M/S Syngenta India Ltd. And Others v. State Of Punjab
!"#$"%& '"'& (% &" )%*$
+ ,- %&%$ ).
+/"0&1
2 &3- 67 ,89 &
7 ,89 &
':
379 	 +-:4
;;;;
2 7 4 < + =-7 4 "
, > >7
? 9 8< 9 >79 (-7 9 @>AB9 9 &9 C9 2- 74< AB AB &9 ?
-<9 &D- + &D- + 2 - 0- < 3 ' <9 >7 <3 ?
<< =- < 2 3 78 2-
4
&3 -<- <28 ) 9 >79 A '2B - 7 28 > >7
? 9 8< 9 >79 (-7 <
5
87
37 2 89 7 < 2 '2
2 6 8
2 2 *57< E # F 52G 8-- 2 *<7 +- 9 #:-< A/+B 86 " 7 & 6 3 9 7 43
26
'2 < 43
26 2 *57< E # 4 47 " * # @9 8--
D2 5 C 43 2 '2 7 6 - 2 *57< E # 2-2 82< 2 @ 82< @ 38 7 2 *57< E # F 52G <<?
- 2- ) 2 82< 87
37 2 8 < ? 2 82< 62
2 2
7 &3 -<- ) 9 (-7 ) 2 82< <45 &8
<5 & 2 2 <5 82< 8 < ' 2
2
@E # 3 E # 7-9 82< %7 7?
- <9 8-- 825
) =- <9 82< < (459 . 4 8 4 2
2 *57< @E # 3 E # =- <5 29
82-3
@
&D- + < 7 -88
&D- +
@ -< 7 -48 82< ? 8 < 263 '2 %7 7
7 7?
< 43 8 7 82< 6 82 ?
5 ?5 ' 7 4 -7 35 4 7 2 4< 8 =-< 5 < 2- 8-- 2 *<7 +- ' 7 4 -7 3- 39 7< 2 4< <<3 5
82< 7 ' 7 4 -7 7
7 4< 7 4
8--9 < 4- ?
9 75 -<<5 ? 4- 5
-< 7 -7 3- 7< -<5 4< & ' -22 9 -< 7 2< < -2 -
C
9
9 @C
9 @ @
9 ) 7 79 -< < -22
82-3 7 <<3
8
' 7 4 3-
9 82<
4
8-7<9 7 4
<4< ' 7 4 -7
3 4< 2-9 4
8--9 < 4- ?
6?<39 %7 4< & ' -22 9 -< 7 <5 2 -48 <5 % (45 < % (459 . 49 2 79 82< 8 '
2
2 23
-< 7 -7
-89 3-
8 - =-7
82-3
'
7 -48 8 -< 2 C 1 2
89
?-< 222 D8 < 2 <?
3
!
!
" #
$
%& '
" (
%& '
"
#
(
%
$
)(
%&
‟
*+
"
$
& , *
$
$
& "
"
$
"
*' "
-
.
"
& /
* "
0 1
+ 0 1
+
&2 &,
3 3
2- & < 3- 82< 6 8 28 > >7
? 9 >7 <5
<45 8--
'
2- "
825 " @
2 4<
=- 7 8-- 2 *<7 +- '
< 22 82<
=- ? 8 < 26 7-9
7 5 6?<3 4- < 263 '
< 22
82< 6 8 < 26 8-- <
8 9 < 4- 35 < 3 2 @ A@B & 2 4<
73 - 4- 8-- 825 2 4< =-< 5 <
8-- 8-- 825 <5
<
=-
7-9 7< 2 4< <<3 5
82< 7< -4<
9 82< ' 37 49 -
?
2
=-<5 :-38 17 -
@@
9 -
!""#$%& %'
A-2B9 $%& %'
A-2B
)''!
*+$%& %'A-2B9 -<
' ?
4 - 9 2
<<? '82-3
A&D- +B A&D- +B << =- < 2 3 78 =- =-7 ,-./,.,0
!" 1+'2+'#%!' 3
*4#' %"
')5 '%4"
1+'2+'##'!"#2 6 '5 '%4"