The New India Assurance Company Ltd v. Palwinder Kaur And ORS
!
"#!
!
"#!
$%&'%#%("%) *!
! * $%&' (& &+ ,%-% $).!
/! * 01& % & )!
/! * Whether only the operative part of the judgment is pronounced? No Whether full judgment is pronounced?
Yes ) 2 34! 44 4
! " # $ %&'&()&*&& # &$ %&+'()&*&&
,! " # -'$ %&'&()&*&& # -'$ %&+'()&*&&
! " # .$ %&'&()&*&& # -$ %&+'()&*&& 4 4 ! - / ! 0"! 0 #01
223 2! " #2
*+*4&*&&
01 2 5 0 !
, 2 # -66# !-7++# !8 0 9! 01 2 2 #
-.!46!6(4:) ;7< 2
2 1 0 12 2 & 5 !$ %)&'&()&*&&! 0 #
01 )
2 1 *+*4&*&&
01 2 5 0 !
, ! 01 2#01 -': 2 )
2 1 0 1 2 2 # -.!46!6(4:) ;7< 2 4 5 ! $ %)&+'()&*&&! 0 #
01 : 2 *+*4&*&&
01 2 5 0 !
, -66# !-7++!# 2#2 !
2 # -.!46!6(4:) ;7< 2! # # = !
&&-&&*-+ FACTS NOT IN DISPUTE ' / ## # 2 &&-&&*-+!
= 2 # 2" 5 # >
! " 2 )10 ?'*)
)7'.(! 2
# # 0 " ##
0 .** !
# #
#@
0 3 !2 2## 0
?'-)?)&744! 0 "01 - " 1#
2 ! 2# 2 #
!$ # % ## != # 2 )1 2# # !0 ! ##
, 2 )1 # 2 #
/
!
#!= # 2 ) 1
2
"
3
"
" # 01 # !3
= # 1
? ! ! ! 2) 1A 201
!
! #
@!
! !
!0 !
20 3
-.*'&*-75 2 2 "$&.. *.*'&*-7! &(7B4*') ! -! !
!> . C# 2! 2 # 2#2 6 $ 2
# !#
# 201 5 0 )
!
"
#$%&#&'(()*++ , - - - - )*++ (
-
. / .-
" . . - ) *+$&( %$ 0 (
# ,
"
! 5 0 2 2 ?" ! )
2 1 0 12 ?!
2 1 #
0 $ %&'&()&*&& D 2#2 0 5 2
" #
$ %&+'()&*&& , 2#2 2 01 5 0 ?! SUBMISSION OF LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE PARTIES. + # E
2 1 $ % &'&()&*&& 1#-*' 1 $$
!
A
0 3
!
! #
# ?#
5 0 #
2?! # 0 7 ! # 2 : $ % &+'()&*&& 5 0 1
2 1 0 12 ?#
2
01 5 0 " 0 5 # ! 0 2 0 ?#
$ %&'&()&*&
2 10 2
-* " #
# -- /# #
! " " # !
) ",12 3
- " 445 % 6 7
3 '
-"
!
"
#$%&#&'((".
8 -
"
, !- .9 7+ $ 5
' 3
!
- : ;& 8 - . &
-
< -#=" 3>! * , !- .9 76
.
/ *
8 " " -
;
/ .
-
-
?,$ '@@%
-
/
- -
:'A(%&3 ,
+ !
B /
.?,$
-
B /
.-- -
8 -
+
6 7
3
C "
#
8 -
0 (, -+ D .
".
.
2>+A3 -
-
?,$2>+
-
". -
-
.
C
* !
"
#$%&#&'((+
.?,$ @@ @%' :'5(%& 3,+! +
3 E
D 2>+
. :(! +!
?,$
@@ @%'
:'
5(%&3,+! 2>+ .
".
2>+( . -
:'5(%&3,+! 2>+% .
-- 2>+@ .- -
2>+4 !
-- . *+E!
5E 5? & !
2>+'2>+
. % 8 "
". &
- " .-
-
" -
.
, -
.
-
?,$ .
- <
-. - -
>
. ?,$ - -"
- ,
-
" " -
- & .
-
"
- -" -> - - -++ ?,$2>+ " "> . - -
". -
" -
C
- .
