Nar Singh v. State Of Haryana And ANR
!
"# $
%&' ()
# *
"# $
%&' ()
# * $ !
&+,-) ./*0 - * 2 /3 #40 11.0 () + # #0 -
6 #,0 - *
2#
,,
* * 7
5#
#,, "
,
4*, 8 9
/44
#,, "
*
/0 #+0
4*, : + 7- )0 4
; ,) */0
7/
*40
4*, 4 # , "5 % ;# 8 /* 4 5
&&0 #+ </ "
" 7/ 4 && * 0 #) **
,
,+ "# GAURI SHANKER 2023.01.21 10:53 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
</
,, / " (
4*, )
4 =#
4*, </
#4 **,)0 "- #4 # ,-
( -) ")
/,
4*, 7 ,)
,, >64 0 # #4 ?
4 ) # 7/ , *
,,
*4
#4 /**
, ( /# #/
4*,
>64 0 # ?
+ 5, " ,,
"- 4
#4 $ #0 * - =# #/
/*
4*, 0 % ;# 0 #7 "#
@"
"# 5 , * 2#) </
#/ /*
4*, 7/
*) ) #
4*, *
4 $ #+0 $0 #+ 7/
+ = # 0
4*,
4*, 2 *-
0
4*, **
7A =
, A4
/ 4 1 +
0 &A$ 0
4 0 * /44
*/ #7, A
B
/ , * /74 /44 *
#
0 5# *
4 #0 ,) ,) "0
/
( *, , 3/ "4 ( C7,
/*4
!" # !$ %& ' $$%!(
/*4
#
/ , *
*
"0 **
* 1 A/ 8 *,) /74
"#,)
"0
4*,
* 4 5 *
,," " *
4*, "#,) /44
* / **,
7, (0 #/ *)
* *
( 1 / 0
4)
/
#0
,,"
/
*
+
*
#,, "
4*,
/44 0 $0
/0
4
* 0
9
* * 5 "
9
B$
* "
/0 7/
5
,)
* 4
2 $-
G G0 *4
"
( H7, /*4 # * 7- "/ (5-0
* *
4*, ,
#,, " &-
0
4*, *
5
44 4 ,
1 0
4*
*
"0
/0 #+0 5#7) ,,5 7 - 0
"! >2 )
A
*/ ,
0
**
*
4*,
9
5# 0 14 4
9
2 $-
G G
4 9
9 14 4
)5#
#,, **,
7, * :/# 4 1
/ *
,,) */, ,5
4
**,
7,
*
-
D
*
,,)
, ,
**,
7, *
4*, 14 4
0
*
,,) 4
0
/ 7,
#,,
,)
5#
,
2 $-
G G
,
5)
$ D
/#
*
4*,
#/ ,,5 /
$0
#-
**,
7, 0
/74
7
"0 #+ *** 0
" B
/ ,
4*,
#7)
** 7
"0 #+
9 1#,4
#7)
5,, 4
"0 #+?4*#
/**, '*
"0 #+
*
,,) # >
/ *
4/ *
2 $-
14 0
0 4 9
#0
, "0 #+
*
4
4
7 +
#
0 #+ )
,0
* ,
,5?
D
#/*
#
4*/"
*
/44 0 * * #
#/ ! >:4
/4
4*, &A$ *,
4*, 0
) ,
,
4*, 7, "
:4 4
4*,
# 4 0
,
,
/
7/
4*,
") 4+
#/4 , 447
*/7,
5 2#/ 0 #
/
4 /44
/
A 82 ( 0
/
/44
A 82
,
*)
4*, ?
1"" -
* 0
G
$ 7
/0
4
9
7 - >4 */ ,
**
/4
1 A/ $ $90
4" 5
/44
/ 4 )
,,", ) *- ) #
/ , *
) -
/4 0
**
"# * * -?
* + /*
7 ( H7, /*4
, B$,
*
#/ !
>
*
,- *
/
+
/ ,
* 4
2 $-
G G0
14 4
8
,)
/ 2#
,)
# D
*
/
/ ,
4*, "/
7 ( "# / 2#/"#
*
*
/ , * 0
"/
) 4
(- "
5 *4 * # *
( "# $ / $
*
5 5+ 0 #,,
( "#
5 4 * #,,
*
5 5+ *
,- *
",)0
?
5 7-0 5
* * 0 ,)
/ ,,
"
/ 7 , )
+
4
-/ -,/
/0 * 7,
# ,5 /
A#/ * / 4
$)% &) * &*+' # $ ) * # &* , & 0
B 0 5#
*
,)
*
0
/
#/"# *,
*0 # ,,"
9 G
0 ( H7, /*4
#,
4,) / 5 /#
,
,
4
5/,
" * #) , 7-
#/ !
> 2#0
/8</ *
5##
5#
#
/0 5##
5 9
9I =#
/8</ 0 ,"
, ) ,-
2 $-
G G0 4 *
/,,)0
* 4
* 4
</
*4 4
* 4
!
>
$ 4 !
: */*
* ) ,0 .- 4 #,,0
/ # @/
( "# /0
.F0 *
)
)
?
>
&A ,/
$ 4 !
: */*
* ) ,0 .- 4 #,,0
/ # @/
( "# /0
.F0 7, &A ,/
4
!
$-
5# /47
.- 4 #,,0
/ # @/
( "# /0
.F0 *
)
0
)
E $-
/# 7,
*
#,,
,)
?
