High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/859/2012allowed

Sarabjit Singh v. State Of Punjab And ANR

2017-11-16Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan7 pages

"#$%"% &' ()

! " "# +","&-'

+) +.&/01$ %2 #/-"

+-1"3"-$-$ &"+) +) 4$55

.&6/7)

+/8"+$&-1$,3"-$-$ &$, +9./,1$&: )

%/-"%

&&";.+"< +":$,-"+"%.&%"+4"#-$ &= /- 5$#"

4-/-$ & 1.>/& $,-+$#- /-/5/ /&% /55 -1" ,.7,"9."&- 3+ #""%$&:, /+$,$&:-1"+"

+ >)

+"+"

"++$&:- $>3.:&"% #"+-/$& /#-,5"/%$&: - +":$,-+/-$ & ,/>"/+"& -$#"%/,.&%"+' 1"3"-$-$ &"+?/,"5"#-"%/,4/+3/&#1$&-1"8"/+

!/&% 1"+">/$&"%/,,.#1-$55

) .+$&:-1"-"&.+" 1$,

$#"/,/ 4/+3/&#1 / # >35/$&- %/-"%

?/, $5"% &&";.+" 5"2"55$&:/55":/-$ &+":/+%$&:$++":.5/+$-8 /&#1/8/- .&%,)-$, .+-1"+ ,.7>$--"% -1/- -1" ,/$% # >35/$&- ?/, $&9.$+"% $&- 78 -1" "3.-8 4.3"+$&-"&%"&- 5$#" @/%$/& $,-+$#- /-/5//&%+"# >>"&%"%- -1"44-1/--1"# >35/$&-$,?$-1 .-/&87/,$,/&%$-,1 .5%7" $5"% & -1"7/,$, -1"$&9.$+8+"3 +-%/-"% )

&&";.+"< )-$,

.+-1"+,.7>$--"%-1/--1"+"/ -"+ -1" $,-+$#- "2"5 3>"&-/&%/&#1/8/-

$#"+ .+%/,3.+2$%"5"--"+%/-"% =)

/5, >/+0"%/&$&9.$+8- -1" 5 #0 "2"5 3>"&-/&%/&#1/8/-

$#"+ 4+$/+: 7$&%3.+/&%-1"

,/>"?/,: -# &%.#-"%-1+ .:1.&$ +&:$&""+ -1" 5 #0/&%/,3"+ -1"+"3 +-%/-"%

,.7>$--"%78-1".&$ +&:$&""+ &&";.+"

<! $-?/, .&%-1/--1"/&#1/8/-A,+"# +%+":/+%$&:+"> 2/5 7+$#0, $,& -3+ 3"+58>/$&-/$&"%)1"+"/ -"+ /& -1"+$&9.$+8?/,# &%.#-"%78 -1"

$#" $+"#- + .+/5 "2"5 3>"&- /&% /&#1/8/- .&6/7 1/&%$:/+1/&%/,3"+-1"$&9.$+8# &%.#-"%78-1"4 /&#1/8/-$ /6 /-/5/#.>&9.$+8

$#"+2$%"+"3 +-%/-"%

/&/> .&-

! =*<?/,,1 ?& +"# 2"+/75" + >-1"3"-$-$ &"+) & -1"+ $&9.$+8%/-"%

)*)

&&";.+"<=?/,/5, # &%.#-"%78-1"4.7

$2$,$ &/5

$#"+) ,3"+-1$,$&9.$+8 /:/$&#"+-/$&/> .&-?/,,1 ?& .-,-/&%$&:- ?/+%,-1"3"-$-$ &"+) B"/+&"% # .&,"5 + -1" 3"-$-$ &"+ .+-1"+ ,.7>$-, -1/- -1"+"/ -"+ /5"--"+%/-"%

))

?/,$,,."%78-1" 5 #0 "2"5 3>"&- /&%/&#1/8/-

$#"+%$+"#-$&:-1"3"-$-$ &"+- %"3 ,$--1"/ +",/$% /> .&-

! =*<)1"+"/ -"+ /& -1"+ ,1 ? #/.," & -$#" ?/, $,,."% 78 -1" $+"#- + .+/5 "2"5 3>"&- /&% /&#1/8/-

