High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/12018/2021allowed

Krishna Devi v. State Of Haryana And Others

2025-12-02Mr. Justice Sandeep Moudgil21 pages

"# $ $## #

# # #

% & # #

" ##$ ! % & "' & " ( ( #(() ( (# #((* + , -*.

"/" " 0 "" " 0

"" &&

" + - .

0 -

" 0& / (2 ( 332

& ""

0 ""& / ( () #(

&& "

4/ 0 (2 (* #($ + , -. " ""&"

0 5(6 /

0& 0 " ""&& 0 !7 8 2(2) #(2 () (* #(2 + , -#.

% " 0 ( (9 #(2 / & 0 - ) !"& " :

& " ( ( #(() ( (# #((* + , -) -*. & 0 "" 0 / "' &

" & " 00 ""&" - 0 0 "

* " "

" + ;

" 0& / (2 ( 332 " 0 - ""

""&"

( () #( % / " 4/ 0 (2 (* #($ 0/ 0 5(6 /

0& 0

" !7 8 2(2) #(2 () (* #(2 & && ""&"

" % & &

& "& < % #* "" "&/" /

" ( ( #(() ( (# #((*

" "

"" " 0& ;

" " / "' - #3 (3 #(* (2 ( #(* "

" / " "

" * $ ! % $ 00"

" #((2 " " " :

"& 0" " " / ""&"

" "

& !7 8 53(9 #(5 * (5 #(9

+ , -3. 4

8 #2 #(9 9 (9 #(9 + , -9. / "" / & & 4/ 0

0 0" & "&"

/" &

% & 0 "

&& 0

( " & / - 0 ! = &

> !"# $%&&'()*+ " & % " ( ( #(() ( (# #((* 0

) (* #((2 % / !7 8 2#($ #(* +?& & @

@ .

" /& & " B

< :

9 ($ #(* & 0

4 /

/ &

4 ""

& /

"" "

" ""- " 0& " - 0 & " """

"&/" " "

0 0 "' 0 ""- " 0& "

(

& / "

/ & "

" , 0 ""0& - " !

7 0 4/ (2 (* #($ () (* #(2

"&"" /" & ""

& "'C # 7 & " :

"& 0" & " ( ( #(() ( (# #((* 0 "& " ) 7 "

"" " " /

" * $ ! %C * 7 "0 "" " " 0

D B

+#(($.

& "& "

0 -/ "C

! $ !

$ ! %&%% ! #% &

# %% ! !% $$

!#%!& &%' !( ))*+, -) ,.* &/0-12 -12, /3/24 4/ "" 0 0 (2 (* #($ + , -. 0 /:

" !7 8 2(2) #(2 () (* #(2 + , -#.

) % 0 / " 0 "

"0 " 0 "

5 "0 "< "&"" "

& 0

/ % "< &

1 , < & "/ & "

"" "0 " 0& / :

"/ 0 "<

"0 "

/ * ! /" " "&"

/ # 0 , # $%&*1(*&1%) " 0 & "

-" / 0" "&

>"" ) $ $ ! # #!

#%%

! ! *&! +

!&% ! !

!! !!

# ! #- & !

% %.

< /

!& 0 0 ""&"

"0 " "" , /" 0 " / ""&" & "

0 " / "0 "/ 1

" "" " "

, "& " < 0 " >- 0F

6 & " & / """

/& "

0 /" "0 $ < 0 " < & - ""& "

" " "" /& 0 "

/ &

$ !

!& $% %!&

# % /&%' !

%# "

! !

%& !%!

! &%' !

( ( ( #(() 8 8 #*G! G )(3G#(() 0 ( (# #((* + 5G! G )(3G#((*. !

& " 0& /

" " & " 0& -

12!% # % & $%

$% 3 #

4 $56 $

" 7$

! !

" 7$

%% &% &! $# 4 $56 $

$ %%% %# !8 0 - ! $

# ! - !

% & $% !

# !

% %

# - $ % ! !8.

% & !"# $ (

8 ) (* #((2 & " "

& #*G#(() 5G#((*

0 "

& / " " & " 0 "' "0 0 1/ " 0&GG "

/ / / " & / " ""0 " "/" " % " & "' 0 /

" // 0 "" "& 0 "0 & "

/" "

#( % " / & / & , - /" " " 0"

0 0

0 & 0 $( " & 0 " 0 "

& 9 6 :$,

- # 2 %&**$%(23)*) :

& "

& 0

7 "' B 0 / )( 0 =H

& B % & "G / "

&& =H , -&& 1 ## I

= 0

& - # %&*%$1(23)11

&" = 0 &

2 4 + .

