High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/11964/2021disposed of

Suresh Kumar And ANR v. State Of Haryana And Others

2024-01-15Mr. Justice Jasgurpreet Singh Puri5 pages

!" #$%$!& '( ( )*+ %,-*.

+ &/ &!, + ((((( $$!& +% 0 +%*% ) !" &/!, +% ((((( %2!&/ &% 3453() )) + % & 3+( + 6), !+ &7/8!# "!+, 2 $$!& +( 3+( *+ 8$&/ 97//9(7 ( )) 7( :5;

( , 2+ % & $% 2 $$!& "$9 /*&/ ++$#9 %<=!", !&%$*$!&!" &/$ "!+$%%* &# !" >+$$&, & *+ !" .

.*% /$+ #$&?, + %2!&/ &% ! + 9 % , $& + % @ AB !&, / 9 1 /

1. &%!"2 &%$!& +1C & "$%!, 2 $$!& +%( ( +& / #!*&% 9 +$&? !& C , 9" !" , 2 $$!& +% %*C.$ / , C!, , 2 $$!& +% > + >!+D$&? $& , + %2!&/ &

+. & $( ( 05 &/ " +

$&$&? , ? !" %*2 + &&* $!&7 2 $$!& + !( + $+ / % ) &$!+ ++$ + %%$% & !& E (=( 2 $$!& +!( 9%!+ $+ /!&, % . / $( (E (=( %%%$% !+ .

&( "*+, +%*C.$ /, , 2 2 +%</!#*. &%2 + $&$&?!, ?+ &!"2 &%$!& +1C & "$%> + %*22!% /!C %*C.$ /

C!*%$F.!&,%2+$!+!, + $+ . &C*%$&# !> +/%, &/!"3 +#, $( ( +!*&/ (E(7 , + > % & !*C+ D !" !8$/

&/ .$# ,+!*?,!*, #!*&+1 &/9!#D/!>&> %$.2!% / &/, + " + 8 & #*+" >> % 9%!$.2!% / &/, + "!+ 7, 2 $$!& +%#!*9/&!"$9 , 2 &%$!&/!#*. &%<2 2 +%C "!+ , $++ $+ . &( 9%!%*C.$ /,

, + " +C!,, 2 $$!& +%+ $+ /!&E (=( &/C # *% !",

$/+ %!&7, /!#*. &%#!*9/&!C %*C.$ /$&$. (, + " +7 !& (A(7C!,, 2 $$!& +%%*C.$ /, $+/!#*. &%2 + $&$&?!

2 &%$!& +1C & "$%%$&# , 2!$&!"$. 7, !8$/

&/ .$#> %!8 +C*, + " +7, + %2!&/ &% 9,!*?,2+!# %% /, 2 &%$!& 2 2 +% C* 2 $/ , 2 &%$!& &/ 2 &%$!& +1 C & "$% ! , 2 $$!& +% " + 9 2% !"%!. $. "!+>,$#,, 1 + &$9 /"!+$& + %( "*+, + %*C.$ / , 2 $$!& + !( > % 2 $/ , 2 &%$!& 2 &%$!& +1C & "$%!&'(( &/2 $$!& +!(> %2 $/, C & "$% !& A(E( ( 9%!%*C.$ /, , + , %C & / 9 1!"= A.!&,% $&+ 9 % !"2 &%$!& +1C & "$%!"C!,, 2 $$!& +% &/"!+ , , + $%&! F29 $!& %!>,1, + , %C &%*#, / 9 1 #!&% G* &917 C!, , 2 $$!& +% + &$9 / "!+ $& + % !& / 9 1 /

1. &%( + " ++ /!, 6*/?. &!"*99 &#,!",$%!*+2 %% /$& H()( &/, > 0%() !"*&6 C &/!, +%I7

=:E;)A7 !

#!& &/, , 2 &%$!& +1C & "$% + $.. /$ 912 C9 !

2 +%!&7>,!, %+ $+ /7*&9 %%, + $% 9 ?

9$.2 /$. &"!+&!?$8$&?

, % . ( E( &, !, +, &/73+( *+ 8$&/ 979 +& ///9(((7 >,$9 + " ++$&? ! , + 291 "$9 / C1 , + %2!&/ &% $?

%*C.$ /, C!,, 2 $$!& +%+ $+ /!&E (=( &/, 1%*C.$ / , $+2 &%$!&/!#*. &%!& (A( &/, + " +7/* ! */$%#+*$&1 !"% +8$# C!!D &/+ 8$ >!"E+/!C% +8 $!&%$&, # % !"2 $$!& + !( &/2 1"$F $!&$%%* %$&, # % !"2 $$!& +!(7, "$9 %> + .!8 /C > &8 +$!*%!""$# %!"05 &//* !, "!+ . &$!& / .!8 . & !" "$9 % C > & , /$"" + & !""$# % !" 05 &/ 9%!