$#"+ .&6/7 &&";.+"<*/&%-1"3"-$-$ &"+,.7>$--"%/+"358 &&";.+"

<%"&8$&:1$,5$/7$5$-8- 3/8/&8/> .&-$, .-,-/&%$&:- ?/+%,1$>) 1"+"/ -"+ 2$%" +%"+%/-"%

-1"3"-$-$ &"+?/, ,.,3"&%"% + >-1"3 ,- 4/+3/&#178-1" $+"#- + .+/5 "2"5 3>"&- /&%/&#1/8/-/&%-1"3"-$-$ &"+#1/55"&:"%-1",/>"7" +"-1"/33"55/-"

/.-1 +$-8 .&%"+ -1"

1"+"$&/ -"+ +"

"++"%- /,-1"A #-A/&%?1$5"%$,>$,,$&:-1"/33"/5 $-?/,%$+"#-"%

-1/-/+":.5/+$&9.$+8>/87"# &#5.%"%?$-1$&/3"+$ % -1+""> &-1,) 1"+"/ -"+ -1"3"-$-$ &"+1/,#1/55"&:"%-1"/ +",/$%-? +%"+,%/-"%

/&%!

78?/8 $5$&:/C )!* =

?1$#1?/,%$,3 ,"% 2$%" +%"+%/-"%

%$+"#-$&:"&9.$+8

$#"+- # &%.#- +",1"&9.$+8) B"/+&"%# .&,"5 +-1"3"-$-$ &"+,.7>$-,-1/-$&3.+,./&#"

-1" +%"+ -1"&9.$+8

$#"+#.> %%$-$ &/5 "3.-8 >>$,,$ &"+

"2"5 3>"&- .+%/,3.+2$%"5"--"+%/-"%

!1/,,.7>$--"% / +"3 +-$&?1$#1/&/> .&-

! =*<?/, .&%+"# 2"+/75" + > -1"3"-$-$ &"+?1$#1-1"3"-$-$ &"+1/,%"3 ,$-"%78?/8 /%">/&% %+/ - /2 .+$&:-1"+/>/&#1/8/-) &-1">"/&-$>" -1"$>3.:&"% )

%/-"%

?/,+":$,-"+"%/:/$&,--1"3"-$-$ &"+?$-1-1",/>","- /55":/-$ &-1/- %",3$-"$,,./&#" -1"& -$#"- -1"3"-$-$ &"+$&3.+,./&#" -1"$&9.$+8 +"3 +-%/-"%

))

-1"3"-$-$ &"+1/, /$5"%- %"3 ,$--1"/> .&- +"# 2"+/75" + > 1$> /&% -1"+"

+" 1" 1/, # >>$--"% -1"

"&#"

3.&$,1/75".&%"+4"#-$ &= )1"3+","&-3"-$-$ &1/,7""& $5"% 3+/8$&: +9./,1$&: -1"/ +",/$% )

%/-"%

C1$5"$,,.$&:& -$#" > -$ & &

-1"-+$/5# .+- ?/,%$+"#-"%- /%6 .+&-1"#/,"7"8 &%-1"%/-":$2"&78-1$, .+-/&% -1",/$%$&-"+$> +%"+$,# &-$&.$&:-$55%/-") 1"+"35878?/8 /

$%/2$- 4 "-"#-$2" 5$#"

4-/-$ & /-/5/ 1/, 7""& $5"% $& -1" .+- $& ?1$#1 -1" /55":/-$ &, 5"2"55"% $&-1"/+"+"$-"+/-"%/&%$-$,,.7>$--"%-1/-,$&#"-1" 3"-$-$ &"+1/, /$5"%- %"3 ,$--1"/> .&- -1"?/,+":$,-"+"%)

= B"/+&"% # .&,"5 + -1" 3"-$-$ &"+ 1/, /+:."% -1/- -1" 3"-$-$ &"+?/,/2/$5$&:1$,5":/5+$:1-.&%"+-1" #-$&# &-",-$&:-1"

$&9.$+8 +"3 +-, $5$&: /33"/57"

+" -1"# >3"-"&-/.-1 +$-8?"55 ?$-1$&+$:1-/&%-1">/--"+?/, $&/558%"#$%"%78-1$, .+-2$%" +%"+ %/-"%

3/,,"%$&C ) !