#) %

2 $%&&'(5116 " " 0&

& 0 / & " 0& / /

& ""0 0 "& ""

" 0& 0 ( " "' & %

" )(3 !

" 0 " 0& % J &K =

" " 0& && " " 0 " " 0 " /& 0 " " ""0 "& " 0&

& & /

;

) # $% !

!# <!#

!# !& # $ = %% % !

$ % # $ !

% 5 & -

! !

$$ $ %% ! #

% 5& $#%%

#& %%

# !

!#!

% !#!

9 0

% & !

9!#% % %

$ #% %%

!$ !

!! !% # &%' ! &!

&% #%

$ ;

" 0 73!3 8# 98+ :;1)<=<;%&*5 3 ( #(#) 0 #(() 0

! "# $ ( / " 0& /& , ," /" " & :

" &

" $ !

" & "

" & " " - 0 0" " 0 " " "

& :

" / "0 :

" "& "

" * @ $+.

! E""0& 0 -

1:"

$!#$%

!% *#

! $ ! #!!

! !

&%' !

# !

%% $%# $% !

&! ! :"", >## !&%

$ !! #

! #

$ ! &%' !

# !

$ %# "

? ! !

$ !#

&%'!& #

# $

) $ ! %% %

%% !

&%' !

! ! !% %

# %&% !#%!&

% :", ) # %

!& $#% !

%5 @ $% #

%$% !

%& !

# %&% !

! &!& %&% &

#!!

! !& ! ! #

# !

& #!!

! # % !& !

$ !!

%% $

! $ !!

# %%

%' !

# $ ! ! !%

&%' !

#5 "

/ " " " & 9 ($ #(* :

>?@?

$ ( " & /

& " "

& "& " "

0- " ,& " / - " 0

0 "

& / , "

0 " 1

/ "0 0 0 " 0

#$ " & && 9 6 + .

" " & ," "

& " - "

" & " % - " 0 " "

"& "

" "&"

0 :

"0 "/" "& & % " "

" "-0& " -& - 0 "

&*89,9:/,* ;<*+,/,9-= #2 H0 " 00"

" 0 & "& , "" 0 "

""&"

" "

1 % > - #9 "# ! $*551(1)55+

&' "& , "

0 " B ) 5 % $! + $! <$!#

$ $! ! $! <$# ! %&% $$

<$# !

#!!

!#$ !

$ !

& !

& ?

! ! !#

$ ! !!%

! %

%%%

% #!!

% <$# !

! $$ !! !

# %&% ! !# > $ $ !

%!&

%& !

#!!

%& <$# ! ) %&#

<$# !

!% !

!# !

% $ # %% !

&% ! !% !# >&!

&!! <$# ! 7# <$# !

% *% %& ! $ #% D # %& <$# !

% # !

& ! !

& !

!! !% ! "

# !#$

%& <$# !

! % !

! %

&! #! $ !#

;& <$# !;

% #

% !& %

!#$ !

! # !

- $%# # $!#$% %

!% *#

! !%!

% #% ! ;!

$!#$%

$ $ !% ; #9 < "

& " #(();#((* 0""-/" >##

%% /& H " """ ""

/ "& & / / " 0 " /:

00"

& " :

"& )( (3 #(() & ""

#10>,/=,9?* -=49,9-=> )-2 *81@/29A/,9-= -@9+B #3 & " ( ( #(() ( (# #((* / " 0& -

" "

&& -

L +.

" < )( (3 #(()L +.

/& )( (3 #(()L +.

" && )( (3 #(()L +.

& " #*( :

"& L +.

/ / /" " I "" )( %

" -

" 0& / (2 ( 332 )( (3 #(() " , " , /

4/ 0" 1 & "

"" " "

" /" """ >#*( F :

)

& /& > )( (3 #(()F "

" 0

( " ""

E/ #( / "& )( (3 #(() """ 0""

)# & >/ - F / "

9 6 :$, " 0 0 "& " & /:

0 " 9 6 :$, " "

" 0

"& 0 ""

0"& "

/ & % 0 "

1 " "" / "

" "

" "" 0 & " / /" " "

)) " && / " " ""&"

( () #( 0 " / 0 4/ 0 & /

" / / /" " ""

H "

/ & /" "0

& )* "

/ " && "

"" " / "' H

! & "" "/" & " - /" & )5 % 0

&& "& """ #*( <

/ :

"- " :

" "&"

" """ ""

/ "&/" /

& " ( ( #(() ( (# #((* ,"

& - "" % 8 "

&%' !

