High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/25498/2021allowed

Pankaj v. State Of Punjab

2022-06-14Mr. Justice Jasjit Singh Bedi38 pages

!"#$# %& '('

%) *

! ,%* -

& ./ ' +++

!" #$ %%% ++0'

& '()** "$" +, -./00/11.0.0

...2.3.) - " * &$ 4 " 4

,&,*4 $ 1002 ,

# 4 $ "

""5 $" "

$" 4 " $ $60367'1084

$ 6 4

" $

"45 $"

4 $"$" 1100 94 " * +,

:$ 9 +, -./0 0/11.0.0 ...2.3.) - $

* 1

4 "" 4 $

$ $60367'1084 " $4

" ;4 ""

4& "$ ,

<& $

" $"

"" 4 5 $" = : $

" #

.000 10$" .0000 5 $" &"> ""$"" "1004

" 5 $" 4

"$ ?""

" 4 ">""#

?<#6 $ 4

&* " "

$ @ "" '. - $ "- 4

43. 4 4

4 = @ " $ $

& " 4 ""

4 " $ 4 " 4 4

" " $ #$

" "

/11.0.0 .(

$ 5" " "

" $" 4

( & * " " " #

#$$"

()*

+, +!", - &

.+ , +!",

+, +!", -

.+, +!", -

+, +!", - 5((

+ , !

'. - 2 > " 4 ""

"9 $ " "

2(+#, 0 0 #

( 6$'

+ , ..- 8(

7(:

- :

;(

7(:

. +43, &'

- ( 2*""

7< 4 9

#// +, . - 2 2"!

+, +!", ( 9(

7(:

+, +!", &* " " $ 5 $" "" 4

"$ $ 4 " '.4 " $ > " "

# * 7$$"

7(:

" #$$"

= &'

4 $

$ "

" '. - >

$ $

" $" ,"* " $ "

4 "$

'. -

$"4 A'

9 %'

&( 7 '

(: ' #'

" !

' %#

! #

!! !

(

)

* !

! #

# !

(

) *

# # !!

+ 7 *

:"*

' <

( '

< (

$$ (

'"!

- ! ' (' :("- * '

$"'

! : < (

(

:" ,

& >B$"

> * 5 '. " #

$"4 &>B$"

*%34+#%567$'+

% 4#9#% :;;

: '

!"#33 %''

A ! ./0 112,&34

5 '

$4'

7(8"%

' 9

9 #

7( ! = 4

! 7

? @ ' 1>A

@' = ,&A$ :'

D '(

! !

6 !

# '

$ 9

$ ;"

+, +!", >

+, '

#$?

0(! +#0, . > +

# '

AAA A2

: (

&""-

" ("

- <* ($$

( :"

< $

(

(@ A?:

7# :

! : *

< (

!$"' <

$ *

(:! ! :

@( . , #

E !

+ B

8" ? $!7 #

7 #

@ $ 8"

' %#

! #

!! !

* !

! #

# !

# # !!

B #

* $ * $($$

( C

:"*

$ "

) <"

! '* :

! $ " '

(

$ '

(: '- ("

) <

! < ?'$

(

+,- <*- <' '""

(- <* ' '"

) < < ""

< 6 ;"

D '-

(

$ *

+, !

$ * :

(

!+ B4

(

+ E <

& '

! !!

! #

(

! # #

E (

, &!

(

& '

E !

# '

( !

(

E #

//B

!$"' <

$ * (:'

+ , +,

!$!:" :(

" !$"' < '

?$"

" '- <*- : ( ' E *

(

7E.

;("$ '""

' ?!

$$ '

(

! '* :

( /)<- 7E &7

(

" < :

(

' 6$'

;("$

- '"

: !$" !$"'

$ *

<' *

3 @

&' #

. :

$ 9

# #

# '

# !

$ 9

.A #

# F

,&3 ! !

; ) * & ( %! 2

+, +!", .=>

+, '

#$?

0(! +#0, > +

&>B$"

* ()*

+, +!", " A

! !

