High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/5254/2005disposed of

Nirmal Singh v. Punjab State Civil Supplies Corp. Ltd.

2019-09-30Mr. Justice Harsimran Singh Sethi30 pages

!"!#!

$!!! !#!

# %% &'

( )( )

''*+ +

*,** ,

*+ )

+ ,

++,

',* *

) ,

) !"

,*,

+'' #

'+* $"

+) , #

*'+ ,

), * (%

)' * "

' *

)+ * $

+'' , (%

)

+ ' ")

+)'+ ,

,,' ,

', +

* )

+++ ) #

)* )

) %

)), ) $

)

), ) !

),+ )

+* )

), + )

)

)+' ,

++'* * +,*

+ , +,*

,+ + ! *

+ + *

,'' , %

, *

, * *%

+ + #

* ,

(

* , ! *

++ ) '

*,) * (

* *

' )

* * , ! *

' ) '

', *

) * (

', * %

' )

, )

+, * *

', + *

* (%

) *

!-& ."/- ( 0!

0- !00

- ' + ' )#"&

/0/1)20340)225/6)20278&044/ .

/0/6&0423

)#"&

2183)24236)/061&04269 .

238/8)52/1&0423 .

28234)02540)0/843)2/84)0270)04537: 04711&0425

244//)24011)/321)7346)73//)7364)7540 7734&0427

' #

)#"&

24066)24018)20465)2228/)24824)24030&0427

' + ' )#"& .

;20125&044/

' *

)#"% ' #

) #"& .

07/68&0423

' %

)#"& .

1/16&0426

' )#"&

1830&0426

' * )#"% ' # )#" & .

;27111&0423

' *

)#"& .

;08856&0426 .

;8654&042/

' $ )#"& .

;05355&0423

' )#"& .

;00526&0427 .

;3523&0446

' #

)#"& .

;2835/&0425 .

;68/8&042/

' * $ )#"& .

;71/1&042/

' #

)#")& <

' = + )#"& .

;27111&0423

' # # )#"& .

;68/8&042/

' )#"& < .

24030)24018)24066)24011)244//)2228/ 7734&0427 ' ' %)#" & < .

7346)73//)7364) 7540)20465)&0427 .

04711)26685&0425 ' #

)#" & ;

21/15) 238/8& 0423

' = + )#"& .

02540&0425 ' #*)#"& 2 0 .

;545/&0423

' %)#"& < .

1/16 /061&0426

' *)##$)

>>>

+ !

0- !001 ( (, " ) "

&% )&% "

) " % ? &% &"

@ "

&% ) ,)% &

)A ) "

& &" " " ," B "

" & < " % " , " "& "

)% "

"" % " & & " , " " & & , " " ,& & %% ") ",) % ) & % "

) " && "

," "" , " " % " ," & ) "&"% "

, )% "

" &

" < "

," "" ," " % " ," & ) "& "

, " " ," & , " & ) ") "

)% ,

B") , " &

@ " &

"% "

= ? &%)% "

% )% ),

" ," & & , " % " , " ,& <

" , " & " " , " & " @ ") , " % " , " & " ," & ) "" , , C " ,% , " ," & " % " ," & ) <" , " & , % " @ % ) ) % "

" ," & " " ," & ", ", % = ? & % , " , ! A &@ %, "

* = ! A&@ % " # 0242 & 2777 " 2% %

3( "

(0((( ")

"&" &" ," & & ,) " & &" " & ", -;

!"#

$ ! A&@

0% 23(0

'5'60+) ," ) % "

& " % , ," , " " " & )% , " , &&") , % & -;

()

)

() $ = " ? &%) % ) ,% ,&"" "

,% "" " & )% " .

2/013&0422 0(( % 3-

2% 2#%

) -;

D#& & ", % )& )" , ,)% % ,) , = )% "

" &") % & % "

" , " & ) E" )

" & , &" = % " ) & , ")" " & %

,! A

A " )% % "& "&" &&" " ,

) " " " @ %&, &" ) " ") & % "

" ," ) , ) " & "

; & % " C"" , .

