Gulshan Rai & ORS v. Charanjit Singh & ANR






   
 
















 




  




    !"


" #  $  "% '"
" '"
"


(

"






)      
 

 *' 
+, 
# 
& '"-
* 

"
) 

./
* -
* 

)
0  
3&
"!

4!-
**-
# %+

)
0&

 



6"

) 

& 
7
#

 !
+, 1


2!,
 !"
 -
8"


" 
" .+
(!
8 '
9 "

'

!

:)
) ;

*< 
# -
 !
+,
)
0

"
 22 '



*< 
#
)
+,
"
 

3 

!
'


= !-
&>&
0'
 
4"

"
"
) 
"
+
 22
 & 
 -
 -
 7-


>
=#

 
 !

!


071


>61  

 !

"% '"
$  !"


"
 6"
+ 
 

"


"
'"

4


"
& '"

4
)2
 

? 
/ '2 2)! 
)

"
)!


"
)),

  



 !4,

>'
4
4
+,
"


"
"
& '"
4"
)  " "
2


 
 
6"
 
)),
 

4
)  6"

) 2) 

4
2-
+"2


8 "-
4"

4
8


+,



.+
(!
2
"
& '"

@ @  6"
4
) 2) 

"
")
+  '
"
 !4,
- 4"

"
4

 

"
 

+ 
4

"
")
4 !

 
"
& '"
< 
AB !!C
4 "
'

"


 
!  '
"
 
)),

 

"



"% '" D
2 

"
& '"-
"
)),

4



+,

'"
68 '
+ 

"
+ 

 "% 
& '"-



 !"
 -
8"


.+
(!

!!'!!,


) 
 
4
 
")-
4"

!
"
"


")

 !!
) 




"

*
8 !!'!
) 
"
 
4
")-
 !"
 -
8"


.+
(!


! '
"
",
"
)  "
"
 
")
" '"
'

 !

6"

!!'
"
"

 
!
 E<B1@-
E<B1@-
E<B1@@

E<1


'
 +


 2
6"
!!'


"
 
!
-
4 " '

 '"-
 !



"
)),

6"
!!'
! 
4

 

 !"


8"



.+
(! 6"
 
 " 
4'!,
 
2  
0



 
  !"


8"


"
+ 

 
!!'
!  
.4-
 +9 !,-
"
 
2  
4
!!
+, * 
!! 
=
-
04""
6"
 

!
' !
  

 

)!
22 
>'-
4 "
'

"


4"

)
D
"
+ 

"
 
-
)!


'


F=
0  
@ 



& 
 >
=#

#!


& >'
' 
"
) -
"


"
 '
4 

" 
'


!

6"
2
4
 '
+,
"
)!

 
"



)
% 
"
 ' 
D
2)! 


 ' -
)!


)
!! 
)

7



+ "
 

.4-
"
2
4
% 
4 "
 

" )!



 "
 '
"
2
E

 "
 ' - )!


)
"
!! 
)

@



+ 
"
2 4
!
% 
4 "
 

 "
 '

"
2 6"-
"


!! 
)
4
 +2 
+,
"
)!


 

@

"
2
4


)
+,
"
 

.4- "
)
) 
 !
+,
"

4



) 


=
"
)!

,
  -

<2 
B

G")!
& '"
4"
) 
 22
 
2  
+,
 

)!

22 
>'

"
)
 2
E<B 1*

E<B 1
  2
E<B 1

E<B 1E

),

  
E<B 1F B
.)
& '"-
*!"2

"
 

* !
& 
3 '- &>&
0'
) 
"
 22
 

)
 2
E<B 1

E<B1 
B
/"2
(!-
#4
 !
>'-
 


&>& 0'
) 
"
 
! '


%2+ 

"
) %2+ 
E<B 1*

@7 @7

E<B 1>

@7 @77
B *&=
#2
(!


!

&&#


-
&>&
0'
) 
"
 22 

)
 2
E<B1

E<B1 
B
  "


& '"
,

'"
 
"
2 2

"
)
) 
.
)
)4

,
E<B1 
. !
)
 2
E<B1

E<B1 
.
!
  2
E<B1

E<B1

 D
2)! 

)!

,
  -
"
 

=!!9 '



 2 
"
)
) 
:

;

' 
"


"
 '
4 

"
!

+ 

"
2
 2-
 22
) 
 !"
 -
8"

 .+
(!



-

 
 !

& 
 -
 -
 7-



>
=#-
 

*< 
#


 6"
) 
+ '
'' 
"
 !
"
)
) 
& 
7
#
!, "!!'

)
) 
*< 
#


 22 '



*< 
#

 !
)) '

+"!

"
) 
"
 +2  "

"
'

 

F=
0 

@ 



&   >
=#

#!


& 
>'
' 
"
) 

" )-
"
 ' 
4
 
+,
"
)!



)!


)

!! 
)
+ 
"
2
4



)
4


+,
"
 


4 "
 

 "
 '
"
2
.4-
" "


!! 
)
 +2 
+,
)!


4


)
6"
) 
*< 
#
 !
+,
"

4



) 


6"
 !

