High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/1558/2002disposed of

Avtar Singh v. Satwinder Kaur And ORS

2025-09-22Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja5 pages

%$ %$ %$ %$

- 678

- 6789-/66: -/66: -/66: -/66:

- 67>

- 67>9-/66:

-/66:

- 68:

- 68:9-/66:'# -/66:'# -/66:'# -/66:'# - ::>-/66 ?

- ::>-/66 ?

$"-/".''-# $"-/".''-# $"-/".''-# $"-/".''-# 66 66 B 66 66 66 66:

00"11%#$ 00"11%#$ 00"11%#$ 00"11%#$

"0-#,"#$

!""#$

/-!

%&'()'*%#+,(-.%$" $)"%001'.%#$2%00"11%#$ %#,0%1+,(-.%$"

-/!"0-#,"#$- 3*""$%'#+,(-.%$"4'$) 3)%1,""0%3!+,(-.%$"

+)%#,'5%!) @@@@ + !%1 + !%1 + !%1 + !%1 - 678 - 678 - 678 - 6789 -/66: -/66: -/66: -/66:

!%;"! * %," '# $)" %001'.%$'-# ' /-! '* *01"%,'#5 $)" %001'.%#$ % 1"

"5%1 )"'!-/%00"11 %#$+4)-,'",-#6A 8 6:

.%" - 68: - 68: - 68: - 68:9 -/66:

-/66:

!% %;"! *%,"'#$)"%001'.%$'-#' /-!'*01"%,'#5$)"%001'.%#$ % 1"5%1)"'!-/!

!"0-#,"#$- 9*$ %$4'#,"!

!%3!+4)-,'",B : 66:

! $)" !"%-# *"#$'-#", '# $)" %001'.%$'-#+ $)" %*" ' %11-4 4",+ 3<&".$$-%11&3 $"=."0$'-#%#,$)"%001'.%#$ %*"#$'-#",'#0%!%5!%0) - 6 -/$)"%001'.%$'- -#%!"-!,"!",$-<"'*01"%,",% %1"5%1)"'!-/!"0-#,"#$- - 9 *$ %$4'#,"! %3!,"."%",'#-!,"!$-03! 3"$)"0!""#$.%" * *"#,", *"*- -/ 0%!$'" ' $%C C"# -# !".-!, "5'$!; $- ,- #"",/31 - 67> - 67> - 67> - 67>9 -/66:

-/66:

-/66: )'

' ' %# %001'.%$'-# 3#,"! ".$'

'-# : /-! 1'$'#5 $)" * *%'# %00"%1%#,,'0 -%1-/$)"%*"'#('"4-/-!, ,"!,%$",: 60%",<;$ $)' -3!$'#

- 67-/6 - 67-/6 - 67-/6 - 67-/6$'$1",G%,)3

%,)3

%*?-$)"!( #'-#

%*?-$)"!( #'-#"!!'$- "!!'$- "!!'$- "!!'$- $-!;+ -!;+ $-!;+ -!;+ )%#,'5%!) )%#,'5%!) )%#,'5%!) )%#,'5%!) D D D D -$ $'."-/$)"%001'.%$'-#

"% %!#", .-3#"1 !"0!""#$'#5 # #-#9%001'.%#$2!"0-#,"#$ %.."

"0$ #-$'."-#$)"'! <")%1/%#,%,*'$$)"%/-!"*"#$ $'-#",/%.$3%1%0".$

0- -#)"%!'#51"%!#",.-3#"1/-!$) )"0%!$'"%#,'#('"4-/$)"0!% %;"! *%,"'#$)"%00 01'.%$'-#+$)"%*"'%11-4", '$)$)".-#"#$-/1"%!#",.-3# #"1 /-!$)"0%!$'"$) )"*%'#%00"%1'$%C"#30$-,%;

'$"1//-!,'0-%1

- ::> ::> ::> ::>- -// -//66 66 66 66 ?

EF ; 4%; -/ 0!""#$ %00"%1+ .)%1 11"#5" )% <""# 1%', $- $)" 4 4%!, ,%$", : B 6 0%", <; $)" 1"%!#", ,,1 '$!'.$ 3,5"+ )%#,'5 5%!) )"!"'#%/$"!$-< <"!"/"!!",%$)"G "/"!"#." -3!$D+4)"!"<; "/"!"#." "$'$ $'-# /'1",3#,"!".$ '-#A!"%,4'$)".$'-#>-/$) )" %#,.J3''$'-#.$+>BH /-! )-!$ G$)" >BH H .$D %$ $)" '#$%#." -/ $)" .