4 #

# '

! ./!

! #

3 !

! 4 #

?@' 9 $

"""

$ '( (' """

'(:" 9 '

!$"'-

(

(: "

!$"' < ("

(

' 9

< $($

$ *

<' ' : "

> +,

$ * <'

(

: ( !$" '

" F +:, !$"'

(

' (" :

< *

$ :"

$ '

* 4'

: '

$ * ") = <'

!$ <

' !

!$"

< 9

! ?

< (" !!C

$($

%&7 #'

$ *

$ '

* * <'

(

( '!"

($('

)

" !$"'

$ 9 "" ( < !

$ *

%&7 #'

$ "

(

+($, 9(-

$$"

''( E ''

(

<""

(

'@(

''(

' (

%&7 #'

E '

''(

< -

' 2

< $

"- <

(

"' '

( $$ $ ('

!$"

$ *

%&7 #'

$$ $

* (' '@(

" !$"'

$ *

: !

'(!:

(

* *

!$"

( (: ' $

' <

"< :

(

+($, &>B$"

* &

.+ , +!", " AA

6 $ 6#

! #

! ?@'

! 3

?@'

$ 9

$ #

# ;"

+, +!", >

+, '

#$?

0(! +#0, . > +

+ B4

(

+ E

' &

! !!

! #

(

! # #

E (

, &!

(

E !

# 9

# '!

# ,

( !

(

E #

//B 2 9

# #

?@' !

' 6

' '

@ '

# ?@'

(

# !

?@'

?@'-

# &

@ '

6 $ > ,

# ?@'

' #

! #

/3///

+ B34

(

' !

! =47 8"9G

AA ! 8"9

# =47

0 C >A !

' E

A2 B # $("

7$ .

* *"

!! "

(

'- "' - 7$ -

! $ - <' < (:@( "

$ '

"'- 7$

! -

' ($

'- <

+ '$

! , #''

" ("

$ '

! $

'- '

!$"'

'( $('

$$"" -

- (" '"!

(

9 " @(

(

$$"- <

! $ -

$ " : ':

- " -

!!('

! $

"'- 7$

< (" (

* !$"'

$ * '

%&7 #'

* *

(

(:! *'

" ("

$ - <

! '

+ ,

%&7 #'

- @(

< -

" $

! - " -

!!('

' $ '

$ '( $(" (

$ *

7 '( (:'

%&7 #'

$ *

$ "

" $'""

!$ < :

! ( <

$ <

:"*

* !!

' $(:" ( $ 6 (:'

(

!" $($ :

&$ !

A?'- %'

'- (

!- *( 6 ""'- ' (:'

+ ,

%&7 #'

" <-

!$ <

! * :

$ - (" '"

)

< < - <

:"*

$ "

) <"-

' ( $ 6 * : !!

! " <' !

( *'

' '" :("- ' ! '

(

'- < (

: < ( (

< (

:" 9

$ $ '(

' :

* ?'"(*

!$"'

- < ("

!$"'

''(! ' !$" ( '

%&7 #'

$ '( !$"

<""

< $ " -

! $ :

(

D ' +($,

! <""

: (!- !"

:'(

(

' '

! $ - <' < "

$ '

"'- !$"' <

$ *

7 '(

* *<

$ :"

(

''$

(:!

" ("

$ -

! $

(

'- "' - 7$

!!('

"'- 7$

< (" ( (

!$"'

%&7 #'

- <

%&7 #'

!$" <

""-

* ' 9( *<- '"( +, '

D ' +($,- < ("

(""

$$"

''(! '

'- < "

$ - :(

!$ !

''($$""

& 4 ''

" 9 $$"

< & >B$"

+, +!", " A3

A//<H !

9 (

'""

: <

)

(

<""

(

( E *

:"*

E !!

!E ! (

6 (' !

( -

:"*

' <

( '

< (

$$ (

'"!