/&%-$55-1"%"#$,$ &

-1$,?+$-3"-$-$ & $-#/&& -7"1"5%-1/--1"3"-$-$ &"+1/,# >>$--"%/&8

"&#"3.&$,1/75".&%"+4"#-$ &= ) B"/+&"%# .&,"5 +-1"3"-$-$ &"+1/, .+-1"+,.7>$--"%-1/- ?1"&-1",1 ?#/.,"& -$#"?/,$,,."%- -1"3"-$-$ &"+%$+"#-$&:1$>- %"3 ,$--1"/> .&- 1"1/, $5"%/+"358/&%5/-"+ & -1"3"-$-$ &"+?/, ,.,3"&%"% + >-1"3 ,- 4/+3/&#1/&%,$>.5-/&" .,58 -1"3+","&- ?/,: -+":$,-"+"% &/## .&- & &%"3 ,$- -1" .-,-/&%$&:/> .&- /:/$&,--1"3"-$-$ &"+)B"/+&"%# .&,"5 +-1"3"-$-$ &"+ .+-1"+,.7>$--"% -1/-78-1"-$>" -1$,?/,+":$,-"+"% &

-1"3"-$-$ &"+?/, & -1 5%$&:-1"3 ,- 4/+3/&#1/&%$&2$"? 4"#-$ &

( -1" #- & >">7"+ -1"/&#1/8/- +4/+3/&#1#/&7"1"5%5$/75" +/&8 /> .&-3/8/75"- -1"/&#1/8/- .&5",, -1" 5 #0 "2"5 3>"&-/&% /&#1/8/-

$#"+ / -"+/

+%$&:/& 33 +-.&$-8 1"/+$&:78 +%"+$& ?+$-$&:/,,",,-1"/> .&-%."- ?/+%,/3/&#1 +4/+3/&#1 &/## .&-

-1",.#15 ,, ?/,-" +>$,/33+ 3+$/-$ &) B"/+&"%# .&,"5 +-1"3"-$-$ &"+1/, .+-1"+,.7>$--"%-1/- +$:1-1/,7""&:$2"&- /,/+3/&#1 +3/&#1- #1/55"&:",.#1 +%"+ 3/,,"%78-1" 5 #0 "2"5 3>"&-/&%/&#1/8/-

$#"+7"

+"-1"

/33"55/-"/.-1 +$-8$)")4-/-" 2-)/&%-1"+" +" -1"+":$,-+/-$ & -1"

%/-"%

"2"&3+$ +- %"#$,$ & -1"/33"/5<?+$-3"-$-$ &

$5"%78-1"3"-$-$ &"+#1/55"&:$&:,.#1 +%"+2$%"?1$#1$-?/,1"5%-1/- -1"3"-$-$ &"+$,5$/75"- 3/8-1"/ +",/$%/> .&- = < & #+$>$&/55$/7$5$-8? .5%/+$,"- +":$,-"+-1".&%"+4"#-$ &= )- $, .+-1"+,.7>$--"%-1/-/ -"+-1"%"#$,$ & C ) !

$& ?1$#1/,3"#$ $#%$+"#-$ &?/,:$2"&- -1"&9.$+8

$#"+- -/0".3-1"

"&9.$+8/:/$&,/>" + >-1",-/:"?1"+"$-?/,3"&%$&: / -"+/

+%$&:

/& 33 +-.&$-8- -1"3"-$-$ &"+ +",1 +%"+7"3/,,"%/## +%/&#"?$-1 5/? / +",1 +%"+1/,7""&3/,,"%/&%-1"+"

