Jai Bhagwan v. State Of Haryana
!" # $ % '(
) *!% +( , -
.%/ 01 *
, #
.%/ *!!"21 *31 '(
)
+(
6%
! 7%!/ )
+(
% * 2 &
%!
1 .2 "
+( )) 2
! 7%!/ 8
8 )
% % 2 ,!
2
1 .2
9 ) ( % : 9# " )2( /
)
% 9 ( 1 "
% : 9# " %) 2
+
) +2
#2 */+2 ( " - :::
( !
! ;9 - :::1
% -#& * "
;
&
<+(1 , %+ = >;&< , %+?@
% +
( !
! ;9 -: 8::81
% "
& 9#1 #2
( */+2
( !
! - ::
1 % #1 #2 ( */+21 2! "
) ;&< ! +
9 /)2
1 ) !
(
! ;9 - :::
;&< , %+
(
)
) 2! "
) ;&<1
! ;9 -: 8::8 2
(
) 2 2! "
) ;&< - ::
/ 5 1 % )2
:::1
) 2 ) ;&< !
! ;9 -: 8::8 ) ;&< !
! - ::
,'
)2
A ! +%
(1
" " )
(
! ;9 -: 8::8 ) 2
! - ::
2 , %+ =
.2@ / !
( "
+( / "
,' 5 / +%!
)2 %
%22(1 ;9 "
! A /)2
! 1 22 "
% 922B ,!
1 .2 *
! / %1 !
/ %
& : 9#1 "
)2 !% 2( 2 2 9 )
1 )
C/ : "
22
#D / # 21 <+( *
1
(
1 ;&<1 , %+ ) 2 EC# :::1 EC# ::
EC# ::: '
2 EC# EC#
!%
'
2
%/ ) )
2 '
%
%
! 1
2 0 )
+( )2
/ EC# #D 9 " & ! 1 &%+ 9 =
@ " % )
! ) / / EC# '
)
2 %
EC#
%
)2 / / / EC# EC#1
2( 9
C/ 1
/ 2 %/ " 0
+( )2 #D & - 1 9 6&'A1 #2 ( */+21
(
! ;9 - :::
;&< , %+ !
+0
( 2! "
) !
! ;9 -: 8::8 - ::
A :::1 / +0
2
" " ) ! ;9 -: ) 2 ! - 2 9
!1 ) " 22 / ;&<
, %+ EC#8
)
)1 /
B%
%+/ ) EC#:1 "
2 !% 2( 8 #D & ! 1 *
&%+ 9 1 )% 1 "
/ ) #2
( */+2 / ::8 ::: )(
" )2 : #D & / <21 &%+ 9 ) /2 ;9
! !
;9 #D *&9 . & ! 1 ,6,'
! ! !
(
;9 - ::: !
!
/
;&< , %+ '
%
+
( ) ! ;9 -: ::8 - ::
2! "
) ;&<1 / ;&< , %+1
% '
% + 22 ! /
;9 ) %/ EC#D 6*1 EC#D 6 1 EC#D 61 EC#D 6
) EC#D 6E #D 9 " & ! 1 *
&%+ 9 )
2( ( ) ::: EC#D6*1
( ! ;9 - :::
;&< , %+ '
+ 22 ! /
;9 "
! /
)))
( +( #D81 E' /+
::::1 2!
)2 %
! )
21 / %
/ / /
EC# #D: +2 -
.%/
8::81
(
;&< , %+ ;
22(1
2
+(
% & #
)2 2
/)2 '"
1 2 (
*
2 )
1 %
9 )
( % : 9# 7%!/ 6 8
! !!
1 ) )) 21 "
"
+( % * 2 &
%!
1 .2 7%!/ "
) / )
/)
+( 2 % " % ( !%
/)
/ 6 "
/)
%2 )(/ 1 % % ! 9 )
/ 1 % : 9#
) ! 7%!/ 6 )
% 2" 8 %
2 "
!
#D %)2 "
%/
+2( )
22
! ;9 -: 8::8 - ::
9
% EC#D6* :::
"
!
!/ ( % %( " 2( !
;&< , %+1
( ! ;9 - :::1
#2 ( */+2 9
% %+/ )
+2( )
EC# EC#
" ! +
!%
5
!%
! /) "
!%
9
%
% ( 2 2 " )%
1 "
+( % 22
( / ;&< , %+ 9
%
)
% /
2
1
B%
/
))) )
22 9
% !%
/)%! 7%!/ 6
% +2
+
: A 1 %
2 "
%)) !
7%!/ B%
%+/ )
/ %
) %2( % 22
;9 -: 8::8 - ::
/
;&< , %+1 +%
"
/
))) )
!
"
9
%
)
+
9
%+/
/ +( %
2
)
*/ 2(
( 2
! ;9 -: 8::8 % 6 9# #2 ( */+21 "
;&< , %+ EC#D 6*
2+( ::::8
) EC#D 6 5 +
(
! ;9 -: 8::81 " /)
) 2 +% 2
2(1
) 2 !2
+2 =B% @ ! 0
2
) 2 )2 ! 0
2 ;/ % 2 EC#1 ))
(
) 2
! - ::
% #1 #2 ( */+2 "
;&<1 , %+ %2( ::
22
!
