Lokesh Kasat And ORS v. Sabsons Fastners Pvt Ltd

 

      





  !"#"$%&'
'





 

        



 %  ()* ' + *+** ) ****   

   !

"



 + $,

-.,/"01' #   $$  " %&&'()*)&'+'' %&& '((+'&'+'' %&&'((+(&'+'' %&&'((,-&'+'' %&&'(.++& '+'' %&&'(./-&'+'' %&&'(.)/&'+''  !00   $   "%&&'()*)&'+''

$    #    1

2 "  !0 $ !0$ 33 %#4-5' " '+'+ 

 /,+('+'+ 2   %  " 67% ! $ 8$$ "1

2"  002

/(+)'+'/ 9 :

';8< 

 00 "

! $" ""!  !

 /)( " 32 $ 7 0  !

$2 8  $$ 1  !2    ! $ "   0

 

$ , !0$  !

 /)( "  32 $ 7 0  !

 9  = 37 !

>;8"$<  &!0  8  0$ $$2

 $

2  ""  !1  8! 8 $$2$<  

- 2 -    "





      " "

2"

 < !$ 2$2 2 $ 0 !#  8   !

 8 $

0

< " < $$2$<  &!0 <  !  $ ! 8   !

   " 5+/.5(5 

 " 2 $2 $  !   

  $2 0

 )-)/(+.5+$<2 !    ! $"

 2

8 

2

4 8" !1 1  !!

8   <& &  " $$2 !0

<   " 0  # !0$ $  2 !" $" !



8

0  ! 2" "  ! "   $ !    $ ! 
  

     

! !!

?" "# $ 

! %%  &'&? (% $  )"

* !  !'+ ! 

 $<  8" !1 8!

"



!0 $$ $  8 2

<" !1

! !

 $ $ <!

"

 &:!

!

 @ $ ! $" 2  2 ! # $ !  0 2    !"!

$$< 

 2  "6  8  1 <$  0!

'+'9/;%% 8 :

0 "



- 3 - 22  2  ! !

0 $ !!" ! $8 $ !  $

   2 2  " !2

 !"!

$$<



!

"

$ 7   $" 20 !   <" ! $  !" !0    A $<   $< $ $ " " !1 1 7 ! :

 0



 8  ""!   32 $ 7 0  !

    !00

 <  !0 <  <  8 8   ! 2 "  8 $  !0 < "  !  "      $ 1

$$< $ < "  ""! <  

< !

 < B!

  2   ""! "  !0 < 8   !   !   !00 "    ""!  0  $ $ "   0  " ""! # !$ $< !$ "0 !

/5/ " 37 !

 8!  & ,-))./0. 
+




 

 
  



 
 


 




 
  


 




 





 






 




 

  

 


 




  
 

  


  

 
  





 

   





 

- 4 - 
  
 

   




!

 


  


 

 


 
"  ) 






  


# 



 

 








 


$ 
%  

&
%  





  

 




$  %  


&
%  











 


$ '()
#

 $ !$ ! 
  

   !

 9  ;    !

 "    8$$<  2  $ 

!

  8 !



0"

!"!1 1 " !

 $ $     !

$ !

 @8    !

   !!

&  

  !$ $<8 B!

" %0 <8  2 2

$<  $     0   <$ "

$  7    $"     0

"!"

 "! <  002 !!

&  $ %     $< !  1 <    !

 '+' %%  $<

 "

2

" 00 !!

& "

! $ #% "



20! !

$$<:

0 

/,+('+'+9 :

&/; %  "

2 $ $<1 2 !!

& !$ 0  ! 2 "   0 !!

&  

 

  !1  

$ " 8! 

$ $    - "  !0$   $" 8!   !$8

 $

" 0

- 5 -  3 0  %1 3 0

B 0

/    9;     +',/,+ /+++++++ '++5'+'+ )++-'+'+ '    9;     +',/,/ (-.*+++ '/+5'+'+ )++-'+'+ )    9;     +',/,' /+++++++ ''+5'+'+ )++-'+'+ 5    9;     +',/,) (./55++ ')+5'+'+ )++-'+'+  @8  (" $2 !"!

0

!!

 $" 0 20 !   <" ! $  !" <8 $ 2

< "  !1   1  8 "

$  0   <0

 !1    

! " $2 $  ! 

+)+,'+'+ 9 :

 %&//; 8!   !    < 

$! 

+-+,'+'+9 :

%&/' %&'+;  "

 !   8  2   &0 2 "   00 !!

&   !! !

'+5 %% 8 $  $

     !

  "

2 "2  8!  & .

1 -) .

234! *+*'
,

  





'

-
.  
  






 









 /


 




  
0*












- 6 -  

 


1





 

  




















 
 

 



 





 
,

 

 
  


 

 







. 


 


 



!  


$ 
&

2








 



$ 














! 


  
*++'
*


1 
  


. 






 




,

 






. 


 


 




!  


$ 
&





















!
 
'



  
  













 






  











$ 


 

 





 
! 







 


'
  2" "  0  0$!$

 2

   "0  

 8   ""!  2 !56    -)762

  

 $

$2$

   !  !



 0 $" !0$ 8 

 2! @8  !$2 $1 0  0 

  2

   

$  8$  2  00      "0 "$$82

 " !

$ 8 3


  1  



 
 


 




 

  



- 7 - 



  


    



! 


'
4

  

 


 


!





 



 
 


 




 
 

  '


. 


 
  




 
 




 

 



 
 

 
 '
5

 











. 

&

6 


 '
5







  







 


  

 '
7

 1
 



 
  




  









 

 
 


 




 !



 '3

D <  8 8   ! 2 "  8  $ !0 <" ! "  " < $0 2 $ " ""!< 

<!

  32 $7 0  !

 #% " 82 <!!$ 0 

$

2 "  2  !  8   $$2

  !0$ <8!  2

B!

" %0 <!

 $ ! 8!0 < $$2 2 $ <"""!7

!

  !

   (  !"!

0 1

!!

& 2$  2

<

!1  8 $2 2 "0 A 20 "  : %     !

 "  8    6  9  "# " ": 

!  4+* # % 8 ! !2$<  !  !!$   $2 " " !

$ 8 $

2

 !

 "

!!

0

!" !





/(+)'+'/ <

- 8 -

$% A $2 $8 

"

$ 8 "0 <    "!" %  !!2$< $$  2   0   < 0 &'
'

 8'8 2+ $,

-.,/"03 .,/

1. Whether speaking/reasoned?

Yes/No

2. Whether reportable?

Yes/No