#!&% G* &!*C+ D!"!8$/

&/ .$#7, !""$# %> + >!+D$&?$&

+ %+$#$8 .

&& +7, $// 9 1, /!##*++ / &/%*#,/ 9 1> %/* !*& 8!$/ C9 #$+#*.% &# %>,$#,> %C 1!&/, #!&+!9!" &%> +$&?

+ %2!&/ &% &/, + "!+ 7, 2 $$!& +% + &! &$9 /"!+ &1$& + %!& , / 9 1 /2

1. &%( (

, 8 , +/, 9 +& /#!*&% 9%"!+, 2 +$ %( '( !,, 2 $$!& +%, /

$& /, ? !"%*2 + &&* $!& + $+ / !& E (=( &/ , 1 #!*9/ &! %*C.$ , $+ 2 &%$!& /!#*. &%<2 2 +%C "!+ , $++ $+ . &C # *% $$%> 99D&!>&, $&, &$+ #!*&+17 , 9!#D/!>& > % $.2!% / /* ! !8$/

&/ .$# !> +/%, &/!"3 +#,7(!> 8 +7, 2 $$!& +%%*C.$ /, /!#*. &%2 + $&$&?!2 &%$!& +1C & "$%!& (A(( , + + >!+ %!&%>,$#,, 8 C &+ " ++ /!C1, 9 +& /)

!*&% 9>,$9 + " ++$&?!+ 291"$9 /C1, $? .($+%917/* ! */$ %#+*$&1!"% +8$# C!!D &/+ 8$ >!"E+/!C% +8 $!&%$&, # % !"

2 $$!& +!( &/2 1"$F $!&$%%* %$&, # % !"2 $$!& +!(7, "$9 %> + .!8 /C > &8 +$!*%!""$# %!"05 &/% #!&/917/* !

!8$/

+ %+$#$!&%7$. > % D &!2+!# %%, "$9 %C # *% $, /!

?!"+!.!& !""$# ! &!, +(

(

$% % 9 /9 >, $& + / 2 +. & 9.!8 . &!""$9 %$& $% 9"$%&!?+!*&/"!+/ 9 1$&?, 2 &%$!& +1C & "$%! &1 .29!1 %$&# ?+ &!"2 &%$!& +1C & "$%$% !&%$*$!& 9$?, ?* + & /*&/ ++$#9 E !", !&%$*$!&!" &/$ %$&# $$%

$?,!+!2 +1(, + "!+ 7!& !", ?+!*&/% D &C1, + %2!&/ &%

., /* !$& + .!8 . &!""$9 %C > &, /$"" + &!""$# %7, / 9 1!##*++ /# &&!C ## 2 /()!"

+ %, + %+$# />!+D$&?!", !""$# %/* !!8$/

&/ .$#$%#!&# +& /7, 9%!# &&!C #!.

?+!*&/"!+/ 9 1$&2 &%$!& +1C & "$%C # *% 8 &$"$$%+ %+$# / >!+D$&?7 !2 2+$!+$1 %,!*9/ , 8 C & ?$8 & ! , + $+ 9<2 &%$!& C & "$% &/ %2 #$ 991$&8$ >!", "

#, 2 !29 > + 9+ /1%*"" +$&?

/* !!8$/

&/ .$#( =( !> 8 +7%$&# , 2 $$!& +%, 8 %*C.$ /, /!#*. &% 2 + $&$&?!2 &%$!& +1C & "$% " +, $++ $+ . &$( (!& (A( 9 %>!.!&,%J$. $% 6*%$"$ C9 2 +$!/!"$. "!+ 2+!# %%$&?, /!#*. &%"!+>,$#,, 2 $$!& +%>$99&!C &$9 /"!+ ?+ &!"$& + %( A(

&8$ >!", C!8 7, 2+ % &2 $$!&$%2 +91 99!> /(, 2 $$!& +%%, 99C &$9 /"!+?+ &!"$& + %@B2 + &&*. " +>!

.!&,%"+!., / !", $++ $+ . &$99, / !&>,$#,, 2 &%$!&

+1C & "$%> + /$%C*+% /!, 2 $$!& +%( &!, +>!+/%7, +$?,!"$& + %%, 99% +"+!. ( ($99, / !"/$%C*+% 9(,

$/$& + %%, 99C 2 $/!, 2 $$!& +%>$,$& 2 +$!/!",+ .!&,%"+!.!/ 1 " +# 9#*9 $&?, % . C1, + %2!&/ &% $?

.( # % 7, $/ .!*&$%&!2 $/!, 2 $$!& +%>$,$& 2 +$!/!"

,+ .!&,%"+!.!/ 17, &, 2 $$!& +%%, 99C &$9 /"!+"**+ $& + %@ B2 + &&*.$&% /!"B2 + &&*.( '( ( :)) ;

,*.$D

( , , +%2 D$&?<+ %!& / %<!

( , , ++ 2!+ C9 %<!