.1%'*%#$ 4% 0%!$1; %11-4", 4) )'1" 5!%#$'#5)"!$)" <"#"/'$-/"#)%#.",*%!C"$(%13 3"I H++8:A290"!%.!"J3% %.J3'!", 1%#, < <"'," %4%!,'#5 -$)"! $%$3$-!;

; <"#"/'$2'#$"!"$ '# )"! /%(-3!

! % 0!-(',",3#,"!$ $)">BH.$

E6F

"% %!#", .-3#"1 /-! $)" 0%!$'" % %!" %, ',"* $)%$ $)" *%$$"! 4 4'$) !"0".$$-$)","

"$"!*'#%$'-#-/*%!C"$(%13"$% %#,%,&3,'.%$",30-#<;$)'- -3!$ ('," '$ ,".''- -# ,%$", : 6 0%", '#

- 67 -/ 6

- 67 -/ 6 $'$1", , % K%,)3 %*%# %,)3 %*%# %,)3 %*%# %,)3 %*%# #, $)"! #, $)"! #, $)"! #, $)"!( ( ( ( #'-#"!!'$-!;+

#'-#"!!'$-!;+

#'-#"!!'$-!;+ )%#,'5%!) )%#,'5%!) )%#,'5%!) )%#,'5%!)M4)"!"<;$)"'*'1% %!1; '$3%$",1%#,-4# #"!0"!$%'#'#5$-$)"%*"%.J3 3''$'-#0!-."",'#5)%("<""#) )"1, "#$'$1", /-! $)" "#)%#.", %*-3#$ -/ .-*0"#% %$'-# I 7829 0"! J3%!" ;% %!,+ %1-#5 4'$) %11 $%$3$-!; <"#"/'$ "1"(%#$ 0-!$'-# /!-* $)" %/-!"*"#$'-# #", &3,5*"#$'"=$!

!%.$",)"!"3#,"!

9 K0"!3%1-/$)"%4%!,-/$)"

)"-11".$-!)-4+1%#,%.J3'!",( ('," #-$'

$'/'.%$'-#,%$",6> 7 BB.-#'$ $-/ ".$ - A8+A>+AB+:+:+ :6+ :> %#, :B 4)"!"% $)" 1%#, %.J3'!"

", ('," #-$'/'.%$'-# ,%$", B > B BB .-# #'$-/ ".$ -A8+A>+AB+:+ +:+:6+:>+:B+7+7%#,8 )" %.J J3''$'-#(',"#-$'/'.%$'-#,%$", 6 B>7.-#'$-/ ".$ - 7B+ 8+ 7+ >+ >6 %#, B6 /-!"%', $)!"" 0 0-.C"$ -/ 1%#, %!" %,&-'#'#5 $- "

"%.) -$)"

)"! )'.-3!$'#*%!&'$'#5).

.%"30!%)%,%"",$)"(%13"

3"-/ 1%#, #,'#*%!&'$'#5).%"30!%I I 7290"!J3%!";%!, "%!

!#", .-3 3#"1 /-! $)" 1%#, -4#"! %!" .1% %'*'#5 $)%$ $)"; <" 5!%#$", '#.!"

"%" I 6L0"!%##3*$)"!"-#/-!$)"$'* *"5%0'#$)"$4-#-$'/'.%$'-#+4) )'.) ' A A ;"%! %#, *-#$) )' .-3!

3!$ /'#, $)" 0!%;"! *%," <; $)" 1 1%#, -4# 4#"!$-<"&3$'/'%<1" )"%4%!,% %##-3#.",<;$)"-11".$-!0"!$%'# #'#5 $-$) $)"%/-!"%',$4-%.J3''$'-#%1-) )-4%00!".'%$'-#-/0!'."'#$)"% %!"%+ 4)'

)'.)'"("#%$%!%$"*-!"$)%#6L L0"!%##3* #*%!&'$'#5).

.%" 30 30!%+ $)" %4%!, -/ $)" -11".$-!