. >
. " .
" "
&> - " . -
".#="3> !
, F
!+
F
F
+ 7#
F '''/!
! !
/!&
. ">- -
"
0 @, ".
?,$2>+ @%' . " %- ?,$
?,$
" -
4*
&
- .
?,$2>+
- - "
" > - /
" -- -
. ?,$2>+ " "
-+ D " .
C
. ?,$ " "
:3 ?,$2>+
.
-
-
"
, *
!.# D
-
.
-
<
". -
- -
-" - -8 -
.
C " -
-- 8 . @%' + D
E 8
-
- "
?,$ " , -
-
- -+
-<D
.
> .
"
!-- +G, !
". !.# D - "
.3 - . "
-
- - @%'
<
". -
# 2>+
.- - "- @%',?,$2>+ 2>+ "
. ". -
- - - -
C ".
.
-.,
- .
?,$ "
.>
-
8 !
".#H"3> !
$
7F
.
/3> ! -/!:(
?,$ (-
#H" 3>! ?,$
-
-
. - "
- "
" - ,
. ( - ?,$
.
>
".
-
-
0 ,
?,$2>+ "(I-
.
?,$ "
.>
". &
-
- - -
-
-
3 - -2>$ - -
.
('2>$(
". &
- .
" " '6 -
"
"
.&3 C
-
$
"
/%9
$ '(/!
#="3>! 6 7
3 '
& 44 4 J6
"
"
.& 3 C
-
0 3 - - " ". ".
$
"
4/($!$/!
/+5#
#="+< " # .
# ! 6 7
3 '
44&3
&, -
7
&, - &
" ".
,
"
- &
"
8
"
+< "9 $ 7 !,7/''(& '
#="# ! 6 7
3 /,7'(' &3& &E
"
&+ - &
(6 ?,$2>+
:( ! +!
- :'5(%&3,+! 2>+
2>+(
" -
- :'5(%&3,+!2>+%
! 63 F
< 9 E6 3 /D
".
--
2>+@ " ".
.
@%' <
". -
C
!
"
#$%&#&'(( % 8
-. + - + D -
"
!
"
#$%&#&'((
C
" 3
.
F -&
# #
01 0
#
" "0 -4 5 5 0 2
1
2 1 " " 0 5 21 # G)- 2
!1)
! 2 , 0 ? ! 2 1" $HA-!
# -(4 ! HA&! )2 2 HA . 2 ! 1 0 2 # 5
! 1 " !#
0A " "! 01" "
# !
5 0 1 D
" ### "01 ) " ### " -' 5 5 0 1 03
1 #$ 0
1 1 #$ # 2 !
# 2 # 1A ! 5 0 1 A #
01 2 3
2 ## 2 2 !
15 -. $
! 5 0
1 # # D 2 2
0# 2 5 0 " 01 # # 0 0 01
#" 0 2 5 5 0 1 2 "
# 1
0
01 0 ! # # 0 0 !
# ) " ### " -6
1!
# # 21 ) #
01 5 0 ! 2 01 ## 2 -(
" # # 2 : 2 ! 2 # , 2 43 37 4 -+ ?90
2
# Sarla Verma Vs. Delhi Transport Corporation and Another 8
.*4+0(%-%&+($ #%#9!
2#2 "
# 2
) I308 -
"-
>
"
!
.
#
"C
!
-
>
"&
/A( -" - .
--" ( & /A% -" - .--" %4 & /A@ -"
- .--" > > 31 "
-
,
"
- . @K
> "
- "
- -2 "
. -
-
" / " ."
.? "<
. .
-
"
- "
, "
. " "
"
. " -
"
/ 328
". " .
- "
" @K "
>"
@K " - .# - . "
-
- -" . & "
>- ."
&
" - .
" &
* * * * * * 42. - " " - !-/% " " / ". .
-- 8- L 8 !
!
- / @ @ . ". .
. 6&: 4 (. 6&4 ((@. 6&@ (4%. 6&% %%@. 6&( %4@. ". .
. 6& @@@. 6&' @44 . 6&: 44@. 6&@ 44:. -7 ?90
2
#National Insurance Company Ltd. Vs. Pranay Sethi & Ors. 8 *4*
9 #
-66!-64) -6+# !-7++!#
) > #
" A 2 J /
#2 # J
# 0 # 1 2 J > 0 #
" ! 21!