$ !

$ &%' !

%% $%

% #! !

>#% !

! !

!( /29,B 39,. #9:9@/2@B #9,1/,*4 :<@-B**> )$ % " "

0 "

& -

& "

& 0 / & / & & "'

& / && /:

00"

0 / & " 0 "&"

)2 I:

" / "0 :

"" "

0 / "

" * !

>A3# @!

B $*56)()1+ " / & :

" 7 / " / " "

/ " 0 "

""&/" / / /" "&"" /" /0 0 " / "' )9

, > # 2 $%&*&(5%)6+0""& " B

"& "

,& "

1 > !

# !

% % 5&E5 #E#% $% %% $!!& ! !%

% $! ! !!% !

!5 &% !

$ # 2!

!! $!

!!% !

!5 <# <#%!& % $%

! !

& ! # $!!& !

# ##!#

! !

0 F"

# !

%% !

% &

! &%' !

% #

!5 <# $% !!& #

# <

! $ ! ! !

$ F"

9 <$ )

!5 <# % ! %% % 5 &E #E $%

$ !

!! #

%!& $ # !

$% %

!5 <# !

$ F"

! #

$ F"

$% !#! % ! # %

!! !

!5 <# )

! <# %% !#%

!% !

%% $%

! !

0 F"

)3 :

" " " #( ""

& "" I ,"

& 0" ,& "" "

2 $ ( &

6 *( % 0 "" / , / "' / " & & "

/ "" / "

" * $ ! % C/2, 9:*D >,/,1> -) <*,9,9-=*2 * 0 & 0 /0 "" & ""& $5 " ) 0"" ' / "

""" && 0" & 0 " /"

" "" " " "& " "

" *# " #*

/"-

0 & "/"

>-F "' "" 0 :

"/" && 0

0 & "

" & " "" " " " " ! "

1 "

*) % >0??# - %&%<,

366=+ &"" / ,

1 ! $$%%!3 % !& ! !!$ #

$ <!!& %% ! !

#!!

% %%%!& !% $$ !! $5

!#% ) !#

$% ! ! !

! ! !

!&% !

! # !

!# && ! & !

%%&%

$ .

** & "' /" / "0 ,/"

< 0 0

& 1 < 0-

& 0& /"& " &

0 " " / / 0 " " "

& :

" ""

H0& 0

$ !! #!

%%% ! - $!#$% % !

G!- 9 6 :

, 7

&%' !

# !&

% !& !! !

# $ # *#% ! $ 5 #%( *5 < " !"# $ ( "" " 9 6 & & / & / 0

% " "

" "&-& / "" -0 " / & *$ " / / &

" * 0""

" $ 0 / "" & /" B

< + .

! #@ : C?

, B)%&%&%1 *5&<%&%1 0" & "

& B

< + .

"& 0 "

" / 0 " " "

& :

" / "0 :

" "& "

" * @ $+.

! " *2

0??$ ( /

, & B

" " 0 & & " /

"0 " & & ""&"

" , 0

%% % # !

9 6 :$, !

$!%' $%

! % !&

# %%%!&

!& !& ! !# !# !

!!% ) *&! &

$! #-

! ! %%&% $$ !! ##! ! !% ! ?

$$ !! !

%%&% $ % ;&% ;

! $% !! % &! #- $

!# ! !# ! !% $

! ! ! % !

# $ !.

% *&! !

9 6 :$, &

#% $##

! ! ! $$ !!

! !% $!#$%

&% $!#$%

$$%

%& #%

% !&5 !& $% ) *&!

!& !

;%%&%;

! ;&%;

$$ !!.

9 6 "

/" " & & "

, /:

*9 "

/"&

" " 0 /" 0 0 "&

& B

0" " " && / 0 " ,

% & " ," & /" "

= & " & /

"& 1/

" " /

*3 " "

& !"# $ ( " / "

5( % 0 / " ( ( #(() + ( (# #((*.

& 00"

" < " 0 "" / &

% & " / "

"&" / / & "

" "

&" , < " " " 0

< ( ( #(() ( (# #((* & " 0

! & ""

" " ""

/ :

" "

& " 5# "& &

"/" & & " " " & "

$6 ""

0"& < "&-" & 5)

"" " " &" 5*

""0

& !

! $-!&E ! + HE

$ % + HE