-! $)"!"'# 4% >:+29 0"! % %.!"+ 4)"

)"!"% '# $)" 0!""#$ .%"+ '$ 4%

6+8:+29 0"! %.!" ..-!,'#5 #51;+ %/$"

"!%4%!,'#5'#.!"%"I6L0"!%# ##3*-# 7290"!J3%!";%!,+ (%13 13"-/$)"%.J3'!",1%#,4-31,.-* *"-3$$- 78290"!J3%!";%!, )" 1%#, #,-4#"!)%11%1-<""#$'$1",$- %11$)"$%$3$-!;<"#"/'$%(%'1%<1"

1"$- $)"* *3#,"!$)".$ -"#3!"$)%$$)"1%#,-4#"! %!"#-$/1"".",<;$)"*',,1"*%# #'# 0!-." -/ ,'<3!"*"#$ -/ "# #)%#.", .-*0"#%$'-#+ -#<1" 30 0!"*"-3!$'#'('100"%1- 7 7::-/6B%!;%#%$%$"#,3$ $!'%1

"( ("1-0*"#$ .-!0-!%$'-# !% %# 3C) %#, -$)"!+ ,".',", -# 8 > 6+ '3", ."!$%'# ,'!".$'-# ,""* '$ %00!-0!'%$" $- '3" % %*" ,'!"

".$'-#'#$)"0!""#$"$-/%00"%1 %4"11 )"%*"%!"%3#,"!

9 N4'$)%('"4$-"#3!"$) $)%$$)"1%#,-4#"!%!"#-$/1"".", ,<; $)" *',,1"*%#+ 4" ,""

""* '$ %00!-0!'%$" $- '3" /-11-4 4'#5 /3!$)"!,'!".$'-# ' )" 1%#, .J3''$'-# 3<-!,'#%$"$-)'*#-$<"1-4$ 5"$ '# $-3.) 4'$) %11 $)"

!"0!""#$%$'("%#,'#/-!*$)"* !"."'(""#)%#.",.-*0"#%$'-# # -11".$-! )%11 ,"03$" -//'.

'."! )%11 1"5%1 $)"!%#C-/%'<")'1,%!+4)-) " 1%#, -4#"! %#,2-! $)"'! 1"

"*%<-3$$)"'!"#$'$1"*"#$%#,!'5) )$$- # '' )".-#."!#",-//'."!) -! $)"'! 1"5%1 !"0!""#$%$'(" $ $)";%1!"%,;,-#-$)%("3.)% )%11%1-'#$!3.$$)"1%#,-4#"!%# $- -0"# %('#5 <%#C %..-3#$ '# .

%..-3#$ %#,2 .%" ''' )" <%#C %..-3#$ #3* 5'("#$-$)" %#,.J3''$'-# *<"! -/ $)" 1%#, -4#"! )-31, , <" -11".$-!4'$)'#$)!""*-#$) '( )"1%#,.J3''$'-# .-*0"#%$'-#'#$)"<%#C%..-3 -11".$-!)%11,"0-'$$)".)"J3" -3#$-/$)"1%#,-4#"!N -/ $)"*%##"!'#,'.%$",%<-(" M )"%00"%1%!",'0-",-/'#$ EAF # ('"4 -/ $)" %<-(" $%#, $%C"# # <; <-$) $)" '," -# /%.$ % %#, %001;'#5$)"0!'

'#.'01"-/0%!'$;+<"',"5!%#$ -/&3$%#,/%'!.-*0"#%$'-#+ 0!""#$%00"%1' 0%!$1;%11-4",'#$"!*-/$)" %/-!"*"#$'-#",,".''-#' " %, %, %, %, %,)3 %,)3 %,)3 %,)3

%*%#, $)"!

%*%#, $)"! !D !D !D !D.%"30!%%#,$)"%00"11%# #$21%#,-4#"!%!")"1,"#$'$1", /-! '*'1%!%*-3#$ -/*%!C"$(%13"I 78290"

"!J3%!";%!,%)%<""#%4%!, ,", $--$)"!'*'1%!1 1;'$3%$",1%#,-4#"!O%1-#54'

'$)%11$%$3$-!;<"#"/'$%#,'#$"!

!"$ %(%'1%<1" 3#,"!

! $)" %*"#,", 0!-(''-# -/

%#, .J3''$'-# .$+ >BH % %001'.%<1"$-$)"

"0!""#$%.J3''$'-#

EHF )"

" %00-!$'-#*"#$ -/ .-*0"#%$'

'-# )%11 <" *%," '# $"!* -/ 4%!,,%$",:

: B 60%",<;$)"1"%!#", , "/"!"#."-3!$+%$)"%*" )% #-$<""#!"9%5'$% %$",<;$)"%00"11%#$ E:F

"# #,'#5%001'.%$'-#+'/%#;)%11 %1-$%#,,'0-",-/ "0$"*<"!

"0$"*<"!

"0$"*<"!66 66+6 +6 +6 +6 $'C 66 66 66 66: ) ) )"$)"!0"%C'#52!"%-#", " )"$)"!!"0-!$%<1" " 2- 2-