← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4079/2001allowed

Jagmohan Singh & ORS. v. Cantonment Bd.& ORS.

2015-12-09Mr. Justice Satish Kumar Mittal5 pages

   

     

"#$ %$&'(')*  + ",-.")'),.")%")#.$/ 00$11")#( 2$/(3(

")#)-$)#"/%4$/5$03/ ")##")%#.$/($(0)%$)#(

 *  67    8 7  /$($)#*9 /")%$$03)&..'4%:&"#$4 /#.$"00$11")#( / (.'"/03/'4%:&"#$4 //$(0)%$)#  (831;$$#8"3/4%:&"#$4 /4 /7'%.34%:&"#$4 //$(0)%$)#(# /8"')4%:&"#$4 /0/ /-"/$(0)%$)#

 <.$#.$/#.$$0/#$/( 1&"1)$=(0"0$/-">?$"11=$%# ($$#.$;3%,-$)#@  ?$/$ $//$%##.$$0/#$//)# A <.$#.$/#.$;3%,-$)#(.31%?$/$0/#$%')#.$%',$(#@ 99 99 7 

7!

-03,)$%')#.$0/$($)#/$,31"/($&)%"00$"1'(#.$ ;3%,-$)#  ")%  %$&/$$  %"#$%  B 4  0"(($%  ?>  #.$ %%'#')"1 '(#/'&#3%,$4$/5$03/4/$:$/('),#.$;3%,-$)#")%%$&/$$%"#$%

B B40"(($%?>#.$1$"/)$% ':'13%,$ 3)'/':'(')!4

99 $/5$03/4  :'%$  =.'&.  #.$  (3'#    #.$  01"')#'

(  /  0$/-")$)# ');3)&#')="(%$&/$$%")%%$ $)%")#="(/$(#/"')$% &"3('),')#$/ $/$)&$")% /&'?1>%'(90(($(('),#.$01"')#'

( (3'#1")%4-$"(3/'), BC")"1( B-"/1"(4('#3"#$%')#.$"/$"

$/5$03/ ")##4 311>%$#"'1$%')#.$.$"%)#$ #.$01"')#4$D&$0# ')%3$&3/($ 1"= /'$ 1>(#"#$%4#.$01"')#'

( "00$11")#(.$/$')!."% '1$%"

(3'# /0$/-")$)#');3)&#') //$(#/"')'),#.$%$ $)%")#(

")%  '$  3);"? <"C  "/%4  $/5$03/ '#> ")% ")#)-$)# "/%4  $/5$03/4  /-  %'(90(($(('),  #.$-  /-  #.$  (3'#  1")%4 ?$"/'),8."(/"+-')

9 B!")%+B-') B9!4-$"(3/'),

BC")"1( B-"/1"(4('#3"#$%'):'11",$3C)"$,34$/5$03/

")##4$D&$0#')%3$&3/($ 1"= .$  01"')#'

("00$11")#(  &1"'-$%  #."#  #.$>  "/$  ') &31#':"#'),0(($((') #.$(3'#1")% /#.$1"(# >$"/(")% C."(/",'/%"="/' /-"3)' B)="/%("/$')#.$'/)"-$.$ (3'#  1")%  '(  ')  #.$  =)$/(.'0    #.$  $)#/"1  :$/)-$)#   .$ %$ $)%")#(.":$)&)&$/)='#.#.$(3'#1")% 7"#$/  )4  #.$  (3'#  ","')(#  %$ $)%")#     ="( ='#.%/"=)=$:$/4#.$(3'#="(&)#$(#$%?>%$ $)%")#4 )"-$1>4 ")#)-$)#"/%#./3,.'#( D$&3#':$

'&$/4$/5$03/4 =.'&.#C#.$01$"#."#))#'&$3)%$/$&#')B  ="(($/:$% 30)#.$-")%#."##.$(3'#1")%?$1),(##.$ $)#/"1 :$/)-$)#

9A9 ")%'(3)%$/#.$-")",$-$)# ")#)-$)#"/%4$/5$03/ .$0(($((') #.$01"')#'

("00$11")#(="(%$)'$% .$  1=$/  3/#4  "

#$/  &)('%$/'),  #.$  &0'$(  

;"-"?")%'$(")%C."(/",'/%"="/'( /->$"/  #'11"/' 4 &"-$  #  #.$  &)&13(')  #."#  #.$  01"')#'

("00$11")#(  "/$  ') 0(($((')    #.$  (3'#  1")%   #  ="(  3/#.$/  ?($/:$%  #."#  #.$ %&3-$)#(0/%3&$%?>#.$ ")#)-$)#"/% %$ $)%")#!=$/$# #.$$

