← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1365/2001dismissed

(O&M) Maghar Singh And Others v. Kartar Kaur And Others

2023-04-28Mrs. Justice Lisa Gill11 pages



        





 !"#"$ %   '( )"$'( $  ()#



*)#+#   ,

), +) $  ()#

 

 &-.  /0&  000 

       



 

  !  



" # $$$ 000% # %

   &

 



! ! !(

  

   ) ) #*** 

+ ,!

 -,  . / 

 0 &'       

     

 

  0

     

 2    &

 (  +

    !(

 

)* ))) &'



. ,!



0 &'

3



(  4



'    (

 

  

5 !     

  



"  0

   '

2  ! !+

!  6 #* # ! )8 #* #

( 7*8 )9 #**:   

   !   

 

   ;  

 +

!   (  0

  1 

(

 !1:)5

#(  

 (     +

 +

  !      #7 ):

#**1 .

" #

' 00



 +

  !  !  

 (  

 (  '



 

3   !- 

&'  

 0/ !4     , !!

! 

 &    +

   .

     00  !

 & 

0

+

+

!   6 #* #



 ! 0

00

'5  

   (

' 2  6 0  &  &' =

!6#

! 

< (&(  

 0

' > (  ! 6

 >    -

/ 6 #* #0  ! )8 #* #0  

   & ! 

 

<

  +

  ! 0

< (&(

0

 & !

( !

&   4 0



!

 0



; 

   & 

2  !

& 6  )1 #**1 



0 0



&

   

   +

   6    )1 #**1 0   '    &' 

 +  ? =  

 0 0  



& '(

!

 ! 6 )8 #* #



  0 0

" #

  2  

2 !(  ! 6 )8 #* # .

" # 

0



0

"  00  

< )1 ) #**8  .

 #  0  !  (

' &    !



   5

6 #* # !

& (

+

!



'6

(   ! 

'  60 



? (  2 

 &

' 

" #

! ( & 0

 

2 6

' 6 #* #



 ! 

 #  (       

 5

+

   !0 &



;

 (  "  7*8   &

 ' 



 

 #   &  

       0

.(  0 !  

 :

?0 ! 0 

!    # 6 

    6 #* # ! )8 #* #@A  6    

        

@A.

6  

 (

& @A.

:

6  6 !

(

@A.

6  ( @A.

6    '     

@A.

 



(

=

!6#-& 6 )7 #* #/> (  !6-

!0

/



   ! (    61  +'   6   )7 #* # -B< #/

' 

  '

#**# *-B< /0 .

" # (

4 & (+ 5 .6# .61

 

0

&< .6  

 > ( !-B< .6#/ ( 

!' 



 '

#**8 *9-B< .6/ -B< .1/

'    50 

+ (

0 &'0 ' 

    !





(

    



  



& & C

 +  ( 



0

(

&'

 6 #* # ! )8 #* # ;0

 &'

 +  ( 

!&



+ ?= 

 !0

> (  !6 -B< .#/  

 ( 6

  !

 0  &

   &

5     6 > ( <    

 

  

 (    &

 



   &  

   &' 



+ ?= 

-B<  A

 / 



! !

  ( ( 



! !!(

 

 ) ) #*** 0  (

 

 . ,!

 

   !(

  

   )* )))  !!

( 

 &



 



' ! &

  & 0   !'  



0 0   ! !(

  

   ) ) #***

 )* )))

 2

' ( !     &'

 

 ;  &( 6 #* #'    &

 &' 

   +   

  0

> (  !C (&   &



  <

 !

 &

&

&

5  



  6   2     

   

(

  5

 !  0

 6  

' <

  

 -B< .#/ &

  



+ ?= 



&'(  

      ( & !   

  (  & 

& 6# &

 '!

;

6





'   ( ' & 6#&     (  & 6 )7 #* # 

!

> ( 

>    60  



!0



0+

!

< (& ( 6 > (  !C (&  6

>   

!

(&( 5 6   '

%

60 !    )8 #* #    "  #)9:  !  " 

(

 6#  0  

 0             6 #* # .   

  ! 0

 6    &    

! &

 

  (( ' 

 &'

A

   (&

C

& 0    

    !   

# 3

   !   !  6    )1 #**1 '

  &' +

   6 0  &   

+  & !   &'  (

 6   )1 #**1 0    &' 

 #     "

    



(

 6 #* #  &'+

!