"
) 
"
 "
 +2  "
"
 
)
) 
4
 !
+,
"

+,
!

'
" 2 !
 
2
"
 

=
"
)
) -

4 '"!

'"
+,
"

"
2  
 

 

"



0

-

"
+ 

!!'
!

4
!


!!
+,
"
 
 " 
.4-
"

 
   !
"
 
"
"
 

4 "
'

!! 

2  4
,
+,
"
.C+!
.

'"
 
 



7 7

*< 
#
)

B# 77

-
4"

"
4
!

2 
  
*< 
#

 

7-

"
)
) 
*< 
#


 

@
4"

"
4
 !
2 "

"
) '


*<  #
+,
"
   
> "

"


   6"
 !

"
) 
"
 "
' 
" 

+ 
)  "

! +!
  

'   
"
4"

)

"

2
"



!
 - +
 
"
!
 

 ) 
6"
 !

" 
 "
 +2 
"
"


"
) 


+  '
"
"

"
-

"
) 

"
  !


2
"
)

.4-
"
 !
 
4"

!
) '
"

2) '
 *< 
#-
 2 
"

:)
) ;
*<  #
' 
"

+ 
4'!,
 22
"
)  7 6"
 !

"
) 
"
 "
 +2 
"

" !

'"

"
!4
! 
4
+,
.C+!
& )2
 




   



  

  
"
) 

2
,
!
) 

"
 84 '
 !!,
4!!
"
"
 
) 

 

"+,
" 
 
"


!


,
)),

"2

 ,
"
)-

"
 2

< 

!

-
  

" '

& 

=#

2
 
' 
"



=
"
+
 "
 +2 
"

"
 2

< 

  !
-
) 
0


 '
"
2

" 
)!
)

, 
",
 

2)
,

" -

',
4
22  +,
"
) 
6" -
"

"

'

"
 

) 2


 +!

"
"
"
) 
4
),

"
< 

,
!  2

 

& 
 
=# @ 6"
)
) 
 
+,
 !

)
0

4"
 +2 
"
"
) 
4
 !!,
4
"
"
)),
9  
4
4
+,
"
& '"1 '"-

" 2

< 

!


6"
) 
84 '!,-

!!  
4 "
"

'
< 
"
 
!


"  
% 


"
 '"

"

4 "
'

)),
9  
=
"
+
 "
 +2 
"
) 
4

+  )  "

"
)),

6"
"
) 
))
"
8  2
+,
 + '
"
)),
4" 
")
4
<  '-


  :
 
)!;
6"
) 
4
 '"!,
 22
+,
"
 !
 
  
 !

& 
 -
 -
 7-
 >
=#-
 
 *< 
#

=

))
"

"
 22 '



- "


 

"
% '2

.C+!
& )2
 


 

!"

#$  4" 

4
"!
"

-
"



" !

)!

!

4
+,
"

2-

"
)
! '
"

2!
 +
"
4

"
2-

 

',

2
 

 "
 "



"
"
)  "


"
4-


)  "
4" 2,
!'



& 

=#
!!'

'
"
"
4
"-






2
!
) 

4"

)
+ 
 "


 2  +!
' 
"



:;-

+"!

"
4

"  
)),

6"


 

!
8 '
% 

!





*< 
# 
*< 
#
)
+,
"
   
> "

"


 

B#  77


7 7

 

7-
) !,
4"

"
4
   !
+,
"


"


)
) 
) 
"
 
" 
*< 
#
4
)

) 

"
 !

"


6"
 
% 

!




+ '
8-

"

 % 



"4 
!
4 "
2 
 

>" ,
0' & 8"
&"


:>0&&
  ;-


) 


"
) 
 & 


>0&&
 
2
"

))  ,

" 

+ '



"
))



+
"
'


8
' H 

 ) 

6"


"
!'

! 

"
"
 
 , )  


))  ,

"
))




) 
"
"





"
 

)
"
 
2
4'!,
8 ' H 
 "
) 


"


+ 

 =
!

'"

"
+
   -
"
)
) 
)!, !!4


2) '

*< 
#


)
+,
" !
 !
 


 

"
 
 

 

)

"

-

"
+ 

"
)!

,
  
 !+!

"
 -
"
!

'"

"
!4
! 
4
+,
.C+!
*)<
 




! #$ 4"

"

!

!


)

% 

& '(  '

  ) *+  ,
"
)!
 
+,
"
) 

"
) 

"
 
"
 
2 !
 
4

  !
+,
"

7


>
) '
"
"
-
))  ,

" 

+ '



"
1"


 !
6"



))
" '"


 !
+
"
!
 !
 

  

.4-
"
)
) 
4 "
'

9 "

'



:)
) ;
*< 
# -
9 
"
)  
 2 

 *,
+ 
2
" 
+



+
 
 
<) 

) 

"
2 

"


"
2

!

 !,

"
) )

 )!

"
)
) 
   

 


   !"#$"#%&'#()*+,-%#(&.+#/0 #&-.

!"#$"#%%#'.%$(12#0 #&-.