High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/1535/2010allowed

Krishan Kumar Alias Kala And ORS. v. State Of Punjab

2019-08-22Mr. Justice Harnaresh Singh Gill7 pages

!"#$#% &' (!&)*'+&,!- (' #.## /' ) 0

)!12 .## 3 !-!

' !" 4'# ##4 )-5,6-7

'(3 !'# 4'##0#0),,'66 )!12#

(,,!5!(3' !3 ! (1)-5*! -- $## 3 - 28 ( ,'!- 0 ! )-56

)3!5'6 9('28 9(, - * !5 ( 33, ,- 28 ( 3 !' 6 ( 1)-5*!

!7 ! !- '-'

-- :##% 3 - 28 ( ,'!- 0)2 7 !, )- , 45 '6!!-3)'0(26( 2!)3(,-#(,'!-0)2 7 !, )- , 45 '6 !!-3)' 0(26 (-

)!- ( 3 !' 5),8)!-'0 !: !- !!

-(* )!-'5

'%* !( !- 38 !

#; (!-6 ! - ),

38*!

!6 )'(' )!-'5 *3, *3'

!*!

!* !(# (

(3'

!( !##6(

' 3'*! 3 - 7 '

&(' <

-6,,5,,8 )!&,9!)!5,!-6

'-!5,86!5( (8(-! ,,- =3 !(3(#(7,,5' 9'

>? , 1 !-69( !

'*-((8(- !)'-30!5(

=(9'0!5(9(((7 #(,,5 !5! ( 3 !' 9 (9(!(89' 33-(1 ! = 28 (

' 3'*! !- * ' -!

(7,,56(8 -((8(-2'

)5(- 9! (

=!-9'!

95 !5 ((13

!10!5(

0 * 0!5(6 9( 9

*3!8!5 (*6 '! 3 ' (&('<

-6

' ,,!5( *7,,5&('# '

*3,

!7 5 ! !- ! '8

'*, 6 (,,!9 3' !-5! (3 !' # ('5 9' '*-5! (

) -3 )!-'0 ! @%!-: #(

) -3,--!

5),8 !- ,*-',# ! '-' 3'

7 6 ( 3'

! (- A*!- *!8 B9! # !( *!'

'--)!-'0 !'# #6 (

) --!-( ('5 !-3,-- , *3, !# (,'!-', )'69(, C)!5(

) - 3

(

)!-'0 !@% 6

!7 -(* )!-' 0 ! : !- !

- 2 76 !!

- (*

'-!5,8#(33, ,-28(

) -3 !' 9 , - * -28(,'!-0 ! )-56 )3!5'# 0,, 55'7-6 ( 3 !' (7 3' ''- ( 3' !'7 !3 !# D'!-

)! ,

' ( 3 !' )2* ( ( ( )' 2, 9 (7 * '- !- * !'3'- ( 7-!

! '

'-6 ! *) ( ( !5'-! ,- - 9! !

>? 0 !: 9'!

7- !'

'-# )'('

!!- ( ! '-' ) ! ( !-!5

5), )!-' 0 ! : 6 ( 3),

- ( ! ,8 ' 7!5 !- '!!5 ( ,!3'

3'8 23'

)3,-9(( (9(, 7!5 !- '!!5 ) ( 3'

3'86 ( =!

9,-5

) ( 3'

3'8 2!5 ,! 3'

3'86

!- ! 3' -!# 97'6!(! ! 6,,( 3 ', =!5#0,,

)'('6 '5)-((''*',

!'- ! !( *!

(3'

! 9! # <(, ' ''!5 *!

<)'

(0!5(!-(

<)'10!5(6

!!--( 3'

'*'6(

) -3 !' (-6

! !5 ( 6 ')! 98 '

* ( 3 6 9('

'-!5 ( ,'6 (

) -3 !' 9' )5( 28 ( 3'

! ( !- (' '6 33'(!-- 28 ( 3 , # 97'6 ( ), 3 ! ! ( ! ! !- (( (-2!'5 '- !##69(' (

) -3 !' (- 2! '' - ! :##6 B## !- ### () 6 9(! (

, 9!

' -3'*!F

, G '

!'- !5 ( (' '5'-!5 ( 7'8 2

'*!, 3'

! ,)!

(- 5! ( 3 !'

) -6 !- ,',8 2, (- ((3'

2 -

*3,

!!- ' ),

-,2' ! !-

! ), ! # ! ( (' (!-6 ,'!- 0

)! ,6 9(, )33 '!5 ( 1)-5*! !- '-' 3 - 28 ( )' 2, 96 (

),- !

2 3'

7- ! '

'- 28 (

) -3 !' (('9 !8,,* 7 !(3'

>:? ( 3'

! , ,8 *3, (

) -3 !' #

('6 ! ( 2

', !- -

)*!'8 7-!

'-6

-3'

7- !'

'-((3 !' 9'5),8

(

)!-'0 !: #!

6(,'!-0

)! ,3'8

'- * ,

('7 !3 !# (7('-,'!-

)! ,

'(3' !-9( (' !

6(75 !('

)5(('

( # ! '-' 3'

7 6 ( 3'

! (- A*!- ,-7 0!5(6

' !5

' <6 )'1 0!5(6

' )'- <6 ,0!5(63)8 !5

<6 0 5! (6 '

('56

3'6 <: !- )'

(0!5(6

' )'- <# 3'( *!

( -9! 6(3 !' , !59( !'*,0!5( !-)'-30!5( * 9'- ( =3 #(3 9'(!-- 7' 0'3!