2#
*4 4
4
/*
7
*4 4 0
"#5) +
AA AA AA G
G $ /
5 9
5 *
"/
5 9
/*
7,
*
*/*
* ) , #,,
,)
73
*/*
0
,
G0
$ /0
D
5) 3/
#
,) / 0
#
7,
*/*
* ) ,0
,/
:D
#" #
"/
0 0 0 0 9
$ ,
A
</ #
D 4)
5
73
*/* 0
#0
*/*
* )
73
*/*
#
7-0
7, 7,
*
A
0 */*
* )
,)
;/ 40 7 -
#
7-0 4,) "/
,)
/
</ #
,,) "/
/*
,
,)
#
?
D 5/,
** , 4+ A*,
A* ,5
&#%%-.!#%+&' %$$%!( /&$"
B
05#
( H7, /*4
0 7 -
#,
#/ !
> ; 5
4
0 5
4* 3/ "4
*
G $
5 3/ " ;
. "/, 1 #+ - 1$
/
4*, , "
2 $-
G G " **,, *,
#" # /*
- "
,) 7 /
"
#" 5 4
" ( "# 4-
</ #
#"
#" # ", " #,
"
3/
#/
",)
" ( "#
#" #
** /
*,
5#
*
7 @: */*
,
, 4 ***
#" ( "# </
**, 7
/
/
5##
"
/,
J "#5) #/
2 0 #- "
1 /
0 @/
2#4 7 -
/
,) J * ) ,H
4 J </ )H
AA AA AA D 4)
2 /7 /
4 9 @ /)
9
0 ,,5 4 0 */,
#,,
,)
,)0
;
$)% &) * &*+'#$ ) * # &*
*
2
0 :D
*/ #7, 82
$ ,
+
/
/ **,
7 ( "# + </ # :D
/44 D
5
2
( "# ,,5
**,
</ #
"/
/ 3/
**,0 5 3/ "
3/ "4 ( "# #,
2
/
0 7/
0 =# - 3/ "4 ( "# /0 @/
##0 *+ 5 3/ " ; #0 7 - !
0*1
5) 3/
, 5
/
>/ 7,
*
#,,
,)
/? 5 J ,)K
"E
0**1D 5
9
$0
+
/,
"# #,
"/,
5/,
" AA AA AA 7,
4
# ,/ 3/
*/* 9
5##
"/, )
/
*3/
/ 3 + 4/,
**, (5-0
4
# ,/ 3/
0
/,
"
#,, "0 /
#"
**
*, "
" D 4/
4
,/ 3/
5/,
-
,)
,/
73
/7 4 -,/ , " ?
/44
3/ "4 0 ,7, *
#/ !
> AA AA
73 9
*-
,)
44 4
4*, , 9 $
**,
7,
, /) +
/44 5,, 2#0 -
+
"/,0
5/,
5 9 $E
-
AA AA -D
,
*
*, ,5
(5-0
" */
,, ,- 4 ,
7
+
# "
4 5/,
,
2#0 J ,/ 3/
H 9 $
*- 2#
"/, ) 5/,
#/
5 9 $E?
D #
$)% &) * &*+ /*
7 -
#0 >2# 5
/
>/ 7,
*
#,,
,)
/? 5
> ,)?
*
// ,)
" D
,"
,/ 5/,
3/
A ,/ -,)
/0
0 5
#/,
># 7,
*
,) #,,
,)
? :/#
7 -
#0 >D ** 7 -
4
/* "- 4
** -
/4* 4 /, *
* $ /
-
) /#
,)
* )
*-
"
447
2 7 :/# 7 -
#0 >2/
,
,,) 7,
7/
*
0
,,) 44*#
, 7 ,/,)
? 2#0
73
*/*
0
#,
#0
5) 3/
0 #/ 0
</ #
,,) "/
#
7,
*/*
* )
/*
,
,)
$! %'' &2 0
GG ( H7, /*4
#, >2# )
-)
"/, )
/,
/ "/
/* / ,
"/, )
/
*7, *3/
*)
</
"
,0 / </
/*
, /) "
@/
- # D #/,
/"# 4
7, +* ,5 7) 2# 5/,
4 ,/ -) ) 4?
,, /#0
#,
$)% &) * &*+ /* #0 >2#0 / ,
/ , # "#
,5 4
/
4+ ) " -
+
#
/0
*3/
?
7 -
#0 >1 /4 + "/4 , / *
"/,0
5#) #/,
5# 7, "
2
44/ ) /?
&#%%-.!#%+& /*0 ( H7, /*4 A*,
*
7 -
#0 >D
-
4
#/ "# /*
#4 $, /*
5
G $0
2#/ 0
"
/ */* +
/
/
4
"
) ," 2#0 " -
"
"
/
*/ #4 *-
4 #/"#
4#
4 0 7/
"
#/ "
/
,"
,
*-
4
/
4
*-
4?
/# 7 -
># 73 #* LLL% $
,) *-
,)
,/
44
,/ 7/ ,
/7
,) *
" /#
/ ,,) F
*
*, * ) ,?
!" /*0
"/ #7,
4/ 0
#" # /74
*,
,) 7 0
/ 0 ( "# #/ 0 #,
"
3/
#/
",)
" D
#" #
** /
*,
5#
*
7
, 0 */*
,
, 4 ***
#" 0
5 /*#,
( H7, /*4
5 -
, ,,"
"
7 -
#,, **,
7, * 2#/ 0
,/
/ 4
5/,
**,
7,
4*,
" # 7 -
,)
#-
/*
#0
,
/ *
4/ *
2 $-
14 0
0 4 9
0
*
"
4 4
#
0 #+0
* ,
,50 5#
;
/4
/ #-
) ,, F
/# * / 4 0
4
5/,
" 0 * *
-
",)0 * * 7 4 #7)
2# 7 - # 7- ,) */* 3/
*
4
/
A* *
4
*# *) 3/ "4 *,
0 1 " -
=## *+ "8
!
M
=## *7, !
M