*' +<'-

'- < (" * ("

*',- $ $ *

+ ,

%&7 #'

- (" * ('

<""

(

:" +, @(

(

: !!('

!! ($

< * <

( 6

$ '( 9

(

!!('

!! ($ #

:* :

( 2' ;"

+($,-

!$"'

@(!

(:'

+ , +,

!$!:"

<*- " !$"' < '

?$" :

(

" <""

: ''$ :" !$"'

!$"'

%&7 #'

(

$ 9 !$(

'""

&>B$"

.+, +!", " A. ,'

(

E !! 8"&A

$ <

8" 8"E

!! 6 $ !

!$"'

+ , $ * - <' :

( :

(

: * + , '

(

' ' '

(

' : < ( (

< (

( 9 '! '

: ! : < (

( -

< (" : ' ("

:"*

' <

( '

< (

$$ (

<' (

: '

(

!$" :

$ *

(:'

+ ,

(:'

< * '

(

' <

$ '

(

' $$ 7&

! < '

@( :

$ *

(:'

+ ,- '

(

< 9 (

*' !

:* + C

"11$ 4 $

$ $"$ $

# $> .''023 '.D1E $ 4$ > "

'.D1E $"$ '.D.E $

"$$ 4

" '.D1E '.D.E

$" $

C > E

8"& 8"&7 !

' 6 <

E ' 6 <

# '

E$ @

< 7 #

# C!!

? 6 //>7$7$ ! +//>'$$ .2/

. "

+ C1' '( " '. &

D1E '.$ "4"

" 4 $

$" " , '( $ 5 '.

9 $ " "4 4

$" $4 "4 "

$ "

9 "

" 182 * *" 4 "

4 " ""

$ $

$ 4

"" C

' < ' :

* :

- '- '

!$"'

+ , $ *

+, ("

$('

''( 9 (

'' " (!:

@('

!$"'

$ *

+ , +,- <

* (

* !$"'

' :

' !

(

7(:

* 2":

+ , +!", =.

> + , 6

* : '

(

'@(

''(

(

' < ('

< (

$ *

%&7 #'

$ * '!

( -

$ *

$ 6

< < $$ > C/6 " $"$"

* , $

4 '1 '.< '. 4

'14"" 4 @ $4

$" "4" $ 44

* , $

" 4

" $ " " <

$" 4 $$ 4

" "

$" $ D.E /1))0 *F7'1'D"E '.

" 44

4 4

$" "" 4

C /

+ C.2&9 $ 9 " $ " & 4

4 ""4 D1E , "

" -

**4

20 - 4 "$ " 49 4 " ,

4 4 " 4

4 "

4 - ,

$ 4

4 "

- D.E < '1D1E" 4

$" * , 4 $"

$ " $ "

" ;

$ 4 4

4 "$"""F4 "

'1D.E'.D1E - ,

- $

4 "$""" D.6E < '1D.E" 4

4 "

D.*E < '.D1E 4

$ "

" $ 446 $"

"4"

* , $

" $ " 4 4$4

" $" 6 '.D1E

$" & 5 4 "

" D(E < '.D.E

4 4

'.D1E " 4

, " "

& 5 6 " 44 4 $ 5 " 4"" $ D'E , "

$ C 4C

** "

" " 4 B

100 182 ** "

4 "" " D'6E , 4

'1D.E 4 "$

**" 100182 ** " 4

4 " $"""4 " " &

$$$

D2E : 4

4" '1D.E '.

" " 4 20$

" $ 9 ""$

$ !@:

9 "

!@:

4 " " 20 4

4 "

" $ 4

4 "$9

D8E & 2.234 "4

'1''$ " ,

" " "" $5 4 #

4""$

4"" C

'C'J! ' I

#E ' < %:

# ?@'

9 '

# ( 2'

(

7(:

* 2"* -

+, +!", > + , .

$ *

%&7 #'

" (!

( 9 ( 2'

" (! 2": D '

( $$ *"

0( 2' G!

* 9

+($, '

< (') :

0( 2'

!'"