(&'*0!5(#'*,0!5(69( 9 '

**2,69 (!-- 7' (3 , 3'8# 3' <)'

( 0!5(6

' )'-6 ##%%% %# 3#*#6 ! !5 ( 6 ( 3 !' '! 98 '

* ( 3 !- ( 9

- 9 ('

9! 98 * - !

28 ( 3 !' !- ( )'- (- 2'

)5( ' '

* * 3'

! E( -- !

'**2' ( !*

( ' 9!'G !- 9

- 9 '! 3 '- ( )

0'3!

( &'* 0!5( !- ( * 9 =! ! !28(3 , ':-8 # ( * *6 <)'1 0!5(6

' )'- -( =3 (-2!! ,,-!5( !##%%% !-##!-(

)'3'

! 6!*,86 !10!5(

>? * 0!5(6 !1 0!5( + !6 &' (! &)*' !- )'-3 0!5(6(-2! !

*!5 '

*(1)!5, -#(8 - ( 9

- (- 2!

,, - !- '! 3 ' ( *6 (8 9'5 !5 (7( ,#(8- , -('!* ( = ## ( # (8 9' )5( !- ,' 33'(!--28(3 , #

,E*3,*!G) -

)!5 ('9

)!- '

*(3 !' !-9(!(8 9( 3'

! ( =3 6(8'!98 '

*( 3 # () 6 (

!'- ! ! ( *!

,9! 63 ! )(! 6(3 !' 9'!

)5( 9( ( 9

- !

' !8

, ) -

)!5 ( ' 6 9 '

7'- '

* (*# ( ,,5- '

7'8 9 *- !5( ! ##%%%;## 9(' ( 9 '5 '-

!### !-3!-!9! 6(-2!3'

-) -28( 3'

!# 0! =( 0!5(6 ,,5- 89! 6 (- !

2! 3'

-) -#9 (* ! '89! #=(9'0!5( (- !

2! 3'

-) - 2!5 9 7'# ,, ( 9! 3'

-) - 28 ( 3'

! 9' (

, 9! !-6 (8

!''--

'! ' # )'-3 0!5( 9 ,,5- 2 ! 038

=(( !-9 C) !-( =3 , !59( ( 3 !' # 0- )'-3 0!5( 9 !

-) - 9! 28(3'

'(' ! 2 =!

9 (*# )'-3 0!5( 9 )** !- )!-' 0 ! % '# ## 7-

'-'--#%#28(', )'#( )** !!5 '-' 9 -28(5( )' ! $##B !(5'

)!-

>B? ()'-30!5((-1)

*3!-(3 ( (8

),-2 )5(# !(3' ! 63 !' #&' (!&)*' 9 '' - !:##63 !' # !10!5(+ ! 9 3'

-) - 28 0 (! 0!5(6 !

( !- 9 6 () 6 '' -

!B##!-3 !' # !10!5(

0 *0!5( 9 3'

-) -28 50!5(6 !

(!-9 6() 6'' - ### ( 3 !' 9'

!7 - )!-' 0 ! : # 3' 0 ! : 6 9( 7'6 - ( ! ,8 ' 7 '! !8 ,!3'

3'86=!

9!5 '(7!5' ! 2,7 ( * 2 ,! 3'

3'86 (,, 2 3)! (- 9( *3'

!*!

('- '3

''*9( (*8A!- ('8' 6 '9( !6 '9(2 (# ! ( 3' ! 6 !(' ( 3 !' (- 7- ( ,! 3'

3'8 !

' (- (8 '!- ( *#

('6 ( 3 !' 9' 33- ( *38 (!--#(,,5-9

-9 !

9((*# ( ,!9

- 9 =-!(( )

&'*0!5(60'3!

(6( )5( (7 2! A*!- '! ( ') ), 3 !# 97'6((-!

2!3'

-) - 3'

!9! # ! '-' 2'!5( *(5),8)!-'0 !: 62 ((!5'-! ##' 7!5!-'!!5( ,! 3'

3'86 *)

A 6 !*,86 (

) - *) ' 7 '! ( ,! 3'

3'8 !-

!-,86 ( *) (7 ( =!

9,-5 ' ' ! 2,7 ( ( 3'

3'8 ,! 3'

3'869(!(*!!5

0 !: #(A3'

>@? H' 7 ' '! F 3 ), ! ), !-

! ') 7 !#0) ( 3), ! ' ,',8, =!5!(3' !

!-6() 6( !-!5

5),'

'--28( )' 2, 9 !

!2,# 7!)'-30!5(69( 9 ! 038 = (3 ) !5( !- !

'*'5'-!5( *6 (- !

2! 3'

-) -# ('6 ( 9 )** !- )!-' 0 !%'# ##!-( )** !!5 '-'6 !

-2 76 9 -28(5( )'# ( )' 2, 9(7* '-(7-!

((

7'8 9 *- ( ! !

( 3 !' # A# 6 ( )5( ( 9 ('

7'868( *(-!

2! 5!-28 (3 !' !

'('9 !8-7 2, (!=-8 # () 6 ) (-

)*!

),-!

(72!',-28( )' 2, 9# ! 79

( 2 76 ( *3)5!- 1)-5*! !-

'-' 3 - 28 ( )' 2, 9 ' !

) !2,# !

6 ( * ' -# ( 3 !' '6

'-!5,86 C)-

( ('5 '*-5! (*# ,, 9-!(2 7'* #

! #$#% - <(('03=!5; !-" ; <((' 3 '2," ;