Sushila Alias Sushila Devi v. Union Of India Through Secretary

    
 

  !  " 
! 

!#$% &' (%)*+*&,  -- ./+0*1# #1*#+ ./+0*1# !%2* ------ %$*$*&,%3 4%3+/+ ,*&, &' ,(*# #,( &$0%3+ ------ %+5&,(%,$+

  6 7

- .
  . 

3%+%,$ 

3- #,* #8 4%38#9 (2&)#$% '&3 $0% 5%$*$*&,%3-

3- +0*+0 :#5&&39 (2&)#$% '&3 3%+5&,(%,$ &- - - -  . 

-

7 - 3#;%3 *, $0*+ )*2*1 <3*$ 5%$*$*&, '*1%( /,(%3 3$*)1%+   &'
&,+$*$/$*&, &' ,(*#9 *,$%3 #1*#9 *+ '&3 *++/#,)% &' # <3*$ *, $0% ,#$/3% &' )%3$*&3#3* '&3 )#,)%11*,= $0% #11&$8%,$ &' 7 !*+$3*>/$&3+0*5 *, '#2&/3 &' 3%+5&,(%,$ &-  #,( '&3 '/3$0%3 ?/#+0*,= $0% 3%51; (#$%( --

,,%@/3% A- - 7%#3,%( )&/,+%1 #55%#3*,= '&3 5%$*$*&,%3 0#+ 3%*$%3#$%( $0% #2%38%,$+ 8#(% *, $0% *,+$#,$ )*2*1 <3*$ 5%$*$*&,- -

, $0% &$0%3 0#,(9 3- +0*+0 :#5&&39 (2&)#$% 0#+ #55%#3%( &, >%0#1' &' 3%+5&,(%,$ &-  ,(*#, *1
&35&3#$*&, 7*8*$%( #,( 0#+ 0#,(%( &2%3 )&5; &' #, &3(%3 (#$%( A--9 5#++%( >; # )&&3(*,#$% %,)0 &' $0*+
&/3$ *,
A9 *,
&/3$ $&(#; <0*)0 *+ $#B%, &, 3%)&3( +/>C%)$ $& #11 C/+$ %@)%5$*&,+D <0%3%>; #, %#31*%3 <3*$ 5%$*$*&,9 '*1%( >; 5%$*$*&,%3 <#+ (*+5&+%( &'9 >; &>+%32*,= #+ /,(%3 


    

                   

      



 

                       

       

        

  

     - 0*1% 3%'%33*,= $& $0% #>&2% %@$3#)$%( &3(%39 3- +0*+0 :#5&&39 (2&)#$% +/>8*$+ $0#$ *, $0% 53%+%,$ 5%$*$*&,9 #1$0&/=0 5%$*$*&,%3 0#+ 8%,$*&,%( 3%=#3(*,= '*1*,= &' # <3*$ 5%$*$*&,
A >%'&3% $0*+
&/3$D 0&<%2%39 5%$*$*&,%3 0#+ *,$%,$*&,#11;9 ,%*$0%3 51#)%( &, 3%)&3( )&5; &' &3(%3 (#$%( A--9 ,&3 $0% '#$% &' +#*( <3*$ 5%$*$*&, 0#+ >%%, 8%,$*&,%( *, $0% *,+$#,$ )*2*1 <3*$ 5%$*$*&,- $ *+ '/3$0%3 )&,$%,(%( $0#$ +*,)% %#31*%3 <3*$ 5%$*$*&, <#+ (%)*(%( &, A--9 $0%3%'&3%9 $0% *,+$#,$ )*2*1 <3*$ 5%$*$*&, 0#+ >%%, '*1%( )1%#31; >%;&,( $0% 5%3*&( &' $03%% ;%#3+ #,( *+ 1*#>1% $& >% (*+8*++%( &, #))&/,$ &' (%1#; #,( 1#)0%+- -  0#2% 0%#3( 1%#3,%( )&/,+%1 '&3 3%+5%)$*2% 5#3$*%+ #,( 5%3/+%( $0% 5#5%3>&&B <*$0 $0%*3 #>1% #++*+$#,)%- - !

3&8 # 5%3/+#1 &' <3*$ 5%$*$*&,9 *$ *+ 8#(% &/$ $0#$ *, $0% >&(; &' 5%$*$*&,9 $0%3% *+ ,& 8%,$*&, #+ 3%=#3(+ )*3)/8+$#,)%+ /,(%3 <0*)0 #'&3%+#*( <3*$ 5%$*$*&,
A <#+ '*1%( >%'&3% $0*+


&/3$ #,( <0#$ <#+ $0% '#$% &' +#*( <3*$ 5%$*$*&,- , 8; )&,+*(%3%( 2*%<9 $0% 5%$*$*&,%3 0#+ )&,2%,*%,$1; )&,)%#1%( $0% '#)$/8 &' 5#++*,= &' &3(%3 (#$%( A-- >; $0*+
&/3$ *,
A- 0#$ #5#3$9 $0% *,+$#,$ )*2*1 <3*$ 5%$*$*&, 0#+ >%%, '*1%( >; $0% 5%$*$*&,%3 #'$%3 8&3% $0#, $03%% ;%#3+ '3&8 $0% (#$% &' 5#++*,= &' &3(%3 (#$%( A--- - ,
    

             

9 # !*2*+*&, %,)0 &' $0*+
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
&/3$ *, )#+% &' !"

#$ 

    %&'((( )*- - 2*(%,$1;9 5%$*$*&,%3 0#( %#31*%3 '*1%( <3*$ 5%$*$*&,

A9 <0*)0 <#+ &3(%3%( $& >% (*+8*++%( #+ <*$0(3#<,9 2*(% &3(%3 (#$%( A--9 <*$0 1*>%3$; $& $0% 5%$*$*&,%3 $& )0#11%,=% #11&$8%,$ &' (*+$3*>/$&3+0*5 $& # $0*3( 5%3+&,D 0&<%2%3 (%+5*$% >%*,= #<#3% &' #11&$8%,$ $& # $0*3( 5%3+&,9 ,& #)$*&, <#+ $#B%, >; 5%$*$*&,%3 '&3 $03%% ;%#3+- - , 2*%< &' $0% #>&2%9 $0% *,+$#,$ )*2*1 <3*$ 5%$*$*&, 0#2*,= >%%, '*1%( #'$%3 $03%% ;%#3+ '3&8 $0% 5#++*,= &' &3(%3 (#$%( A-- *,


A9 )1%#31; +/''%3+ '3&8 (%1#; #,( 1#)0%+ #,( $0% +#8% *+ #))&3(*,=1;9 (*+8*++%(- - %,(*,= #551*)#$*&, +9 *' #,;9 +0#11 #1+& +$#,( )1&+%(-

 . 

! -- +CB+ 0%$0%3 +5%#B*,= 3%#+&,%(  "%+ & 0%$0%3 3%5&3$#>1%  "%+ &