+" -1"+":$,-+/-$ & /- $&$-$/5,-/:"?/,3+">/-.+") B"/+&"%# .&,"5 +-1"3"-$-$ &"+,.7>$--"%-1/-$&3.+,./&- - -1"%$+"#-$ &:$2"&78-1$, .+- /&/> .&- = </5+"/%8 7""& %"3 ,$-"% $& 3/&#1/8/- .&% $& 3.+,./&#" -1" +%"+ %/-"%

*3/,,"%$&-1$,#/,")-$, .+-1"+,.7>$--"%-1/- &-1" /#"

$- -1"/55":/-$ &,>/%"$&-1" &&";.+"< % & -# &,-$-.-"/&

"&#"3.&$,1/75".&%"+4"#-$ &= /,-1"$&9.$+8+"3 +-+"5$"% .3 &$&-1"?/,,"-/,$%"$&-"+>, -1"6.%:>"&-%/-"%

3/,,"%78-1$, .+-$&C ) !

& -1" -1"+ 1/&% 5"/+&"% # .&,"5 + -1" 4-/-" 1/, ,.7>$--"%-1/--1"$&9.",-$ &1/,7""&+":$,-"+"% &-1"%$+"#-$ & $,,."% 78 -1" "3.-8 >>$,,$ &"+ .+%/,3.+ /, -1" 3"-$-$ &"+ $& 3.+,./&#" -1" ,1 ? #/.," & -$#" /$5"% - %"3 ,$- -1" /> .&- -1"+"

+" -1"

"&#".&%"+4"#-$ &= 1/,7""&>/%")

-"+1"/+$&:5"/+&"%# .&,"5 +-1"3/+-$", $&%>"+$-$& -1"3+","&-3"-$-$ &)

%>$--"%58 ?1"&-1"$&9.$+8/:/$&,--1"3"-$-$ &"+,-/+-"%

( -1"3"-$-$ &"+?/,/2/$5$&:1$,5":/5+">"%8- #1/55"&:"-1",/$%+"3 +-$& -"+>, 4"#-$ &

( -1" #-78?/8 $5$&:/33"/57"

+"-1"

# >3"-"&-/.-1 +$-8/&%-1"+"/ -"+ 1" $5"%/?+$-3"-$-$ &$&-1$, .+-) +%"+%/-"%

3/,,"%78-1$, .+-$&C ) !

$, +"3+ %.#"%/,.&%"+'

#$ "

& '

!(" )*

+ &&

./ 0

0% "

!(" )*

3 4 !5&3&6278&)09 3:( 7/ "+.,/5 -1$, +%"+ ,1 ?, -1/- +":.5/+ $&9.$+8 +"3 +- &&";.+"

+>$&:7/,$, 1$,,.,3"&,$ &/,?"55/,+":$,-+/-$ &

-1" ?/,,"-/,$%" /&%-1"$&9.$+8

$#"+?/,%$+"#-"%- 3/,,/ +",1 +%"+/&%-1"+"

+" -1"2"+87/,$, +":$,-+/-$ & &&";.+"

-1/-$,-1" &9.$+8+"3 +-$,& > +"$&";$,-"&#") +" 2"+ -1" 3"-$-$ &"+$&-"+>, 4"#-$ &

( -1" #- / -"+ +",1$&9.$+8?/,

* # &%.#-"% /,3"+-1"%$+"#-$ &,:$2"&78-1$, .+-2$%" +%"+%/-"%

1/,/5+"/%8%"3 ,$-"%-1"/> .&- = <-1"+"

-1"

"&#".&%"+4"#-$ &= $,& ->/%" .- + >-1" /#- 7/+"

+"/%$&: -1") +-1"+"/, &,,-/-"%/7 2" -1$,3"-$-$ &$,/55 ?"%/&%-1" )

%/-"%

&&";.+"< +":$,-"+"%.&%"+4"#-$ & = /- 5$#"4-/-$ &1.>/& $,-+$#- /-/5//&%/55-1",.7,"9."&- 3+ #""%$&:,/+$,$&:-1"+"

+ >/+"9./,1"%) $%&'() '(*+ ,(*-,(.

/)*0

()

* ,% C1"-1"+,3"/0$&:<+"/, &"% ",< C1"-1"+"3 +-/75"

",<