7 * 7

.+, +!", = > + ., = 9 ( 2' $$ *

(

2": D '

(

' ( '

($'

< " :

( 2'

' ('

* "

< ("

""'

'" ($'

''( E

(

!$"'

( <

!$"'

. 9 7! #' < 5

//7$7 $ ! .>A + // '$$ 1 $

A/4 #

A/4

$ 9

' : #9 #'

# '

! &!

A 3+ C2 , "

4" D;1E 4

4 "4

$ D.E

'. "" 20 $ "4

$ 44$

!@:

8 ;

D.E '. 204

"4$

4 $" ,4 "

""4 "$ C 4

$ 9

$ 5

#' 6 //1A7$7 $ ! AA+//17

703.>+//1 >'$$A.1

# '

A/E $ 9

E (

+ CD1E, 74

!C #'

%: ///7$7$ ! 3+///'$$A. 7 6 * " " '. -

$ 1)/2 D C- CE "

4 4 4

4 "

, ':

!#' 5

//.7$7$ ! >/>+//3'$$314 4 "

$ 7 6 4 " '.4

$ " " 4

D.E ,4 "

" $" '.

@ 4 4 @

4 " $ * 6 "

D(E & $# - "

"" 4""

$ *" "-

G5 4 4

4 4 4 $4

$" "

"44 $ " $"5 "C #

" (! -

( 2' '!

'"(

!$"'

@(!

!$!:" < " !$"' <

?$" <""

: ''$ :" !$"'

9 ( 2'

' $$ 9 $

' <

!$"'

+ , $ *

* (! :

(: "

!$"'

+ , $ * #

:* :

*- :

' <

: ('

!$"

$ *

(- '"(

(

!$"'

+ , +, < $ *

(

&>B$"

* 2

+, +!", " A E #

# #

E 7

) E "

# !

B B

. ?@'<

$ 0

: '

. ?@' !

?@'

!$"'

@(!

%&7 #'

9 '

(

< 0 " - : "( "

!$"'

!$!:" 9

" ( "

'"( < :

(

!$"'

' : ''$ &>B$"6$ >* 5((

+ , !

" AA ?

? @ '

! ,3

'@< !

# E '@< ,3

! '

) $!

! ' @ ?A 1=

1138" ?>

/ 4

' ' ' &@# <

'@< 4

) %7,3

) $!

' < $ @

5 F

) $!

E !

? @ ' !

3 ? @ '

! #

! '

' : #9 '

11.'$$11+11$ F0.2/ = 9(

'- "

)

"- - <

' '-

$($

+ ,

&( 7 '

(: ' #'

- < &74- )-

< "' 6$'

- 7E.

( - '""

!$"'

&74- ) <

?! < :

$ '( B( - "

($ - !" - 7 < *

" #''

7E.-

! < $$

)$ -

$$-

$ (' :

$ '(

) <

A?:

( '

! < < *

($ -

(' < :

$ (' 9 * '(! -

&74 ) < " <

$ "' $

$$""

" 7E.

!! ($ - !" - 7- <

* :

"$ - $

7E.- < - $ A?:

( < $ (' 6

: '

!$"' :

(:'

+, (:'

+ ,

&( 7 '

(: ' #'

'- A?:

: $

< !$"'

+ ,

&( 7 '

(: ' #'

'(!

< $ (

$ "' $

!$" :

+ ,

&( 7 '

(: ' #'

*" - (!

! < * :

(

$$""

"" '

(

' < 7E.-

* (" - < @(

:"* < @(

&( 7 '

(: ' #'

- 7E.

* '"!

< ('

! < * #''

7E.- &74

" !

(

7- <'

"$ 4

- <

(: '

" # "

7(:"'

7 '(

! < *

7E.

&74 )-

''(! '

< '

!$"

&( 7 '

(: ' #'

: (: "

!$"'

&( 7 '

(: ' #'

&( # 7 '

(: ' #'

$ *

$ "

( (: ' #

* !