 (

 %      6   )7 #* #   &

 '



   

 ;   &(  

  !

  

    (



'  

&'+

!

  ( &'.61

*

   

 !    (( 

    & 

!

( 0

 0

('

 0 &  

   ( (&     ( ( 

  

0 +

 !0

     ( ( &

 '!

&'&

& 0

;&( 0 !&

2  0      # 6 !

 &

!

0 ! 

@  6  

  ! 0

 > (  6 &

 

  0   2   &   !  !

&

 +@ 6  & 

   +

  + 0

 ( ! 

 

@ ## ;    '

 

 & 0  (!

!(

  

   ) ) #***

 )* )  

 + ,!

 -,  . / 

 

 

 

. ,!

 

    ' &   

  

3

& 

! #

    

 # 0

 ! 

!(

  &'

 

&( &

  & 0 

 0



 !  !(

    '

  

 ;    '



& (  #1 >



   

 !

! 0  & 

#:

 '   2 ( ' &    +

  +

 &'00 >  

 0- 

& /

'   !

  !  , !!

  !   (  !- 

/

     !   , !!

  ! 0   

 +

 +

  !     #7 ):

#**1    +

  !D 

 ( " 7*80  &

:

):

#**12  '  +

  ! 

    00  %    0    0 

  ! ! 6 )8 #* # 



        0  

  

 +  ? =   C



+ ?=    )9 #**:     !  6   )8 #* # 

 

 0    !  6    )1 #**1   &'

3 





(

!D '

 &'0 '

  0 

&' 

 +  

       1# )# #**7 0 &  !   

5 !    &  



+ ?=

! ! ! 



   





5 !0

  ' 2  <

    &   !  6   )7 #* #  ;

0  

 +  ? =  

      )* ):

#**7 



 (

     &  

 !+ ;  

 #7 >    6 #* #

& 0 

3

  6 ; 



  81 ;

  0

 0   6  81 ;

        1!+ "$  +$2)"3"4'  5"44# EB '     ('

<  





(

 ('



 (

   6  ! 0 ! E - /%      !

   

<  ( 5   6     &  !

 &' (        

&'  -&/% !

( 5   !

    !

 (   &       

 0 

&'!

 0 6 -/%  6   &  &' 0  (  0



 0( 

 !



<( 5  6 

(    !

6  

         (    

5 0 !

  !

  ( 5    !

     F

 0

 !

6 

 &  &

' (

0

&

  ( 

   (  &

'

#8 % 6 2 

(

! 0

' > (  ! 0    6  ;   

  0

&



+ ? = '

#**:    '   0



 6

   

! !



!

 60 

&

5   60 '

 0(

 ! < &' ! 

 '

#**: &



&'(     ( ;

   6 ( 

( &'(&



+  ?=

%

 !(

 

 

 &

 

    &  !

!

  

'(  A   (   '

<

   &' 6 &    &  

'   

&

     ! 

 

 &' 6 

 ( ' 0' 

#9 ( ' !(

      &

  ( '   &   



     

& 

        &

   &   



 . ,!

  

(

  0



' >     ; 0    >    !   

+

!

 & (

4 ( '      &

! 5

 !    0 

  ( < 0

 0 



 6 )7 #* # #    (

  &         



<

 < 0

( 6 .& ' &

 (  G   

 0  

   &' +

! &    

  

  

 

 .61 !     0  

 %      ' 2  

  ;

 0  '

&'.61 

&   '  (

0 



    6   )7 #* #      

 3          

 +

    ! !

 %   

  0   +

! &

 !0



   !(

'

   -B< .1/   5    '0  !!

;

( (

 +

 !0 



;

 +

! 

 0 

0  <   0&  ! 

%  

  +

!

 !0

  '0

'   (

  

 (



(  !  6   )7 #* # &'   

 &  !



#*  !' 2   0    

0  

  

 #  !



(

! ! ) ,!(

  

   ) ) #*** 

+,!

-, . /

0  !(

 

)* )))   &' 

 

 . ,!

 

 0 



! !(

   

 C

   

  

&     

'  '

('   (!

 !(

  

  ) #***

)* )))0  

&'+  

!

&'&

+& 0  # " !(

 &

  

  !'( 0   60"# "447 2)"48%   + '  6 

5



H " 6   & H "