Avtar Singh And ANR. v. State Of Punjab And Others
!"#$%$&'(
)'*+, "%-*"!'- +&
+&
.
+&$& ,'*'
$"/*0*"!*"'- +
"'&
2- ++ 1+'
+&3 *3"
4&1*1 +&5*60 *334 !'&
/$!%5 "'7 0 ++ !'+ 1+'
+&+"'7 2- +'- /$!%5 "'&-$3!0 1+'
! "'- % &'7
"'# + 9+ &-*", -*/1*3(!) *'
+'- +&
+ ,$3'*", "%- 33(( $"/*0 ++
,'*'
"
++
+&("*5 36()'*+, "%-(*3/ '9*$+*"! *+*5/ ', "%- -*) 3 "'1 ' ' "+:$*&- "% !*'
!;
' "&8=8(8==( (+ % &'
!*' ,'*' "(*"!*( &'+ '&- *+1$+ - 4*&+ % &'
!"'- 513* "'+ ,$0-*&--*43*>,$0-*&--*"!
+&""!
+/ '-*43* '-*&0
*33 "'-*'- -*&'4&"&*"!*!*$%-'
& 3!
+&"*%*"
-*43*-*&%"
*0+*!4- *&6$"% +&" -*"-*43* &&'$!6 "%*'
$?
+ *"(*"!- &!*$%-'
+6' *3* &1+ 1*+ "%+ @*5 "*' "+'-
3*&& A +!*'
0 +'- &<
= "
(- &!*$%-'
+6'
*3*-*!%"
+'$ ' "*' 81 "- 6*1$+-*33**"!4- "- & 4 9*) '* *" -*!%"
'0+ "%- +!*$%-'
++5'$ ' "(&- 4*& "+5 !06'- '$ ' "5*&'
+'-*'6' *3*! !"' 5 '- 5+&'$!6
2- "'- &* '4*&0+$%-'''- ?"43 !% '- +(- *5 0* ?
+5- &&-1'& *+ -- &!*$%-'
+(0$' $3!"' "!- +! "%36('-
5*''
+4*&+ 1+'
!''- 13 "8 *0$'- &5 && "%!*$%-'
""'
5' "-*) "%0
" &&$ !06'- &$+'('- 064*6* !*) '9*+*")
+, "%-(
,(, (,$0 ) & "(*"!*( &'+ '&- *+1$+-*&0
" 3 !"0 -*3+
,'*'
&+ 1+'
!06'- ("'
&&$ !'+
!0* ?$"& +) !4 '-'- 1+''-*'+ -*& @1 !- & !*$%-'
++5- &1+1 +'6 -$& ''*"'*5$"'+ $&*3+5& +) *"!
+ ( ' &!
!& +)
4 +(""
-*&1$' "*11 *+*"
"
-*3+ '1$+&$ '- *&
- "'
"'&'- "'
' ' "-*) "''-$&0
" "'+) +'
!06'- ! $"& 3 + '- 1 +& -*& "'
"!
! '-*' '-
*33 %*' "& "'- *+ *3&
-
*"!6' *3*
'-
!*$%-'
++ *+ 5*/+*"!-*) &3 5" C +5*++ *%
*"!*+ 3 ) "%-*11 36 -
*"!6' *3*D!*$%-'
+ E-*) &3 5" C +5*++ *% 4 '-$'*"6'-+ *'+ + "*"!'- % &'+*' "'- "' &"'- "%0$'*"*''
51'' 5$"'1+ &&$+ "'- +&'-*"!) +'- $&'!66' *3*' - +1*+ "'&(4- *&6' *3* &"'4 33 "%'+ '$+"0* ?'- +1*+ "'*3 -5
,- &+ & ! "%4 '-'-
*"!3 ) "%*-*1165*++ 3
, 5 3*+36(" -*&0
" 55 ''
!061 +& *"!8*& && &'
+1
*"!1 8 &0+'- + "3*4D /*E'-
! $"& 3+'- ,'*'
(" "&'+$ ' "&,*!*"
-*"(-*& "'
"!
!'-*''-
*"!6' *3*%'+ +!
+&'*'
"'&4 '-'- 13 ,'*' "($334*3'-*''- 6-*)
5*++ ! * -'- +4 '-'- ++
"& "'*"!'- 6*+ 3 ) "%-*11 36*& -$&0*"!*"!4
6' *3*-*&" 513* "'*%* "&''- +& -*) - *+!3 ! $"& 3+'- 1*+'
- "F03 3- %- $+' "
!
"#$% &'$#' !
!"'-
0+$*+6( 8' '3 !*& (!
)) * )( (&5 4-*' "& 5 3*+ + $5&'*"
&(-*&- 3!*& +#
"# "$
% ! "#'
$''
( (
"# "$
% ' '
'"
'
$
# +
# $* + #$
' & ' ," , #$,
#$
(
- .
/ +
-
%
#$,
'0 "
#* "
' (
$
&$
'
(& *
$ 1" & ( "$ ,"
(
$ +'
"
2'
0,
+
* 0, $$ (& ,"
'" '
+$
$* /'
'
' # + 0 "
, * ( 0&
"
,$
& '
3
"
- (' ",+
# # ( '
' #, 5 0
$$,
(
(& *
& ' 1" , 3& '''
'**('
" , ,$ $0
'$+'
( *
, + #$ (' '
, #
(
( "
& &''
- ! 6 ,$ $( '$+'
' $0 ' ," (
$$ + # 0 #*
' & ' $ "
2'
0,
+
* 0, $$ (& ,"
'" ,
+$
$* /'
' & ' - '"
' , "0
' # + 0 "
, * ( 0&
"
,$
("
( # '",
' "'
0
'
'( 0 ( "$ #*
' & '
+
& #* "( (
$ + "'
7
, 5 3*+36( " !+( )) & &, (* )( -.- /#00'1'$#'/* * * $#$''$#"(* ) & " " - "F03 3- %-$+'-*&- 3!'-*' '- % +3 &5+ '-*" =6 *+& *"!)3$"'*+ 36*"!- +4"4 33* 51*"
&*1 +&"'- 1+
! "%& ' "8=8+8;= *"0 :$*&- *+* '- 1+' &
@'+* '
!- +# 5
-
'
(
0'
' ( '" , ,"
"
'
' (
' '
,"
*
$ ' ( $ #
&
,$$ # ," '
&,
8 '"
9% -!
'
" / 0 ($
#
&&$ 1" # '
"
$$
!
(' '
$
*
'
' # 0
#* + # 0 '
G "& !
+ "%'- * ''-*''- -*&"'1'
!' "'
&''- "'1 ' ' "*"!"5*'
+ *3-*&0
"13* !"+ +!06'-
! $"& 3+'- ,'*'
'&-4'-*'6' *3* &&'*6 "%4 '-'-
$"!
+*"61+ &&$+ ('- &$+'
3&'-*''- ":$ &' "
&"'- "%0$'*"*0$& 1+ &&3*4*"!('- + ('- &*5 &3 *03 ' :$*&- +! "%36('- "'1 ' ' " &*334 !*"!
% !*'
!;
$"!
' "&8=8(8==( (+ % &'
!*'
,'*' "(*"!*( &'+ '&- *+1$+*"!*33&$0& :$ "'1+
! "%&*+ & "% +5 &:$*&-
F*%$''F