&& %

B ) "; ( "

& , , 0(( % . 578 6 % " 2%

9 :( ;

0 % 79. 8 %3 < < 0 1 56/ + -;

D3 C && )" ) ) 273/) " ,)% % ,) , @" ," , , & ) " , "

) ," &"

= % " " ,& %

, ! A

0% 230

'5+60 & 0(0(!;

3 ;

"%4<% :%

%2 91

=7<

)5*60/ /8 @% & "& ,"&" &&") " " " < ) " , %% & 0(( % . 578 6( @ %& &" % )" %

"&"

, , & ) "

% " #"" ,) % "

20 0420% & % "

0420 = " & % &% & &"&"&",& F #& % % ? &% , " ",

! A&@ %, % ,"&" " , " , " & " " , " & ) , " " ," ,% ,& " " " " < & <

) ""

% % ,

" ;

" % "

) , "") & " ," & & , @ "& ,)" &, ;

," " % " , " & " ," , # % % " 2% %

. 578 69

0% 2. 578 6> 0(( % . 578

9. 578 6) , ,

" ," ," % " ," & & , " , " "& ,"

) " % , " ," ,& " " ," & B ) "" 0 0& "

), ;

)% "

% ,

" % " , " ") & " , " "& "

)% "

&, & & " ," ) " ,&

= & 0 0&

" ,% " )% ) ,% % , && & B"% ) " & <

)

" " ," & &," % " ," & ) % " ,E&,) %% " " & ", ,&&% "&%,& " &&" " " , " "&" ) ",), &" & ?, "

& < % " .

;06305&04217% 0% 23(7 ?!2 7% 8 % 5!6/ 01 0423

)

% " & " , " ," % " , " ,) %%

&"& ?, &"

' " & &"& ?, " " , " & " & ," " & " % "

, < &%, 7% 0% 2. "

@ % )% "

","& 82 4/ 0427) % "

&% %-; D " & % .

28003&0426

)% &%%

",& "

;

) " & & ( "

4/ 0427 ) )% "

"" % % "

,& , %)" ?& "" & & ," % " ",, % && % " , & & ;

) " &

# ( )

' ") ) " ) , ,) ?," , " ,&"& ?,%" " "

%% % ,& " " ,% "

% ,% "

% " ") ,&""

% & ," &" & ,)% "

, &&, ) % " %

@ " , , && " " &"& ?,) &,

; " & " , " "

; "& )% "

; & " " & )% "

) " , " & & " % ?,&&" "&"

; ,) ?,) ?,% &&"& & , , " %& % , "& & , ?,&&" " " & ,

,& && "& % "

, ) " ), E&

* % ) " & ), " & "

, , " % "" " % &%) && ) %

" & %

& &) % " )% "

%"& E&

# 84 # ",& " && " "" " &&

% ) " ,

& "

)% "

,&" " " ,"

% " )% "

, "

% ? &" & ?,) % , " " , E"

)% "&& "" ) " &" & ?,) & , < ", "

< "&" ) ",

" & < ", " &"& ?,% ,& ")% "

& 7% 0% 2. ) &) "

& " " " ," & , " )% ,& ) % &"

" & " "

&, " )

% "

& " % " ," & ) ",& "

" "" ,%&"

& , % , B( "

& % "

+ , B( "

!(0(

@ . 578 6 ,% && , &% & " B( "

% & "

% %% " & &") &, ) &) ",& "

" "" & , % ,&" ) " " ,%,& & & , & , &

" & " & & , & % "

)% "

) , && %%

) & " & &&" , & & %

)& ) ",& "

)% "

& %

" && ") " " & "

) && ,)&% "

, &$,#")2730% & " %& " )% "

& ", & )& ,)", "

, % &" & ?,) &) &" & ?, " ? " " ",

" & "&%) &) & , & "

&" " & " & )@ "

" " "

& " " ," & " %

" ," & & ,)%

& & , ;

% , " # , & & < , &% & && C " &%%

, < % ," ) " % "

%, " & )" ""

C " & "

& " )", % %% " ," , "

"" & % "

& % %

) &) %

& &)% ")

") " "& %

&% % &" <" ) , " & ")% "

, &&") %& %% !(0(

@ . "

* & -;

D " , " , & &

), ," & & #% % &" "" "&"

" ,% E" % & & % "

% , #E '

@& " ,& & "& , , , && & ,) , &"

" ) ) ,%, " , & &, % & , ); ( "

& ! "

#$%&' ( ()** % , <,) ,% & & -;

D= & & &" A , , , @ & & , @& " , , " & % % ,, ,

" " " " & & &

@ "" ") & " & " ,% "

, % ",& % , @ % ) )% "

&& "

)% ,

) % ," & ,) ") " & " , !(0(

@ . 578 6 (0( 9 . 578 6& &

= & " & " " %

" &)& ,),

,&& &", ) ") )" "" #&,) & & , & , " % , &" & "& @ " & , & & , &)" , " & @ ") ,? &) & & ",& ,)% "

", ") " "% , ) ,)% && &" , %)

& " %

, && ) " &

& G3H ,& &, & "

& @ ""& &E, &% & & )

" & )&% "

"% &% & &"&"&",& , "" % &

@" %, ;

" & ,,) "& &"& ?, ", "% "& " % "

) && = ",& % , ,& "& " &%

0- !006

# .

< ; I J< .

I J<