* :(

$ * :

'- ' ( $ * <'

:* '

" 9

$ * !)

' !

! - (" ('

< "

<" '

(

' $ * (

$ *

+ ,-

@( " -

!$"

@(!

$ '( '

- *

" + 2": D ' + /0 = , +($, >

5! #' :% 111'$$$ 21+11A$ F0/2

# (

(

? @ '

E @# 9

$ F! 9:

#' C 112$ F0A.

? @ ' !

(

" 6 *<

(

'"( :

(

!$"'

&( 7 '

(: ' #'

$$""

* @( " -

$$""

*<- < '

< "

$$"" -

< !

' 6 ' $

! ""

: (

&>B$"

$"4 - $ "44 "

$ #

$"4 &>B$"

* + 4#* %,<= % %#> % %#%4'7$'+

64 ,56%$;"

4 ! :#"< =+(( " K3 E

# 6 #

5 !4

# = !

12//.

E ' (

$ * =

%&7 #'

< "

' (

' < :

$$""

" =

$$"'

$$"" -

< ""-

< ( * "

%&7 #'

!$(

(

"" * "

(' * "

9 !$"'

<' (" *

(

$$"' 4

! #

7A//// #

8$G?@' C

+ E

(

' E! ?,

$ * E

# :

@ $ C

! . E

> E '

1 , #

& * 8(

7(:

+& K $!

# '

?@'< !

! #

.2 ?@'

.2 $

H H

(

! # '

?@'

=47 # !

$ !!

L & * :

;(

7(:

. +43, &'

" = -

" ("-

- !

!- :

#6 * &- (:!

$ '( ' - ($ $

! $'

$! '-

(

$ '

(: '+, 9

- !$ *

$!$

(

:'! '

'- $'"" - <

( '"

( - :

" ("-

$! :'!

(!- - ( - - (-

' <

(

" '- <($

< (" :'

! *"- - "

(: '- < (" :

<*- $$ "

$$ (

' < :'!

$ "'

'" '-

" ' 2

! -

(

$ "'

'" '-

$ '

*""

$! '- :(

!$ * (

(

:'! '

$ "'

'" '-

! : (!-

( C

' < -

" '- '

: * ")"

''(

$$ (

(

$ '

(: '+,- :'

<*- * $'

* !$ * (

' - ?'$

' < - :'

" '-

" ("

(:! -

(

! ('

!$" < - :

$ "'

'" ' 6 @('-

- - ! ($

$! '- - "

* -

- :'!

$(('

- $!

: '"(

: * - !(' - :'

(

$ * !:

%&7 #'

- $ * <

!$"'

/ $ (

!: 6 #

! 7A////G&

$ G$

0 C G@C

&>B$"6$ >*

*,6 ?:

@ 4 4$'7$'6+

! $6 // <4#=( "

A. ' 9 G ' '

' 9 !

?@'6 !=47

(

?@'

6 ! &!

F +

$ 9

6 !$

' % !

?@'

! >///

# E

AG/ !

?@'6

!! $

6 #

C : % : A ?@'

(

?@' !

! 2 3 4

! E

! ! '

?@'

2 '

(

?@'

?@'F

' 9

;( * 9

+2"

#$$"' %

. $ 7: !5

(

$ 4

+ B1 !

# ?9 ' E =47

4@#

6 #

! '

J !

?@'E #

?@'B > E

# $

?@' E

' 9 ! !

+!"

#$$"

+ B 0

4 #

# A.

# !

# + B ,'

(

!! 8"&A

$ <

8"& 8"&E

!! 6 $ !

B / 9'

(

)

AG 4 #

! #

?@'

(

! E

+ B.A

(

+ E

' & -

! !!

! #

! !

(

! # #

E (

, &!

(

& '

E !

# 9

# '!

( !

(

E #

1 //B

* " !$"' !$"

($ :

(

! '* 6

- '

!$"'

+ , +,-

$ :"

''( # "

2( +#, 0 " 0 #

( 6$'

"'F

#6 +E, = -

!$"' ' :

$$"'

:" 6

$$"' "

: "

:" '

$+ <7@87 4

7 7A////G& #

$ !

