 #((K + * , ) ,
, * + H *
) ) * -
75 !
5 * 4 8 8
)*
#32- $! @) * -
75 !
5 )
-
4 + *, , 4 F 4 , * , E4)
4
) 9* +)
*)
I 4
, F
+) 4 *
. 4
;
F
+) *
*,
, * *
) B
4
+
*+
* 4 * *+ 5
$" @
-
75 !
5 )
*) *
4 , , +
2 F +
*+
@
*+
5
+ 4 + , @ , +
*+ )
+ , * , *4 $$ @
+
+
H ,
+ )* ,
4 * 4 * ; )
4
,* 94
,
#33- * + ) * 4
+
4 8
)%
5= (##- !##%)ED* -
8 4
+ *8 +
F
+ 8 $7
+
* , E
* ; 4 * * + , 4 5 * )
1 4 , * &6)" (;
, 4 4 4
&()"%& -') 4
F
+77)%6)7%"H)L&!-' $% 4 *)4
*
+ , ' !
! ! , B #66% # -
"#7)ED* - F
, ,,
,
4 F ,4
8
H 0"
""
##
B"
"
"
"
"
7 %
#
"
"
#34-
7# #
% )
"
%
B #
"
# "
# "
"
" #
"#7 # "
#
"
#B"
# " B"
' " # #" # "
7% 5" "
#% "
"
B' " %
#
"
"
#B"
%
#
" 7
#
B"
# # # "%3 $& !,) !
!- #66!
-
%"7) 5F
E , 4 5
7
$6 8 , !
$ B) = $ $!) ( " - !7) 5F H 0.%
"
" $ " LA"
@ #
"
"
#35B" " " B" #
"
% 9%
" # " 3%:%8 "%7 ; 8 99I7
>FG +/>% "
" "
# #
B"
"
"
"
&-&( 7
, 7 &&-99I7
>F "
7 %* &-% ) $%7%D% 7 % 1 "
9.- ( 7
>
" # # " B"
" G +F% B" " B"
B"
" "
#
B"
% 8 "
"
"
" B"
B"
"
"
B"
% "
#
#
" "D"
B"
# 1 (F%* &% ; "
# LB"
@
B"
" :% 7" % 0# )
"
% ,% &-& & 7
&I>
G +-% )
# B" " # 5" "
' # " B"
## " " "
#36- ## " " B" " "
" % 4 # "
"
%0
# "
"
# '
" " 5" "
% )
"
+B"
* " %* 7(
) 5 $!) .)!
!
( $ - # (
4 4 ED* -
4
7# ED* - + 5 (("$6( ( $M D'E'
$ .) !
! =!!
$ )) (# (" ( $
4 4 4,+ @ 4 *
-
+, + +,
,
1 4
*+ *
C1 D) +
, , , 2
, 4 *
7 4 *)>*:55>,/*>7-,9*,-,-.
+ 1
,4
L7K @ ;
,
*) 4
4 *
+ $( 1 4
#374 , ,&6)" (;
, 4 + + *+
2 ,
+
1 *, 1
,
@ * ,
7! . 4 ) 4
F H
* ,4 *+ ,
@ *
4 , * , @
I , ,H B
+
4
* N 4)
) *+ ) 4
)
4
) ,
*) * ,
)
+ * 4 *
5 + *
*+
, *) , ) 5
4;
, * * 7" 5
7$
$ !" & ',/97-53
( $ ! & 2 ;
, O 2
* O