← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/1099/2024dismissed

Cambridge College Governing Council And ANR v. State Of Punjab And ORS

2024-05-16Mr. Justice Deepak Sibal,Mr. Justice Deepak Manchanda10 pages

1       



 !"# $%&%!'()*+* 

,-.%#/ !00 / !1 .'%'/!2'$%0 '# '!3 .



 !"2'5 - '#!3 .&  

(  6*4 74  6*4 7                   

      

!   "   

94%- 0:* # $

 %&###''(  )(  * +   )#,"   + "     )# -      *"  

 "     , #%%(.%#.   )(   

  "    / 0/  1 2+    

* " $+ * + 

        %&###''(    

   

 "      3        

   *      * 

          

"   *   )(   *"   + 

  

  "

+  4  "  *  "  *

2 . ,         

    "   "*   )( 

   ""3 

-  

"$

 "  

 %#%'.%#5  6 *     )(6       ""* ""3 " -  

" 7 8  *  .%#(   )(    

  0 "  "

    

 2"   

 + 8 

    

* " ) #7  1 9 +   "  ). $ 

    "      %#%'.%%:3 *" ).;<  9  "

 "   ). =  9              )(           "  +      "  " "

      %&###''( $

  

    )( "



  "  " +"   %&###''(8     

      %&###''(    

   )#" +*     

              *  + 

  

     

"   *    )( 8

  

  "    

  "

+

 "

4     *  

 $ * "  "+  "  + 5 ,        "  

   " "

 "    "   , 88  ##    "  )(6   

  

3  

    )( ""3 

" $

     #.%5.%#'    /  0/   1 2   +     )( ""3 

"> 

"   

  %'%'.%#'   / 0/  1 2 + 

 +   ###%.%#'  "

     "* 

  

"  *  )(      $

" "   "   

 ;:(7%;.%#';    

+   <   +  



 )(   " /  %'%'.%#'8       



  *  

   

$      

  3  "  .%%&.%.5 ( 8  + 

      %'#%.%#'

  )(    ? ++

        0"

  =  ?2  

            )#  ++       +    %&###''( $? "

 +    1 *++

 + 0"  ;  12  

 

     .%##.%#'       1 

 + 0"  = 12  "*   "  "*  )( "  $+*      * 1 1 -    

+ - * )#" *      

 

" "    "   

 >;

5#7%;.%.%;+   <    

  

4 "   

$

        

  * ?   + * 

    ++    *   

  "   +    " ?   " - *"          "       

 

      +  

        + *   )(  ? *1

 *"  6        )( "      ,  @@ 8   '        +  "  A ++

     

 "    

    $ "  *     +

 "      , %7%5.%.5 "     + *

+

   " "          "  



 +   .5%(.%.5  +                *  -    "  8  + *

 "

"        $

   8 ;

             *      /     *  %7%5.%.5           *-    "   : A      "  

+    

   *  )("  ?   +  * + 

 

 B

*"  )(6 

       

        *    

 "  

    

* *   

       " *   )( 

5       + "  

 

    ""3;

 +

" " +

"

 B

    )(6      ?  - *    *         **  

B  "   +   +

   * 

  *    +   

*  

B  

 * - **          +    *-         

 +

            *B +

  

 *

    "      *      +B  

       +  "  A ++

                 

 +

    ++  " +

   

  "       *  )( C ,   "

     

 " +  * "    ;

"     *      

+     +

    "*    

   + "  A ++

      +   +  *  *""  "  +        

    * 

    6   $ "   + " *  +







      

    

  

!""  # $ %  # $

6 &    

       '

()

((  



*    +  & $ "

+

  +  ""        ' 8   %

 

  + 

     " ; +( $    ,  %-   

 .



  %- # % '

#

       #  #

/.

% .



1  /% #

-  % 2   

 

%  -    %

 1  /% #

-  %  

 /%  

-

  % - ## %  #

 %     %

 1  /% #

-  % %

 



 

2  /%   

3& %   #  

%

 4   /%  

  #%  

.

#  %



 %    #

&. 



1  /% - %

%  % 

 &%  -'

3 /%   #

-    

 .  3 . #  

5   &.  %%.

 % 

(

#    

  /

   #    -  &.   #  

% "

       1  6!

4

( # '

3

 

  /%'

. -  #

-  %%   -     

. #  /  . 

 -    %  -'

-

 # -   . 

%

 

 '

/% /

## % 



 3

.  3 . #   $  %-

  /% #

  % . 

 

3 '

 '

  # '

&.   #  

# # .

 

     

 

1    '

  #

.

  % . 

 

 

7&.   # 

# # .

 

       

 8

#% $   +

  %

 

      ;

      

       + 

7    +



* " D 

 

 

   "* -  

 

*   +  B   "*   

    +  *  *""  "  +     +

"*  

 -    

  +  " + $ +

"

         ;

          + 

    

 *      /  *  "   

"     +  "

+        +

+** +  

  *  "*  +      "      ## 8     "     *   + 

    %

     "    ;

 +  #. $

                 - *  * ?   )(6   

   )( 

 

"   * ?   -  + +*  

  "  )(6  *     + 

       %&###''(      )( 

 "  %&###''(

  )(       *     "    

     

 ""    *

8 #7 $  + *

   *        

    *  ?     )(6        

 *  )( 

  ""  ?   *   

 +   "  ?

       

 

    

 *   

#5 8 

" 

     /   "*  )(  , @@ 8  '        +  "  A ++

     

 "        "   **      +     $   "  * 

 * #( 8     "  "  "  

 

  +

         /                 "  $    *       "

++

 $  

     "

++

  "*   *      /          3 +    " " +  *    8  

       "*   

   +

  +    +  4   ""   "  + $ "    "  *  +

  %

 

   ;

  + 

9 #: "    +  *"    ;



    "      + #C              "       /      "         "  *    *  )(8   " 

  *  )(   

  %&###''(    *     +   "  

 "     *   "

+



   *

 ""    *,       + *   "  

  + *

 )(*       *-    * "  

 "+      

  "   +           

  

 * "    * #& >  +    

 "    3         

 +

   

  +   .5%(.%.5   ;  *          "   * "    *     

*     



+ 

 

  

  

*   + 8  "  "     "          + 3  " 3   *  

 

10 #' $ +

          

  $      * 

    *    "  "            *    $   *  "  $ " " +   *    ;+      "* "*;  *    

  8 +* 

   6 8*   " "    " +

  +   *            "  "   + .% 8   "   



  "  "   +

     *      /       *  %7%5.%.5 .# 1 +

 

94%- 0 2#/ )*+*    

9 '$3 '# . 2#/ >      E 4) >    E 4)