High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/20486/2019allowed

Banarsi Lal Khanna And ANR v. State Of Punjab And ANR

2023-03-22Mr. Justice Sandeep Moudgil22 pages

V VISHAL 2023.09.22 14:03

!"#"$%&'&'

% ()*& + *+ ** ) ****

# $ %

!" &' + $,

-.,/"01 & # " ()' ** + $, - , ./ &'01 '220'23) " ('2 /* 45 36 , 7

- " , , &3 ' 88 7 88 7 "! +$$ 4 , " 6 7 7 +

&'9

,, ./""

, "('2/* + " " ./7 , " *+ " &'8 ,

# ,,$$ , &'7

- 2 - 6 ! "

, $$

+ + &7: 7,1 " ,7 " " ,, , $$ 3'82(8'231 ;! " < )1 222=8 ,,# ,$$ 7 > 7

" :$3(8338'231 " 12 " ,# ,, +! $$ 7+ &7: '282'8 '23?

$$ 7

7$&7: "

,&7: $$ " $7

> , 7 * @ &7:

+ * @ ,! !" A "

,!&7: + "+7 *- + ./7 , + " ""

, " " ./" 7 ./7

! ""

, ! , 7 8 7 , " "" "('2/*/" ./"8 "0; ," + ", , , ,

- 3 - &' , , / ! " , ./ , , B ! "

$$ "$&7: # ! ", + $$ ! , !, 7 , ! " , 7 ! + / 5+ + + ", " / "

, " !, ,

" "

, ./ #

, " , , ./ "

7 " " !,, ,"+ , , ! ./, , # " = ' ! 7 + " 4, 88 7 88 76 /" , 88

7 4$$ 6 ,,&7: 7 " "+ / 8 ./ " " ! ./ " "(01/*7 "

"" " + 77 "

- 4 -

, " ! + " " "$/ !+"! +

+ " 7 , 4 '6# "$ + "

./ ," 7 . ! " "

" + !,,,"+ "3C<**"" $7 , , ,!,

7 7 , &78:

, ,+ " (01 /* 7

, "7!" / !"3))** "/ "$",>" " 7 "

" "/ 7 !" * %! . ! + " , " 7!+7

7 !" ! 7 "! 7

45 (6 7 "

+ '23C , , ./ +'2307+ "

$ + "

, " 7 !+7

7 !, " "

# $%% &&'((" ,7, "+ "7 5,,

,,"

- 5 - , ! $ ! 7, " !"(0)8/*

+ " " ,7 !7

&"7 2?21'230 7 3?2''2'< 7 * 5 "

*" * * ;7! ""

"" 302<'2'< "

7 "$ * + + <22)'2'' + " , + 7

7$ D $, !D 7 # / " "&7:

+ +7$ / + " 77$,D*7 "

&7: %!,"! ,! " "

+ ,&7: + ' +" , ', + &7: ,7 - + "

, ""$&7: 7$ * , ,

, ' ,

12 $ 7 + ' , , # , '

- 6 -

, " $7 7 E , + ,

"$,7 /, &7: "7"

"!,!+&7 : "D* "/D# , ' 7 ! + * @ "!7 "

, "

7$!7 , ; 7 "

, "

# , ' ,7 '7$ $ !, !" "" " , 7 7

, ' 7 "$ , 7 7 "

""" " 7 # '7 "! + +7 " !, !" &7 : + ! "

' , +

+ !

+ " ,$$ 7 /7"" ' , "+

+ 7 + $$ 7 " + + , # +$ '$

, E ! , $$ ' 7 , + &7 : 7+ ! 7

"$$$ ,,"$ &7: $$ 7 / 7

- 7 - , 7 + &7 : &7 : ! + # " " + " $ 7 "

' +" 7 ,

/ ! ,

+ , 7 ! +$ / , '7" 7 ,,"+

7 "

7,! " 7

,! 7 31 + 7 +, , &7 : , 7 "

$$ 7" ! / !7 "+ 7 + &7: '?2''23?$$ 7 , +,

77"+ 7

$ 7!+ + " + , 7 7

/ ,$$ , + 7, $, , , " ""7 "

" ="" &7 !