?A2 /

?@'

' @ 0 444 E

# !

&>B$" ">* 2 2"!

+, +!", " A 9 ( $ * (

(

$ ' <

'( "

< *<

*' *

(' ' * $(!

$ * (

! $

""'

( '

(: ' 7 "

' ' '"

- '

( $ *

:* '($("

(" # $ '( :

! '

' :" * "

"< :

$ :"

"< '

- (

:" $ '( # " :

#$?

( -

$(! -

)

(

( $ * ( '($("

< 6

:" "

:* (

(

( * :

< :

' 9 ('

* :" ! "

' $

(

< '""

< * ( :

' '

!$ <

" ("

$ ('

(' ! "-

(

$ '(" "

: :

( 6

$$"' <

' @( !$"' (

9 @( <

( (" ( :"

' C(

! "#$

( '

& & & & )&

' ) &

* & &

& &

' &

&& & * ( ' ' '

= 9 $$"' * : '(

! "

($'

* C(

$ *

* : :" "

* " -

(

<""

: ( '

(:!

(

(- :"

' : ' * "* !!'"

(

:" (

:"*

''(

")"

' <"

'(!(" *

* 9 ?$ ( =+ ,+:,+,

I :" (I <' ?$ ! !

' (

(: "

$ ::" '(

:"*

''(

:" :"

!$"

( $

? '

''(! ' (

!"*

(

''(

' '

"! $($ ""

''(

(

'"" ($

:" (

:"*

''(

(

? '

(' (

$($ -

(

$ (' (!

'@(

9 (

''(

")"

(" "

! ! "

(' '"( J * ) ; +($,K

'- <

:("

( * " < !$(

!" :'-

< (" ("

( '

!$"'

: "

)

< (" ("

( '

$$"'

: '(

!$" 9 ( D '

(:'

+:,+,

%&7 #'

:" (

:"*

''(

= ('

'"(

:" (

:"*

''(

: *

'"(

"- -

(

9 (

$ :" :

$ $

< :" ( ?

:"*

''(

'"( 6

< -

! " <

(

:" (

:"*

''(

(

<""

: (

) "

* (

' '

% <

@( <

(

<""

: ( "

$$"'

")"

' <"

:" 9 $ '(

$$"' $ < '!"

* "* !"

' " ' !

C( :

$ *

$$"'

" ' :

' '

:( -

"! $($

$$"' -

(

:" (

:"*

$$"'

")"

' <"

:" "

)

( -

:" $ :"

$$"'

" * ""

- !

$$"' ' : "

'"(-

! '"

:* !

"! $($

$$"'

$ ?$ :

* ""

! (

" ( ' ' ) +,!!!!!-.+)' / ' ' /&

) *

0 1E &

" ""

$ , :

"" $4)11 "" " "4 " .E & "" "

H "" 4 (E & ""

4" $" 'E &

" """,4

"" $ &"* 44H, "

9 "

" ""$"$

" $ * # # # : $

& * ( 9(

7(:

+, +!", "

A E

.1 $ $

=47?3 //./

3 >A ?@' '9@ C #

" !

< 1/1/

+& BF

=47?@'

# 6 #

# '

A/ #

A/ 7 .// @

B .

2( 0 0

( 6$'

"' $ +

$ # !

7(:

+ , 7/

= 9

$ '

A/ !

# %

=47 !

# '

6 :

E #

# %

'4@ '

! A !

$ G@C 3 <

" '. - "4

4 " 44"" " 4

$"444 " " '.

"$"

,4 $

(3 - $" $" "

4 ""

4"$" "

> 4

""4

%) * $ $" $"

" *7=

( & ""

$ " "" "

" 4 "

2 , "

" 4"$"4 "$"$

" "" $"

&$ "

" "* ""#

<++= ,% 0 E $)H 5H%

E $ :" 5H%