# !
# 2 # A ! J H $
# #
# ##
2 30J #)21 #A 1 5 " #3 2
) I52. 3 conventional heads
> $ <M, $@
> $
- $
- 8
- > 8$ < E
- -8
.
"
- "
"
"
"
1 - -
"C 3.C
-
" 8
"
> "
- .
"
8
-
"
-8 " -"
* " > -
.
- - -"
" --
. .
C
". "
."
8
6 -. > "-,- "
-.
- > " $@ $% $@
. 8
"
F
"
&
C -&
"
-
C " "
.
. - " K
.
"
"
.
N N N N N 59.3 - -
@K
. -
- <" " %. "-
8
"(K " %@. ,
" @4.
"@K3 . "
. > 59.4,
&-. / > .
%K " - "
" %. 3
@K " %@. K "
@4. "
.
* - - 8 " - -
-- > - 59.5? - -
> " "
".
(( 7 - O
" 59.6. 8 - "
" 7 - P
% < - 59.78 ""
.
- 59.8$ "
-. - > "$ @ $% $@
.8
- " K . . 0 &* ?90
2
# :- % %( 1 #+( ,% &-0 ;3<-<$% =#! + - 1< #>+>(+ -$>%(#8 4 / 9 # 4 (1 =%(- #+0( ( ;4%$><4+0(
2 "
# 2
) 213! F ! + . M
- "
*
-, Q -Q -
-
- Q -Q Q
-Q Q
-Q8 - - .
-
- . > Spousal consortium .
"
&
-
Q - .
.
.
< Q Parental consortium - Q
.
Q ( Filial consortium
-
3
. - . 8
. - !
-
- . 22! -
- -
"
6 <
&
= - > -
-
6 <
- "
- - 8 -
-
-
2386 7
3 "
-
- -
-,
-
-
"
-
-+ -
-
3 3
# !
- #
.
- "
- 248 - - "
- " ".
- Q -Q
+ . M,
-
-$%
- &-
# # )
2 1 5 0 2 )# # ! 2
! " # 2 5 0 " 2 #
# 2! 2 2
01 # &&
# #
" 5 0
1
# '61
*72 & 1 01 , 0 # 1 2 # -4 &4
#
# 0 ,
10
0 ₹ 4*!*** 2?" ! 2 1"
2 &' $
2 ! 5 0 ! 0
!
"# $
%
.
&
%
'
( !
'
)
* +
&
&+ $
# " 5 0
1 -:'
" A # !
&7 " ! 5 0 2 2 " #
# # A ! # !
D #
34 4- "# 01?90
2
0" #
3 2 ! FAO No. 2847:2022 # 01 2 : FAO No. 2427:2022 # 01 )
2 1 2
5 *+*4&*&&
2# 15 ) 2 2 # 2 2 )
)
Sr.
No.
Heads Compensation Awarded - 12 -&***:) & $
;&.< 4***:)&.<#-&*** >
A
-:4 4(.*:)-.***K-:' ' 5 2 --&.*:)-.***)4(.* '
-4 .
>1 -(!..!***:)--&.*K-&K-4
#H -+!-.*:) ( $ HA
-+!-.*:) + HA
64!.'+:) 7
# -!74!6**:) $ '+!'**:)A- '+!'**:)A&
'+!'**:)A- &$ 1&-0% # $<&
#! ? ? @ % +,$<&
2 015 0 #!6?/*?*/@ > ,% -&+ $ #!6??6@ 6/**/ 4&
# ! 01?90
2
Dara Singh @ Dhara Banjara Vs. Shyam Singh Varma . /* R.Valli and Others VS. Tamil Nadu State Transport Corporation 6 4+0(%-% &+($ #%# ? ) 2
;7< 2 2 # 2 ## # 2 # L 44
)
2 1$ %&'&()&*&& 2 #2 5 0 #2 # 2 #1# 3 25 5 0
2 #2
# 2 : $ %&+'() &*&&! *+*4&*&&5 2 : $ %&+'() &*&& #
0 , 5 0 4' !# 1! # 4 4 .!
/! * @
"
G , :) , ,
G 0 M