7 $$ , + "+ , " ""$/ $ " 7 , !+ $,,!77 , , , "

+ $ "" " "

"! 7 "

7 "" $$

- 8 - " $, , , , 7 / " " ! , , ./3<? <32)'23C/#$ ./ 3C? <32)'23C"'? * , $$ " ""$/ " + , "!, "-"$$ "! "

7 7 7

7 ! &7: / " , ," ,& +

! , ,7

"-" + , ,""$ + + 3?32'230 7 ! -+ " 7 " " + A+ " *"

A" -+ & 3<)=*=A= '<2)'23) " , " A" ;7! " , " " 4; -6 7 1)(=*==;F= 218208'23) " , 7 $$ !

4 6 ! "

" $$

+ &7 : 7, 1 " ,7 " " ,,

- 9 -

, $$ 3'82(8'231;! " < )1 222=8 ,, # ,$$ 7 > 7

" :$ 3(8338'231 " 12 " , , ,, +!$$ 7 &7 : '282'8'23?

$$ 7

7$ &7 : "

, &7 : $$ " $7

> ,7 * @ &7:

+ * @ ,! !" A "

, !&7: + "+7 ,&7: +# $$ "$/ +'23? ,7 8 7 + * ,

7 33222 &7 : A

# $$ +# $$ , 7&7: # " ; - """

,,$$ 7

7 * @ "7 ,

"('2/* ! "7,

, -+ / ! " , , "

- 10 - " ('2 /* ! 7 ! "

+ " "! !+++ $ + 7 +! "+ + , 7 "

, 7 "

" ,"! ! "+

7 "

+ 5 !+

+ * "&" ) )

+ , (,+ , " " " ('2 " " "

, " (31G "

+ " # "

, , "" " "('2/* / " " !"('2/* " +! "" "

+ , + " 7 "

!+# " " 46 "+ 46 + + ", !+++ 46 "" $, "/, 7 +, " "

, 5 "7 7 /-

8 E +E > "7, ,7, 7

- 11 - " 7 "

, !+ + " " " ('2 /* * + "

"" ",!" " "('2 7, ,, "/ -

, , + "('2 ! "

" + / , "! 7 D DDD

" " $ *""&8 "

!+" "" D. D7 , "3'4364"6 " 46 " + + , 46 " " , H " ,! 7 + + 7 $7 , 7 , > , * !

" ! + , , + "" 3? +

,?)' 7 !

7,!

!" #

$%!

- 12 -

$& / " , 7 $$ 4" B , 6 B

7 > 3(33'231

+ 7 7++ + # , " + /I # 45 '6 , + /7 7 !+ ""+ ,

+ " "

,$$ &7: # 5 " 7 , +&3 ,, ! 5 7 ""&3! $45<6/ " $$ $7 7 !" 7! "

4" 6 ! 7 "

45 (6 J '?2''23? 7 " 7" 7 7 - , " ""$ 7 47 7 6 , "+&7: "

H $$ "$ /

""7 " 7 " 0 ;

" ", , 2121'23)4516/ "$ "8 ./ , '220'23)

- 13 - !7

7 , ""

./# + ./ , " "! " , ,7

5,,7 , &' " 7 +$+ ,, ,/" !,

# , ,, 7 "

, ", ""

+ " "" / + + !

! "

" ,

! + " "

"" "('2/* 46 "+ 46 + + ", !+++ 46 "" $, "

+,'

! ""

, 7 "

5 !+",!, ! + " ! "

"3C<**7 "

+ ! " #

, ./ "" , 7 * @ $,33222&:

- 14 - $$ + ,

, #

, " ;

" 7 8 "

!+ " " "" / 7 " + + + " 7 , + ", " , +" ! + , , + "" ,

, , ./

, + " 7 $$ !"