$&##."#"(0$/3/:$>4#.$(3'#1")%?$1),(##.$

")#)-$)#"/%4$/5$03/=$:$/4("'%(3/:$>/$0/#'()# &))$&#$%  ='#.  #.$  (3'#  1")%    .$/$ /$4  #.$  (3'#    #.$

("00$11")#(  ="(  %$&/$$%4  /$(#/"')'),  %$ $)%")#( 

/&'?1>%'(90(($(('),#.$01"')#'

("00$11")#( /-#.$(3'#1")%4 $D&$0#')%3$&3/($ 1"= .$ '/(#"00$11")# 3/#4=.'1$/$:$/('),#.$ ')%'),(

#.$1=$/ 3/#4#C#.$:'$=#."##.3,.#.$01"')#'

("00$11")#( "/$')0(($((') #.$(3'#1")%4?3##.$'/0(($((')'(3)1"= &&30"#'))#.$03?1'&0/0$/#> .$/$ /$4#.$>&"))#&1"'- ');3)&#')?$'),#.$#/$(0"(($/( )($E3$)#1>4#.$(3'# '1$%?>#.$

("00$11")#(="(%'(-'(($% .":$.$"/%#.$1$"/)$%&3)($1 /#.$0"/#'$(")%.":$ "1(&"/$ 311>,)$#./3,.#.$ '1$"(=$11"(#.$1=$/ 3/# '1$ #.#.$ 3/#(?$1=.":$,':$)&)&3//$)# ')%'),(

"&##."#"(0$/#.$/$:$)3$/$&/%4#.$01"')#'

("00$11")#("/$')

99 0(($((') #.$(3'#1")%)#.$/$:$)3$/$&/%4#.$(3'#1")%'( /$&/%$%#?$')#.$=)$/(.'0 $)#/"1 :$/)-$)#=$:$/4 ?$ /$  #.'(  3/#4     +9      ="(  '1$%  ?>  #.$

("00$11")#(  #  ?/'),  ')#  #.$  )#'&$    #.'(  3/#4  "

#'

'&"#')%"#$%A  #(.=#."##.$(3'#1")%."((')&$ ?$$)#/")( $//$%#3);"?<"C "/% .$01"')#'

("00$11")#( .":$"1(01"&$%) '1$#.$F"?31>"#)"-" "##")"-"! /#.$>$"/ 9A#&1"'-#."##.$>.":$)=,##.$1")%)1$"($ 3);"?<"C "/%.$0/$($)#(3'#="( '1$%')#.$>$"/  .3,.#.$/',')"(#.=#.$01"')#'

(&"-$')0(($((') #.$ (3'#1")%'()#0/:$%4?3##.$ "&#/$-"')(#."##.$(3'#1")%'( /$&/%$%"(,/":$>"/%(')&$  ")%#.$01"')#'

("00$11")#("/$') 0(($((')  #.$/$   %-'##$%1>4  "  #/$(0"(($/  '(  )#  $)#'#1$%  # %$&/$$ /');3)&#') =$:$/4'

#.$0(($((')'($(#"?1'(.$% (')&$1),4.$&"))1>?$%'(90(($(($%')%3$&3/($ 1"= .$/$ /$4"- #.$:'$=#."##.$ '/(#"00$11"#$ 3/#$//$%') /$:$/('),#.$ ')%'),( #.$1=$/ 3/#")%%$&1')'),');3)&#') ,/")#$%##.$01"')#'

("00$11")#(?>#.$1=$/ 3/# #?$'),(4#.$0/$($)#/$,31"/($&)%"00$"1'("11=$% .$;3%,-$)#")%%$&/$$%"#$%B 40"(($%?>#.$1$"/)$% %%'#')"1'(#/'&#3%,$4$/5$03/4'(($#"('%$")%#.$;3%,-$)# ")%%$&/$$%"#$% B B40"(($%?>#.$1$"/)$% ':'13%,$

3)'/':'(')!4$/5$03/4'(/$(#/$%=$:$/4'#'(-"%$&1$"/

9+9 #."##.$ ")#)-$)#"/%4$/5$03/4'

3)%#?$=)$/ #.$ (3'#  1")%4  &")  "1=">(  ')'#'"#$  0/&$$%'),(  ","')(#  #.$

("00$11")#(  3)%$/  #.$  3?1'&  /$-'($(  :'&#')  

)"3#./'5$% &&30")#(!&#4  4 //$&:$/> 0(($((')

7 !

 

  + (;C(