"
;9 -: 8::8 - ::
2! "
) ;&<1 , %+ '"
1 22
) ;&<1 /
))) "
)
( ) ! ;9 -: 8::8
) 2 ! - ::
* - ::: EC#D6*1 )
(
) 2 !/
/)2
/)
! ;9 - ::: % -#& * #2 ( */+21 "
;&< , %+ 9
EC#D6*1
/ 22
=) @ ) ;&< 2
! ;9 -: 8::8 % 6 9# #2 ( */+2 - ::
% # #2 ( */+21 / ;&<1 , %+ :::
"
! " 22
;9 -: 8::8 - ::
2! "
) ;&<1 "
)% ) +(
*/ 2(1 ::: EC#D6* "
%) +(
"
!
9
)) C ( :::1 "
% #2 ( */+21 - ::: " '"
%/ "
/0
+(
)
E * 2( ) )(
2+2 %
/
)
/
+2 ;/ % 2
) )( :::1
+ +( #D " & ! 1 ,' '"
1
)2 2 "
))
+C #D ) ( % ::: "
" ) %
)2
! ;9 -:
8::8 - ::
1 #D . &
:
!
/20 #2 ( */+2 E 1 #D 2
( ! ! ! ! ( % ::: 9
;&< , %+ " 2 ::: =EC#@ / &%) #2 1 ( */+2 )2 2 "
)) 2 % ( 22
( ;&< )
! ;9 -: 8::8 % 6 9# #2 ( */+2 5
2 " /0 ,6,' %! &'A #2
( */+21 /)2 ;/ % 2 EC#
%/
) ::: +( ,6,' . & ! 22 ) ;&<
( ! 2
! ;9 -: 8::8 % & 6 9# #2 ( */+2 '"
1 . & ! "
))
+C #D
! EC#
"
" +0
EC# 9
C/ #D
/)2( ! % ( 2 ) 22
(1 +%
2 % ( 2 '
% / % ( 2
+
!%
% ( 2
% +( /
/
% +( ;&<1 , %+
/
+ /
9 +0)
/
/ +( #D
C/ 1
)
6" ! )) ! +0
EC# 2"1 "
)%) + " +( #D . & ! 9 %/
1 )
) /)2 2 EC#1 )) 2 % ( "
% %
22
( B%
/ ;&< , %+ 8 %/ EC#D 6 #D 6E !
(
! -: 8::8 % & # #2 ( */+2 "
/)
) 2
) 2 ! %/
( "
;&< , %+ 8::8
%/ ! + !
: 9
)
%
) ) ;&<
! ;9 -: 8::8
)) ! +0
EC#
) 2 ) ;&<
- ::
% #
)) ! +0
EC#1 +( ;&< , %+ 9
)
+
!%
)
/
! "
! "
% / +(
2 ;&< , %+ 5
"
" !
!%
)) !
EC# EC#
2( * %/ EC# EC# 1 #D /) 2 2 ;&< , %+ ( " ! )
%/ '
%
!" =) @ " ) 22( 0" /
"
/ " ! * 1 #D
! EC# EC#
+% // 2(1 1
+
%/
!
G%+ 2(1
" !
!%
%/ '"
1
/0 ( !
/)
" !
!%
+
1 "
/ " !
!%
" / +( #D 9 " & ! = &9@ "
!
2 %
EC#
% +
#2 A
/
+2
+
2 %
1 (
( "
)2 * 1 #D 9 & -( " &'A #2 ( */+2
C/ 1 / ,' ! ( /)2 " !
/ 22 ::: 5
+2
/ ) % 2 EC#8 EC# :1 + " / ::: ;% 1 #D " "0 ! >,%
?
#2 ( */+21 /
C/
" 2
+( ;&< , %+ ;% / )) %/ 2 " 0 )
+(
! ! % !
!
5
" / +(
! ! / 2( #D 9 " & ! "
))
+C
+2
/ ) % 2 ( / / EC#
9 ! +
%
1
)
22
B%
/ ;&< , %+ % 1
% / +( 2 ;&< , %+ */ 2(1
22
2 7%
%2
% % 2(
2 %
! )) 22
7%
'"
1
2 )"
+
)))
/( +
(
7% %+ 7% /
"
2 1 %
9
2"
/% )
?
( +2 %+ ! %
9
1 + % 2" 0
2 % ( 2
%/ +(
B%
"
"
)% "
"
% 2 ;% 1 / 2 %/
:::
+(
% 22
B%
/ ;&< , %+ ::: "
+(
% / ;&< , %+
/20 !
) )
E * 9
1 2 "
%1
%! )% )
/) % (1
! ' ! ! %/
+ 1
)
% :
9# ! 1 + ( " %+
%22(1
)
22"
7%!/ )
% * 2 &
%!
1 .2 7%!/ 6 8 )
% % ,!
2
1 .2
B%
"
!
!"#!"$%&"'()*+,$"'%-*"./ "%,- !"#!"$$"&-$#'01"/ "%,-