# " $$ , , ""$/ !"

,+ $! "

, 7 "

+ " 0 4 ", , 6" ,+ 7 "

7 7 , ! + + !+"

, ! ,7 $$ # + 77 !"$/ !,

, ./ " " 8 "8 " , +

" / " " '

# ''

+ AIR 1973 SC 326 *

, + ""

, 7 7

- 15 - $, "

" " "

- +

!7 $ "- '

# .

% " " '

# ''

, ( / "! '

'. /0 #.1+'23+ 34

8 ( !

$) !'

! ! $& /2# ' A!"

;, *

7 *$+ ! ,

$) !

$ ( ! ! , " #

! !

$ - . .

$ #/ !

# ,

- 16 - !

$& / " $7 , + ,

+","+

" "+ "

, " 7 " # "

+ " + , "+/"5" " "(0)8/* ! ! 7 H " " , "

" 7 "

! 7 -! " , " 7+ "" # ! " + " + 5,, !

" " " /,

+ + " 7 "

" ./

8 !" 7 K"""B !"/5" 7+ +

!+ " "(0)8" $

,, !," ! " , # "+ ",

!+"788 + ! ""

" " " # " !

- 17 - 5 + " " , 7 " $ ," " 7 , 7 " #

, " - "> 7 , " """ I5" ! , " " " "+ , / "$7 , " + " E ! 7 + 7

" " , # ",5 + , / 5" 7 7 ;, * - " ," ""

7, " ,"7

" " " - " , , - # !, ;, *E 7 "! " , "

! + " 7 "

" " , , , 7

"/" " ! " " !+ 7 "

" " $7

+ ;, *- , " , "# " , 7 , " , "" , 7 + , # "

, "+ $, ! 7 " !7 "

$! 7 ;, *

- 18 - " 7 " 7

" 7 " "E / 7,! ;, * "()'** 7 " !" " / " " * , + 7 - ! * 7 !+

# * "", "

! + + * !

)

3 '

((4 @ " " " , 7 "

7 "!

H " " " , + 7 " , " + 7 ! ;, * 7

5" " "()'**- " , # * 5'

$$ $ ''

, 7 " ()'** "

''? */ - 5" !+, "

$ " ,# 7 " + " ;, * " "" , "" # "

7 5" , + 7 """ "

- 19 - # * " + $ !7 + 5 +7!" " "# I, " ! 7"

! "!/,

+, *7* 7 " " /

'') # 67 $'7 7 8 , %9 4% A!

7 " " " ,"" "7

7 "" 67 $'77 #!* )8 ,

9 " 7 7 ! + " " " ! !5 , 7!; "E7!"

," "

+! # 5 * " ! > 7 + ;, * "()' * !+7 !+ 7-, "5"# "" " 5" 7 " # 7

5" ,""E , 7 !""" ,!"# ;, *

+,!,

" "7

"" >+G 7 ! "

" " " ! !

- 20 - " , "

, +" "!7 " L" " 7, "7 "

;, *7

5" 5 + "- , " ,+, / "

#32 0 *): ,

,, * ! 7 7 " ()'** ;, *- " ,7 " ""

7, " ,"7

" " "- " , , - # ;, * ! ! 7 7 "! " "

! + " "" ,, , 7 " / " " ! " , 7 , " "" , 7 + , # "

7 ,-" " " /2

3* )#5 2 ,

% 5*

8 0$$$$$(

! "

, !

- 12345

, $ -

! !$ 6 ! !

- 21 -

! "

$% !

- 78412,# # #

, !

$0 / 2

# 0 7

: # *$

/ : ,;;

, ! C 8 02$%

!' !

$% ! !

! # !

' # !

$0 # , ",

, ./ + "" 7 7 7 +

! 7 $$ $ "",""

, , "

8$ , " " " "+

+ "$,

- 22 - * " !7 " "" ,

+ ", / , " ./ " " " ,, 7

, " 7/ """ " , , 7

- "" , +

7 ./&'01 '220'23)4536

-"- " , +- &'&' 9$9 5+ $,

-.,/"02

.,/

1. Whether speaking/reasoned?

Yes/No

2. Whether reportable?

Yes/No